Here I Stand
If both sides in a naval battle score enough hits to wipe each other out, do both lose all their squadrons?
Rulebook section 16.2 step 8 applies casualties from both sides' hits and covers the both-eliminated case.
- Here I Stand rulebook · Rulebook · 16.2 Naval Combat
Yes, casualties are applied from both sides' hits. If both sides would be eliminated, the side that rolled more dice keeps 1 unit, and if the dice were equal the defender keeps 1.