RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
Triumph & Tragedy: European Balance of Power 1936-1945 thumbnail

Triumph & Tragedy: European Balance of Power 1936-1945 FAQ

544 questions players ask · Updated Nov 16, 2026 · Full rulebook

Introduction and ComponentsThe MapThe NationsThe UnitsCards & MarkersSetup and Sequence of PlayNew YearDiplomacyTechnologySeasonsMovementCombatReBasingSupplyWar and PeaceVictoryShort Game (1939)Two-Player RulesOptional Rules

Introduction and Components

  • What changed between the second and third edition of the Triumph & Tragedy rulebook?
  • Can one Rival send Production or RES to another Rival as Lend-Lease?
  • What does Friendly mean for movement and control?
  • What happens if a production value goes above the top of the Production track?
  • Do Diplomacy wildcards still work against a faction you are at war with?

The Map

  • In a 3-way battle for a capital, who gets control when the original owner is eliminated?
  • Can a fleet move through an unoccupied enemy-controlled Straits, such as Gibraltar?
  • When an enemy unit leaves Malta or Gibraltar, does control revert to the West?
  • When an invader leaves a Soviet or other Great Power area, does control revert to its owner?
  • Can an air unit keep an area under control after the ground units leave?
  • When is area control checked during a turn?
  • When does an empty enemy area change hands after a ground unit or sea invasion enters it?
  • Is a neutral minor friendly during movement, so an intervening unit can disengage into it or move through it?
  • Does a control marker still keep control of its area after the units that took it leave?
  • When a rival captures a resource area, when do its POP and RES count for production?
  • Do the POP and RES of a neutral's non-capital land area go to the faction that occupies it?
  • Can a lone naval unit take control of an empty enemy-held territory by moving into it?
  • If the Allies attack the Ruhr and the defence holds, does the Axis keep the Ruhr's resources?
  • When does a territory that was captured and then vacated revert to its original owner?
  • Can a naval unit move directly between two coastal areas separated by a strait, such as Algiers to Morocco?
  • Can sea or air units pass through a Rival or Neutral Straits without a Violation of Neutrality or declaration of war?
  • Can a unit pass through a Rival's or an enemy's Straits, and must it stop there?
  • Can a strategic sea move pass through a Rival's Straits?
  • How many ground units can attack Istanbul or another Straits across its land borders?
  • How much movement does crossing a Straits cost, and can a Straits be attacked by land without the invasion penalty?
  • Does a convoy alone in a sea area control that sea area?
  • Who controls an area when two rival factions' units both survive combat there, for example Berlin after the USSR and the West each attack Axis-held Berlin?
  • When Allies take a territory while Berlin is still German, do they gain its population and resources?
  • If you take a neutral's capital, do you control its other areas, and does the former controller lose everything?
  • Is Crete part of the Greece area, or a separate area?
  • If a British fleet occupies Jordan after the Axis takes Suez, does British control of Jordan last?
  • Does moving through an occupied minor's area flip control to the mover?
  • Is Malta an island that needs a sea invasion, or can ground units move onto it by land?
  • Is an enemy home territory that I occupy with no enemy units still friendly territory to me for strategic movement?
  • Can a naval unit bypass the Denmark Straits by going from the Ruhr into the North Sea?
  • Does the Denmark Straits create a sea space linking Norway and Sweden?
  • Do the Azores block direct sea movement from the Bay of Biscay to the Mid-Atlantic Ocean?
  • Can units move between the South Atlantic and the West Indian Ocean, around Africa or by the map arrows?
  • Can units or aircraft use violet out-of-play areas such as Van or Switzerland, including flying over them?
  • How do the Straits work: are they separate regions, and do they cost extra movement?
  • Is attacking into or out of a strait an attack over land, and what engagement limit applies?
  • How do Malta and Sicily work for land movement and sea borders?
  • Does Delhi have access to the sea?
  • If an attack on Delhi fails, do the areas taken from India for control, such as Karachi and Bombay, revert?
  • Does an area stay yours after your units leave it?
  • Does occupying a neutral's factory or population town give control without taking its capital?
  • If an attacker moves into an empty territory, is a fort placed there?
  • Does an unoccupied land area become yours when you attack a country whose capital you control?
  • Does a land area count as occupied when units of two factions share it?
  • Who controls resources in a neutral's territory when a rival unit enters but the capital is still held by someone else?
  • If a faction declares war and enters a space where a former rival's units are engaged, who controls it?
  • If a rival that is not at war with the USSR takes Odessa from the Axis, does Odessa stay in that rival's hands?
  • If a capital's defenders survive an enemy attack, is the capital still friendly for trade and supply?
  • Can an armed minor's territories have split control?
  • When an occupying power leaves an empty area inside a minor, who controls it?
  • Can two rivals each control different areas of a neutral's Population and Resources?
  • When an enemy takes a satellite's capital, who controls the rest of that country?
  • If a conquered colonial capital is vacated, does control revert to its original power?
  • Does occupying a colonial capital give control of all unoccupied territory in that colony?
  • If a satellite's territory is partly occupied by an enemy, does the controlling Great Power lose the POP and RES from the occupied area?
  • What is a Coastal Land Area, and can naval units be placed in one?
  • Is Romania a coastal land area, and can fleets enter non-coastal land areas?
  • Does a unit in a coastal land area fight enemy units in an adjacent sea area?
  • Does a unit that leaves an area to attack lose control of it?
  • How many units can cross a strait border into an unfriendly territory?

The Nations

  • Is Canada a British home territory where new cadres can be built, or a colony?
  • Does Canada stay West if London falls, and does Glasgow stay British?
  • Can new cadres be built in British colonies such as India, the Middle East or Gibraltar?
  • After France falls, can a British unit in Algiers or Syria keep the French colonies under Allied control?
  • If the British unit leaves Algiers after France falls, does Algiers become an Armed Neutral?
  • When Paris falls, do French units still fight in other battles that Combat Phase, and do any French forces survive under Allied control?
  • Can a power enter an undefended French colony such as Algiers before France is defeated without a Violation of Neutrality?
  • What happens to a Major Power's units and colonies when its capital falls?
  • What happens when a Great Power loses its Main Capital?
  • After a Major Power is defeated, can its units be built again, or its capital recaptured?
  • Can USA forces arrive in a disputed area after the USA becomes a West satellite?
  • Can USA units be built with West Production before the USA enters the war?
  • When the USA becomes a West satellite, do the West gain its POP and RES, and does the USA muster its own units?
  • Do USA population and resources go to the West when the USA is a trading partner?
  • Do Italian or French units follow separate political rules inside their faction?
  • When a neutral becomes a satellite, what happens to its own force pool?
  • If a neutral's capital falls during a Violation of Neutrality, what happens to the other areas still being attacked?
  • What are the entry requirements for associates, protectorates and satellites?
  • Can troops pass through a minor's territory to reach a distant area without taking its capital?
  • What counts as a capital for French North Africa, and what happens if Algiers falls?
  • If an enemy captures or occupies a colonial capital, does it gain control of the colony's unoccupied areas?
  • When a Major Power's capital is conquered during combat, when is its defeat evaluated, and how is capture defined?
  • Does Albania get a control marker when a power occupies it?
  • Does violating Albania trigger reaction cards, fortress defenders or combat?
  • Who gets a defeated Major Power's POP and RES when its capital is taken?
  • How is control of a minor decided when a rival's land units are in its territory?
  • What happens when a minor nation is invaded: does it produce units for the conqueror, or is it defeated?
  • Does Malta gain a fortress when it becomes an Armed Neutral?
  • Does a colony that the Axis already controls become an Armed Minor when its mother country falls?
  • Can substitute neutral fortresses be used when the game's fortresses run out?
  • Where can fortresses be built?
  • Can a Fort cadre be built in colonies or other land areas a faction controls?
  • Where can new cadres and naval units be built?

The Units

  • Can you add steps to units in a disputed area, at sea, or in an unsupplied area, including fortresses?
  • What is the firepower of Infantry against naval units (N)?
  • What is Infantry's movement allowance?
  • Is each faction limited to deploying only as many cadre types as its standard stickers provide?
  • Are convoys subject to supply checks?
  • Must a hidden block be revealed when entering an empty enemy territory?
  • How many blocks can a player build if they run out of the physical pieces?
  • Can carriers strike submarines in a shoot-and-scoot attack?
  • Can air units rebase onto a carrier, or launch planes from one?
  • Are convoys naval units, and can they rebase?
  • Can convoys engage an enemy in a sea area, even with naval escorts?
  • Can a multi-CV unit be split into several smaller blocks?
  • Can ANS units (air, naval and submarine) gain control of a land area, or only keep it?
  • What happens when two Command cards in one season have the same letter?
  • Are there stacking limits in Triumph and Tragedy beyond border limits?

Cards & Markers

  • How does a Tech pair in the Secret Vault count against hand size, and does a revealed Tech count?
  • What is the Current Hand Size marker for?
  • Can a Coup card turn a satellite nation into an Armed Neutral?
  • Can a Coup card be played on the USA?
  • Does a Coup cancel influence cards played this turn whose influence has not yet been placed?
  • Does a Double Agent card counter a Coup when the Coup player has no influence on the board?
  • When Double Agent is played against a Spy Ring, is the original card cancelled and its effect turned on the first player?
  • Does a Diplomacy wildcard change influence at once, and does it make a neutral a satellite on the spot?
  • Can a player tell the others what they saw with a Mole card?
  • Can espionage cards be played against enemies, or only against rivals?

Setup and Sequence of Play

  • Does the USSR still start with a 3-CV infantry in Moscow, and does Britain start with units in Karachi or Gibraltar?
  • Do the force pools change in the second edition?
  • Where do the Axis start with two cadres: Munich or Hamburg?
  • Does the Playbook setup place a starting Cadre in Glasgow?
  • Does the Axis always take the first turn in 1936 under the official rules?
  • Are the phases of a season the Command, Movement and Combat phases, or the whole season?
  • Does the game start in 1936, and do players start with action cards?
  • When can a player look at their initial hand in Triumph & Tragedy?
  • Is buying at setup done the same way as buying in production?
  • Can the player choose which unit goes where at setup?
  • How many Resources does the USSR start with, and can they all be used?
  • Does the first player change between seasons of the same year?
  • If all three rivals play the same USA card in the Government phase, how does it resolve?

New Year

  • Where can cadres be built, and do colonies count as home territory?
  • How far can Industry rise in one year, and does Sabotage or Foreign Aid change the limit?
  • Can USA units arrive in 1942 if the USA only becomes a West Satellite from the free 1942 influence?
  • Does violating a neutral cost you the next Peace Dividend, even with no battle?
  • Does occupying part of a neutral without a battle cost the Peace Dividend?
  • Does violating a neutral or fighting an Armed Minor end a faction's At Peace status?
  • Does the game start with the New Year procedure in 1936, including Peace Dividends?
  • Can an unsupplied Air Force or submarine be built or upgraded?
  • Can a naval or submarine unit at sea, or in a battle, be built or upgraded?
  • Can Infantry, Armor or Fortress units be built in unsupplied territory, even in Home Territory?
  • Can Italy build its own fort in Malta after capturing it, or only a German one?
  • Where can Major Power and Great Power fortresses be built?
  • Can a Great Power build non-fortress cadres in a satellite or other non-home territory it controls?
  • Can cadres be built, or CVs added, in Gibraltar and Malta?
  • Can new cadres, steps or CVs be added in an area where a battle is being fought?
  • How is Production level calculated at peace versus at war?
  • Can you look at Action or Investment cards as you buy them during Production?
  • Can a player who passed earlier in the Government phase play cards later?
  • Does a contested but still controlled capital still produce?
  • How many new cadres can be built in one home territory during a Production phase?

Diplomacy

  • Where can a control marker go in a neutral country, and does it stop enemy units from moving?
  • If a neutral country is split between two factions, who controls the areas that no one occupies?
  • Does a third Influence marker make a neutral a Satellite as soon as it is placed?
  • Are Diplomacy Wildcards resolved immediately, and can they be played in any order with other Diplomacy cards?
  • Does a Diplomacy Wildcard cancel an opposing Diplomacy card?
  • Can a rival's card or a Coup remove a Wildcard's influence marker?
  • What do the orange and green text boxes on the Diplomacy Wildcards in rule 8.3 mean?
  • How are several Diplomacy cards played on the same neutral resolved?
  • Does turn order matter when Diplomacy cards conflict over the same neutral, or can the first player lock a rival out?
  • When a Diplomacy card places an influence marker, do POP and RES change immediately?
  • Can you remove your own influence marker to stop a rival's attack from forcing war on a protector?
  • Can repudiation remove a Control marker, such as a satellite's or an occupier's?
  • Can a Coup turn a satellite back into a neutral, or be played against the USA?
  • Can Isolationism be played to cancel a USA card the Axis just played?
  • Does Fear & Loathing let you remove your own influence, or a Rival's, from a Neutral?
  • Does the USA get an automatic influence marker in 1941?
  • How does the West's public opinion influence on the USA interact with an existing Rival influence marker?
  • Can the Axis or USSR place influence in the USA, and does it cancel with the West's?
  • When the USA becomes a West Satellite, which Satellite effects still apply, and what does it place?
  • What happens if the Axis violates USA neutrality, or lands units in the USA or Canada?
  • Can the Soviet Union violate USA or Canadian neutrality to bring the USA into the war?
  • Can free USA units be built up in the same Production, and does 'not if England' bar building in Britain?
  • Do USA forces arrive in separate yearly waves once the USA is a West Satellite?
  • If the USA is not a West Satellite when its free forces are due, can the West still build them later?
  • Can the West build USA units with Production once the USA is a West Satellite, even before 1942?
  • Does the West get the USA's POP and RES once it has an influence marker or is a satellite?
  • Can the West use neutral USA population and resources in a year when the West is blockaded?
  • What are the 'primary types' of USA Forces in rule 8.45?
  • Do sea-invasion reaction forces for the USA depend on whether it is neutral or a West Satellite?
  • Can the Intimidation card target Sweden from Germany?
  • What do a minor's muster-value units do when it becomes a Satellite, and where are they placed?
  • If a minor gets two Influence markers, does the controlling faction gain extra POP or RES?
  • Does a unit's attack on a Protectorate's town or city require a declaration of war?
  • Can a player take back a Diplomacy or Action card already played?
  • When must a player declare war relative to other players' moves in a season?
  • Can a nation end a war by declaring peace?
  • Can two factions that are not at war agree to let troops cross each other's territory?
  • Can you play a card for influence when every target minor is already a Satellite or an Armed Minor?

Technology

  • Can a player hold a second copy of a technology they already have in the Secret Vault to stop rivals gaining it?
  • When both sides have FirstFire in a combat, who fires first?
  • Are Technologies in the Secret Vault active before they are revealed, and does a hidden Motorized Infantry get its movement bonus?
  • Must Atomic Research stage 1 be revealed before stage 2?
  • How do you show that Atomic Research stages were achieved in the right order?
  • Can you skip Atomic Research stages with a Mole card, or pair different Atomic cards to reach a stage?
  • How does Industrial Espionage let a player gain a revealed Technology, including into the Secret Vault?
  • Can Industrial Espionage be paired with a Science card, or with the Technology printed on its own card?
  • Does Air Defense Radar let one combat value of air forces score two hits?
  • Can the active player use Air Defense Radar in a disputed area it controls?
  • Can a faction reach five Technologies on its first turn by buying all Investment cards?
  • Can air units bomb an enemy's Industry at its capital, and can the defender fire back?
  • Can Science or Industrial Espionage cards be placed in the Secret Vault?
  • Can a Technology be developed in the vault with a Science card from a later year?
  • When can a player reveal a secret Technology?
  • How do you verify that the tech pair in a Secret Vault was chosen correctly?
  • What does the M value on Technology cards such as Heavy Bombers mean?
  • Can a player develop a Technology such as Jets as early as 1936?

Seasons

  • Does resolving a land battle carried over from an earlier Season need a Command card, and can Emergency Command do it?
  • Can I resolve an existing battle if I don't play a Command card?
  • Does each ongoing battle need its own Command card, or can one card resolve several battles?
  • Can an Emergency Command card move a ground unit into a neutral or an Armed Minor to intervene?
  • Can units moved by the USSR Winter command leave Russia, or can units outside Russia move in Winter?
  • Which movement value and Command order value apply when the USSR plays a Winter card?
  • Who sets Command Order when Command letters tie, including when one card is Emergency Command?
  • Can Emergency Command reinforce a disputed battle in enemy-owned territory?
  • Can you play more than one Command card in a Season?
  • Can an Investment card be played as a dummy Command card?
  • If you have no Command card for the Season, do you still get a Player Turn?
  • How many combat phases can happen in one area each Season when several players have units there?

Movement

  • Is entering an empty Straits a sea invasion, and do coastal invasion limits apply?
  • Can a land unit pass through two adjacent Straits in one move, and can a Straits be used by land or by sea?
  • Does entering a Straits cost a movement point?
  • How many ground units can cross a Straits border in one turn?
  • Are land border limits counted per border or per country, and can units from two neighbouring areas each cross?
  • Do border limits restrict ordinary movement, or only engaging and disengaging?
  • Do border limits apply when moving land units into an area that already has a battle?
  • Can a strategic move pass through a Straits, or through a neutral or rival land area?
  • Can a sea move pass through a neutral or rival Straits without stopping?
  • Must a fleet or submarine stop when it enters an enemy-controlled Straits, even if it is empty?
  • Can a sea move pass through a Straits and carry on, or end in an adjacent coastal area?
  • Can a convoy make a sea invasion of a coastal area from a Straits?
  • Does LST technology let two ground units land across a coastal border, including a Straits and a friendly battle?
  • How many ground units can invade a coastal or Straits area from the sea in one turn, and is the limit per border or per area?
  • Can a convoy land in a friendly battle or a disputed friendly area as a reinforcement, and can it fight that turn?
  • Is a convoy landing in a territory you already control a sea invasion, and what limits apply?
  • Can ground units landed by sea invasion fire or retreat on the turn they land?
  • How does a sea invasion resolve when the landing Infantry faces a Fortress with fleets in support?
  • Can a convoy engage enemy ships at sea, fight another convoy, or enter an enemy sea area to start a battle?
  • What happens to convoys sharing a sea area with rival units when war is declared?
  • Can a convoy invade a coastal area it already sits in after declaring war, without first disengaging?
  • Can a naval or submarine unit use Land Movement to enter an adjacent coastal area, and must it start at sea?
  • Can a naval or submarine unit move by land between coastal areas on different coastlines or different seas?
  • Must a fleet or convoy stop when it enters a coastal land area during sea movement, and are naval units limited by coastal borders?
  • Can a naval unit pass from the Baltic to the North Sea through the Ruhr?
  • Can a fleet leave a coastal land area by any coastline, or into any adjacent sea, regardless of where it entered?
  • Can a coastal fleet move from Oslo to Stockholm without stopping in the Denmark Strait?
  • Does an enemy unit in an intervening sea area stop a convoy's sea move?
  • Must enemy naval units be cleared from a coastal land area before a sea invasion can land ground units?
  • Can a unit combine land movement and sea movement in one move?
  • Can an air unit move over both land and sea in a single move?
  • Can an air unit stay at sea without moving, and where may it go if it moves?
  • Where must an air unit that starts its move at sea end, and can it join a sea invasion or a land battle that turn?
  • Can an air force that starts its move at sea use Strategic Movement?
  • Can air units fly over enemy territory without stopping, and does passing through count as a raid?
  • Can naval or air units without ground support attack an enemy land area?
  • Can naval or air units alone take over an unoccupied enemy territory or capture an area?
  • Can strategic bombers raid an enemy capital that has no defending units?
  • Can a ship move one sea space and then raid a land area, or must it be adjacent to that land first?
  • How far can a ground unit move by Sea Movement, and must it stop when it reaches a land area?
  • Can a unit sail straight from one coastal land area into another in a single move, such as London to Paris?
  • Can a sea invasion or a convoy move strategically, or invade after a strategic move?
  • Do submarines, carriers and convoys get the strategic movement bonus?
  • Can subs or aircraft move strategically through an enemy-occupied sea area, and do escaped submarines block strategic movement?
  • Can submarines move past enemy fleets without engaging them?
  • Must ground units stop when they enter an area containing an enemy submarine?
  • How do American land units reach London, and how many can enter from Glasgow?
  • Can a land unit and a convoy both use the Denmark to Norway crossing in one season, and can a convoy sail through Denmark and invade Norway?
  • How many land units can attack Leningrad from Finland?
  • Can naval and submarine units move into inland, non-coastal land areas?
  • Does a ground unit that enters a sea area become a convoy for the rest of its move?
  • Does a convoy take double hits after it lands?
  • Can a single infantry convoy conquer an undefended major capital?
  • How do BattleGroups work in a sea battle, and must units in one start together on the same route?
  • Must a unit be in a Straits to interdict enemy movement through it?
  • Does entering a violated neutral's territory count as an invasion for border limits, even when only Armed Neutral units are there?
  • Can units pass through an empty enemy-controlled area without stopping, and can they disengage into it?
  • Can units keep moving after entering an empty enemy land area, and does passing through it count as disengaging?
  • If units enter a vacant enemy area and leave units there, can other units attack from that area in the same turn?
  • Does moving units into an existing battle force that battle to be fought?
  • Does moving into an area with only enemy units and an enemy fort count as Aggression, forcing combat when a rival intervenes?
  • Is entering a sea area that holds only enemy units an act of Aggression?
  • Can a player disengage from one battle to reinforce another battle in the same movement phase?
  • Can a Western unit fight in Berlin to help the Axis if the USSR holds it?
  • Can a ground unit engage or disengage across a coastal border by land?
  • Can units leave a battle by normal movement, or must they retreat, and can a unit in a battle disengage into another area?
  • Must a ground unit moving through unoccupied neutral territory stop there?
  • Can rival naval units not at war share a sea area, and can my units pass through a sea where two rivals are fighting?
  • Can units of rival factions share one land area without combat?
  • Can a unit from Norway or Berlin enter Denmark by land through the Ruhr, and is a Baltic sea invasion disrupted?
  • Is there a separate Coastal Area space type that units can move through?
  • Can a strategic move end in enemy territory after a declaration of war?
  • Does the Mechanized Infantry movement bonus apply to infantry carried as a convoy?
  • Can one unit use its whole movement allowance across several separate moves in one turn?
  • What does it cost to enter an Ocean, Sea or Land area, and do air units pay the Ocean cost too?
  • To move a unit from the Red Sea or Gulf of Aden to the South Atlantic Ocean, must it pass through the West Indian Ocean?
  • Does a naval unit sitting in a coastal land area make the adjacent seas enemy-controlled?
  • Does flying an air unit through a neutral area without stopping count as Aggression for a Violation of Neutrality?
  • Do border limits apply when naval units use Land Movement?
  • Must a unit stop in Albania when moving through it toward Yugoslavia?
  • Can a naval unit sea-move across a land border, for example from Marseille to Gascony?
  • Can a ground unit move into an empty enemy land area and occupy it in the same move, even if it cannot fight that turn?
  • If a unit enters an area with an ongoing battle against an armed minor, can units from another area pass through it?
  • Must you announce what movement type each hidden unit uses, and can a boat hidden as a block invade an empty enemy coastal area?
  • Can a sea unit raid a neutral space to destroy a one-CV fortress so that a convoy can land the next season?
  • If Axis declares war in summer while its units sit in a sea area with the West, must those Axis units stay stuck?
  • Can a land unit convoyed from Milan to Barcelona move three spaces in one turn?
  • Can a fleet move through sea areas occupied by rival or enemy units?

Combat

  • Can an air, naval, or submarine unit take over an empty enemy territory such as Rome?
  • What is a Raid, and must raiders retreat after the combat?
  • Does air or naval aggression at sea count as a Raid?
  • Is a fleet attack on an enemy coastal or Straits area a Land Battle and a Raid?
  • Where can a unit that attacked this turn retreat to?
  • If an attacker moves through an empty enemy area to engage, can it retreat back into that area?
  • When a fleet survives an attack on an enemy-held Straits, can it retreat anywhere other than where it came from?
  • Can a defender retreat into an area that a raid is attacking, and does the retreating unit take part in that raid?
  • When an attacker faces two rival enemies in one sea area, which enemy is fought first, and do the fights merge?
  • Can a unit in a battle decline to fire and simply stay in place?
  • In what order do units act in a combat round, and can a unit retreat before slower units fire?
  • Can an aggressor retreat in the first round of combat?
  • Do units that have not fired retreat after the other side is eliminated in a battle?
  • Does a combat value of 0 against a unit class stop that unit from attacking or retreating?
  • When several units of one type attack, can each unit choose its own target class?
  • Can a unit target a class that has no units in the battle, or a class that has no effect on it?
  • Do identical units roll together, or does each block fire on its own?
  • When a hit lands on a carrier or convoy, does the extra damage spill onto another unit, and what happens to two one-CV carriers?
  • Can a defender choose which ship in a mixed naval group takes hits, to shield carriers or convoys?
  • Can a convoy fire, retreat, engage, or rebase in a sea battle, and can an escort shield it?
  • Are convoys targeted separately from other units in a naval battle?
  • Does a ground unit that landed from the sea still count as a convoy when it fights?
  • If an ANS force retreats and leaves a convoy in a land battle, does the convoy stay in the battle through seasons with no command card?
  • If only aircraft attack an unguarded convoy at sea, can the convoy survive?
  • After a declaration of war, must units left in a sea area shared with the new enemy fight?
  • Can ground units landing from the sea fire in the turn they land, and does that include tanks?
  • Do disrupted or newly landed ground units count as ground support in the same battle?
  • How many ground units can engage across a Straits border, and can units landing by sea fire that turn?
  • Do land battles last more than one combat round, and what happens to a fleet left alone against land units?
  • Must the order of several battles be fixed before the first one resolves?
  • Must naval or air units retreat when enemy ground units enter their land area, or when the territory changes hands?
  • Can a naval unit stay in a land area after the ground units that entered with it have left?
  • Who controls a contested area when only enemy ANS units and friendly ground units remain after a battle?
  • Can a defending submarine stop enemy ground units from taking control of a coastal area?
  • When ground support is lost mid-battle, do unsupported ANS units have to retreat, and do the battle's remaining units still act?
  • Are battles that were not activated checked for ANS ground support when a combat round ends?
  • Must an air unit rebase after a land battle when friendly ground units remain, or after winning by bombing?
  • To take over a country, must every enemy unit be eliminated, and what happens to a lone submarine?
  • When can a submarine escape from a battle?
  • What does an escaped submarine do to control, movement, supply and trade routes?
  • Can enemy units re-engage an escaped submarine, and does doing so cost command?
  • After a submarine escapes and stays in a sea area, who is the aggressor in a later combat there?
  • Can a second battle group attack a submerged escaped submarine in the same season?
  • How many battle groups can join a sea battle in one combat round, and do earlier groups keep fighting?
  • Does a sea battle end when its first battle group is destroyed while other groups have yet to join?
  • What counts as a battle group?
  • Can a second battle group join an escaped submarine's battle in the first round?
  • Must air units rebase after a sea combat round, and when does each battle group's air rebase?
  • When an air unit joins a late battle group, or arrives by another route, must it rebase?
  • Can a carrier make a Carrier Strike from a land area?
  • Can a carrier retreat or rebase during a sea battle with several battle groups?
  • Does an air force at sea cut off a fleet's retreat by sea?
  • Can engaging air units block a defender's retreat into the area they came from?
  • Can a ground unit retreat through more than one space?
  • Can a fleet retreat into an ocean, and can ground units retreat into a sea area?
  • When a land battle is lost, can a defending fleet retreat along the coast into an adjacent land area?
  • Do naval units in different coastal areas of one land space fight each other, and can enemy ships in a coastal area you attack leave by sea?
  • What is the difference between retreating, rebasing and disengaging?
  • Can an ANS unit retreat or rebase into an area where a land unit has just invaded from the sea?
  • Are units in a contested area hidden, and when are units placed face up?
  • Can fortresses fire in combat, including when an enemy stays in the fortified area?
  • When a neutral fortress fires in a battle, who chooses the target?
  • Does First Fire Surprise apply when attacking a neutral?
  • Can defenders upgrade units in a battle still ongoing when the next year starts?
  • In a battle with three factions, can the defenders fire at each other?
  • In a three-faction battle, how does the attacker choose which enemy faction to target?
  • In a three-faction battle, can a faction target a rival it is not at war with?
  • In a three-way battle, what fires first when one defender has an initiative tech?
  • In a three-faction battle, who owns a disputed area when the current owner is eliminated?
  • If a unit moves into an enemy-controlled area, must it fight in the next combat phase, and must a side that did not aggress attack?
  • Does an ongoing battle need a command card to continue into the next season, and does it cost command value?
  • Can units reinforce a disputed area without making it an active battle, and must reinforcing units attack?
  • If a side activates or counterattacks an existing battle, which side counts as the attacker?
  • Does Surprise let an attacker fire first against a defender with First Fire technology?
  • If both sides have First Fire technology and one of them declares war, who fires first?
  • Does the First Fire bonus from a declaration of war last past the declaring player's turn?
  • Does strategic bombing replace a unit's normal attack, and where must the bomber be?
  • When air units bomb an enemy capital, do the capital's units fire at the bombers, and who fires first?
  • Can an air force scout a rival at peace to reveal it?
  • Can a unit retreat from a battle in one season and move back into fighting later with a command card?
  • After a raid or a supporting attack, can a fleet forced to retreat return to its sea area?

ReBasing

  • Can an active naval or air unit rebase after a combat round even if the defenders survive?
  • Can an Air Force or submarine pass through enemy-occupied areas when it rebases?
  • After a battle is won, must a naval, submarine or air unit rebase, or can it retreat?
  • Can a submarine rebase forward through an enemy-held strait such as Gibraltar?
  • Can an active naval or air unit rebase after it has used all of its movement?
  • Does rebasing after surviving a land combat round count as a retreat?
  • Must an active ANS unit have won the battle to rebase after combat?
  • Can a naval unit rebase into a sea area or a disputed area?
  • Can ANS units retreat by rebasing when they are forced to retreat in the Supply Phase?
  • Must air units rebase at the end of a sea combat round?
  • Must defending air units rebase after a ground battle when the attacker still has ground units there?
  • How do air forces patrol at sea, and how do they get back to land?
  • Can a convoy retreat or rebase after a naval combat round?
  • Where can attacking units retreat or rebase after engaging this turn?
  • What is the difference between an ANS rebase and an ANS retreat?
  • After a submarine fights a unit it cannot damage, must it rebase or may it retreat normally?
  • Can an air force choose to retreat in combat, and when must it rebase?
  • After eliminating every enemy unit in a combat round, can participating air forces rebase by strategic movement?
  • Can a fleet or carrier retreat or rebase through an enemy-controlled strait?
  • Can victorious air or sea units rebase into a land area they just captured in the same combat phase?
  • After a land battle, must air units without ground support rebase?

Supply

  • Can a unit's supply trace to a sub-capital such as Delhi or Rome?
  • Can supply lines or trade routes pass through neutral or rival territory?
  • How many land and sea segments can a trade route or supply line have?
  • Do convoys have to trace supply at sea, and do unsupplied convoys take attrition?
  • Can a blockade be declared in the year war is declared?
  • Which units at sea block supply lines and trade routes?
  • Is there a Winter Supply Phase, and which units does its supply check cover?
  • If I temporarily open a blockaded route during a season, does that lift the blockade?
  • At the end of Summer, what must a faction trace to avoid a blockade marker?
  • When are blockades declared, and must a Faction at War mark them?
  • Must a blockade be in effect at both the Summer and Fall checks to reduce a rival's production?
  • Can resources captured in Fall be used for next year's Production if a Summer blockade covered their area?
  • If the Main Capital falls, are all POP and RES blockaded, and does regaining it in Fall lift the blockade?
  • When do units in an area that changed control during a movement phase check supply?
  • Once two Rivals go to war, when do their units start checking supply?
  • If a season passes with no player taking a turn, is the Supply Phase still resolved?
  • Must units in a satellite draw supply from the satellite's own capital?
  • Can you place units in a satellite that have no supply line to them?
  • Does Washington count as a supply source once the USA is a West satellite?
  • Which capitals can supply a faction's units?
  • After a Major Power is defeated and its capital is retaken, can Paris, Rome or Washington still serve as supply sources?
  • Is a supply line still valid if it starts in or passes through a disputed area?
  • If a unit attacks through an out-of-supply area, is it in supply after combat when its supply line runs through the battle area?
  • Do ground units surrounded in Konigsberg by enemy units have to check supply?
  • Does a conquered territory without units still count as supplied?
  • When an ANS-held area loses its supply, must the ANS unit retreat when all friendly ground units are removed by supply losses?
  • Can a supply route be traced between the South Atlantic and the West Indian Ocean?
  • What does a Mediterranean blockade do to population and resources?
  • Is each POP or RES source traced separately when checking blockades?
  • If a Great Power partly conquers a neutral or enemy territory, does it get that area's resources?
  • Are population and resources that you only influence, not control, affected by blockades?
  • At Year Start, are all POP and RES sources rechecked for blockades?
  • Does controlling the Azores shut down Atlantic supply routes?
  • Can a convoy or an air unit at sea blockade a trade route?

War and Peace

  • Does the Surprise bonus from a declaration of war apply against every enemy or only the faction you declared on?
  • Does the Surprise bonus apply when attacking an Armed Neutral?
  • Can a sea invasion convoy slip past a rival fleet in the English Channel before war is declared?
  • If the aggression needed for a declaration of war is blocked, can Intervention still follow?
  • Must an intervening power stop its land units when they first enter the neutral's territory?
  • Can an air unit fly over a neutral's territory without first declaring a Violation of Neutrality?
  • Does a second entry into an Armed Neutral need another Violation of Neutrality, and can it return to neutral?
  • Must an aggressor stop in a violated minor that has no towns or cities?
  • When the Axis violates a minor while at war with the West, does the United States draw a World Reaction card?
  • When can World Reaction cards drawn from a Violation of Neutrality be played?
  • What happens to influence markers and POP/RES when a neutral is violated?
  • Must a Rival declare a Violation of Neutrality before moving into Albania?
  • Does Albania, which has no capital, need continuous occupation to stay under control, and does a violation create a fort or World Reaction?
  • Can a war be ended, or can a player make peace with another faction?
  • Does violating a neutral cost a faction its peace dividend, and when can it earn dividends again?
  • After declaring war, must units sharing a sea with the new enemy fight immediately?
  • Does attacking a satellite make the minor an Armed Minor or trigger World Reaction?
  • If a protectorate or satellite is invaded, does it become an Armed Minor?
  • Can a trade route pass through an Armed Minor, and must a violator still trace supply while at peace with its other Rivals?
  • After a failed invasion of a neutral, does the surviving fort stay on the map?
  • When an Armed Minor's capital falls, do its fortresses in other territories disappear?
  • Which units do an Armed Minor's neutral fortresses fire at first?
  • Does a fort in a neutral minor stop a unit moving through it during an Intervention?
  • Can one Intervention convert all of an Armed Minor's remaining fortresses into any unit type?
  • Can an Intervention convert an Armed Minor whose territory is still held by enemy units?
  • When does an Intervention convert the fortresses?
  • Does an Intervention still work after the violating units have left the neutral?
  • Must an Intervention happen in the same year as the Violation of Neutrality?
  • After an Intervention into a minor's capital that still holds enemy units, is a control marker placed in the capital?
  • Can a power that joins after another has violated a neutral still partition it, or intervene?
  • What is the difference between Partition and Intervention when a second power enters an Armed Minor?
  • If a Major Power is defeated while a Rival unit is in its colony, does the colony become an Armed Minor?
  • Does a Rival unit entering the capital of an Armed Minor colony count as a Violation of Neutrality?
  • When is an Armed Minor defeated, and does occupying its capital without changing control defeat it?
  • If Axis units capture an Armed Minor's capital, must the battles in its other territories still be fought?
  • If the Axis defeats France, does French North Africa become an Armed Minor, and can the West intervene if it is violated?
  • How long does the Surprise first fire last after declaring war?
  • What does a declaration of war cost the declarer and the victim?
  • When in the turn must a declaration of war be made?
  • When must a Violation of Neutrality be declared relative to movement?
  • What aggression must follow a declaration of war?
  • Can a declaration of war be made just to attack rival ships at sea, and does moving into a protectorate count as the aggression?
  • Can units that appear through a declaration of war or an Intervention, such as converted fortresses, be the aggression that justifies the declaration?
  • Must you declare war on a Rival before moving into an area that contains its units?
  • Does a Violation of Neutrality require aggression, and can a player declare one and then not invade?
  • Can a Violation of Neutrality be declared against a neutral that you cannot reach?
  • Can one move pass through several unoccupied neutral territories, and does an empty neutral still count as a Violation?
  • Can an attacker declare war and a Violation of Neutrality on Persia and the Soviets, then move through empty Tabriz to Baku in one season?
  • Do you need a Violation of Neutrality to move through a neutral country?
  • Do enemies as well as rivals draw World Reaction cards when a neutral is violated?
  • When a protectorate is invaded, is a Violation of Neutrality needed as well as a declaration of war?
  • What does an Intervention need, and what does it do?
  • Does an Intervention require controlling the minor's territory, and does supply matter?
  • Can a Rival enter an undefeated Armed Minor's territory without a Violation of Neutrality?
  • Can two Rivals split one neutral between them, and must they declare war on each other?
  • When a neutral's capital falls to one Rival, who keeps the areas where another Rival's units stand?
  • If the units that hold an area in a neutral leave it, does control revert to the capital holder?
  • When a neutral's capital is held by its Armed Neutral units, does an invader gain control of the non-capital areas it occupies?

Victory

  • Do blockade effects count toward a 1945 Economic Hegemony victory?
  • Do blockades from last Summer still count at the New Year victory check?
  • Do blockade effects reduce a faction's Victory Points during the game?
  • What makes up a faction's Victory Points?
  • Does the printed Industry marker count toward Victory Points?
  • What is a Great Power's final score if its Main Capital has been captured?
  • If your Main Capital is taken and you have no Action cards, can you recover?
  • Do diplomatic alliances give victory points?
  • Does Military Victory need two capitals of the same rival, or can they come from different factions?
  • Must the two enemy capitals for Military Victory be controlled at the same time?
  • Does a faction need to hold its own capital to win by Military Victory?
  • Does capturing a Rival's capital count toward Military Victory if you are not at war with that Rival?
  • When does a captured capital count toward Military Victory, and when is the win established?
  • Must occupying units trace supply to a friendly capital to control an enemy capital for Military Victory?
  • Does a capital taken in Fall 1945 combat count if no Soviet Winter phase follows?
  • Does Washington count as a West sub-capital for Military Victory once the USA is a West satellite?
  • When is an Atomic Victory won, and when must the air unit be in range?
  • Must the bomber survive defenses to deliver the bomb for an Atomic Victory?
  • Can naval air deliver the atomic bomb for an Atomic Victory?
  • Does an Air Force engaged in combat still count for an Atomic Victory if it is within range of the enemy capital?
  • Can an A-Bomb victory be won by showing that a friendly Air unit could reach a Rival Main Capital?
  • If two factions reach 25 VP at the same New Year check, who wins the Economic Victory?
  • If two players declare victory at the start of a year with equal points, who wins?
  • How is a tie in victory points at the end of 1945 resolved?
  • If a Great Power loses its capital and sub-capital, does the game end?
  • Does a faction need to declare war to enter an associate's territory, such as Sweden?

Short Game (1939)

  • In the short game, do the Axis's 7 Diplomacy cards come from its 18 starting Action cards?
  • How is the build order for initial cadres in the short game (1939 scenario) set?
  • Can a unit gain more than one step from the extra builds in the short game setup?
  • In the Short Game, does the Axis place forces when a minor becomes a satellite through its unopposed Diplomacy play?

Two-Player Rules

  • How does the passive ally get its starting action cards in a two-player game?
  • In the two-player game, do the Allies win if each takes one sub-capital in the same turn?
  • Which Allied starting cadres must be Fortresses in the two-player setup?
  • In a two-player game, do identical Soviet and West diplomacy cards cancel each other?
  • In the two-player rules, what is the second card for on an offensive turn?

Optional Rules

  • What does the Territorial Straits option do at Suez and Istanbul?
  • What does the Britannia Rules the Waves optional rule add to the West's setup?
  • Is the Home Seas rule part of the official Triumph & Tragedy rules?