Deep Regrets
Must you have a card to discard before you can catch a Fish whose catch ability forces a discard?
The designer ruled that catch abilities resolve after the catch, and the rulebook's appendix on sharks says the same.
- judson_cowan · Designer · 2025-04-21
- judson_cowan · Designer · 2025-04-04
- Moose Malloy · Community · 2025-04-03
- judson_cowan · Designer · 2026-06-28
- inm8 · Community · 2025-04-29
- PeterM2158 · Community · 2026-06-28disagrees
- Deep Regrets rulebook · Rulebook · Fish Clarification
No. The discard happens after the catch, so if you have nothing to discard the effect fizzles and you still catch the Fish. The same applies to sharks that ask you to discard a small Fish, which is why the Appendix says to catch the shark regardless.