The Pillars of the Earth FAQ
92 questions players ask · Updated Nov 13, 2026 · Full rulebook
Game Components
Round Structure and Game End
Phase I: Selection of the Resource Cards and Craftsmen
Phase II: Master Builder Assignments
- Must the master builders drawn from the bag be placed before the ones that were passed?
- Are master builders free to place once the cost marker reaches zero?
- If a player passes on placing a drawn master builder, when is it placed and does it cost gold?
- How does the event that lets each player place only two master builders work with the bag?
- Can one player occupy several spaces in the same area, such as both Kingsbridge Priory spaces?
- If one player takes both Kingsbridge Priory spaces, how many victory points do they score?
- Can you place more than one master builder at the Market or the King's Court?
- In a two-player game, what happens to the cost marker after all six master builders are drawn?
- Can you place two of your own master builders on the Market or at the King's Court?
- Can you pay a master builder's placement cost with victory points if you lack the gold?
- Who draws the master builders from the bag, and can the starting player draw again?
Phase III: Events and Protection
- When an event makes you lose a craftsman, is it a craftsman card, a master builder or a worker?
- Does the Archbishop's Office protection stop a positive event, and can you still take a resource?
- If you cannot pay an event's 4-gold cost, do you lose victory points?
- Does a master builder in the King's Court exempt you from the William Hamleigh tax event?
- How long does an event card's effect last?
- Does the Archbishop's Madonna statue event give you an extra craftsman, or raise every craftsman's capacity?
- Is the resource taken from the market with the Archbishop's Office free, and does it need a Woodworker?
- Can the free resource from the Archbishop's Office be metal?
Phase III: Game Board Actions
- Do resource fields 6, 7 and 8 need a master builder to claim their resources?
- If the supply runs out of a resource, do workers come home empty, or are resources unlimited?
- Is there a maximum of 30 gold a player can hold?
- If you cannot pay the King's Court tax in full, how many victory points do you lose?
- Can victory points go below zero?
- Can you exchange victory points for gold to pay a cost?
- When in the round does the market happen relative to converting resources into victory points?
- In what order are the game board actions resolved?
- Are victory points from craftsmen scored in turn order or all at once?
- Do you pay gold to claim a craftsman on Shiring when the board resolves?
- When do the gray workers from Shiring Castle return to the supply?
The Resource Market
- How many resources can you sell to the market in one action, and where do the sold resources go?
- Can you buy more of a resource than the cubes shown on the market?
- Can you buy and sell the same resource type in one round at the market?
- Can one market action buy or sell more than one resource type?
- Can you sell metal at the Kingsbridge Resource Market?
- Can you place two master builders in the Market to get extra buys and sells?
The Craftsmen
- Can you spend gold from one craftsman on the Goldsmith, or pay another craftsman's points, in the same round?
- Can one metal count for the Tool Maker and also be used by another craftsman in the same round?
- Does the Tool Maker use up the metal it counts, and does more metal give more gold?
- Do you need a Mortar Mixer to score points with a Mason?
- Can you own duplicate craftsmen, how many can you keep, and can a round-one craftsman with an exclamation mark replace a starting one?
- Does a capacity increase affect craftsmen with no capacity arrow, like the Architect or Tool Maker?
- Does the Architect give 1 victory point each round, or only once?
- Do you need a Woodworker to buy wood at the resource market?
The Privilege Cards
- Does a privilege card that gives an extra resource need workers on that resource to collect it?
- Do you get a privilege card's extra resource in the round you take the card?
- What does Brother Francis do, and does it protect you from events that make every player lose gold?
- Can Archbishop Thomas cancel 'The King will not grant an audience' in the round you claim him?
- What do the 1x, lightning-bolt and infinity symbols in the corners of privilege cards mean?
- When can the player holding Ellen look at the event card?
The Pillars of the Earth: Expansion SetExpansion
- Can the expansion board be used in a two-player game?
- Which master builder replaces the black master builder, and do you pay when you place the replacement?
- What happens if the black master builder is drawn after all your master builders are already placed?
- Where does the black master builder go when it is drawn?
- Does your third master builder go on the track only when one of your colored builders is placed on the board?
- How is the order of the third master builders on the track set, and what if nobody places on the board?
- Can Regan Hamleigh let you trade 3 gold for a victory point, or only a victory point for 3 gold?
- Can you sell a victory point to Regan Hamleigh before the tax die is rolled, to avoid losing a second VP?
- Does the Sally privilege card let you ignore the restrictions on your starting craftsmen?
- Can the Inspiration in Saint-Denis card copy a craftsman whose capacity was boosted by an event?
- Can Saint-Denis be used with a craftsman that has no capacity arrow or a capacity of 1, and does the -1 apply when you use your own worker?
- When you use someone else's Mason through Inspiration in Saint-Denis, whose Mortar Mixer is needed?
- Can the Apprentice boost any craftsman, including metal craftsmen and craftsmen borrowed through Saint-Denis?
- Can the Assistant (Gehilfe) boost a craftsman reused through Saint-Denis?
- Are the Expansion Set cards compatible with the German base game, and how do you tell them apart?
- With five or six players, which resource cards and cubes does the expansion use?
- How much gold do the 5th and 6th players start with?
- What does the King's Ore Mine metal space do?
- Can you send workers to the Crusades every round instead of taking a card?
- Can you split leftover workers between the Crusades and the Wool Mill in one action?
- In the expansion, do the King's Court and Tax Collector spaces give the same benefits?
- If an event removes a player's master builder from the King's Court, does the metal still go to the next player?
- In the six-player last round, can you claim the victory point instead of a space's action, and when?
- In the six-player last round, does the Market Warden score for every master builder assigned to the market?
- Can you use the expansion's Master Builder strip with fewer than five players?
- Do the expansion's gold-paying craftsmen need a Master Builder at the market to sell resources?
- Does the craftsman buy-and-sell limit apply to the expansion card that lets you buy and sell at the marked price?
- Can you use stone made by the Brickmaker to convert to victory points in the same turn?
- When can you use the Beggar's free resource?
- Does the 2-gold income from Graf Bartholomaus come at the start of the round or with the worker income?
- When can you use the Empress Maud card, how many times, and does it work like the market?
- Does Bishop Waleran still pay 2 gold when your master builder goes on the 0 space?
- Does 'The King will not grant an audience' stop only permanent privilege cards, or also one-use ones?