RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
Tammany Hall thumbnail

Tammany Hall FAQ

53 questions players ask · Updated Nov 17, 2026 · Full rulebook

SetupThe Play AreaPlayer TurnsStep 1: Castle GardenStep 2: ActionsStep 6: Populate New ZoneHolding a Ward ElectionSpecial Ward BenefitsStep 3: Name Immigrant LeadersStep 4: Score Points and Name MayorElection TiebreakersEnd of the GameGeneral

Setup

  • Can the immigrant cube supply run out before the game ends?
  • When do Italian immigrants enter the game?
  • Can you run out of Ward Bosses?

The Play Area

  • Are two wards that touch only at a corner adjacent?
  • Does Tammany Hall move to another ward during the game?
  • Are Wards 12 and 16 part of the play area?

Player Turns

  • Who is the first player in Term 1, and does the first-player position rotate?
  • Must the parts of Phase 2 be played in a fixed order?

Step 1: Castle Garden

  • When is Castle Garden refilled: at the start of each turn when it is empty, or at the start of each year?
  • Is Castle Garden emptied at the end of every year, or only at the end of a Term?
  • Do immigrant cubes already on the board clear after each election?

Step 2: Actions

  • What can't happen in a ward the Council President has locked?
  • Can you spend political favor chips in a ward the Council President has locked?
  • How many wards can the Council President lock, and how often?
  • On a turn, can a player place two Ward Bosses instead of a boss and an immigrant?
  • Can a player slander more than once in a Term, or slander a second opponent?
  • What does it take to spread a slander into an adjacent ward?
  • How many favor chips does a slander that spreads into an adjacent ward cost?
  • How far can a single slander reach?
  • When you slander, does the removed boss count as one piece, or do all matching bosses in the ward go?
  • Can you let another player use your office benefit as part of a deal?

Step 6: Populate New Zone

  • In a 3-player game, which zones are active at the start, and when do Zones II and III open?
  • How are the starting cubes placed when a new zone opens?

Holding a Ward Election

  • Can a player mix favor colors in one ward bid, and pay with any combination?
  • Do unused Political Favors have to be returned after an election?
  • Are the Political Favors a player holds hidden from the other players?
  • What happens to the Ward Bosses when a ward election is tied?
  • Must a player with a Ward Boss in a contested ward take part in the election?
  • Does winning an uncontested ward require spending a favor?
  • How is a sealed bid carried out in a ward election?
  • In what order are ward elections resolved?
  • After a ward election, do the Ward Bosses left in the ward stay for the next round?

Special Ward Benefits

  • Where does the bonus immigrant cube for winning Ward 1 or Ward 2 come from, and where can it go?
  • Does winning Ward 1 or Ward 2 also give a favor chip along with the bonus immigrant cube?
  • Can a bonus immigrant be placed in a ward the Council President locked during the same election?
  • When you win Ward 4 or Ward 7, can you take a favor chip of any color?

Step 3: Name Immigrant Leaders

  • Is the Immigrant Leader bonus decided by favor chips or by immigrant cubes?
  • Do the Immigrant Leader markers give any benefit between elections?

Step 4: Score Points and Name Mayor

  • How many victory points is winning the Tammany Hall ward worth?
  • Does the Mayor's 3 VP bonus apply every Year, or each time someone wins Mayor?
  • In what order are wards resolved, favors awarded, victory points scored, and the Mayor named after an election?

Election Tiebreakers

  • If the Mayor race ties through every tiebreaker, does the incumbent keep the office even if not tied?
  • In what order are the Mayor tiebreakers applied?
  • Do favor chips gained in the same election count toward the Mayor tiebreak?

End of the Game

  • Does the Mayor elected in the final election still get the 3 VP bonus?
  • How is the final election scored before end-game scoring?
  • After the fourth election, are favor chips still awarded before final scoring?
  • If two players tie for the most victory points at game end, how is the winner decided?
  • Can you save slander tokens and use them in the last Term?

General

  • Can players make deals, alliances, or trade political favor chips?
  • Can you give a slander token or victory points to another player?
  • Are negotiated deals binding in Tammany Hall?
  • Do the rules differ between editions of Tammany Hall?