Provopoli: Wem gehört die Stadt
Provopoli: Wem gehört die Stadt Rulebook
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
Ten Ways to Play Provopoli
The manual opens with ten playful suggestions for variants, before the rules begin.
-
The state-preserving variant (for police academies and constitutional protection officers) cannot be prevented in principle, but it defeats the purpose.
-
The "an important contribution to the political education of young people" variant (for schoolchildren) should, by ministerial decree, find wide distribution.
-
The therapeutic variant (for enraged petty bourgeois) serves the harmless discharge of aggression and leads nowhere.
-
The left-sectarian, dogmatic, reformist-and-whatever-they-are-all-called variant (for professional leftists) usually culminates in the founding of a new organisation with an exclusive claim to leadership.
-
The liberal-academic variant (for the established) might at least get a few people to think.
-
The nuclear-family variant (for rainy Sundays) usually begins harmlessly and ends in hard disputes between two or three generations.
-
The extended-family or commune variant (for progressives) is great fun and gradually turns into a tender celebration.
-
The kindergarten variant (for anti-authoritarian petty bourgeois) turns children into collectives.
-
The "do-it-yourself" variant (for tinkerers) is what the publisher fears most.
Game Components
The playing board is a stylised street map of "Grünstadt" (Green City).
The game also contains:
- 10 blue figures, numbered 1 to 10
- 10 red figures, numbered 1 to 10
- 5 neutral, unnumbered figures
- 10 blue identity cards
- 10 red identity cards
- 30 task cards. Of these, 20 are white and contain "open" tasks. Roman numerals mark the difficulty of each task: I (easy), II (medium) and III (hard). The remaining 10 task cards are 5 red and 5 blue, and contain secret tasks for the respective party.
- 50 chance cards: 15 blue, 15 red and 20 white (neutral). They correspond to the division of the marked chance spaces on the board.
- 10 blank cards for extending the game as the players wish and imagine (5 chance cards and 5 task cards)
- 4 vehicles (set up in the vehicle sheds)
- 6 barricades (set up in the timber yard)
- 6 explosive devices (set up in the military base)
- 5 black marker pins (to mark a figure that is temporarily blocked)
- 5 white marker pins (to mark a figure that has a special assignment to carry out)
- 3 dice
Explanation of the Board
Entrances (semicircular spaces). Buildings may in principle only be entered through this entrance space (grey).
Chance spaces (spaces marked with three lines). a) red zebra crossings b) blue zebra crossings c) white zebra crossings
When a figure enters a chance space, the corresponding card is drawn. Red chance spaces apply only to red figures, blue chance spaces only to blue figures, and neutral (white) ones to both parties.
One-way streets (spaces marked with an arrow). Streets with this marking may only be walked or driven in the direction shown.
The buildings belonging to each party are coloured in that party's colour. (A picture of the board is at the end of this booklet.)
Explanation of the symbols on the task cards. Each task card carries up to three symbols: vehicle, barricade and/or explosive device. (The symbol pictures themselves are not reproduced in this text.)
Course of Play
Number of Players
The game requires two groups that play against each other. If there are not enough players, the group situation can also be simulated by placing a corresponding number of figures on the board. Each group may – after prior agreement – deploy any number of figures (up to a maximum of 10 per party).
Identity Cards
Depending on the number of participants, shuffle an equal number of identity cards. Both parties must be equally represented. Each player then draws one card. The identity cards determine each player's party membership and serve as their identification throughout the game. (Example: with 8 players, 4 red and 4 blue cards are taken; with 9 players, 5 red and 5 blue, so that in this case one card remains after drawing and is returned. With an odd number of players, one party may therefore have one player more.)
Task Cards
The party that rolls the higher number on the die draws a task card from the face-down pile. (Beginners are advised to start by choosing only tasks of difficulty I.) Open tasks are read out and may be consulted throughout the game. Secret tasks are made known only to the members of the party concerned.
Starting Position
Unless the task card prescribes otherwise, the figures begin in the two START positions. (Which party begins in which corner is left to the players.) Any number of figures may be placed in the three start spaces.
Figures
- Each player receives at least one figure in the colour of their party.
- As needed or by agreement, more figures can and should be placed than there are players: a) as additional mobile figures at the start (or in the starting position prescribed by the task); b) as additional mobile figures at any position on the board (by mutual agreement); c) as non-mobile figures stationed in particular buildings (e.g. BLUE in Police Station 1 or RED in Commune 2). Non-mobile figures stationed in buildings may be additionally mobilised during the game (see below: "Liberation", rules 1 and 2).
Rolling the Dice
The group that did not draw the task card begins by rolling the dice. Each group rolls three times, regardless of the number of participants (so also with two, or four or more players or figures). The roll may be made by a single player with three dice, or by different players with one die each. If, through elimination or arrest, the number of mobile figures falls below 3, only as many rolls are allowed as there are mobile figures (so 2 rolls with 2 figures, and 1 roll with 1 figure).
The figures advance on the street spaces according to the numbers rolled. The numbers rolled by a party may be added together, but they cannot be divided arbitrarily. That means the party whose turn it is may either a) add the numbers together and move a single figure by the total; or b) distribute the numbers as they fell, across at most three figures. (Example: the dice show 3, 3 and 5. They may then either move one figure 11 spaces; or two figures 6 and 5 spaces; or two figures 3 and 8 spaces; or three figures 3, 3 and 5 spaces.)
Rolled numbers cannot be saved for a later turn. However, a turn may be forgone. In contrast to the usual competitive games, rolling a 6 brings no further advantage. Why should it?
Movement on the Board
- Figures may be moved freely on the board (but not in opposite directions within a single turn).
- Figures of the same party may pass one another in any direction. Figures of opposing parties block one another; passing or overtaking is not permitted for them.
Green Areas
Green areas (the city park and the river bank) may be entered with a direct roll from any street space; the city park and the river bank each count as one space. Entering and leaving a green area must be done in separate turns. Vehicles must be parked on the street.
One-Way Streets
Figures may move only in the direction indicated by the arrow.
Entering Buildings
Entering buildings or green areas is possible only with the exact number rolled; the entrances and the interior of the houses each count as one board space. Cars may not be taken into buildings, but must be parked on the street.
Arrest
- Arresting (detaining, abducting) a person is possible when one's own figure reaches the space of the opposing figure with the exact number rolled. In this case the arrested figure is out of action for its own party. ("Exact number" means: if an opposing figure is, for example, 3 spaces away, the arrest is possible only if the arresting party rolls a 3 on its next turn.)
- The removal of arrested persons is possible only in the next turn. Since a prisoner slows progress, the number rolled is from now on halved. If the result is odd, one point is lost. (Example: with a roll of 6, 2 figures advance 3 spaces; with a roll of 5, only 2 spaces.)
- Pedestrians cannot arrest persons who are in vehicles. The reverse, however, is possible.
- At most two figures may move together. (So the arrest of two persons at the same time is not possible.)
Liberation
- Persons held in buildings can be freed when figures of the same party reach the interior of the building with the exact number rolled. The freed figures can then be deployed actively again.
- The same rule applies to the deployment of the non-mobile figures. Variant: persons held in buildings of the opposing party cannot be freed.
- Liberating arrested persons who are being transported is possible only if one reaches the space on which they are currently located with exactly the number matching the figure number of the prisoner. At the same moment the guard is arrested (or abducted). (Note on this: see "Arrest", rule 3!)
Chance Spaces
When a figure reaches a chance space belonging to its own party or a neutral chance space, the player takes the corresponding card from the pile. (The chance cards must, of course, be well shuffled before each game.) Depending on the content of the card, the player carries out its instructions immediately or keeps it for later turns. If carrying out an instruction takes more than one round, the chance card is laid out face up until the task is complete, and only then returned to the bottom of the card pile. Figures that are blocked for more than one round can be marked with the marker pins.
If, as a result of a chance card, two opposing figures come together in a building, an arrest is not possible. Advancing onto spaces on which a figure of the opposing party already stands is also not permitted by means of a chance card.
Cards that do not apply to the course of the game may be passed over without replacement. (Example: a player is awarded a vehicle, but all vehicles are already in use; in this case they must forgo the vehicle and return the card.)
Technical Aids
- Taking over technical aids (explosive devices and barricades) is likewise possible only with the exact number rolled.
- Removal takes place in the next turn with the full number rolled.
- A figure may carry only one technical aid in addition to a vehicle. The aids are set up, as far as the respective task provides for them, as follows: 2 vehicles each in the two vehicle sheds; barricades in the timber yard; bombs in the military base.
Vehicles
- When a figure reaches a vehicle with the exact number rolled, it may board and, from the next turn onward, move at double speed (double the number rolled). Carrying one additional person or object is possible in addition, without halving the number rolled.
- When entering buildings or green areas, vehicles must first be parked on the street. Walking and driving may not be combined; they must take place in separate turns.
- When a figure leaves its vehicle, the vehicle is from that moment available again to everyone who reaches it with the exact number rolled.
Barricades
Barricades serve to block streets and entrances. At the start of the game they are set up in the timber yard, as far as the task provides for them.
Each barricade can be used only once in the game: once placed, it blocks for the whole game and can no longer be removed.
Variant: To make the course of play more mobile, the following rule change may be agreed by mutual consent: barricades may be removed or moved when two figures of the same party reach the corresponding space.
Explosive Devices
They are represented by stylised powder kegs. Their placement at the start of the game takes place, as far as provided, in the military base.
The way an explosive device is placed shows whether it has been detonated (opening facing up) or not yet detonated (opening facing down).
- The effect radius of a detonated explosive device is one space around the point of detonation. Detonated charges block the affected spaces for the rest of the game.
- The party in possession of the explosive device determines the moment of detonation. However, it may detonate only when it is its turn. The figure carrying the explosive device should, before detonation, be at least 2 spaces away from the point of deployment, so as not to sacrifice itself.
Help Cards
Among the chance cards are some that have the function of technical aids (for example, the card "False Identity" once prevents an arrest).
Help cards may be kept and played at the tactically right moment. Afterwards they are returned to the pile.
Object and End of the Game
The object of the game is, through skilful tactical behaviour, solidarity and the combination of individual turns, to render the opposing party unable to act.
provopoli in Practice
The example that follows is one model of how play might run on a simple task. It is emphatically one of many hundreds of possible courses for the same task.
Secret Task BLUE
"Blow up the red headquarters!"
- Starting position: RED and BLUE in their start positions (BLUE has at least 3 figures)
- Additional rule: BLUE may not combine dice numbers and may not use vehicles.
- Aids: car, barricade, explosive device
Start of Play
Because this is a secret task, its content is accessible only to BLUE. When the blue party draws the task card, it withdraws to confer (note: take this booklet with you, with the city map it contains; this makes strategic planning easier). It is advisable to set a time limit for group discussions – as a rule five minutes.
Since only BLUE knows the task, BLUE makes the deployments: the distribution of the aids and of the figures. By agreement, the two groups have settled on five figures each. Of these, BLUE places three in the start positions, as the task prescribes; the other two each are placed on the board by RED and BLUE as non-mobile figures (these can only actively intervene once they have been "visited" by the mobile figures and thereby activated; it is advisable to mark such figures with marker pins until they are activated).
The more figures there are, the more exciting, but also the more complicated and longer the game becomes.
BLUE's Planning Strategy
Since the opponent does not know the task, it is at first unnecessary to advance on the Red Headquarters; on the contrary, this would even be harmful, since it would draw RED's attention to BLUE's intentions. Much more important is to acquire the explosive devices, which are the prerequisite for fulfilling the task. It is also expedient to activate the non-mobile figures and to gain possession of the remaining aids.
RED's Planning Strategy
RED at first seems condemned to inaction. But this is not so. There are already a number of possible actions that improve the group's position even when the object of the game is still unknown. For example, RED can
- acquire vehicles (double speed) and other aids for every eventuality;
- shadow the opposing figures, so as to be able to intervene immediately if necessary;
- shield buildings that are presumably threatened (with figures or barricades);
- conduct active espionage (on the Mata Hari principle) and activate non-mobile figures;
- unsettle the opponent through its own spontaneous actions.
Arresting the opponent without knowing its intentions is usually senseless and hampers the course of play. provopoli is a STRATEGIC GAME and is not to be turned into Ludo ("Mensch ärgere dich nicht").
BLUE's Playing Strategy
In keeping with the task, BLUE proceeds aggressively. 2 figures fetch the explosive devices. Consideration: how many explosive devices are needed? In principle only one. But what happens if it is lost? Should the others be rendered harmless by detonation? Or are they to be carried as a reserve – which in turn impairs the figures' ability to act? Possibly the disadvantage for BLUE of having to go on foot, imposed by the special rule, could be offset by blowing up every vehicle BLUE gets hold of. In any case it is expedient to activate the non-mobile figures and to secure the transport of the bomb as well as possible.
Even now, by clever action, it can be prevented that the opponent recognises the true intention. For example, BLUE can stage diversionary manoeuvres – gang fights, marches, hall brawls, field games, men's choirs or running amok. Or use psychological terror and misleading chants such as: "Throw the guest workers out, we are the only ones at home in the station!" By such detours BLUE should approach the object of the game.
RED's Counter-Strategy
As soon as BLUE's turns reveal concrete intentions, RED takes countermeasures. It quickly becomes apparent to RED, for example, that explosive devices play an important role for BLUE. So it is important to arrest the bomb carriers and render the bombs harmless (by playing the relevant chance card, by detonation in the city park, etc.).
Once RED has recognised that the Red Headquarters is BLUE's target, it is necessary to secure the building accordingly (barricades).
Another way for RED to influence the course of play is aggressive action, so that BLUE is forced onto the defensive.
Skilful guerrilla actions paralyse a tenfold superiority.
Who Has Won?
BLUE has won if the task is fulfilled: entering the Red Headquarters, depositing the bomb there, leaving the building and then detonating the bomb.
BLUE has also won if the bomb and the bomb carrier are enclosed in the building by RED and the bomb is nevertheless detonated. This, however, happens at the sacrifice of a blue figure. Is this sensible? Should fanaticism triumph over reason? Does the end justify the means? The decision is left to the players.
RED has won if it has hunted down all of BLUE's explosive devices and rendered them harmless.
RED has won if it has barricaded the two entrances of the building (BLUE can indeed blow up the barricades, but by doing so it denies itself access to the building).
RED also wins if it succeeds in encircling, blocking the opponent, or by good persuasion convincing it of the pointlessness of its undertaking.
Normally the game ends here: the assigned task has been fulfilled according to its text.
Deviating from this rather rigid conception of play, almost every provopoli task can be extended and repurposed. In this case, for example, it would be possible for RED to regard captured blue figures as hostages, and thereby gain a means of pressure to make the game end in a draw by negotiation, or at least to prevent an immediate detonation.
Another conceivable situation is that, towards the end of the game, both parties have each laid a ready-to-detonate explosive device in the opposing headquarters.
From this there develop: bilateral negotiations, with or without result; bitter discussion within the group; attempts at recruitment; attempts at poaching; defections from one party to the other; espionage affairs; role fixations to the point of identification; critical reflections on one's own person; group processes such as are not found in textbooks; friendships and enmities, loves and passions; party-order, expulsion and admission procedures; collectives, organisations, initiatives, training courses; spontaneous festivities, orgies of creativity; systematic destruction of the game board and a vow never to play provopoli again; project groups to develop new social games, etc.
provopoli – Changes and Extensions
At the beginning it is certainly sensible to keep to the proposed rules and to choose those tasks in which the course of action is clearly fixed (difficulty level I).
With increasing experience of play, however, the following holds: the freer the players are with respect to the material, the more imagination and creativity the groups develop among and against one another, the more exciting and varied the courses of play become.
On the whole, the tasks presented here are not a finished or exhaustive solution; they are rather proposals and suggestions, which can be changed according to one's own ideas and needs.
A first approach to this is surely the task texts and courses of action themselves. From the basic situations (occupation, demonstration, arrest, and so on) further situations and tasks can easily be developed.
Groups that work with a pedagogical or group-psychological aim could use provopoli for the playful working-through of experiences. Starting from real conditions allows role plays with strong identification. On the other hand, players are asked to observe critically their own behaviour, as individuals or in the group, during the course of play. The temporary adoption of the political "counter-position" through the chance-based "change of role" – the new distribution of the identity cards after each game – could serve the purpose of testing one's own state of consciousness through the (apparent) adoption of the opposing side's modes of action and arguments.
Or let us take the pleasant case that there were a kindergarten in which a provopoli game still existed in its entirety. Let us further assume that the children had just come back from a joint action – say a demonstration for better and more child-friendly playgrounds. Instead of working through the children's experiences on a theoretical level, a spontaneous re-enactment of the experienced situations develops.
To this end, a children's playground is first drawn onto the board. The discussion is conducted on the basis of the course of play. Experiences of success and failure can thus be produced or worked through in a playful way.
Afterwards, the events during the game could be considered on a more general level and – formulated as a task – entered on one of the blank cards.
This admittedly sounds utopian, but it need not be. Even where no kindergarten is at hand, a great deal can still be done with provopoli. Our tasks contain in several places hints and suggestions for free play, or, where there is sufficient intensity of play, invite improvised continuations.
You may leave the tasks as they are. You may change them. You may think up new tasks. You may enter new tasks on the enclosed blank cards.
Furthermore, there are many possibilities for extending the tasks and altering certain game factors. This starts with solving the task not by the main rules but by the variants given or invented. The next step would be, as needed, to agree on new rules between the groups before play begins. Anyone who wishes can also bring further external factors into the course of play, as we have done for example in the following Shah-of-Braunistan task, which develops from the basic situation "assassination". In this task the factor of time plays a decisive role:
The Shah of Braunistan will stay in Grünstadt for a short time on a state visit. Strict security measures have been demanded, announced and taken from all possible quarters, since the monarch enjoys little sympathy among the population, not only in his home country. The visit follows an exactly fixed timetable:
| Time | Event |
|---|---|
| 12.05 | Arrival at the airport |
| 12.10 – 12.15 | Motorcade to the town hall |
| 12.15 – 12.20 | Reception |
| 12.20 – 12.25 | Serenade by the singing society "Morsche Knochen" ("Rotten Bones") |
| 12.25 – 12.30 | Attendance at the inauguration of the new gasworks |
| 12.35 – 12.40 | Snack at the hotel with representatives of business and the high clergy |
| 12.40 – 12.45 | Journey to the station (incognito), probably Ringstraße |
| 12.50 | Departure of the special train |
Play begins at 12.00.
Starting position: the Shah (neutral figure) at the station
- RED: Start
- BLUE: Start (airport side)
Figures: BLUE has one third more figures than RED. The neutral figure does not move of its own accord, but is transported according to the rules.
Course of action for BLUE: Half of the units in play must go to the airport to welcome him. At least one figure remains constantly in the immediate vicinity of the potentate. For the inauguration of the gasworks, half of the officials must be present; for the departure, the entire force.
Course of action for RED: After a discussion of principles, RED chooses one of the alternatives:
- a symbolic attack (smoke, stink or pudding bombs);
- an actual attack (avoiding any endangerment of the civilian population).
In some cases it is attractive to change the dice mode (compare the "Piggy Bank" task) or to agree on particular modes of movement. Routes of demonstrations or marches can be laid down in detail and with corresponding alternative paths; the figures may act individually or in groups.
Perhaps there are people who find our chance cards unfunny or too silly. The solution is simple: write your own chance cards. Blank cards are enclosed.
A real extension of the provopoli game ultimately depends on how far the players have freed themselves from respectable norms and educational mechanisms, and are willing to include physical and psychological components in the game, without the danger of discrimination against individuals arising (tenderness cards, movement cards, invitations to sing, dance and make music).
At some point there was also a discussion about introducing so-called will cards, with which minority factions among the players could assert themselves. But past play has shown that individual actions are possible in any case, and that, as a rule, only those groups have a chance of winning the game that play together with great solidarity.
Whoever acts blindly without discussing loses. provopoly is not a game for hermits, but for people who want to talk with one another.
On this basis there arises a type of play that we have called the "persuasion game". It might run something like this:
"The Grünstadt Daily News reports: During the course of the day, Prof. Theophil W. Gilberich, a world-famous specialist in xy research, is expected in the city. G. is a well-known eccentric, unworldly and quirky, in short: the prototype of a lovably odd specialist idiot. One of his quirks is that he speaks only in rhyme and answers only questions that are asked in rhyme …"
Course of play: Prof. Gilberich, represented by a neutral figure under the direction of a rhyme-happy player – who in this special case (?) acts on his own – arrives at the station and, warned by friends, tries to hide in neutral buildings (he rolls the dice, steps onto neutral chance spaces, and so on). The two competing parties, RED and BLUE, pursue Prof. G. and try to get into his hiding place.
It now depends on the persuasive power of the respective players, and of course on Prof. Gilberich's insight, to which party he will finally make his research results available.
Dramatic complications of every kind arise from the attempts of the initially weaker party to get hold of Gilberich despite his decision.
The party he has joined can in any case benefit from his knowledge only if it succeeds in bringing him to safety in one of its buildings.
One of the many questions that arise from this context: are there games in which the formation of a third group (neutral figures) makes sense?
provopoli can, incidentally, become very realistic if the groups agree that all actions shall be based on the rules of the applicable law or its interpretation. A variant which, by the way, is excellently suited to uncovering unexpected connections between anarchist and bureaucratic behaviour.
How many other ways there are to extend, concretise, update, play in all variations or invent something new, we do not yet know.
To play provopoli could mean: beginning to change a game. To change a game could mean: beginning to examine the circumstances. To examine the circumstances could mean: beginning to recognise the contradictions. To recognise the contradictions could mean: beginning to act.
We think: starting a game is better than never starting.
Sun Dsi: Know the enemy and know yourself – a hundred battles without defeat. Mao Tse-tung, Selected Works, Vol. I, p. 380.