Struggle for El Salvador thumbnail

Struggle for El Salvador

Rulebook PDF: Avalon Hill (The General magazine, Vol. 22 No. 6, 1986) ยท PDF

Struggle for El Salvador Rulebook

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Scenario Design Guidelines

It is strongly recommended that Optional Rule 23 (Wounds and Cover) and Optional Rule 24 (Morale) be used in all scenarios. For some scenarios included in "Struggle for El Salvador", victory conditions dictate that Optional Rule 24 must be used.

The squad groups listed here should be viewed only as a starting point. Players should feel free to add to these as play balance or their own research dictates. Generally, the quality of FMLN formations peak in 1982 and has declined since.

The workhorses of the regular FMLN appear to have been the LMG5 (MG1, MG2 and MG3), LMG20, RFL5 (FAL), RFL10 (M16A1), PST1, PST2 (HP35), PST3 (TT33) and SMG7 (Uzi). The primary weapons of FMLN militia units seem to be FRL7 (various types), RFL18 (M1 Garand), PST1, PST2 and PST3.

Squad Groups

Points Computed for 5-Turn Game

  • FMLN Squad (1978 on): 3/2; 1S; 2 x PST1 or PST2, 6 x RFL5, 2 x SMG7. (113 points; Group 5)
  • FMLN Squad (1978 on): 4/2; 1S; 8 x RFL5 or RFL10, 2 x SMG7. (181 points; Group 7)
  • FMLN Squad (1979 on): 3/2; 1S; 1 x LMG20, 8 x RFL5 or RFL10, 1 x PST1, PST2 or PST3. (158 points; Group 6)
  • FMLN Squad (1979): 3/2; 1S; 1 x LMG5, 8 x RFL5, RFL10 or RFL11, 1 x SMG7. (173 points; Group 7)
  • FMLN Squad (circa 1982): 3/2; 1S; 1 x LMG5, 9 x RFL5 or RFL10. (182 points; Group 7)
  • FMLN Squad (circa 1982): 4/2; 1S; 1 x LMG5, 9 x RFL5 or RFL10. (241 points; Group 10)
  • FMLN Squad (circa 1982): 3/2; 1S; 1 x LMG20, 9 x RFL5 or RFL10. (170 points; Group 7)
  • FMLN Squad (circa 1982): 4/2; 1S; 1 x LMG20, 9 x RFL5 or RFL10. (225 points; Group 9)
  • RN Guerrilla Squad (1979 on): 3/2; 1S; 1 x LMG20, 7 x RFL5 or RFL10. (140 points; Group 6)
  • RN Guerrilla Squad (1979 on): 3/2; 1S; 7 x RFL5 or RFL10, 1 x SMG7. (116 points; Group 5)
  • RN Guerrilla Squad (1979 on): 4/2; 1C, 1S; 1 x LMG5, 7 x RFL5 or RFL10, 1 x PST1, PST2 or PST3. (212 points; Group 8)
  • FMLN Militia Squad (1978 on): 3/2; 1S; 9 x RFL7, 1 x PST1 or PST2. (89 points; Group 4)
  • FMLN Militia Squad (1978 on): 3/2; 1S; 8 x RFL18, 1 x SMG7, 1 x PST1 or PST2. (110 points; Group 4)

FMLN Equipment List

It is virtually impossible to formulate a truly comprehensive equipment list for the Salvadoran revolutionaries, due to the vagaries of the international arms black market and the uncertainties of Soviet-bloc aid. It is further complicated by the FMLN practice of using captured government equipment, a practice that seems to have been much more important in 1980 than it was in 1985. The following list is intended to be a guide, one to be amended similarly to the squad groups list.

FMLN Weapons: GLR2 (few), GLR3 (M203 - very few), GMG4 (M60), GMG5 (MG1, MG2, MG3); LMG10, LMG11 (FAL), LMG20; LCW1, LCW2 (B10); LPL3; MPL19, MPL20; MRT1, MRT5, MRT6 (M2, M19), MRT12 (MO-81-61, M29), MRT13 (M1937, M248); PST1, PST2 (HP35), PST3 (TT33); RFL1 (AK47 - relatively few), RFL11 (mainly 1978-80), RFL13, RFL18 (M1 Garand); SMG1, SMG2, SMG7 (Uzi).

FMLN Vehicles: TRK1 (Weapon 1, 3), TRK5.

Scenarios

The following scenarios are based on actual battles and campaigns in El Salvador between 1979 and 1985.

"Ambush 1981"

In January 1981, the FMLN unsuccessfully attempted to topple the Salvadoran government by staging an offensive. This scenario represents an action in the hinterland of Morazan staged by the People's Liberation Army.

A. MAPBOARD TERRAIN: Only mapboard panel 2 is used. (Diagram: mapboard panel 2, marked ATTACKER with an entry arrow.)

All dark green hexes, as well as tree hexes, are considered tree hexes. Brown hexes are mud in Mud weather, but are otherwise clear hexes. Ignore all fences and hedges. Hills are height "4".

B. SPECIAL RULES: Game length is 3 Turns. Attackers exit off either or both short sides. Defenders exit off either or both long sides of the mapboard. Players decide on which side the attacker enters by agreement or competitive die roll. Defender sets up secretly as per "AMBUSH" special rules (on page 45 of FIREPOWER Battle Manual). Attacker enters in accordance with the same set of special rules.

WEATHER: Roll the die: "1-7" - Normal; "8-10" - Mud.

VISIBILITY: Roll the die. "1-7" - Observation Condition 1; "8-9" - Observation Condition 2; "10" - Observation Condition 3. If Observation Conditions 2 or 3, roll the die again: "1-2" - Night; "3-7" - Fog; "8+" - Raining.

FIRES (OP): Wet if Mud or Raining - otherwise Normal.

C. OPPOSING FORCES:

a. Defenders: ERP Guerrilla Squad: 3/2; 1S; 1 x LMG20, 9 x RFL10; 1 x BNC, 17 x HGN3 and/or HGN5 (G only). (120-102-18 points)

b. Attackers: Salvadoran Infantry Squad (+): 4/2; 1C, 1S; 1 x LMG4, 10 x RFL10, 2 x SMG7; 1 x BPD, 2 x NST, 1 x SCP, 13 x BDA, 6 x RGN2, 22 x HGN3 and/or HGN5. (240-180-60 points)

D. VICTORY CONDITIONS: Each side gets two victory points for each surviving soldier that exits the mapboard during Turn 3. Defending soldiers must exit off the long sides of the mapboard and attacking soldiers must exit off the short sides of the mapboard to receive these points.

"Ambush 1984"

In 1984, the Salvadoran army took the initiative against the FMLN, pressuring the insurgents over the entire theatre of operations. The following scenario depicts an ambush of FPL guerrillas and militia units by Salvadoran infantry in an agricultural area of Chalatenango department during the summer.

A. MAPBOARD TERRAIN: Only mapboard panel 2 is used. (Diagram: mapboard panel 2, marked ATTACKER with an entry arrow.) Use all standard terrain values. Hills are height "3", depressions are height " -2".

B. SPECIAL RULES: Game Length is 3 Turns. Defender's set up and attacker's entrance are per the special rules of the Ambush 1981 scenario.

WEATHER: Roll the die: "1-7" - Normal; "8-10" - Mud.

VISIBILITY: Roll the die: "1-5" - Observation Condition 1; "6" - Observation Condition 2; "7-10" - Observation Condition 3. If Observation Conditions 2 or 3, roll the die again: "1-6" - Night; "7-8" - Fog; "9-10" - Raining.

FIRES (OP): Wet if Mud or Raining - otherwise Normal.

C. OPPOSING FORCES:

a. Defenders: Salvadoran Infantry Squad: 4/2; 1S; 1 x LMG4, 8 x RFL10, 1 x SMG7; 1 x PMN2, 15 x HGN3 and/or HGN5, 1 x NST, 1 x BNC, 1 x BPD, 1 x SFX. (167-137-30 points)

b. Attackers: FPL. (334-295-39 points)

  • FPL Guerrilla Squad: 4/2; 1C, 1S; 1 x LMG5, 8 x RFL5, 1 x SMG7.
  • 1st FPL Militia Squad: 3/2; 1S; 9 x RFL18, 1 x SMG7, 1 x PST1; 1 x SCP.
  • 2nd FPL Militia Squad: 3/2; 1S; 8 x RFL7, 1 x SMG7, 1 x PST3; 2 x SCP.
  • Extra Equipment: 1 x LPL, 2 x BNC, 18 x HGN3 and/or HGN5 (G only), 13 x HGN8, 2 x SHG.

D. VICTORY CONDITIONS: Each side gets two victory points for each surviving soldier that exits the mapboard during Turn 3. Defending soldiers must exit off the long sides of the mapboard and attacking soldiers must exit off the short sides to receive these points.

"Urban Combat 1979"

When reform-minded army officers deposed the military government of El Salvador in October 1979, the Salvadoran left was not impressed. The FMLN perceived the new government, which included civilians who later rose to the highest ranks of the FMLN and FDR, were just as wedded to "reactionary" domestic elements and "Yankee imperialism" as that of General Romero. Following the coup, the ERP took to the streets of San Salvador.

A. MAPBOARD TERRAIN: Only mapboard panel 4 is used. (Diagram: mapboard panel 4, with north arrow.) All buildings are constructed of wooden planks, except Building L, which is built of concrete. Ignore all hills. No building is more than two storys in height.

B. SPECIAL RULES: Game Length is 5 turns. Units may exit off any side or portion of a side encompassed by their setup hexes.

WEATHER: Normal.

VISIBILITY: Condition 1.

FIRES (OP): Normal.

C. OPPOSING FORCES:

a. ERP (Defenders): Set up the defenders anywhere north of the two-hex-wide east-west road and east of Hex Row G, inclusive. Roadblocks may be set up anywhere in the east-west two-hex-wide road or north of it. (350-302-48 points)

  • ERP Urban Guerrilla Squad (+): 3/2; 1C, 1S; 1 x LMG5, 8 x RFL5, 3 x SMG7.
  • ERP Neighborhood Militia Squad: 3/2; 1S; 2 x RFL7, 3 x RFL13 (M2), 4 x RFL18, 1 x SMG7, 2 x PST2.
  • Extra Equipment: 2 x BNC, 13 x HGN3 (G only), 25 x HGN8, 4 x RBL.

b. Salvadoran Army (Attackers): Set up attackers anywhere south of the east-west two-hex-wide road and west of Hex Row 7 inclusive. Attacker may also set up in any hex of Buildings A and B. (438-388-50 points)

  • 1st Salvadoran Infantry Squad (+): 3/2; 1C, 1S; 1 x LMG19, 8 x RFL11, 1 x SMG7, 1 x PST1.
  • 2nd Salvadoran Infantry Squad: 4/2; 1S; 1 x MMG1, 7 x RFL11, 2 x SMG7.
  • Extra Equipment: 2 x BNC, 40 x HGN3 and/or HGN5, 3 x BDA, 2 x PST2 (for LMG and MMG).

D. VICTORY CONDITIONS: Each floor of Building M and N are worth five victory points to either side. If both ERP squads are panicked at the end of Turn 5, the attacking player automatically wins, regardless of victory points.

"Attack on Radio Venceremos 1984"

Located somewhere in Morazan department, the ERP-controlled Radio Venceremos has long broadcast to the rest of El Salvador. In November 1984, the Salvadoran Army launched airmobile operations in Morazan intended to find Radio Venceremos and put it out of the air permanently. At least one transmitter was found and captured, as were many audio tapes of future broadcasts. But Radio Venceremos continues to operate.

A. MAPBOARD TERRAIN: All buildings are constructed of wood plank. All dark green as well as all tree hexes are considered tree hexes. Hills on panel 2 are height "2". Hills on panel 1 are height "3". Ignore all hills on mapboard panel "3". All depressions are height " -2". (Diagram: three-panel mapboard with north arrow and panel labels.)

B. SPECIAL RULES: Game length is 6 Turns. The Salvadoran Army may exit off any outer mapboard side that is part of panel 1. The ERP player may exit off any outer hexside that is part of panel 3. The Salvadoran Army player gets one "bonus" Impulse Phase after setup is completed. Any desired action may be performed during this Impulse Phase, and the sequence units are drawn normally after its completion.

WEATHER: Normal.

VISIBILITY: Visibility Condition 1.

FIRES (OP): Normal.

C. OPPOSING FORCES:

a. ERP (Defenders): Set up in any whole hex on panel 3. (452-377-75 points)

  • ERP Guerrilla Squad: 4/2; 1C, 1S; 1 x MMG5, 8 x RFL10, 2 x SMG7.
  • ERP Militia Squad (-): 3/2; 1S; 3 x RFL7, 3 x RFL18, 1 x PST1.
  • Extra Equipment and Defensive Units: 1 x BNC, 40 x HGN3 and/or HGN5, 1 x LPL3, 2 x DFX, 3 x SFX, 4 x PNM1.

b. Salvadoran Army - Antonal Brigade (Attackers): Set up on any whole hex on mapboard panel 1. (949-891-58 points)

  • 1st Atonal Squad: 4/3; 1C, 1S, 1A; 1 x GLR2, 1 x LMG4, 7 x RFL10, 2 x SMG7, 1 x BPD.
  • 2nd Atonal Squad (+): 4/3; 1S, 1A; 1 x MRT6, 1 x LMG4, 7 x RFL10, 1 x SMG7, 1 x BPD.
  • Extra Equipment and Ammunition: 2 x BNC, 8 x BDA, 5 x GLR2AMO, 5 x MTR6AMO, 25 HGN3 and/or HGN5.

D. VICTORY CONDITIONS: Both players receive 2 victory points for each enemy soldier killed, wounded or driven from the mapboard by panic. In addition, the ERP chooses one building on panel 3 to contain the Radio Venceremos transmitter, secretly noting it on a sheet of scrap paper. Control of this building is worth 10 victory points to either player at the end of the game.

"Battle at La Union 1985"

1985 was a very bad year for the FMLN. It was unable to carry the war to the enemy. In fact, the strategic offensive was firmly in the grasp of the government. On October 10, the formally unified FMLN struck the Salvadoran Army training center at La Union. The rebels apparently aimed to kill some of the United States advisers training Salvadoran recruits at the base. They did not succeed, but did manage to kill forty-two Salvadoran soldiers. Ten insurgents died, all of them when paratroopers counterattacked and relieved the base. The government forces suffered a stiff defeat.

A. MAPBOARD TERRAIN: All tree hexes and all dark green hexes are considered stumps. Ignore all hills, fences, and hedges on mapboard panel 2. All other hills are height "2" and all depressions are height " -1". All buildings and fences are of wooden plank construction. (Diagram: three-panel mapboard with north arrow, panel labels, and ATTACKER entry arrow.)

B. SPECIAL RULES: Game length is 5 turns. Salvadoran Army soldiers may exit off any outer side that is part of panel 3, and FMLN soldiers may exit off any outer hexside that is part of panel 1. At the start of the game all attackers must make a "bonus" Impulse Phase. No combat actions may be taken, and the sequence units are drawn normally after its completion.

WEATHER: Normal.

VISIBILITY: Visibility Condition 3, Night.

FIRES (OP): Normal.

C. OPPOSING FORCES:

a. Salvadoran Army (Defenders): Set up on any whole hex of panel 3. Wire, abattis, double wire, and ditch counters and mines may be set up on any whole hex of panel 2. (681-469-212 points)

  • 1st Salvadoran Infantry Squad: 4/2; 1C, 1S; 1 x MMG4, 8 x RFL10, 1 x SMG7, 1 x BPD.
  • 2nd Salvadoran Infantry Squad: 4/2; 1S; 1 x LMG4, 8 x RFL10, 1 x SMG7, 1 x BPD.
  • Extra Equipment and Defensive Units: 6 x BDA, 3 x BNC, 49 x HGN3 and/or HGN5, 6 x RGN4, 2 x PST2 (for MMG and LMG), 3 x NST, 5 x PMN1, 2 x PMN2, 2 x LPL3, 5 x ABS, 3 x DCH, 4 x DFX, 2 x SFX, 13 x DWR, 5 x WIR.

b. FMLN (Attackers): Enter mapboard on "bonus" Impulse Phase onto the long edge of panel 1. (890-776-118 points)

  • 1st FMLN Guerrilla Squad (+): 4/3; 1C, 1S; 1 x LMG4, 1 x GLR2, 8 x RFL10, 1 x SMG2.
  • 2nd FMLN Guerrilla Squad: 4/2; 1S; 1 x LMG4, 1 x MPL20, 2 x RFL1, 6 x RFL5.
  • 3rd FMLN Guerrilla Squad: 4/2; 1S; 1 x GLR2, 1 x MPL20, 6 x RFL10, 1 x RFL13 (M2), 1 x SMG7.
  • Extra Equipment and Ammunition: 4 x BNC, 45 x HGN3 and/or HGN5, 2 x RGN2, 1 x RGN4, 2 x DMC, 16 x MPL20AMO, 4 x PST1 (for LMG, GLR, and MPL).

D. VICTORY CONDITIONS: Each player receives 2 victory points for each enemy soldier killed or wounded. The FMLN receives 5 victory points for each building on panel 3 under his control at the end of the game, and 5 victory points for each Salvadoran Army squad panicked at the end of the game. The Salvadoran Army player gets 7 points for each FMLN squad panicked at the end of the game.

Playtester's Note

Much of the excitement of FIREPOWER lies in the ability to simulate yesterday's newspaper headlines. "Struggle for El Salvador" arose out of Mr. Werbaneth's master's dissertation, an intensive study of the issues in that troubled land. When the article arrived, the designer asked for playtesting, and the following are some suggestions from those notes for those who might play the accompanying scenarios.

A certain atmospheric difference should exist when playing the following scenarios and those dealing with, say, the Russians and West Germans. This difference should go beyond the mere designation of various kinds of terrain or weaponry - although these are obviously important. An irregular force will generally not perform over time as well as regulars, as Mr. Werbaneth's fine article shows. While the reasons for this are many, most gamers will not experience it on the game board because they usually play the scenarios in isolation with no connecting framework. Therefore, I would recommend two ways to derive the best experience from these scenarios.

The best method is to incorporate them in a campaign game as set forth in the FIREPOWER issue of The General (Vol. 21, No. 6). The second method is through the use of Optional Rules which add distinction to each scenario. Since I know that most gamers will shy away from a campaign involvement, I think the use of the following rules would be the best choice:

  • 16.2 - Assorted Optional Firing Modifiers
  • 16.4 - Suppression by Non-Automatic Weapons
  • 16.5 - Written Combat Orders
  • 16.6 - Pinned and Inactive Status
  • 16.7.2 - Optional Nightsight Rules
  • 16.8 - Extra Major Personal Weapons
  • 16.9 - Standing Behind "2" Height Cover
      • Fires
      • Wounds and Cover
      • Morale

If you play these scenarios, you will agree with Mr. Werbaneth that the use of Rules 23 and 24 are very important. So, if you don't try anything else from the above list, please try those.

Play balance is an elusive thing in a system like FIREPOWER. Sometimes one side will positively cream the other, while some games come right down to the wire. However, if you find that balance is a problem, gradually adjust the weaker side. Do not just add 30 more grenades and think that this will help - it generally doesn't. These scenarios have been tested and reviewed several times and are good as is. But if you really think a little help is needed, try adjusting squad ratings - add a spare sequence chit or impulse. Try an additional leader ("A" level). If a guerilla squad is perceived as weak, try exchanging older weapons for better ones - always within the framework of the equipment lists. Nevertheless, the five scenarios have been checked for balance and should give no trouble.

A word is needed about housekeeping. You will need to make many more location arrows, posture chits and status chits - especially for the larger scenarios. The number of speed chits in the original game should be sufficient. Finally, don't overlook the value of multi-player usage in these scenarios. Suggest referring to the rules in the Battle Manual (17.).