Deep Regrets
If a fish's catch ability requires discarding an item or small fish you don't have, can you still catch it?
The designer answered this directly on BGG, and the rulebook's All Sharks note says the shark is caught regardless.
- Deep Regrets rulebook · Rulebook · Fish Clarification
- judson_cowan · Designer · 2025-04-14
- sundaysmag · Community · 2025-05-03
- judson_cowan · Designer · 2025-05-03
Yes. A catch ability triggers only after the fish is caught, so it is not a condition for catching the fish. If you have nothing to discard, the effect is skipped.