RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
Deep Regrets thumbnail

Deep Regrets FAQ

266 questions players ask · Updated Nov 17, 2026 · Full rulebook

SetupHow to Play: The Four Day PhasesSea ActionsFish AnatomyPort ActionsMake PortRegretsMadnessThe EndSolo / Co-operative: Ocean SurveyAppendixReferenceGeneralEven Deeper Regrets

Setup

  • Where do the Madness cubes go at setup?
  • What is the Fair to Foul ratio at Depth I?
  • Do unused Dinks or leftover money carry over from one week of solo play to the next?
  • Do I place four dice in Port at setup?
  • Do shoal sizes change with player count?

How to Play: The Four Day Phases

  • When do passed players take their passing reward, and does it cost a die?
  • If no Dink is left, must a passing player discard a Regret instead?
  • Can I take free actions on the turn I pass, such as dropping a sinker?
  • After I pass, can I still take actions or free actions for the rest of the day?
  • Can I pass while I still have fresh dice, and must I reroll them?
  • Can I take only free actions on my turn, without a main action or a pass?
  • Does the last player still in the round get a passing reward?
  • When the last player takes extra turns, do players who already passed get more passing rewards?
  • How many turns does the last player get once everyone else has passed?
  • Who takes the first turn of each new day?
  • Do boats at Sea keep their depth into the next day, or do they rise?
  • Do I get extra dice refreshes when I arrive at Port, and again when a new day starts?
  • During Refresh, must I reroll my Fresh dice?
  • During Refresh, can the dice I roll push an unrolled Fresh die out of the Fresh pool?
  • If I reroll at Port, does the Life Preserver holder change?
  • When can a Reel that changes dice be used relative to the Life Preserver toss?
  • After a Rod or Reel is used for a day, does it go back to my hand or get discarded?
  • If I equip a new Rod or Reel while one is already equipped, what happens to the old one?
  • Is equipping a Rod or Reel, and using its ability, mandatory?
  • Can I equip a Rod or Reel I just bought at Port on the same day?
  • If the Lifeboat returns my ship to Port mid-day, can it go back out to Sea the same day?
  • If my Can of Worms is already face-up at the start of a day, do I flip it again?
  • On Saturday, if there are not enough orange dice for every player, who gets one?
  • Can I fish more than once in a day?

Sea Actions

  • Can I use several Dinks, items, eaten Fish or sinkers in one turn?
  • After a main action such as Fish or Abandon Ship, can I still take free actions that turn?
  • If I cannot or choose not to catch a revealed fish, is that a pass, and do I spend a die?
  • If a revealed fish is discarded or leaves the Shoal, do I still spend a die and take a Dink?
  • Can I fish directly for a Dink?
  • Does revealing a fish while fishing always end my turn?
  • Where do used Dinks go, and what happens when the Dink deck runs out?
  • Can I eat a Fish that has no Eat ability, just to remove its restriction?
  • Do I spend a die to catch a fish that costs zero, and do I need a fresh die to start fishing?
  • If a fish must be caught with exactly N dice, do I still spend N dice when its difficulty is zero, and can I overpay?
  • Do spent Tackle Dice go back into the bag when they are moved to the Spent pool?
  • Does dropping a sinker cost one die per depth level, and which die can pay for it?
  • Can I catch a fish from a Shoal deeper than my boat's current depth?
  • Can my boat go to Port from Depth II or III, and which depth do I return to Sea at?
  • After Reel of the Deep moves my boat to Depth II, does it return to Depth I later that day?
  • Can I use the Can of Worms to peek at a deeper Shoal and then fish a different Shoal?
  • How do peek effects work with a fish that is already face up, and do its reveal abilities trigger again?
  • Does a card that says to flip your Can of Worms work whether the can is full or empty?
  • When another player's card makes a Fish reveal, who gets the reveal ability's effect?
  • What does the Heart of the Fathoms item do, and does a fish that discards itself stop it?
  • When an item reveals several fish, do I resolve each reveal before revealing the next?
  • If I am limited to the column where I caught a fish, and an item reveals fish in another column, can I fish either column?
  • Can more than one player fish from the same Shoal?
  • Does a Refresh ability take a die from the Spent pool, or can it take a Fresh die?
  • If a Shark's effect takes my last Fresh die so I cannot pay for a Dink, do I still get the Dink?
  • Does emptying a Shoal in some other way than catching its last fish give a Regret?
  • After I abandon ship, can I take Port actions that same turn?
  • What does the Lifeboat do, and what does it cost?
  • Does dropping a sinker with the Bone Wheel cost a whole die?
  • With the Bone Wheel, how is change taken when a fish takes two or more dice, and can it save a die at zero?
  • With the Bone Wheel, where does the change go when I spend an orange die?
  • With the Bone Wheel, do I get change back when a fish requires exactly two or three dice?
  • Does Bucket of Chum make the Sub Matriarch free, whatever fish I hold?
  • When can I use the Cloche, and does the Claw Hammer need Port?
  • Can I use the Rod of the Infinite on every cast during one day?
  • If I choose not to trigger a fish's ability with the Rod of the Dead, what happens to the fish?
  • Does taking a passing reward count as a fishing action for the Centerpin Reel's triple Dink?
  • Can I use free actions, such as Dinks, supplies, eating Fish or the Life Preserver, during a fishing action?
  • Can I spend some dice toward a fish, refresh them, and spend them again on the same fish?
  • After I cast at a Shoal, can I flip more Shoals or keep fishing elsewhere?

Fish Anatomy

  • Does a Fish with no printed Difficulty, such as Giant Cuttlefish, trigger its reveal ability?
  • Can you catch a Fish that has no printed Difficulty by fishing normally?
  • Can a Fish's Value ever be reduced below zero, and what does it sell for if Madness makes it negative?
  • Must you have a card to discard before you can catch a Fish whose catch ability forces a discard?
  • Does Heart of the Fathoms reveal every Fish in the sea or just the top Fish of each shoal?
  • When a Fish effect says all players, does it also reach players in port or far from the sea?
  • When a Fish says it cannot be mounted and makes other Fish easier to catch, does that affect every player or only its controller?
  • Is every card from the sea a Fish, even a foot, a mammal or the Amulet, for effects like a shark discard?
  • Must a Dink with a discard symbol be discarded right away?
  • Does The Plug trigger for players who have already passed, or for players in port?
  • Does The Plug trigger on the turn a player decides to pass?
  • With The Plug, which Fish do you discard: face up, face down, or from the top-left pile?
  • Do reveal abilities trigger when a Fish is revealed by an item, a Supply or a reveal-all effect rather than by fishing?
  • With a reveal-all effect, if the top Fish of a Shoal is discarded or caught, do you reveal the Fish beneath it?
  • If Mollusk reveals Gloom Orphan, does the active player catch it automatically?
  • If a Fish says it is caught automatically, can you decline it and take a Dink instead?
  • Can you eat any Fish at any stage of fishing, and must it have an eat ability?
  • Do Parasitic Larvae, Colossal Squid and Gloom Orphan keep their abilities after being sold or mounted?
  • If you sell Parasitic Larvae, does its extra-Regret ability apply to that sale?
  • If you use Rod of the Dead to ignore a Fish's reveal or catch ability, does the ability still affect other players?
  • If Rod of the Dead lets you skip a no-difficulty Fish's text, is the Fish still discarded?
  • When a Fish's coin flip gives all other players $1 on Tails, do you get nothing too?
  • When a Fish's reveal or Heads or Tails effect does not say all players, who does it apply to?
  • Does Varicolla's red anchor Regret icon apply when you catch it, or only when you sell it?
  • How does Brittle Lung work, and is it lost if you don't catch it that turn?
  • How does the Mollusk's eat ability work?
  • When a card says to discard one small Fish, can it come from Fish face up in front of you, or only from your hand?
  • Does the vertical divider between two abilities on the same line mean 'or'?
  • Does Trauma Leech stay in your hand if you are the player with the most Regret cards when you draw it?
  • What is the catch difficulty of Fugu (Porcupinefish) when it is revealed and on later turns?
  • Does Tri-Tentacle count itself when its catch ability draws a Regret for each Foul Fish in hand?
  • When a Fish requires an exact number of dice, must the dice also meet its Difficulty, and do values or items change the count?
  • Are Fish reveal effects mandatory?
  • Does a catch ability that says reveal count as catching the Fish?
  • When Remora reveals a Shark from your hand, does the Shark stay face up in front of you?
  • What does it mean to reveal a card from your hand, such as Sea Lamprey's catch?
  • After catching a Colossal Squid, can you still fish in other columns?
  • How does Vampire Squid's cost reduction work when several players are at depth II?
  • When you swap Hadal Shade for another player's mounted Fish, where does Hadal Shade go?
  • Are the eyes on the Omen Die pips, and does the Omen Die affect Madness?
  • Can a Shark discard the Amulet of Agartha, and what happens to the Omen Die?
  • When the Lamentable Tentacles Great Old One is revealed, can you move your boat from Port straight to Sea?
  • How does Giant Cuttlefish's catch-underneath effect resolve with the reveal ability of the Fish beneath it?
  • Are Fish displayed face up in front of you considered in hand for abilities like discard, Giant Isopod or Sub Matriarch?

Port Actions

  • Can you use Can of Worms while your boat is docked at Port?
  • Can you use Dinks, Supply items and eat Fish while at Port, and can you use Supplies right after buying something?
  • Can you use an item at Port, and do reveal abilities trigger when you do?
  • Can you use a Reel's ability while at Port, and when does a newly bought rod or reel become usable?
  • Can you sell a Fish displayed face up in front of you, and can you sell a Fish worth nothing or less?
  • Can you use a Dink to change your Madness mid-sale, so some Fish sell at a different price?
  • At Port, can you make several purchases with a single action?
  • Can you sell or mount Fish in several separate actions during one Port visit, or over several turns while in port?
  • When can you sell Fish: at any Port visit, or only at the end of the week?
  • When you buy Tackle Dice at Port, do you draw at random from the bag or choose a color?
  • How can a player reach eight dice, the maximum?
  • When buying Tackle Dice takes you over your max dice, which dice move to the Spent Pool?
  • After you buy an item at the Shop, do the other revealed items shuffle back into the deck or go to the bottom?
  • Can you replace a mounted Fish with a different one later in the game?
  • Can you mount a Fish that is displayed face up in front of you?
  • If you pass while in port, do you still get the passing reward?
  • Can you use your Fresh dice in port after refreshing them there?
  • Does a Fish's face-up negative effect stop when you mount it?

Make Port

  • When calculating refresh at Port, which dice can you reroll?
  • When a refresh or item returns dice from the Spent Pool, do you re-roll them?
  • When you make Port, does the Can of Worms flip, and is the flip a separate ability?
  • Can you return from Port to Sea on the same day you made Port?

Regrets

  • Where do discarded Regrets go, and is that pile shuffled when the Regret deck runs out?
  • If the Regret draw and discard piles are both empty, can you take Regrets from different players?
  • In a 2-player game, which mounted Fish do you lose when you have the highest Regret value?
  • When you must discard your highest-valued mounted Fish, do you compare printed values or calculated values after Madness and the mount multiplier?
  • When an effect makes several or every player draw or discard Regrets at once, in what order is it resolved?
  • When an ability says you draw and then all other players draw too, who draws first?
  • Do players who have already passed still suffer effects that say all players draw Regrets?
  • When do you draw Regrets?
  • When you must discard a Regret, or a card or Port action says to, can you choose which one?
  • If a rule says to discard a Regret, can you decline to discard it?
  • When you pass, is the Regret you discard chosen by you or random?
  • Can Iron Coffin's Regret exchange be used repeatedly on the same day?
  • Gloom Orphan's Weather draws one more Regret: if you would draw three, how many do you take?
  • Do you draw a Regret when an effect, such as The Plug, empties the last Fish of a Shoal?

Madness

  • If Madness drops and you have more Fresh dice than your maximum, must you move some out of the Fresh pool?
  • If your Madness keeps extra dice out of your Fresh pool, can they move to Fresh if Madness changes during the day?

The End

  • When players tie for the highest total Regret Value, including at zero, who discards a mounted Fish?
  • In a 2-player game, which mounted Fish is discarded when both players tie for the highest Regret Value?
  • If you have the highest Regret value and a Fish is mounted on the Cloche, do you lose the Cloche Fish as well as your highest-value mounted Fish?
  • If the player with the most Regrets has no mounted Fish at game end, do they lose anything extra?
  • What is the highest score a single mounted Fish can give?
  • Are leftover Fishbucks counted in the final score?
  • Are Regrets subtracted from the score?
  • Does The Plug ending the sea end the game immediately?
  • Do Parasitic Larvae, Colossal Squid and Gloom Orphan still score if they are face up in front of you, not mounted?
  • What happens to the yellow Tackle Dice received on the final turn if you are already at your dice limit?

Solo / Co-operative: Ocean Survey

  • How does Treasure Chest work in solo (Ocean Survey) mode?
  • What size should Box Jellyfish, Corpse and Sockeye Salmon be in solo mode?
  • In solo mode, are spent tackle dice discarded?
  • In solo mode, do money, Regrets, Dinks or unspent points carry over to the next game or week?
  • Is The Plug recorded on the solo ocean survey sheet?
  • In solo mode, do tackle dice you buy in the shop stay with you for the campaign, and can you buy more than one of a colour?
  • In solo mode, do spent tackle dice go back into the bag, or are they available every day?
  • In solo mode, do you discard revealed fish that were not caught at the start of each new day?
  • In solo mode, does the Can of Worms refresh each day or is it one use per game?
  • Does a fish being Foul or Fair matter in solo mode?
  • In solo setup, do you remove the fish listed on the cards, and does the survey sheet have enough spaces for every fish?
  • In solo with Lamentable Tentacles, do fish stacks stay 13 deep, and can you make sure a particular fish is in the game?
  • For solo items marked once per game, is a game a single week or the whole campaign?
  • In solo mode, does bringing a fish back at the end of the week count as selling and give a Regret?
  • In solo mode, what happens if the Colossal Squid empties the column I am locked into?
  • In solo mode, does a depth change or one-use equipment last past the current week?
  • Can I use the Lamentable Tentacles cards in solo mode?
  • In solo mode, can fish be sold, and do sell-based effects apply?
  • After a solo week, are fish and Regrets reshuffled back into the setup?
  • In solo mode, does a reveal that gives the fish to the player with the most regrets still apply?
  • Does Colossal Squid keep you fishing in its column only for that day, or until the end of the week?
  • In solo, do you keep the Omen Die from Amulet of Agartha for later games?
  • In solo, are fish you have already documented removed from the deck for later games?
  • In solo, do fish I have already documented count toward end-of-week value when I catch them again?
  • In solo, what do you do with Supplies, Rods, and Reels that are not on the Ocean Survey?
  • In solo, does the boat stay at its depth after you use a die to go deeper?
  • In solo, do fish you caught earlier in the week count as in your hand for Sub Matriarch?
  • In solo, can Dink cards that reduce shop costs be used at the end of the week?
  • In solo, do you draw Regrets for foul fish you bring back at the end of the week?
  • In solo, which Regrets count toward your final score?
  • In solo, do pre-printed fish on the survey count toward end-of-week value?
  • Does Overmind's mounting ability apply in solo mode?
  • In solo mode, how do you discard an item?
  • In a 2-player co-operative solo game, do you share one character?

Appendix

  • Does the Lucky Pole still work if the first fish revealed has no printed Difficulty?
  • How does the Rod of the Infinite work after the nerf?
  • Did the Rod of the Infinite nerf change the Rod of the Deep?
  • Can the original and the nerfed Rod of the Infinite be shuffled into the same game?
  • With Rod of the Dead, what happens if you ignore the reveal ability of a Fish such as Parasitic Larvae or Gloom Orphan?
  • Does the Amulet of Agarta count as a small Fish for discard effects?
  • Can you keep a zero-value die with the Bone Wheel?
  • Does a mounted Fish keep its ability, such as Gloom Orphan's?
  • When a shark forces you to discard small fish and you have none in hand, must you discard a mounted small fish?
  • How often can you use Whispering Skull's peek: once per turn, or once per day?
  • If a fish's catch ability requires discarding an item or small fish you don't have, can you still catch it?
  • Does Bone Wheel's refund let you rotate a die down instead of spending it?
  • Can Bone Wheel's refund cover a die spent on a dink or on dropping a sinker?

Reference

  • What does Peek mean, and does peeking trigger a Reveal ability?
  • When you peek at a face-up Fish with an item, what happens to it?
  • Where do discarded or used Rods, Reels, Supplies, Dinks, Regrets and Fish go?
  • Does the Cycle the Market icon on the reference card do anything?
  • What does Increment do, and does 'next highest value' mean the next value above the current one?
  • Can Increment be used on a spent die?
  • When you refresh a die, must you roll it?
  • What does 'Refresh (single action)' mean on the Icon Reference: does each refresh apply to one die only?
  • Can Whispering Skull or another peek effect let you look at fish in another player's hand?
  • Do Mermaid's Eyes let you peek at two Shoals, or at two cards from one Shoal?
  • What does 'peek' mean for Book of the Deep or Curious Spyglass?

General

  • Do effects that hit all players also affect players at Port or players who have already passed?
  • When uninstalling the mini-expansion, do you also remove Psychic Interloper?
  • When an effect says to discard a Fish or item, which cards are eligible?
  • Does Psychic Interloper have the tentacle icon for Lamentable Tentacles?
  • Are items, Dinks, Regrets, and caught fish kept face down in your hand?
  • Is there a limit on how many fish you can hold in your hand?
  • Does Whispering Skull keep working while you are at port?
  • If a card gives an increment of 2, can it be split across two dice?
  • Does Rod of the Infinite have limited uses?

Even Deeper RegretsExpansion

  • Can Rod of the Dead be used on an uncatchable Fish such as The Dam?
  • Where can Nightcrawlers or Can of Worms be used, and can Nightcrawlers reveal sea Fish?
  • Is Corryvreckan discarded as soon as its effect triggers, and what happens to its Shoal?
  • How does Hamish the Boa Constrictor count for Madness?
  • How does Leon the Chameleon change end-game Regret Value?
  • Can a player's total Regret Value be negative, and who discards a mounted Fish then?
  • When calculating Polyp value, which Polyps count?
  • When using only some expansion sea fish, must all Polyps be included?
  • Does an ability that reveals all Fish also reveal Inland shoals?
  • How are columns and rows laid out in Inland?
  • How should Bad Penny, Lucky and Feesh be handled, given the infinite loop with empty shoals?
  • Does the game end when the sea is empty but Inland still has fish?
  • How do you catch Queen of Cadzow in solo mode?
  • In solo mode, do Bottlenose Dolphin and Corryvreckan take coin-flip actions?
  • If the Dog Eilidh is in play, can opponents still take Clout from you?
  • When a card gives you the Omen Die that another player holds, what happens?
  • If discarding a Rod or Reel of Agartha gains the Omen Die, is the die yours for good?
  • Do Reacher Marlin and Eldritch Sea Spider draw a Regret when sold?
  • Does Even Deeper Regrets change the solo mode?
  • Can I use Fish Totem after I have already started a fishing action this turn?
  • When Rocabarraigh is revealed, does it discard from the inland shoals (River and Loch) as well?
  • If the Clout bag is empty when I need to draw a Clout, whom do I take it from?
  • Can Bean-Nighe be scored, and what does she cost at game end?
  • If you sell Bairn Bane, how many Regrets do you take?
  • When you leave Port, can you go to Inland instead of Sea?
  • When a card says to discard Clout, do you discard all your Clout or one token?
  • If a KS card like Feesh is placed on a Shoal by an effect such as Fish Totem, how does it behave?
  • Does 'any one shoal' on Polyp Colony mean only Shoals in the same location as the card?
  • If Eldritch Spider protects your most valuable mounted fish from the Regret penalty, must you discard the next fish?
  • How does The Black Sphere work: must the chosen player fish that Shoal, and can it be used at Port?
  • Is peeking at or flipping a Naval Mine an action?
  • Does Cube Jellyfish's ability to ignore discards also stop discards directly from a shoal, such as the Leatherback Turtle?
  • What does the Nessie the Loch Blob ability to discard all fish in the Loch remove?
  • Are Bottlenose Dolphin and The Corryvreckan used in solo play?
  • Are Polyps included in solo play?
  • Can Nightcrawlers be used at sea to peek at an inland shoal?
  • Can you use a Can of Worms while Inland to peek at a sea shoal?
  • Can you use Nightcrawlers or a Can of Worms while in Port?