Unfathomable FAQ
225 questions players ask · Updated Nov 14, 2026 · Full rulebook
Components and Setup
- Is the Cultist loyalty card added to the loyalty deck in every game?
- Should the Cultist loyalty card be used in a first game?
- How many skill cards does each player draw during setup in a first game?
- How many skill cards does each player draw during setup in a standard game?
- Can a character take three skill cards of the same type during setup?
- Can Unfathomable be played cooperatively with no traitors?
Fundamental Concepts
- What counts as an ability in the Rules Reference's Abilities section?
- Can Shriveling or another enemy-targeting card be used on a Monarch?
- Can Edmund Mallory's reroll ability be used on a die roll made by another player?
- Can you play a skill card on another player's turn, and does a card with no Action label cost an action?
- Are discard piles face up or face down in Unfathomable?
- Do only the current player draw skill cards at the start of a turn?
- Can you get fuel back during the game?
- When a draw empties a skill or Mythos deck, is its discard reshuffled at once?
- Are spaces that touch only at a corner adjacent?
Playing the Game
- Can Jeanne's Full Steam Ahead feat be used when the Boiler Room is damaged or has a Deep One in it?
- Does the Infiltrator Mythos card spawn a Deep One in a space that was not damaged?
- Can you use the Bridge action to look at the waypoint deck, and what does it cost?
- Can a Cultist reveal as a traitor?
- What can a character in the Brig still do, and can they use items?
- How does a human escape the Brig, and does the move out cost an action?
- Can another player start a brigged player's escape check?
- How does a revealed traitor get out of the Brig when they can add only one card to a skill check?
- Can a human leave the Brig when a revealed traitor is also in the Brig?
- When a human in the Brig draws a Mythos card, which parts of the card resolve?
- What happens when a character-specific Mythos card is drawn for a character who is not in the game, is in the Brig, or is a revealed traitor?
- On a Mythos crisis, who does "you" refer to, and who gets the effect when a card says to draw or choose?
- Can players add treachery cards to the chaos deck during the game?
- Must a player take two actions on their turn, or can they take fewer?
- Can Coordinated Effort let another player play Ransack or Perform Rites, and must Ransack be played first in the action step?
- Can extra actions from different sources stack?
- If Coordinated Effort gives another character an action, can that character use a once-per-turn ability again?
- Can a player use the action on another player's skill card during the current player's turn?
- Can a revealed hybrid use Coordinated Effort to give an action to an unrevealed hybrid?
- How does Astral Travel move characters and Deep Ones?
- Can you play Shrivelling with no valid enemy target just to get rid of it?
- Can Combat Training reroll any attack roll, and how many can be played?
- What counts as an attack, and is Shrivelling an attack?
- Can Combat Training reroll a die that Perfect Number set, or a roll boosted by Keen Insight?
- Can you attack from Sick Bay with a gun in an adjacent space?
- Can Travel Pharmacy save human characters from being defeated?
- Can Repeating Rifle target an enemy in the same space as you?
- Can Elder Sign Amulet's double effect target two different enemies, or the same enemy twice?
- How do you resolve Elder Sign Amulet doubling Lesser Banishment?
- When a crisis shows several activation icons, in what order are they resolved?
- Can a Deep One taken from the deck by Lesser Banishment be moved onto water?
- Does Shrug It Off protect a character from a second defeat in the same event?
- When Accusation's Decline to Act is chosen and one player is both the current player and the Captain, how many skill cards do they discard?
- Does a Boiler Room roll advance the travel track even when the die result is high?
- Can the Chapel or Boiler Room roll be made without discarding the card it requires?
- Is there a limit on how many item cards a player can hold?
- Who can rescue a passenger, and what does it cost?
- Can you rescue a passenger in a space that holds a Deep One or a revealed traitor?
- When several passenger tokens are in one space, can you look at them before choosing which one to rescue?
- What does "risk a fuel" or "risk a food" mean on a card or room?
- Can a player choose a crisis option that risks passengers when no passengers are left to risk?
- When a choice crisis says another player chooses, who picks the track and the Deep One activation order?
- Does each player take a whole turn before the next player, or do all players do each step together?
- Can a player use the same space action more than once per turn, or use two different interior space actions?
- Can a revealed traitor in the same space block humans from using the space action?
- If a player is defeated on their own turn, can they still leave Sick Bay with a remaining action?
- Can a revealed traitor use Lucky Ring on a skill check that is already passing, to add Treachery cards to the Chaos deck?
- Can Shrivelling snipe a Deep One out of The Deep?
- When a Keeper's Tome action reveals two spells, must you resolve one of them?
- What happens to a Spell card after it is played?
- Are items in a player's play area face up?
- How often can an item be used?
- Can the Jam Tin Grenade be thrown into a water space to hit enemies there?
- Can Edmund's or Mallory's Fortunate Son ability be used to help other players on their turn?
- When Edmund Mallory's Uncanny Fortune says "before you resolve," when does that timing fall?
- Can a reroll modifier change the result of Beatrice Sharpe's feat?
- If a die is rerolled, do modifiers used on the first roll still apply to the reroll?
- Can Unconventional Leader be used to avoid a crisis choice, and does the Mythos card still resolve?
- Can an unrevealed hybrid use the Galley's ship-space ability?
- If an item grants an extra action, is a basic attack taken with it a nested action that loses Kitchen Knife's bonus?
- Can Kitchen Knife's attack bonus be combined with another active item?
- Can a character draw from a skill deck outside their own skill set?
- When a combination crisis lets you choose the skill check, which effects do you resolve?
Travel and Ritual Tracks
- If a waypoint card has a choice on it, who makes that choice?
- Are monsters in the water removed from the board when the ship reaches the Arrive space?
- When does the travel track advance, and how do monsters at the front ever move back?
- When the travel track reaches Arrive, do monsters move before the waypoint resolves?
- What happens when the travel track reaches Arrive?
- Can Shrug It Off prevent a character from being removed during a Ritual?
- Can the Captain look at both waypoint cards and show them to the other players before choosing?
- If the last fuel is spent paying for a Boiler Room roll as the ship reaches land, does the ship get there?
- If the travel token reaches Arrive in the middle of a turn, does the turn end?
- If an effect advances the travel track past Arrive, do the remaining spaces still move after the waypoint resets?
- Does the game start with any Waypoint cards in play?
- Does Jeanne's extra-distance ability trigger on any player's Boiler Room action, or only her own?
Titles
- When a title is lost, who takes it, and can the original holder get it back?
- If every human is in the Brig, who holds the titles, and do they pass to the first human who escapes?
- Who chooses the track when a human in the Brig draws a choice-of-tracks crisis?
- Can one player hold both the Captain and the Keeper of the Tome titles?
Resolving Skill Checks
- Can you play several copies of the same skill card, such as two Determination, into one skill check?
- When several players want to respond in the same window, who decides the order?
- Can humans play negative skill cards into a check to sabotage the Mythos?
- Is a skill check mandatory, or can a player fail one without contributing cards?
- Can other players add skill cards to a skill check that sends a character to the Brig or releases one from it?
- How many skill cards can a character in the Brig add to a skill check?
- Can a character in the Brig play Determination after the skill check total is calculated?
- Can Edmund Mallory's Fortunate Son reroll the same die many times?
- Can Edmund's Fortunate Son reroll a die set by Beatrice Sharpe's Perfect Number feat?
- Can Beatrice Sharpe's Perfect Number set the result of any die roll?
- Are Treachery cards added face up to a skill check made by Family Ties or Memory of the Deep after Nothing to Hide?
- How is the chaos deck rebuilt when it runs out?
- Does the chaos deck add cards to every skill check, including the Captain's Cabin and escaping the Brig?
- Does Keen Insight's modifier still apply when the die is rerolled?
- In what order do players add cards to a skill check?
- When you pass the Memory of the Deep check, is the card discarded, or can William keep it in play?
- If a feat such as Self Sacrifice decides a Ritual Coordination check, does the extra ritual advance for exceeding the target apply?
Activating Monsters
- Can the Book of Dagon push Deep Ones off the ship?
- When Mother Hydra damages the ship and the closest interior space is already damaged, which space takes the damage?
- Where does a Deep One move when its space is already damaged?
- When several Deep Ones in the same interior space activate, do they each damage it?
- Do Deep Ones stay put under Barricade the Hatches when their only possible move goes into the interior?
- Can Deep Ones move off the back of the board into the Deep, like when the ship travels?
- Do Deep Ones in the same space move together when they activate?
- After a Monarch activates, does it move one space or all the way to the front of the ship?
Damage
- Can the Brig be damaged, and can a character still be sent there when the Captain's Cabin is damaged?
- When a space is damaged, are the humans in it defeated?
- When Structural Damage lands in a space with a revealed traitor, is the traitor moved to the Brig?
- Does a Jam Tin Grenade move existing damage when it hits an already damaged interior space?
- Where does the ship damage from Jeanne Lafarge's extra travel step land?
- Can Combat Training reroll any attack, including attacks by Deep Ones or on other players?
- Can you attack Father Dagon or Mother Hydra with a weapon that reaches water spaces?
- Can a damaged space be repaired while a Deep One or a revealed traitor is in it?
- Does repairing a damaged space count as an action?
- If a card damages a specific room that is already damaged, what gets damaged instead?
- Are Deep Ones defeated when a ship interior is damaged by a Mythos card or Mother Hydra?
Defeated
- If Flesh Ward is in my play area and I would be defeated, can someone else play an ability to prevent it so Flesh Ward stays?
- If Shrug It Off prevents one defeat during a Rampage, does it stop the remaining attacks, or later defeats in the same sequence?
- Can Shrug It Off be played in response to Self Sacrifice that defeats you?
- Does Svetlana's ability keep the passenger on the board when it prevents that passenger's defeat?
- Does a defeated character need an action to leave Sick Bay?
- Are unrevealed traitors defeated by Sewage Backup?
- Who rolls the die for Flesh Ward when the spell is in another player's play area?
- Does being defeated end your action step or cost your remaining actions?
Risking Passengers
- If a mythos card says to risk N passengers to do X and fewer than N are in the supply, does X happen?
- When several passenger tiles are in the Deep, can you flip them all before choosing one to resolve?
- May players look at passengers that were defeated and removed from the game?
- Can the top option of Incoming SOS be chosen when there are fewer than four passengers, and what does it give?
- Does a passenger placed in a space with Deep Ones get resolved immediately?
- Can you still be sent a passenger risk when the passenger supply is empty?
Ending the Game
- Can you spend the last fuel and still arrive at Boston in the same Boiler Room action?
- Can an Unfathomable game be continued if a player has to leave partway through?
- Can the Cultist win on the last waypoint when that waypoint reaches 12 distance and also causes a resource loss?
- Does a non-structural damage card that is resolved and removed right away count toward the six damaged spaces that end the game?
Traitors
- What happens to a traitor's second loyalty card if the ship has already traveled 12 or more when they reveal?
- When a hybrid reveals, what happens to their remaining unrevealed loyalty cards?
- If a player holds both a Hybrid and a Cultist loyalty card, which one do they reveal, and what happens to the other?
- Can a Cultist reveal, and can they do it late in the game?
- Can a revealed traitor be sent to the Brig by the Captain's Cabin?
- Can a player reveal another player's loyalty card to the table after looking at it with Deep One Ancestor?
- When can a hidden traitor reveal?
- Does revealing as a traitor use one of your actions, and can you act afterward?
- Do revealed traitors keep their item cards?
- Can a revealed traitor acquire a new item after revealing?
- Can a revealed traitor use skill card abilities such as Determination?
- How many skill cards can a revealed traitor add to a skill check?
- Can an unrevealed traitor win with the humans if they play cooperatively?
- Can a revealed traitor go back to being human?
- Do I need to hand off the spare loyalty card when revealing in a three- or four-player game?
- Does the Chapel treachery card require the traitor to be in the Chapel at the start of their action step, and does it work if the Chapel is damaged?
- Does the Ransack treachery card require the hybrid to start the turn in the room, and does it use up the turn?
- Do Mythos effects that name humans apply to revealed traitors too?
- If the humans lose before any loyalty is revealed, do unrevealed traitors win or lose?
- Can a revealed traitor still use an unused feat, such as Arrest Order, after revealing?
Turn Structure for Revealed Traitors
- When a revealed traitor is dealt a second loyalty card in the Awakening phase, what happens to it?
- Do revealed traitors draw a full hand of skill cards each turn?
- Can a revealed traitor leave the Brig, and what does it cost?
- Do revealed traitors draw a Mythos card at the end of their turn?
- Can revealed traitors use item cards?
- If a revealed traitor reveals while in the Sick Bay, should they move out?
- If you reveal as a traitor on your own turn, do you still get a Mythos phase or your remaining actions?
Interacting with Traitors
- What can a revealed traitor not do while in the Brig?
- If a revealed traitor in the Brig is defeated, what happens?
- Does a traitor's reveal penalty still apply if they reveal while in the Brig?
- Can revealed traitors damage the ship?
- Can Coordinated Effort force another player to reveal as a traitor?
- How does a human player get out of the Brig, and can other players add cards to the escape skill check?
- Does any Mythos card let players leave the Brig?
- Does a human in the Brig still resolve Mythos cards on their turn?
- Can a player use items while in the Brig?
- Can the Captain send a player to the Brig if the Captain's Cabin is damaged?
- Can a revealed traitor in the Brig still draw cards and play action cards?
- If a traitor openly sabotages during Nothing to Hide, are they revealed?
Secrecy
- Can players claim which skill cards they added to a check after it is revealed?
- Can players declare the card types, colors or values they add to a skill check?
- Can you use a character's skill set on their character sheet to work out who the traitor is?
- Can players say in advance, or describe as high or medium, how many skill cards they will add to a check?
- Does Ishmael's feat let you tell the other players that a player is a hybrid?
- Are discarded cards hidden from the other players?
Clarifications
- When Lucky Ring is used on Gift of the Mother, which chaos deck do the two Treachery cards go into?
- If Return the Ring is processed on Gift of the Mother and Lucky Ring is in someone else's play area, is Lucky Ring removed from the game?
- If The Game is Afoot passes, may Jamie choose Sick Bay or the Brig for the Deep Ones?
- On The Game is Afoot, if Try to contain damages no space because Fuel or Food is damaged instead, do Deep Ones spawn?
Unfathomable: From the AbyssExpansion
- Can you rescue all passengers on one space with a single action in the base game?
- Can you give the Cursed Mask to another player repeatedly in one action to draw the whole Treachery deck?
- When the Valise action searches the item deck for an improvement, can you choose any card?
- As a revealed traitor, can you use Spirit Board and then play Ransack or Perform Rites in the same turn?
- Does the Notebook let you take the boon card Companion back to your hand after playing it?
- Are Horror monsters enemies for human players, so cards such as Shriveling or Summon the Beast Within can target them?
- If an Ally is defeated, does it count as a lost soul on the Resource Dial?
- How do Boon cards enter the game?
- When discarding a skill card for a check, does a skill type such as Lore or Strength refer to the card's color or its exact text?
- Can you use an ally before playing Coordinated Effort as your action?
- After Coordinated Effort fully resolves as your second action, can you use an ally?
- Does a room with a Minor Structural Damage card count as damaged for the hybrid win, and does that card defeat players or make allies flee?
- Does Antar's Gather Evidence trigger after every skill check, or only ones he starts?
- What does From the Abyss change about the chaos deck, at setup and when it runs out?
- Can a player granted an action through Coordinated Effort use an ally, and can the granting player also use one?
- How is the Grasping Tendril spawned in the water spaces?
- What does a Mythos card with a specific horror icon do?
- How are horror monsters removed from the board?
- Can a horror pushed into the water still be attacked or repelled?
- Can Sardaana's Watch move her onto a space that holds a passenger?
- Can a revealed traitor, such as Guillame, use allies?
- Can you use the Cadet ally to play Coordinated Effort?
- Can humans use Treachery cards in skill checks, or only revealed traitors?
- Can the Ingenuity boon card count as any skill type to pay a discard cost?
- When a Personal Crisis Mythos card is drawn, which player resolves it?
- Can the Host ally (the Stewardess in the German edition) move a player out of the Brig or Sick Bay?
- When a horror icon pushes the horror track to the last space, does the horror spawn and act right away?
- What happens when a horror in the water space is activated?