RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
Here I Stand thumbnail

Here I Stand FAQ

902 questions players ask · Updated Nov 15, 2026 · Full rulebook

GeneralGame MapPowers and RulersMilitary UnitsCardsSequence of PlayDiplomacySpring Deployment and the Action PhaseControl & UnrestMovementField BattleSiegeNaval AffairsUnit ConstructionThe ReformationWinterThe New WorldMajor PowersMinor PowersVictoryHere I Stand: 2-Player Diplomacy Deck

General

  • Where is the 1532 setup listed, and which spaces are the 19 Protestant spaces?
  • Is the Scots Raid card in the 1517 and 1532 starting decks?
  • Why do the Ottoman home keys have Catholic-side control markers?
  • Can the 500th Anniversary rule changes be used with 2010 edition components?
  • Are hexagonal control markers limited, and what if you run out?

Game Map

  • Is Malta in the Italian language zone?
  • Is Calais in the French language zone, and is it an English home space for Protestant VP?
  • Are Hapsburg-controlled German spaces Hapsburg home spaces, including for Charles V's teleport?
  • How is distance counted for "within X spaces" and for the nearest fortified space in Winter?
  • Are the Tyrrhenian Sea and the Ionian Sea adjacent?
  • Is London a two-zone port?
  • Is Milan a French home space in the 1517 scenario?

Powers and Rulers

  • If a ruler is captured, does his power still get his card bonus and admin rating?
  • Where do the Hapsburgs place SCMs when they take German electorates?
  • Can a home card be played only for CPs?
  • If Gout stops Charles V's transfer, can the Duke of Alva transfer on his own?
  • Must a Hapsburg home space be Hapsburg-controlled for Charles V's home card teleport?
  • Why does English General Dudley have no square regular counter?
  • Does excommunicating Luther reduce the Protestant hand size?
  • If a major power you are at war with has activated a minor power, are that minor's units your enemies?

Military Units

  • Do mercenaries count as Catholic or Protestant units for conversions?
  • Is the Knights of St John unit a cavalry unit, even when a besieger attacks it?
  • How many land units can a fortified space or capital hold?
  • Can the Pope defend in a space with more than four land units?
  • Can a power voluntarily remove or disband its own units, to make change or to rebuild elsewhere?
  • Is there a limit on how many units can occupy one space?
  • Can a formation that has no leader still move and fight?
  • Do two leaders in one stack add their command ratings together?
  • Can a stronger land unit on the map be swapped for several smaller units of the same type from the pool?

Cards

  • Can Roxelana's return of Suleiman be used when Suleiman has been captured, and by a power other than the Ottoman?
  • Can Roxelana return Suleiman to Istanbul after the Habsburgs have captured Istanbul?
  • If Roxelana is played for CP or as an event, must the choice be declared before moves are made?
  • Does Roxelana's free assault apply to a key, or only to a fortress?
  • Can Diplomatic Overture be played as an event when you have no card to give another power?
  • Is the card given under Diplomatic Overture shown to the other players?
  • Does "played as last card" for Diplomatic Overture include a Home Card?
  • Does Diplomatic Overture let the giver choose the card to hand over?
  • Can a Mandatory Event card be held in hand from one turn to the next?
  • What happens to Schmalkaldic League or Master of Italy when drawn but its condition is not met, including on turn 1?
  • If a Mandatory Event is drawn at random for a discard or draw, what happens to it?
  • Can you choose to discard a Mandatory Event card, for example one drawn by Patron of the Arts or Sack of Rome?
  • Is Defender of the Faith removed from the game after it is played, even if its event does nothing?
  • Why do some event cards say "remove from deck if played as event" while Mandatory Events do not?
  • Are Edward VI, Mary and Elizabeth events mandatory even if no player is dealt them?
  • Can the Gout card stop a naval leader's move?
  • Does Gout stop the whole formation from moving or assaulting, or only its leader?
  • Can Gout be played against Treachery, which is an event rather than a CP spend?
  • When can The Wartburg be played against a Leipzig Debate?
  • Can the Wartburg card be used to cancel a battle card, a Home Card or a Mandatory Event?
  • Does playing Halley's Comet in response cancel the event just played?
  • When can Halley's Comet be played?
  • Can a Response card be played in reaction to an event, such as Akinji Raiders or a discard event, before it resolves?
  • When can a Response card be played, and can several answer the same trigger?
  • Can a card just played as an event be played again, or picked back up, in the same turn?
  • Can Here I Stand retrieve a card another power played as an event this turn?
  • Can Here I Stand be played as a Response card to claim a card from the discard pile?
  • Must the Protestant reveal which card is taken from the discard pile when using Here I Stand?
  • Can the Protestant build or receive mercenaries from cards before the Schmalkaldic League forms?
  • Must Landsknechts or Swiss Mercenaries played as a response in battle be placed in the battle space?
  • Can Landsknechts or Swiss Mercenaries add mercenaries for another power, or into an ally's spaces?
  • Can Landsknechts added in a field battle be another power's mercenaries?
  • Can any power play Landsknechts as an event to add or eliminate mercenaries?
  • If Landsknechts or Swiss Mercenaries add units before a field battle, are they limited by the formation size?
  • Can Landsknechts or Swiss Mercenaries be played before a fortified space goes under siege, so the garrison can withdraw inside?
  • When can the Swiss Mercenaries card add mercenaries to a fortified space?
  • When Unsanitary Camp is played, which stack is hit, and can it eliminate a single unit?
  • If Unsanitary Camp is played on a besieging stack, can Swiss Mercenaries played in response still be placed in the besieged space?
  • When Mercenaries Bribed adds units to a stack in a field battle, must you swap counters?
  • When Mercenaries Bribed and Surprise Attack are both played in one field battle, which resolves first?
  • Do mercenaries bribed or placed in a Sack of Rome battle fight in that battle?
  • Does Mercenaries Grow Restless remove mercenaries outside the assaulting formation, or from a Sack of Rome battle?
  • Does "removed from play" on Mercenaries Grow Restless remove the mercenaries from the game permanently?
  • For Mercenaries Demand Pay, are mercenaries counted as units or as physical counters?
  • Can a power give mercenaries to another power it is at war with?
  • Can Clement VII and Paul III both be in play when the Paul III card is in a hand and Clement VII is still in the deck?
  • When does Copernicus enter the deck?
  • When can Copernicus or Servetus be played, and can Copernicus give victory points to another power?
  • Can Plantations be placed on a power that has no colonies?
  • Does Thomas Cromwell cancel only the excommunication, or also the debate, when used against Papal Bull?
  • Can the Papacy play Maurice of Saxony in a 2-player game?
  • When Maurice of Saxony is played for the Hapsburgs, is he removed in Winter, and can the event bring him back later?
  • If Maurice of Saxony is captured when his card is played, does he switch sides no matter which power captured him?
  • Does the Printing Press card give three Reformation attempts in each language zone, or three in total?
  • When England declares war on Scotland with the Six Wives card, does France intervene for free?
  • After Henry VIII dies, can England still declare war on France or the Hapsburgs with Six Wives of Henry VIII?
  • Can the Six Wives card be played when Henry is the besieger rather than the besieged?
  • Can the Papacy be excused from a Bloody Mary-diverted card's action when the Pope would rather not debate?
  • Can the Ottoman build corsairs with Shipbuilding before the Barbary Pirates event has occurred?
  • Can Foul Weather be played during a Scots Raid event that another power triggered?
  • When City State Rebels hits a key where an ally's units stand, do the allied units take losses, and must the eliminated units belong to the controlling power?
  • If City State Rebels inflicts a hit the controlling power cannot make change for, does the key revert?
  • If the Hapsburgs play Imperial Coronation with Charles V in the Italian zone, do they draw two cards?
  • Can Andrea Doria be played as an event to activate Genoa, including while Genoa is unaligned or inactive?
  • Can Shipbuilding build fleets for an allied minor power, such as Scotland, in that power's home port?
  • Can Venetian Alliance or Shipbuilding bring back fleets that were eliminated earlier in the same turn?
  • Can Search for Cibola cancel a Voyage of Conquest released by Smallpox, or cancel a Cabot exploration?
  • If Fountain of Youth cancels Cabot, does Cabot's explorer die, and is the Cabot counter in the random draw?
  • Can a Cabot explorer be drawn as a random explorer when an Exploration Underway draw happens?
  • After one power's Cabot discovers a place, can the other powers still use their Cabot explorers?
  • Must Auld Alliance be played immediately after England declares war on Scotland?
  • Can France add its Swiss Mercenaries or Landsknechts to a Scottish stack while the two are allied?
  • Can the Scots Raid booty build units anywhere other than Scotland, such as in France?
  • Can Charles Bourbon and his mercenaries be placed in a space you control that is under siege, or does a reformer make a space occupied?
  • Can Charles Bourbon be placed in a minor power that you have activated?
  • Does Charles Bourbon act as an extra leader for one turn, letting a formation exceed four units?
  • Can Trace Italienne be played in a space you control if enemy units occupy it?
  • When the Knights of St. John draw a card for St. Peter's, or take one from the Ottoman, does the power keep the card?
  • Where does Dragut go when Barbarossa dies after Barbarossa is already out of the game?
  • After a Sack of Rome papal defeat, what happens if the St. Peter's track has fewer than 5 CP?
  • With Search for Cibola, is a random explorer placed on the turn track when an Exploration or Conquest underway marker is used?
  • After Foul Weather costs a CP, can the formation keep moving into the same unfortified space on the next point?
  • When the Schmalkaldic League forms, do the Hapsburgs get the VPs for electorates not under Protestant control?
  • Can the Knights of St. John be placed in a space that is under siege or holds enemy units?
  • Can the Papacy play City State Rebels against a Hapsburg key while the two are allied?
  • If the target key of City State Rebels has no troops or fleet left, does the revolt succeed automatically?
  • Who chooses where Dudley is placed when the Edward VI card is played?
  • Can the Protestant play Venetian Informant during spring without having an impulse?
  • Does the Sack of Rome card's loss of 5 CP from St. Peter's also move the VP track down?
  • Can Philip of Hesse be removed from the game with Bigamy while he is captured?
  • Can a power use Foreign War to raise new troops elsewhere once the card's required troops are already met?
  • On Cloth Prices Fluctuate, does the unrest clause apply when Action A is chosen?
  • Can units in a Treachery siege's naval forces be destroyed when the fortified space falls?
  • Does Treachery count defending naval units when checking whether the besiegers outnumber the garrison?
  • Can the Council of Trent's two Protestant participants come from different language zones?
  • Can a player describe or share the cards seen with a Venetian Informant, and make a deal on that information?
  • Can a diplomatic marriage be played to activate a minor power on behalf of another power?
  • Do repeated Master of Italy VP awards accumulate?
  • When do discarded event cards return to the deck?
  • If a random discard selects your Home Card, what happens?
  • Is it compulsory to fight a foreign war, or is resolving a Foreign War optional for the major power?
  • Can a power play Mercator's Map to launch a Voyage of Exploration for another power?
  • Where are cards added to the deck by a rule or scenario placed?
  • Can England use besieging units for an external war under the Revolt in Ireland card?
  • Can City State Rebels be played on a space that is under siege?
  • Can City-State Rebels be played on Wittenberg?
  • If City State Rebels removes the French from a conquered Genoa, do they stay at war with France?
  • Which units does City State Rebels place: independent units or the minor's?
  • Can City State Rebels give another power control of an independent Tunis?
  • Does Schmalkaldic League make the Hapsburgs and Papacy allies, and what happens to Hapsburg-held spaces such as Rome in the 2-player variant?
  • When Schmalkaldic League is played, what happens to Hapsburg control markers in German spaces?
  • Does the Schmalkaldic League convert spaces that hold a Fortress marker?
  • Can a player play a Combat card to help a power whose units are not in the battle?
  • If Lady Jane Grey is played by the Pope or Protestant, can they draw both cards?
  • Can a national home card be spent only for its Command Points, ignoring its event text?
  • Does the Scots Raid leave play after it occurs, as the mandatory-event rule suggests?
  • When Swiss Mercenaries are played in your own impulse, can you build them into an empty home space?
  • Can the Spanish Inquisition card make the Hapsburg player discard a specific card from the English or Protestant hand?
  • When Master of Italy is played in the 2-player variant after France conquers Venice and Florence, do VP go to the Protestants?
  • Does the Papal Inquisition card let Caraffa take part in the debate it starts?
  • If Oran or Tripoli was converted to Protestantism, does playing Pirate Haven on it leave it Protestant?
  • Can France use a Shipbuilding card played while allied with the Ottoman to build Ottoman squadrons in an Ottoman-controlled port?
  • Does the New Scots Raid card give France 6 CP when Stirling is already under French control?
  • Can the Shipbuilding card build Ottoman corsairs in Algiers or a pirate haven?
  • If the Protestant wins a Counter-Reformation Sword Attack and captures leaders in a space it cannot control, does the space revert to independent?
  • Can the Plague card target electorates converted to Protestant before the Schmalkaldic League?
  • Can Threat to Power target a minor army leader who is fighting a Foreign War?
  • When is the result of Master of Italy checked?
  • If the Papacy does not control Rome, does it still defend Sack of Rome with a die?
  • After Hungary falls and the Hapsburgs control its spaces, which regular does Trace Italienne place in a Hungarian space?
  • Can Treachery be played on a stack besieging a fortified space, or to force an assault on a siege that is not your own?
  • Can Here I Stand reactivate Luther after the Pope's Leipzig Debate sequesters him?
  • Does Huguenot Raiders need a Protestant French home port, and does it stay in play after that port loses Protestant influence?
  • Can Surprise Attack be combined with Field Artillery for two bonus dice?
  • Does the Spanish Inquisition card work when no Spanish spaces are Protestant?
  • Does the Ransom card exist in the two-player game?
  • Do you spend command points to play an event card?
  • Does the Papal Inquisition draw from another power's hand have to be random?
  • For the Scots Raid card, which units are counted?
  • Why are some cards purple-backed, and are they used in the full game?
  • Can Knights of St John be placed in a Hapsburg port that holds Hapsburg or loaned fleets?
  • Does Calvin Expelled's Commit Calvin instruction leave Calvin committed in the next turn?
  • If Cloth Prices Fluctuate is your only card and you play it as an event, does the event still resolve?
  • Can the Surprise Attack card be played in a siege, or a field-battle combat card be played in an assault?
  • Does the Holy Roman Emperor card let the Hapsburgs move Charles V with troops?
  • When "at least half" of losses must be regular troops, is an odd number rounded up?
  • If Trace Italienne fortifies a space occupied by enemy units, what happens?
  • With the Treachery card, does the attacker take a fortress when it has more units but loses the assault roll?
  • Is Algiers in play before Barbary Pirates is played?
  • Whose fortified home space must Siege Artillery's line of communication reach?
  • Can Threat to Power target any minor army leader, or only the named ones?
  • Does the card text or the page 16 impulse example govern how many reformation attempts Katharina Bora gives?
  • What happens to the Thomas More card when Henry marries Anne Boleyn and the card is played?
  • Can the same power play the Plantations card twice in a game?

Sequence of Play

  • How many cards does a power draw in the Card Draw Phase if it has lost all its keys?
  • Can the Hapsburgs and France end their war in Turn 1?
  • How many turns does the game last?
  • Can England roll on the Pregnancy Chart after the Pope grants a divorce and again when it plays Six Wives of Henry VIII in the same turn?
  • Can powers other than England and France, or England and the Habsburgs, make deals on Turn 1?
  • Can England declare war on the Habsburgs on the first turn of the 1517 scenario after allying with France?

Diplomacy

  • If the Papacy is already at war with Venice, can it still intervene after a later declaration of war on Venice?
  • Can Diplomatic Marriage activate or deactivate a minor power during the Diplomacy Phase?
  • When suing for peace recovers only one non-key home space, do you still pay 1 VP?
  • Can players show or describe their cards to each other during Diplomacy?
  • Can a diplomatic agreement or alliance offer be conditional on another power's action?
  • Can you promise in the Diplomacy Phase that another power will sue for peace?
  • Can one announcement bind three powers in a single deal?
  • Can a space be passed on again in the same negotiation, such as Ottoman to Habsburg to French?
  • If a power receives mercenaries but has no room in its counter mix, does the unit go back to the giver?
  • Must the other power accept a sue-for-peace offer?
  • Can two powers at war agree to peace and form an alliance in the same Diplomacy Phase?
  • Can two powers end a war by mutual agreement without either suing for peace?
  • If two powers at war both sue for peace in the same turn, do both earn War Winner VP?
  • Can powers swap keys in negotiations and then have one of them sue for peace?
  • When a power sues for peace, must it give back a home space it gained earlier through diplomacy?
  • In a sue for peace, who decides which keys, leaders and spaces come back?
  • Does the losing power give up its own VP when it pays a War Winner VP to regain a key?
  • Can a ransomed or regained Protestant leader return when the Protestants have no capital or home keys?
  • Does a power need permission to move through an ally's territory or retreat into an allied fortress?
  • Can a captured leader be ransomed without the capturing power's consent, and must the capturer accept?
  • Can a third power pay the ransom for another power's captured leader?
  • When ransoming one of several captured leaders, who chooses which one comes back?
  • When a power sues for peace, does it get its captured leaders back for free?
  • Where does a captured leader go on ransom or return when his capital is under enemy control?
  • Does suing for peace cost the losing power any VP?
  • Does a power that wins a war involving the Ottomans get 2 VP?
  • Can a power sue for peace without losing a home space or an army leader?
  • Can a power sue for peace when it has no units on the map left to remove?
  • Can a key given away in diplomacy be taken back later?
  • In a sue for peace, can the losing power regain home spaces lost in an earlier war that the winner still holds?
  • Does suing for peace return minor-power keys, or keys that are not the winner's home?
  • Can a power sue for peace with more than one power in the same turn?
  • When a sued power's units are displaced, can they split between the nearest fortified space and the capital?
  • Where do a power's naval units go when a sea space changes hands in a peace settlement?
  • Can a power give a key or electorate it controls to another major power, even an enemy's capital?
  • Can a major power give control of an allied minor power's key to another power?
  • When the Papacy grants Henry's divorce, does the marker move to Anne Boleyn at once?
  • When can the Pope grant Henry's divorce, and what if England moves the marker and the Pope refuses?
  • Can excommunication be lifted without making peace, and must the Papacy accept the payment?
  • Does excommunication stay with the power or the ruler when the ruler dies?
  • Can the other side refuse a sue-for-peace concession, a ransom, or the removal of an excommunication?
  • Can the Hapsburgs declare war on the Ottomans before Hungary falls?
  • Can one player's two major powers fight each other in a game of fewer than six players?
  • Can you declare war on Venice in the Diplomacy Phase while allied with the Papacy?
  • Can France or the Papacy declare war on its natural ally, Scotland or Venice?
  • Can the Habsburgs declare war on Venice to bring the Papacy in?
  • Can England use its Home card to declare war on an ally?
  • Can England declare war on Scotland while allied to France, including with its Home card?
  • Can England make peace with France and then declare war on France again later in the same Action Phase with its Home card?
  • Can a power declare war on a power it made peace with earlier in the same turn?
  • Does England pay CP when it declares war with its Home card?
  • When England's Home card declares war on Scotland, must France play a card to intervene?
  • What does declaring war on a minor power cost in CP?
  • How is CP paid for declarations and interventions in the Diplomacy Phase?
  • Can a Mandatory Event card be used to declare war?
  • Must a power declare war in the Diplomacy Phase before moving into another power's spaces?
  • Can a major power be allied with two other major powers at the same time?
  • Can two powers that are at war be allied at the same time?
  • Does declaring war on a power also put you at war with its ally?
  • If the Habsburgs declare war on France, does that put them at war with England, France's ally?
  • Can allied powers combine their land units to attack or besiege the same space?
  • Can a power loan fleets to an allied minor power, and does an allied minor's fleet need a loan?
  • How is the nearest port measured for loaned squadrons, and where can they be stationed?
  • What happens to loaned squadrons if the lender and borrower go to war in the same turn?
  • Can a power give spaces, cards or mercenaries to an enemy in an agreement?
  • How many random cards can one power give another in a turn, and do separate deals add up?
  • Can a power give away a card draw or let another player draw from its hand during the Action Phase?
  • Can the Pope and the Ottomans exchange cards, or play events for each other?
  • When Diplomatic Overture gives a card to another power, does the playing player choose which card?
  • Can players talk strategy, make threats or strike deals before the game or outside the Diplomacy Phase?
  • In a deal among several powers, who announces it, and must later powers confirm on their turn?
  • Within one agreement, must the changes be made in a fixed order?
  • If an offer bundles several items, can the other side accept only some of them?
  • Does giving up a home space in negotiation stop a power suing for peace that turn?

Spring Deployment and the Action Phase

  • Can spring deployment cross more than one sea zone, even with Spring Preparations?
  • Can spring deployment cross a pass and a sea zone in the same move?
  • Can England spring deploy to Calais while a French fleet sits in Brest?
  • Do fleets in ports block spring deployment across their sea zone, even allied ones?
  • Can naval units still be in a sea zone during Spring Deployment, blocking a crossing?
  • Is spring deployment across a sea zone capped at five units?
  • Can a power spring deploy from a capital that is in unrest?
  • Can spring deployment pass through electorates before the Schmalkaldic League?
  • Can Protestant troops block Hapsburg spring deployment before the Schmalkaldic League?
  • Does a formation in spring deployment need a leader?
  • Do squadrons loaned to another power block your troops during spring deployment?
  • Can you construct a unit and then move it in the same impulse?
  • Can you fight two different foreign wars in the same impulse?
  • Must a power spend all the CP from a card it plays?
  • Is there a limit to how many times a power can pass in one turn?

Control & Unrest

  • When the Schmalkaldic League flips a Protestant home space to Protestant control, must Hapsburg units in it be displaced?
  • Can any power remove unrest, including from a space another power controls?
  • Does an enemy besieged army in a neighbouring space stop you removing unrest from your adjacent space?
  • Can a power remove unrest from a space where its own units stand even if enemy units are next door?
  • Can one action both take political control of an enemy-held unfortified space and remove its unrest?
  • Do electorates in Unrest count toward the Protestant's extra card bonus?
  • How is an electorate in Unrest handled when the Schmalkaldic League forms and the Protestants control it?
  • Are control markers limited in number, so that they can run out?
  • Does a lone army leader in a space count as occupying it for placing unrest?
  • Can a major power trace a line of communication through a home fortress of its ally's activated minor power?
  • If a space is in Unrest, do its units, reformer and Jesuit university still add dice to attempts made in that space?
  • Does a reformer or a Jesuit university count as occupying a space for placing unrest?
  • Can a power take control of an unfortified space next to an enemy minor power's land unit?
  • Can a power gain control of an unfortified space occupied by another power's land units?
  • Can unrest be placed in a besieged key, and does it stop an assault on that key?
  • Can a line of communication be traced over a mountain pass?
  • Does a power keep control of a fortified space an enemy is besieging, and can it build units there?
  • Do displaced units need a valid path to the space they are sent to?
  • Can a power take control of an unfortified space that has Unrest, and must the Unrest be removed first?
  • Do Peasants' War unrest markers on Protestant spaces change political control or religious influence?
  • Can an ally besiege and assault a key that an enemy took from that ally, and does the key transfer?
  • Do units of a power you are not at war with break your line of communication through its spaces?
  • Does an Avoid Battle retreat transfer control of Buda, and must units retreat to a friendly fortified space in Winter?
  • Do spaces in Unrest, including electorates, count as Protestant for victory points?
  • Where do displaced units go when their target space is under siege?
  • If a space has no political control marker, is it treated as controlled by its home power?
  • Does a space in Unrest need a siege before the Unrest can be removed?
  • Can a line of communication run through a sea zone holding enemy naval units?
  • Can the Protestant remove unrest from any Protestant home space before the Schmalkaldic League?
  • Can the Habsburgs trace a line of communication to Prague without Vienna?
  • Can a fleet enter a port that is in Unrest, including during Winter?
  • Does removing unrest from a key return its political control to the original owner?
  • Does a fleet in a port stop Unrest being placed on a key?
  • Which side of a control marker shows Protestant religious influence?
  • Does Unrest stop a space counting as controlled for a card that requires control?
  • Do units under siege still count as adjacent when another power tries to take an empty space beside them?
  • Can the Protestants assault a key they do not need?
  • Can the Ottomans control Mohacs without a unit there while Buda is held by Hungary?
  • After a field battle wipes out the defenders in a key, does the key change control immediately?
  • Can Unrest be removed from a fortified space with no units in it?
  • Do keys in Unrest count toward the cards drawn at the start of a turn?
  • What can a port or fortress in Unrest not do?
  • Can Reformation attempts target a space that is already in Unrest?
  • Can a space in Unrest be transferred to another power by trade?

Movement

  • Can a power allied to both sides relieve its own besieged units in a fortified space?
  • Can a power that is not at war with the moving power intercept its move?
  • Can a formation intercept a move into a space where its units are under siege?
  • Can a formation intercept into a friendly fortified space that is under siege?
  • Can a formation move through an enemy fortified space in a single impulse?
  • Can a formation move past an independent fortified key in one impulse?
  • After the Ottomans win the Buda field battle and Hungary falls, can the same stack keep moving in that impulse?
  • Can a stack split into two parts that each attempt Avoid Battle toward different spaces in the same impulse?
  • Can a formation that includes units that already lost a battle avoid battle automatically if fresh units are part of it?
  • Can the attacking stack avoid battle after the defender's interception brings in more units?
  • Can units that their power just placed under siege move out of that space in the same impulse?
  • Can a formation move into and through an enemy fortified space that was besieged in an earlier impulse?
  • Can a response card be played after a move into a fortified space but before the siege check?
  • Can a formation move again after it captures a fortified space by assault in the same impulse?
  • Can units that just moved into a space form a new formation and move on in the same impulse?
  • Can an allied formation move into a fortress that another power is besieging, to reinforce the garrison?
  • When a formation moves into a space that holds land units of another power, is the move allowed?
  • When enemy units allied to a fortress's controller withdraw inside, must the controlling power also have a unit inside?
  • Can a formation intercept into a space that holds both its ally's units and another power's units?
  • What happens to a lone army leader in an unfortified space when enemy land units arrive?
  • Can a line of communication be traced through a space that is under siege?
  • Can a power move into an enemy-held space where its ally's units are already stationed?
  • Can a formation that lost a field battle earlier in an impulse intercept again later in that impulse?
  • Must a formation stop at an enemy fortification it enters, and what happens when the defender withdraws inside?
  • When do units withdraw into a fortification instead of fighting or being assaulted?
  • Can an enemy stack withdraw into a fortification after a successful interception?
  • Can a defender split its units between avoid battle and withdrawal into a fortification?
  • Can a capital hold an unlimited stack, with some units behind the walls and some outside, during the Action Phase?
  • Can you move only part of a stack, splitting a formation in two?
  • Can units be picked up or dropped off while a formation moves?
  • Is there a limit on how many units a stack can hold, so that a defender can fight with the whole stack?
  • If a leader's command rating drops and he cannot command all his troops, do the troops lose strength?
  • Can the Pope besiege a fortified space holding four units without a leader?
  • Can allied powers fight each other when a unit moves into a space held by an ally?
  • Can a formation moving into a friendly fortified space that is not under siege be intercepted?
  • Can a Hapsburg Home Card relocation of the emperor be intercepted by the Ottomans?
  • Can a Hapsburg army move into Bordeaux while a French naval squadron is there, and can it assault or build there?
  • If one power succeeds in an interception attempt, can its other adjacent formations also attempt interception?
  • Can multiple formations from the same space intercept in one impulse?
  • Can a formation move into a space controlled by a minor power?
  • Can a formation move into a space holding land units of a power it is neither allied with nor at war with?
  • Can a formation move or intercept into an independent space that holds another power's land units?
  • Can units move through an occupied space of an inactive minor power?
  • Can you attack a space held by allied units of your enemy?
  • Can an army leader move alone?
  • If my units are intercepted, do I lose the rest of the card's CP?
  • Can a pass be used for wintering or for retreats?
  • What does Foul Weather or Gout cost the affected player?
  • Can a major power intercept into an independent key when an enemy is entering it?
  • In an online move, who rolls for an interception, and must the interceptor commit before rolling?
  • Are spaces across a pass adjacent for every purpose?
  • Can a formation move again after a failed assault on a fortified space it is besieging?

Field Battle

  • After a field battle tie that wipes out the defender, does the attacker still have to retreat?
  • In a field battle with equal hits, who wins, and does eliminating the defenders change that?
  • If both sides are eliminated in a field battle, can both sides' leaders be captured?
  • If both sides are eliminated in a field battle, who keeps a unit and captures the leaders?
  • If a side wins a field battle with more hits but loses all its units, does it still win, and are its leaders captured?
  • In what order are combat cards and response cards played in a field battle?
  • Do extra units from Swiss Mercenaries, Landsknechts or Mercenaries Bribed add attacking dice in a field battle?
  • When two allied powers defend a field battle together, how many leaders and extra defender dice count?
  • How are casualties split between allied powers in a field battle?
  • When a third power attacks a space its controller holds, do allied units already there defend alongside the controller?
  • When units from two powers defend a fortified space, who decides whether to withdraw into the fortifications?
  • If an attacker's leader is captured when a multi-power defense wins, which power takes him?
  • Can a leader retreat alone from a lost field battle after the rest of his stack withdrew into a fortress?
  • Can a lone army leader attempt to avoid battle when enemy land units enter his space?
  • When only some units avoid battle, is the army leader's battle rating added to the avoid-battle roll?
  • Where must an attacking stack retreat after losing a field battle, and what happens if it has nowhere to go?
  • Where does a leader go when its stack must retreat and has no legal retreat space?
  • When an attacking army is wiped out in a field battle against a minor power, what happens to its leader and to the space?
  • Can independent or minor powers capture leaders?
  • Can a defeated army retreat into a space that is still under siege?
  • Must a stack of five or more units that is attacked in a fortified space or capital fight a field battle?
  • Can a stack in a capital withdraw four units plus leaders when a fortified space is attacked?
  • Does a field battle need a line of communication to take a space like Buda?
  • When a stack is attacked, does every unit defend, and does a leaderless stack defend with all of its units?
  • Can a formation that already lost a field battle this impulse avoid battle automatically when attacked again?
  • Can a power attack a stack that avoided battle again in the same activation?
  • Can a victorious formation chase a defeated enemy formation into another battle or siege in the same impulse?
  • Can only some units in a space try to avoid battle, while the rest withdraw into a fortification?
  • In a relief battle, who is the attacker and who is the defender?
  • When a Mercenaries Bribed card switches enemy mercenaries to your side, are the combat dice recalculated?
  • In a field battle between a besieged garrison and its relief force, who decides how casualties are distributed?
  • Can a power intercept a move into a space that holds an independent regular, such as Metz?

Siege

  • Does Mercenaries Grow Restless remove all mercenaries in the besieging stack or only those in the assaulting formation?
  • Can units outside the assaulting formation, or cavalry, be taken as casualties in an assault?
  • Is establishing a siege optional when a formation enters a fortified space with more units than the defenders?
  • Can Landsknechts or other response-card mercenaries let a leaderless four-unit stack outnumber the defenders and start a siege?
  • What happens when both sides are eliminated in an assault?
  • Must the correct number of units be on the map at the end of an action, and can a unit retreat into a space that already holds units?
  • Can two allied powers that are both besieging the same city combine their units into one assault?
  • Can attacking leaders be captured in a siege or assault?
  • Does a siege need a line of communication (LOC), or only an assault?
  • What counts as a line of communication (LOC) for an assault?
  • Can a line of communication run through a sea zone to reach a key reachable only by sea?
  • Does the Relief Forces rule (15.2) apply when the besieged space has no defending units?
  • After a tied battle to relieve a siege, can surviving relief units join the garrison?
  • When a relief force loses a field battle at a besieged fortress, can units or leaders inside the fortress leave with the retreating force?
  • If a fortress holds only a leader, does a lone leader halve the attacker's dice in an assault?
  • If an attacker loses an assault on an island fortress, do its forces retreat by sea or get eliminated?
  • Can an ally of the besieging power also besiege the same fortified space?
  • Can England besiege French troops in a Hapsburg-controlled space when France and the Hapsburgs are allied?
  • Can a second army join an assault on a fortified space that is already under siege?
  • Can a power reinforce a siege by moving more units into a space already under siege, and then assault with the combined force?
  • Do naval units arriving in an adjacent sea zone break a siege, or stop an assault from proceeding?
  • Do defending naval squadrons block an assault on a fortified port?
  • Do allied fleets in a port or adjacent sea zone count toward blocking an assault on a key?
  • How many ships in adjacent sea zones are needed to assault a fortified port that touches two sea zones?
  • What naval squadrons does an assault on a port like Genoa require, and does the test apply to a minor power's port?
  • If a fortified port falls in an assault, what happens to the naval units inside it?
  • Can naval transport add defenders or a leader to a besieged key, or move units out of it?
  • Can a single unit assault a fortified space that has defenders?
  • Can the attacker change the declared formation size of an assault after Combat cards are played?
  • How many units can assault without a leader, and what limit does a leader's command rating set?
  • Can response cards like Swiss Mercenaries enlarge an assault formation past its limit before an assault?
  • Can a besieging force assault again in the same impulse after an unsuccessful assault?
  • Can a power assault in the same impulse in which it first placed the siege, or assault a space an ally besieged?
  • Can units that survive one assault move on and assault a second besieged space, or fight and besiege, in the same impulse?
  • Must an empty fortified space or key be besieged before it can be taken?
  • Does an assault from a sea-delivered stack continue the siege like a land assault?
  • Can cavalry lay siege, and can a lone leader assault?
  • If every attacking land unit dies in an assault, does a surviving leader keep the assault alive?
  • Can an assault formation be a single land unit?
  • Do army leaders count as besieging units for a siege?
  • When an assault strips the defenders from a key, does capturing it count toward the attacker's key-based victory points?
  • What happens to naval units and a naval leader in a fortified space that is captured by assault?
  • If Henry has Gout during a siege, can he move or assault, and does the siege hold?
  • Can besieging units keep a siege without assaulting, and can units in a siege that is neither broken nor successful go home in winter?
  • Can a major power take over a besieged independent fortified space after winning a field battle?
  • Can a siege artillery line of communication cross a sea zone to reach a national space?
  • After a siege fails, can units that arrived by sea be retreated over a land line of communication?
  • If the besieging stack moves away voluntarily, do units left behind keep the siege?
  • If Mercenaries Grow Restless breaks a siege before the roll, how much CP does the attacker have left?
  • Is a fortified space under siege right after the defender loses a field battle there?
  • When defenders withdraw into a fortification, when can the attacker assault?
  • Does a successful Sack of Rome cost the Papacy 4 CP of St Peter's progress or 5 CP?
  • Can units inside a besieged fortress add dice to a relief-force field battle beyond the formation limit?
  • Can units from one successful assault join a second siege in the same turn?
  • Does a siege continue from one turn to the next?
  • Can more than four units be inside a fortified capital under siege?
  • After a relief force lands in a besieged fortress and loses a battle, can the leader retreat into the fortress?
  • When an allied force and its ally are both in a besieged space, does each power decide separately whether to avoid battle?
  • Can Charles V's Home card break a siege on his capital?
  • If the besieged garrison and the relief force are both destroyed, are the leaders captured?
  • Can the defender start a field battle with no units in an empty key so it can play Mercenaries Bribed?
  • Does England need to be at war to capture a key?
  • Can the defender play combat cards after Treachery initiates an assault?
  • Can a leader and a cavalry formation assault an undefended fortified space, adding the leader's battle rating?
  • Can multiple formations move into the same siege in one impulse?
  • When a major power captures an ally's home space that its joint enemy occupies, who gets control?
  • After a relief force loses a field battle in a besieged space, does the besieger gain control without an assault?

Naval Affairs

  • Can a fleet retreat into a port while another attack on that port is about to be resolved?
  • Can a naval leader be loaned to an ally without a squadron?
  • Can friendly naval units move into a port that contains enemy land units?
  • If a naval transport that is also a siege relief ties in a field battle, can its units retreat into the fortress or are they all eliminated?
  • Can a naval stack intercept more than once in the same impulse?
  • Can a fleet avoid battle into a besieged port that its power controls?
  • Can a minor power be the target of Ottoman piracy?
  • When a naval winner takes an odd hit, is an Ottoman corsair eliminated?
  • Is there a limit on the number of fleets that allies can loan you in one turn?
  • Can a fleet pass through Gibraltar between the Mediterranean and the Atlantic?
  • How many CP does it cost to transport land units across sea zones?
  • Does one CP of naval movement move all of your fleets at once, including fleets in different sea zones?
  • Do squadrons in a port add dice when piracy is in an adjacent sea zone?
  • What happens when a naval battle ends in a tie, or with no hits on either side?
  • Do ships in a port take part in a land battle there, or retreat with the land units?
  • How does a naval interception work when stacks from several spaces try to intercept?
  • Can a naval leader be captured or held prisoner after his ships are lost?
  • Can a power that is not at war with the Ottomans attack their corsairs at sea?
  • What does a naval unit's vertical or horizontal orientation affect?
  • Can a naval unit move into or out of a port that is under siege?
  • After a naval attack on a port, where does the retreating attacker go?
  • What happens to ships in an unfortified port when an enemy takes control of it?
  • What happens to ships in a fortified port when a besieged city or key falls?
  • Can enemy fleets avoid battle in a sea zone where one of them intercepted successfully?
  • When two enemy naval stacks move into the same sea zone, how is interception resolved?
  • Can a fleet intercept a naval unit that enters a port?
  • Can a squadron in a port intercept an enemy ship entering the adjacent sea zone?
  • Can an enemy fleet in a port intercept a squadron entering the adjacent sea zone when the active power is also moving into that port?
  • Can a naval unit intercept a move into a sea zone that already holds enemy naval units?
  • Can part of a naval stack intercept one move while the rest stays back or intercepts another move?
  • If a naval attacker loses a naval battle, must it retreat to the space its ships came from?
  • Can a squadron in a two-zone port such as Gibraltar be attacked from either adjacent sea zone?
  • Can transported land units land in a port that holds enemy naval units, or that has no squadron of yours?
  • Can fleets capture a port space by moving into it?
  • If a naval-transported stack loses a field battle in the port, can it retreat by sea?
  • Can land units enter a port and then start a naval transport in the same impulse?
  • Can a naval transport carry five land units without an army leader?
  • Can naval transports carry troops into Candia or Rhodes for 2 CP?
  • Can units without a leader intercept a naval landing?
  • Can a naval unit enter or pass through an allied major power's port, including a two-zone port the ally controls?
  • Can a squadron move through an enemy port to reach a farther sea zone?
  • If both sides in a naval battle score enough hits to wipe each other out, do both lose all their squadrons?
  • If a naval battle is lost with zero hits against one hit, does the loser lose a squadron?
  • Does a defending fleet at sea get the extra defender die in a naval battle?
  • Can squadrons that retreat after a naval battle be intercepted at the sea zone they retreat to?
  • If war breaks out mid-action and two powers' naval units share a sea zone, what happens?
  • When a city has two port symbols, which port does a naval unit occupy?
  • Can a fleet move through several sea zones in one impulse, or move more than one zone by spending more CP?
  • If a fleet is intercepted from an adjacent sea zone and loses, can it retreat back to where the interceptor came from?
  • Do naval units get an automatic avoid battle at sea?
  • What naval superiority does an assault on a fortified port need?
  • Do an ally's squadrons help in a naval battle or count toward preventing an assault?
  • Does a naval leader count toward naval superiority when assaulting a port?
  • In a naval battle in a port, which side retreats, and what happens to the defenders?
  • Can transported units split at a port and go to different destinations in one naval move?
  • Can Corsairs transport troops?
  • Can piracy target a port controlled by an ally's minor power?
  • Can the Ottomans commit piracy against a major power they are not at war with?
  • Can a fleet that just lost a naval battle still perform piracy in the same impulse?
  • Can Foul Weather stop a second piracy attempt in the same impulse?
  • How much does piracy cost, and can it hit a land unit in a port?
  • Who decides the award for each piracy hit?
  • How many dice does a target get against Ottoman piracy?
  • If the pirated power has no defending dice, does piracy still roll?
  • Are unconnected sea zones such as the Barbary Coast and Atlantic Ocean adjacent for piracy?
  • Who controls a loaned squadron in a battle or piracy, and who decides which fleets are lost?
  • Can corsairs in a stack avoid battle separately from the squadrons they are with?
  • Do all ships in a sea zone fight together, and does orientation change who takes part?
  • Can anyone use Algiers, Oran or Tripoli at the start of the game?
  • Is a naval squadron the same as a fleet?
  • When Hungary-Bohemia is defeated and an immediate naval battle follows, can the Hapsburgs intercept or avoid battle?
  • Are all ships in a conga line of naval stacks interceptable?
  • Can a line of communication run through a sea zone that holds an allied major power's naval units?
  • Can the Ottomans pirate a port they gave to another power?

Unit Construction

  • Can land units be built or recruited in a space that is under siege?
  • Can naval squadrons be built, or added by the Shipbuilding card, in a port that is under siege?
  • Can units built this impulse be moved, activated or marched into a siege in the same impulse?
  • Can you swap smaller unit counters for a larger one when the counter mix is short?
  • Can a power raise units in its own home space that is currently under an ally's control?
  • Can a power build units or mercenaries in another power's home space, such as an ally's or a minor power's?
  • Can I build units in a space I have captured from another power?
  • If France plays Scots Raid to recruit, must the units built be Scottish?
  • Can Janissaries add extra regulars to a Foreign War card beyond the units it requires?
  • Can units be constructed in a capital that is in Unrest?
  • Can units lost in battle or to piracy be rebuilt in the same turn?
  • What units can be built in Algiers, and can Janissaries be added there?
  • Can the Ottomans build corsairs or start piracy before the Barbary Pirates event?

The Reformation

  • After winning a theological debate, can the winner flip spaces in another language zone?
  • Once a debate's chosen zone is fully flipped, can extra hits flip spaces outside every language zone, such as Amsterdam?
  • Can flips from a theological debate chain, so a newly flipped space makes the next space eligible?
  • When a debate flips a space that holds a reformer, does the reformer stay in the space?
  • When Bullinger defends in the second round of a debate, does he count as committed or uncommitted?
  • In a debate's second round, can the debater from round one be picked again?
  • Can a committed debater start a debate, or can only uncommitted debaters attack?
  • In a later debate round, does the attacker still get +3 dice while a committed defender gets only +1?
  • Can the Here I Stand card bring Luther into a debate in both rounds, or after a Leipzig Debate excluded him?
  • Can Here I Stand put Luther into a debate outside the German language zone?
  • Can a theological debate be called in a language zone that has no Protestant debater in play?
  • Can the Pope call a debate in a language zone that has no Protestant spaces?
  • Can the Papacy call a debate in the English zone before any English space has been reformed?
  • Can a theological debate be called in Italy or Spain?
  • How many dice does each side roll in a theological debate?
  • What happens when a theological debate ties?
  • How does Aleander's debater bonus change a debate result?
  • Does Campeggio's bonus change a debate result when he is not the final Papal debater?
  • Can Contarini's +1 die bonus be used when Charles V is off the board, and can he be flipped anyway?
  • How far does a debater's within-two-spaces bonus reach, across passes, sea zones and unrest?
  • Does an uncommitted Bucer add his rating to a Reformation attempt near Strasbourg, and does he convert a space when he enters?
  • Can a debater from one language zone give his bonus to a Reformation attempt in another zone?
  • Does a debater committed by an event text still give his bonus?
  • Can a debater be committed without using his bonus?
  • Can a power use more than one debater bonus in one impulse?
  • How many debaters can a power commit voluntarily in one impulse, and do event commitments count?
  • When can a debater's bonus be committed during a Reformation action, and can a debater that gives extra attempts be added mid-action?
  • If a debate in England with only Tyndale ends round one tied, does Tyndale debate again, and is he committed?
  • Does a debater bonus such as Bucer's apply to the 95 Theses event?
  • Does a Protestant port across a sea zone add dice to a Reformation attempt?
  • When is a port across a sea zone a legal target for a Reformation attempt?
  • Do adjacent Protestant spaces still add a die to a Reformation attempt when the target is in another language zone?
  • Do units, reformers and Jesuit universities in a space in unrest still count for attempts in adjacent spaces?
  • Does a failed Carlstadt conversion put unrest in a space that holds land units, and how many markers does it place?
  • If a failed attempt leaves unrest in a space that later converts, does the unrest marker stay?
  • Can a Reformation attempt target a space with no adjacent Protestant space, even with the Printing Press in play?
  • If no space is eligible for a Reformation attempt, can the Protestant still act?
  • Do units under siege still count for Reformation and Counter-Reformation dice?
  • When two stacks share a space, how many Reformation or Counter-Reformation dice do they add?
  • Do units in the target space of a Reformation attempt add dice?
  • How is a land unit's religion decided: by its space, or by the power that raised it?
  • Are Hungarian units Catholic when they sit in a Protestant or Catholic area?
  • Can the Protestant place Hungarian markers in reformed Hungarian spaces before the Schmalkaldic League forms?
  • Do English troops count for Reformation dice, and as which religion?
  • Can a space be the target of a second Reformation or Counter-Reformation attempt in the same impulse?
  • What does the targeted language zone decide in a Reformation or Counter-Reformation attempt?
  • Can a Reformation attempt target a space outside the named language zone, or outside every zone?
  • When a card's Reformation or Counter-Reformation attempts target all language zones, are the attempts split per zone?
  • When an attempt targets all language zones, where does the Protestant win ties?
  • Who picks the target language zone when a conversion is made?
  • Do all coloured map areas count as language zones for conversion attempts?
  • Can the last Protestant space in a language zone be converted back to Catholic, and the reverse?
  • Can Loyola's Jesuit University bonus combine with another debater's bonus in the same impulse?
  • Do Carlstadt's or Calvin's bonuses need a Publish Treatise action first, and must all three of their attempts be made?
  • When Carlstadt's or Cajetan's debater bonus is used, must three spaces be available in the target zone?
  • Can a Publish Treatise action place one attempt inside its chosen zone and one outside it?
  • Must all Burn Books attempts fall in the chosen language zone?
  • Does burning books with Tetzel's bonus give 2 CP toward St. Peter's when the action makes two attempts?
  • Can England publish a treatise before Cranmer is on the map, or after Cranmer has been burnt or excommunicated?
  • Can English treatises use debater bonuses, and can the Protestant commit a debater to help one?
  • For the Knox and Latimer debater bonuses, does England include Calais?
  • Does a debater's +1 die bonus apply to both conversion attempts in one Publish Treatise action?
  • Does a debater's +1 die bonus cover every attempt in one action or event, or only one roll?
  • If a debater's bonus is gained during or after a Bible translation, do all six translation attempts get it?
  • Can a debater bonus from completing the New Testament advance the Full Bible marker?
  • Does the Protestant earn VP for each completed Full Bible translation?
  • Does a neighbouring conversion or a Bible translation give the Protestant a bonus on Reformation attempts?
  • Does targeting a language zone limit where New Testament translation attempts can be made?
  • Must the Protestant take all of the Reformation attempts from a Bible translation once it elects to make them?
  • Can the Protestant convert English spaces before Henry VIII marries Anne Boleyn, or before Cranmer enters the game?
  • Does the Protestant need an adjacent port to flip English spaces in a debate?
  • When does the English Reformation start after Henry marries Anne Boleyn?
  • Can the English New Testament be completed before the English Reformation has started?
  • Which reformers and English debaters enter the game on Turn 4?
  • Are electorates treated as fortified spaces for Winter, assault and other effects?
  • Does the Schmalkaldic League convert a Protestant home space that holds a Fortress marker, or does its errata stop electorates converting?
  • Do Hapsburg fortresses built in Germany before the Schmalkaldic League stay Hapsburg-controlled after it forms?
  • Do Protestant spaces in unrest count toward forming the Schmalkaldic League?
  • Are spaces in unrest converted to Protestant political control when the Schmalkaldic League is played?
  • When the Schmalkaldic League forms and there are no Protestant electorates, what happens to Protestant troops already on the map?
  • If Protestants convert an electorate and Catholics convert it back, do the Protestant units placed there stay on the map?
  • Can a Protestant electorate's regulars be placed while the electorate is under siege, or when it converts?
  • Can a Papal debate flip an electorate to Catholic influence after the Schmalkaldic League has formed?
  • Do Habsburg units in Protestant home spaces have to move when the Schmalkaldic League forms?
  • Does a German space that has converted to Protestantism stay Hapsburg-controlled before the Schmalkaldic League?
  • Can the Hapsburgs place or move units into electorates before the Schmalkaldic League forms?
  • Are electorates treated as occupied before the Schmalkaldic League forms, for Peasants' War unrest?
  • Do Protestants get armies in electorates when they are reformed, and when does that change after the League?
  • Can Jesuit Universities be built in a Catholic electorate even when Protestant armies occupy it?
  • What is the Electoral Display used for?
  • If Protestants convert a space without political control, do they still score for it?
  • Does the Papacy score VP from the religious track, and does it gain VP when other powers place political control markers?
  • Is the French counter mix limit on Protestant-flipped spaces in France absolute?
  • Does a Reformation attempt place an uncommitted debater on the map?
  • How many spaces is Linz from Wittenberg for the Frederick the Wise card's nearest-German-space conversion?
  • Is an excommunicated reformer still usable for the rest of the turn, or drawn for a debate, and when does he return?
  • Can an excommunicated reformer or ruler be excommunicated again, and does making peace lift it?
  • Can a mandatory event be used as the commitment card at the Diet of Worms?
  • In the Diet of Worms, how many spaces change religion when the two sides' hits are unequal?
  • If the Papacy debates in English while no Protestant spaces are in England, do Protestant spaces in other zones flip instead?
  • Does the Leipzig Debate card exclude a Protestant debater from both rounds, and can it pick a committed reformer as the debater?
  • Can a Protestant convert an electorate that holds other powers' units before the Schmalkaldic League?
  • Can Faber's +2 debater bonus apply to several electorates in one impulse?
  • Can Mighty Fortress or Catherina Bora be played as events while Luther is excommunicated?
  • Can the Calvin Expelled event be played when Calvin is already off the map?
  • Can a debater committed earlier in the turn use his bonus when he is called to a later debate?
  • Does the one-debater-bonus-per-impulse limit apply to theological debates?
  • Can the same debater bonus be used more than once in one impulse?

Winter

  • How is the nearest fortified space measured when land units winter?
  • Does a unit stop at a friendly fortress it passes on its way to a farther winter target?
  • Can land units return to a capital farther away than the nearest fortified space in Winter?
  • If the nearest fortified space already holds four land units, must wintering units go to the capital?
  • In the two-player variant, what happens to units that have no legal fortified space in Winter?
  • Is there a stacking limit on land units during the Winter Phase?
  • Where do excess land units go when a fortified space holds more than four units in Winter?
  • Can land units stay in a fortified space their power controls during Winter?
  • Must land units in an unfortified space return home during Winter?
  • How many units does a stack lose to attrition when it has no safe path home in Winter?
  • Does a stack that returns through a space in unrest take attrition?
  • Do units that stay where they are in Winter take attrition?
  • Does a capital in unrest, or one held by an enemy, produce a Winter replacement?
  • Do minor powers get the Winter replacement regular for a capital they hold?
  • Can an army leader move by himself to his capital during the Winter Phase?
  • Can a lone army leader be left behind when his units leave a space in Winter?
  • Can land units already in their home capital move during Winter?
  • Can minor power units in a major power's capital move to the minor power's home key in Winter?
  • Can Hapsburg land units return to either of their two capitals in Winter?
  • Can Hapsburg units move from one of their capitals to the other during Winter?
  • Can Hapsburg units return home through electorates before the Schmalkaldic League?
  • Can a fleet return to a port in unrest during Winter?
  • Can naval units pass through another power's port or enemy-held spaces on the way home in Winter?
  • Can an activated minor power's fleet return to a minor power home port in Winter?
  • Can land units return home across sea zones in Winter, and do they need a friendly fleet there?
  • Can a winter return path go through a space that is not friendly-controlled?
  • Can Scottish units stack beyond four in Edinburgh or Stirling during Winter?
  • What happens to Scottish land units when Edinburgh and Stirling are both enemy-controlled in Winter?
  • Can Protestant units return home by sea in Winter?
  • What happens to Protestant units in Winter before the Schmalkaldic League?
  • Do Protestant units in a fortified space they control move during Winter?
  • Can minor power units stack beyond four in their own home key during Winter?
  • Can an active minor power's units move between its own home keys in Winter?
  • Do units of an inactive minor power move during Winter?
  • Can minor power troops in a fortified space held by their major ally return to the minor power's home key in Winter?
  • Does Winter remove minor power alliances as well as major power alliances?
  • When do Mandatory Events resolve in the Winter Phase?
  • Can a besieged army leave a siege by sea, or move to its capital, in Winter without losses?
  • What happens to units that must return to a capital held by an enemy in Winter?

The New World

  • Does New World Riches shuffle the new cards and the discard pile once per turn, or is there a separate draw step?
  • Does Mercator's Map's +2 apply to a circumnavigation attempt?
  • Does Sebastian Cabot's voyage count against the once-per-turn exploration limit?
  • Does Mercator's Map's +2 change the order in which explorers resolve?
  • Can Smallpox add its +2 to a conquest that is already underway?
  • Can a power launch more than one conquest in a turn, counting the starting conquistador and Smallpox?
  • How is a New World conquest decided from the voyage roll?
  • Where is a conquest placed on the New World map when a Voyage of Conquest succeeds?
  • What happens when the discovery a voyage rolls is already claimed?
  • Which New World actions draw extra cards?
  • How many NE results does the Colonial Governor turn into cards in one Card Draw Phase?
  • Does the Colonial Governor give an extra card on a Galleons result?
  • If a Colonial Governor is already on the board and another player plays the card, what happens?
  • Do Galleons apply to future colonies, conquests and Potosi, and how do they combine with Plantations?
  • How does a Galleon get into play for the New World chart?
  • What does playing the Potosi Silver Mines card give you?
  • Do explorers and conquistadors enter play at the start of the game or when a voyage resolves?
  • Is the VP for discovering a New World region scored once or every turn?
  • Can another New World power attempt circumnavigation after a failed attempt?
  • If Search for Cibola or Fountain of Youth cancels Mercator's Map or Smallpox, does the benefit stay with the player?
  • When Search for Cibola or Fountain of Youth delays an exploration marker, must the owner pay for the exploration again?
  • When Sebastian Cabot dies, what happens to his markers and card?
  • Can a voyage that rolls 10 or more on the exploration table claim something other than circumnavigation?

Major Powers

  • How much does the Papacy lose from the Sack of Rome when it has St. Peter's CP but no VP?
  • Does the Papacy need to control Rome for the Sack of Rome to cost it CP or VP?
  • If England and the Protestants are allied when Henry marries Anne of Cleves, do they draw cards?
  • What happens to English impulses when Mary I rules England?
  • If an English army is destroyed in the Irish Foreign War, is its leader captured by the French?
  • Can Henry VIII roll for a pregnancy after the Pope grants the divorce while he is captured?
  • After Elizabeth and sickly Edward are born, can Henry's marital status marker still roll to advance to healthy Edward?
  • Can the Papacy invest more CPs in St. Peter's after the basilica is complete?
  • If a card forces the Papacy to lose St. Peter's track CPs, does the loss come off CPs before VPs, and can the track go negative?
  • Does excommunication pass to a dead ruler's successor?
  • Can the Papacy grant a divorce more than once, and can England advance the marital marker again in the same turn?
  • When the Pope excommunicates a power, which of its home spaces can be put into unrest?
  • Are the VP for a birth roll scored when the roll is made, and does a sickly Edward VI still count for 5 VP?
  • Does an excommunication end when the excommunicated ruler changes?
  • Does declaring war with the English home card, Six Wives of Henry VIII, cost CP?
  • Can the Pope excommunicate Tyndale?
  • Can leaders on a Foreign War card return home in Winter?
  • When Henry divorces Catherine and marries Anne Boleyn, where does Catherine's marker go, and is there a pregnancy roll?
  • Can England keep marrying after the healthy Edward result, and is there still a pregnancy roll?
  • When do the reformers and event cards from Anne Boleyn's marriage enter play?
  • If Henry is captured and then dies, is Edward placed on the board?
  • Where does a resolved Foreign War card go, and where does its War Winner VP marker end up?
  • Can Unpaid Mercenaries or Swiss Mercenaries target units on a Foreign War card?
  • Does a Sack of Rome win automatically when the Papacy has no regulars in Rome?
  • Does a power earn War Winner VP for winning a Foreign War?
  • When does England roll on the Henry's Wives pregnancy chart?
  • If a Henry's Wives pregnancy result has already occurred, what happens when it is rolled again?
  • When does Edward VI enter the deck after a pregnancy roll?
  • Can mercenaries and cavalry be used in foreign wars?
  • Can the Papacy build St. Peter's in Rome after it has lost control of Rome?
  • Can the Hapsburg build units in German electorates before the Schmalkaldic League?
  • Can the Protestant place regulars in an electorate it converts before the Schmalkaldic League?
  • Does 'England' in Mary's trigger text include the English home space Calais?
  • Can a power place more units on a Foreign War card than the required number?
  • Can a player send two leaders to a Foreign War to add two dice?
  • Are Protestant land units subject to attrition before the Schmalkaldic League is played?
  • After the Schmalkaldic League, can a Protestant regular be placed in a converted electorate that the Hapsburgs still control?
  • Can the Protestant besiege or assault before the Schmalkaldic League?
  • Are the Edward and Elizabeth pregnancy VP bonuses cumulative?
  • When the Schmalkaldic League converts electorates, does the Protestant gain VP, and does the Hapsburg lose VP?
  • After the Schmalkaldic League, do Protestant religion spaces such as Innsbruck, Zurich and Linz gain Protestant political control?
  • Can the Protestant buy Landsknechts before the Schmalkaldic League?
  • Can the Papacy excommunicate a Protestant ruler such as Luther or Calvin?
  • Can a reformer be excommunicated more than once?
  • Which regulars defend Rome during a Sack of Rome?
  • Does ending a war remove an excommunication on a ruler?
  • Are the two quick ways to marry Henry to Anne Boleyn legal?
  • If Mary I is in a hand or the deck when Edward VI is born, what happens to the Mary card?
  • Can the Pope excommunicate the heirs of Henry VIII?
  • When Hungary surrenders after an assault that the attacker loses, what happens to Buda?
  • Can City State Rebels be played on Algiers after the Ottomans control it?
  • Does a space in Unrest count toward the Protestant's 12-space Schmalkaldic League threshold?
  • Can units enter or move through electorates before the Schmalkaldic League is played?
  • Can a Protestant unit be placed in an electorate that another power occupies?
  • Can you fight the same Foreign War twice in one impulse?
  • Can the Protestant receive mercenaries from cards such as Cloth Prices Fluctuate before the Schmalkaldic League?

Minor Powers

  • When a minor power is activated, do wars with it end, and must they be declared again after it is deactivated?
  • Does playing Venetian Alliance or Auld Alliance to intervene replace the 2 CP activation cost?
  • When a minor power is deactivated, does a squadron loaned to a major power go back to the minor?
  • Can a naval squadron loaned from a minor power be taken as a loss in combat or piracy?
  • When a deactivated minor's units must choose between equidistant ports, who picks the port?
  • Can France, the Hapsburgs or the Papacy play Andrea Doria to activate Genoa when Genoa is inactive, neutral or at war with them?
  • Can a power other than France, the Papacy or the Hapsburgs play Andrea Doria to activate Genoa for itself?
  • When Andrea Doria moves Genoa to a new ally, what happens to the units of the old ally?
  • Can Andrea Doria still be played to ally Genoa after a neutral Genoa has been taken by force?
  • Does a conquered minor power stay conquered when its key is ceded, or when an event reactivates it?
  • When a major power activates a minor power, what happens to the spaces the minor controls?
  • When the Hapsburgs activate Genoa, does France keep the Genoa key it already holds?
  • If Hungary falls while no Ottoman units are in Buda, who gets Buda?
  • If the Hungarians survive an Ottoman field battle or assault on Buda, does Hungary still fall?
  • After the Ottomans win a field battle against Hungary-Bohemia, does their retreat resolve before the minor is judged defeated?
  • If the Ottomans beat Hungary-Bohemia in a field battle that leaves five or more Hungarian land units, how many withdraw into the fortifications?
  • If the Ottomans take a besieged Hungarian key, what happens to Habsburg units inside it?
  • When the Habsburgs activate Hungary with Diplomatic Marriage, must the Ottomans declare war right away?
  • Can the Habsburgs activate Hungary with Diplomatic Marriage before the Ottomans take Buda?
  • Are Hungary and Bohemia allied with the Habsburgs at the start, and can Habsburg units enter Hungary before then?
  • When Hungary-Bohemia is defeated and activated as a Habsburg ally, do its units place Habsburg control markers?
  • Does an alliance with a minor power end after one turn, like an alliance between major powers?
  • Does the Ottoman player get 2 VP for winning a war against Hungary-Bohemia?
  • If the Ottomans make peace with the Habsburgs and then attack Buda, do they go back to war?
  • Do inactive minor-power units, or independent regulars, with four or fewer land units withdraw into fortifications when attacked?
  • Do the units of an inactive minor power ever move?
  • Can another major power enter an independent key that is already under siege, in order to besiege it too?
  • Can you declare war on an active minor power, such as Venice whose cities a major power controls?
  • Can the Papacy intervene after a declaration of war on a minor power that is already at war with another power?
  • After the Papacy intervenes in a declaration of war on Venice, must the declaring power be at war with the Papacy?
  • If the Ottomans are at war with Venice and the Pope activates Venice as an ally, are the Ottomans still at war with Venice?
  • When Venice is deactivated, can displaced Habsburg land units go to Malta, or must they go to Vienna?
  • In Revolt in Ireland, can the swapped-out unit be a mercenary or an allied power's regular?
  • If a city one power takes from a minor is later taken by another power at war with it, who owns the city?
  • Can the Papacy play Venetian Alliance only to activate Venice during the Diplomacy Phase, without a declaration of war?
  • Can Andrea Doria command a fleet that includes Papal ships but no Genoese units?
  • After England besieges and takes Edinburgh, can England rebuild Scottish units?
  • Who may intervene on behalf of a minor power that is at war?
  • When France has activated Scotland as its ally, must England declare war on France to fight Scotland?
  • If France activates a neutral Scotland while France and England are at war, is Scotland automatically at war with England?
  • Can an active minor power's land units winter in one of that minor's home keys, or go to an allied major's capital?
  • Can an allied minor power's fleets break a siege on a major ally's key?
  • Do minor powers add a regular to their capitals during Replacements?
  • If a minor power's units are all eliminated when its capital falls, is the minor power out of the game?
  • When a minor's key is taken by force and no one intervenes, what happens to the minor's naval units?
  • Can City State Rebels be played on a minor power's key that another power controls?
  • Can City State Rebels be played on Algiers after Barbary Pirates has been played?
  • When City State Rebels destroys the last unit in a key, does the key become independent, and who keeps a captured leader?
  • If City State Rebels succeeds against an independent key holding a leader, is the leader captured or removed to the turn track?
  • Can Swiss Mercenaries be played before City State Rebels resolves?
  • How many Hungarian regulars can the John Zapolya card bring into Buda, and can independent counters stand in when Hungarian counters run out?
  • How can the Ottomans take the Isle of Rhodes from the Knights of St John?
  • Can the Scots Raid event let France invade or capture English-held spaces when England and France are not at war?
  • Can Diplomatic Marriage activate a minor power that another power already activated?
  • What happens to a fortress in a minor power's home space when that minor is deactivated?
  • After a major power conquers a minor's home spaces, do the minor's units stay there, and can France still activate Scotland?
  • When an uncontrolled Genoa is besieged by land, where does Genoa's naval unit go?
  • If France conquers a neutral minor's key and the Papacy then takes it, must the Papacy declare war on the minor?
  • Does Venice count as at war with the Ottomans when Venice is allied to the Habsburgs and the Habsburgs go to war with the Ottomans?
  • If a major power declares war on a minor power, can it later activate that minor for itself?
  • If the Ottomans conquer Hungary, can the Habsburgs regain Hungarian home spaces by surrendering to them?
  • When suing for peace, can you remove a minor ally's units to settle the war?
  • Can an eliminated or captured minor power such as Scotland or Genoa come back into play?
  • If Auld Alliance deactivates Scotland, what happens to Scottish troops sieging a space?
  • When the Genoese squadrons are loaned to another power, who controls Andrea Doria's second effect?
  • If England declares war on Scotland and France intervenes, can England still enter Scotland, and does playing Auld Alliance stop that?

Victory

  • If the Hapsburgs and England are still tied for victory at game end, who wins?
  • When powers tie for victory at game end, how is the tie broken, and what if only some of them are tied on an earlier turn?
  • Do the Protestants earn 2 VP for political control of a key?
  • If the Hapsburgs regain a key during Sue for Peace so that their last key goes back on the map, do they win immediately?
  • When one player controls two powers, are their victory points averaged?
  • When does England claim victory points for Henry's heirs, and does England keep them if the heir dies?
  • If a Protestant electorate is lost to the Hapsburgs, how do the VP change for each side?
  • Do you get War Winner VP for defeating a minor power?
  • How are Protestant VP tallied?
  • Does the board's Victory Track count the Religious Struggle track points a second time?
  • How do the SCM markers change VP and card draws?
  • Does a besieged key count toward a military victory?

Here I Stand: 2-Player Diplomacy DeckExpansion

  • In the 2-player variant, do the French, Hapsburg or Ottoman powers get a free regular in their capital during Winter?
  • In the 2-player variant, can Hapsburg units forced back to Vienna in Winter stay there?
  • In the 2-player game, are French, Hapsburg and Ottoman army leaders removed during Winter, even if captured?
  • In the 2-player game, can the Papacy move and attack with Hapsburg units once they are allied and at war?
  • In the 2-player deck, do the Protestant's extra options on Diplomatic Marriage and Shipbuilding apply when the Papacy plays the card, and who builds the squadrons when Shipbuilding is played?
  • In the Corsair Raid diplomacy card, does the enemy choose which card to discard?
  • How does the Diplomatic Marriage card resolve in the 2-player deck: is it one activation or deactivation, and must the Pope deactivate one if both minor allies are active?
  • In the 2-player deck, can the Protestant or the Papacy take Metz and Liege?
  • In the 2-player deck, can a captured Protestant leader ever return?
  • In the 2-player deck, can the Protestants call Luther into a theological debate triggered by Henry Petitions for Divorce?
  • In the 2-player deck, do the Hapsburgs and France start the game at war?
  • In the 2-player deck, can the Papacy build Venetian units outside the Italian language zone if Venice is its ally?
  • Does Venetian Informant in the 2-player deck let you view a player's Diplomatic cards?
  • In the 2-player deck, when is the Mary I roll made?
  • In the 2-player deck, can the Protestants play combat cards for a sacking power that is not at war with the Papacy?
  • In the 2-player deck, does activating an allied minor power give its major ally political control of its home spaces outside the Italian zone?
  • In the 1517 scenario of the 2-player deck, do starting wars come from the setup markers?
  • In the 2-player variant, where do Ottoman naval units go in Winter when the invasion of Italy fails to capture a key?
  • In the 2-player variant, does the ruler-only wording of Papal Bull stop it from excommunicating reformers?
  • Which Andrea Doria card belongs to the 2-player variant?
  • In the 2-player variant, can the Hapsburgs hand Florence or Milan over to the Papacy in the Diplomacy Phase?
  • Do Galleons or the Huguenot Raiders come into play in the 2-player Diplomacy Deck, and how?
  • In the 2-player deck, does the Plague card let the attacker choose which units are removed, and can regulars be targeted?
  • Can the Protestant play the Ottoman invasion card against the Hapsburgs, and can major powers be at war with each other in the 2-player game?
  • Does the Henry petitions for divorce card change when Elizabeth I enters the 2-player deck?
  • In the 2-player game, may a power voluntarily return a non-player major power's land units to the capital in Winter?
  • In the 2-player game, can France end a war with the Papacy on its own?
  • How many cards are in the 2-Player Diplomacy Deck?
  • In the 2-player game, can the Papacy retake a 4-unit fortified space without a leader?
  • In the 2-player game, do France and the Papacy start at war?
  • In the two-player game, can France and the Papacy go back to war in the same Diplomacy Phase after making peace?
  • In the two-player game, is Venice allied to the Papacy at the start?
  • In the 2-player game, where do Hapsburg regulars placed in Nurnberg go in Winter?
  • In the 2-player game, can Hapsburg mercenaries be placed in electorates before the Schmalkaldic League?
  • In the 2-player game, can the Papacy declare war on a minor power such as Genoa?
  • In the 2-player game, do the German and Italian language zones get the full normal unit setup?
  • Can you play Henry Petitions For Divorce as a Diplomacy card when Mary is on the English throne?
  • In the 2-player setup, is there still a Hungarian regular in Prague, and how many regulars does Vienna start with?