Pagan: Fate of Roanoke FAQ
204 questions players ask · Updated Nov 14, 2026 · Full rulebook
Game SetupExpansion
- Is the discard pile face up or face down?
- Who chooses the green faction when no scenario is played?
- How are the factions chosen during setup?
- Does owning a faction mean the Witch or Hunter owns those villagers?
- Can I mix base game, expansion and Kickstarter cards, scenarios and factions freely?
- Should a first game use Scenario 1 with the starter deck?
- Which villagers should a first game use?
- Can influence go above 20?
- Is each player's current influence visible to the opponent?
- What happens when clue, secret or favor tokens run out?
- Is the order of villagers within a faction fixed during setup?
- What are the factions in Beyond the Palisades, and which one is the dual green faction?
- Can villagers from different sets, such as the Ancestors villagers, be mixed together, and how are factions drafted?
Playing the Game
- On the Witch's first turn, must both villager visits use villagers of the same faction?
- In what order do upkeep effects resolve, and which ones are mandatory?
- Are the villager skill and asset distribution optional when visiting a villager?
- When a villager's skill is repeated, do its clues and secrets get distributed again too?
- What are the start-of-Upkeep and end-of-Upkeep steps for?
- Can the Witch consume a brew after taking her third action in a turn?
- Does Scenario 2's Hunter bonus let the whole visit happen twice on the first visit each turn?
- Does Scenario 2's Witch effect also apply in her first upkeep?
- Are scenario cards required, and what do they change?
- Does the Witch place all three action pawns before the Hunter acts?
- Can you play cards from your hand by paying their cost without taking an action?
- Does a Witch-owned card's upkeep effect trigger during the Hunter's upkeep?
- Do exonerated suspects count toward the Hunter's hand size limit?
Cards
- If a card's cost is reduced to zero, does the Hunter still gain influence from Navigator Warren?
- Do Craftsmen villagers give clues or secrets to the Hunter?
- How does the villager Thanassis's extra card work, and what does its cost reduction depend on?
- Can the Scout card (#0212) be used every round without being removed?
- Can Lethargy or Disorientation change a card the Hunter plays for free through Houndskeeper William?
- How do Hypnotism's villager effects interact with Lethargy, Disorientation and a villager's cost reduction?
- Where do clues paid to lift an enchantment come from?
- Can Evolve familiar cards be targeted by cards that target familiars?
- Does Village Center give a clue when the favor was placed or converted during the same visit?
- Does Obscuring Mist (#41) limit all clue distribution, including bonuses from other cards?
- Does Ill Omen trigger on the Witch's actions, and do clues from different sources count together?
- If Dematerialize removes gloom from a location and destroys it at the same time, does the Cleanse effect trigger?
- Can a card's cost be reduced to zero, or below zero?
- Do two copies of the Lethargy enchantment raise the Hunter's card costs by two?
- Can two copies of the same card be in play at the same time?
- What does Reveal do for a card such as Scrutiny (105)?
- What happens when a player must draw but the draw deck is empty?
- Can you discard a card already in play to make room for a new card?
- If you replace a location that has an action pawn on it, where does the pawn go?
- When the Witch visits a villager with Favors, does Town Center's second effect trigger even if no Hunter pawn is on the card?
- Does Mother Grace's flipped side let you play 3 cards when the neighbouring villagers are of the enemy colour?
- When a card says target faction, does it mean the setup faction, and who picks it?
- How does the Advisor card's placeholder work during upkeep, and can the Clerk discard a card on it?
- When can an ally's ability be used after playing the ally?
- Does playing a Charm with an immediate effect take an action?
- Does Warehouse remove the replayed card from play, or do locations, allies and investigations stay in play?
- Does a card that removes Secrets also affect a Favor token, since a Favor is made of three Secrets?
- Does Hunter Adams' +1 influence cost apply once in total or once per card when he plays two cards?
- What do the book and hand-card icons on the cards mean?
Hunter Cards
- What does the Message Board location do during upkeep, and where do its clues come from?
- Is the exonerate villager action mandatory after activating Message Board (card 24)?
- Does Message Board's exonerate effect need an extra pawn, and can you exonerate more than once?
- Does Message Board's exonerate step cost three evidence, like the player-board exonerate action?
- Does Message Board need an action pawn placed on it before you can trade two clues for one evidence?
- Must the Hunter place clue tokens on a location when out of tokens?
- Must the Hunter pay upkeep for each Ally, or can it discard one instead?
- With Cooperation and Supervision on the same villager, which villager skills does the Hunter use on a visit?
- Can Constable move a second investigation onto a villager when Scholar is in play?
- Do stacked investigation cards stay on a villager after Scholar leaves play?
- Does the Operative ally's clue trigger on every Witch visit, including visits made by the familiar pawn?
- When does the Operative ally's clue get placed during the Witch's visit?
- When is the clue from Stakeout House added to a villager?
- Does Harsh Treatment's extra clue have to go on the villager it is attached to?
- Can the Hunter use a villager's skill through the Prison card without readying the villager?
- Can resources gained from the first card played by Hunter Adam's skill pay for the second card?
- Can the Hunter move clues from one villager to another villager that already has three clues?
- How does the Post Office location work?
- Can On the Trail discard a potion that is full of secrets?
- What does Survey (card 69) pay out in Evidence?
- What does the Hunter reveal for the card Mental Image?
- Must the extra asset from an investigation card go to a villager of the same faction as the one it is on?
- Does an investigation card stay on a villager after it triggers, so it can trigger again?
- Where may an investigation card be placed, and can a villager hold more than one?
- Can a villager hold two Lockdown cards, and what happens when the Witch visits it?
- If the Witch visits a Lockdown villager with two favours and a familiar pawn, how many villager skills and familiar skills trigger?
- Who chooses the target of card #10, a potion or a familiar?
- Does the Village Center location's clue placement need the Hunter to place an activation pawn on it?
- Can the Hunter use a villager's skill twice by playing the Supervision investigation on that villager?
- If the Hunter has several allies that trigger in upkeep, do they all activate or does the Hunter choose one?
- Does Connecting Clues also cost three Evidence on top of the card's cost?
- Can you play a card that removes a Clue from each villager of a faction if some of those villagers have no Clues?
Witch Cards
- When does a familiar card's skill resolve during a visit, and can the Witch use it outside a visit?
- When the Witch's familiar pawn is used, do all familiar cards trigger or only one?
- Does the familiar's empowered version replace the normal skill, or does it add to it?
- Does the empowered Qualm return an investigation from any villager, or only the visited one?
- Can Qualm move an investigation onto a villager that already has one?
- Does Merge With Familiar let the Witch trigger the same familiar card once for each familiar pawn?
- Does a familiar trigger twice when a visit has both Lockdown and Merge Familiar?
- Does the Preacher gain a token when the Witch places a familiar pawn but does not use the familiar skill?
- Can the Agile familiar skill let the Witch use the skill of an adjacent villager?
- Does a Witch's Isolation card (#44) still count an eliminated villager as adjacent?
- With Isolation in play, where can the Hunter place action pawns on villagers, and must the second pawn be placed?
- Does a potion or other effect that readies a villager cost an extra secret from that villager?
- Can you use more than one potion in the same turn?
- When can a Brew be used during the Witch's turn?
- Can you take several Brew actions in one turn?
- Do two copies of Jar of Glibness, or two potions with the same effect, stack?
- Can the familiar Undermine add secrets and also remove a location in the same activation?
- Does the empowered Facilitate let the Witch play two cards?
- What is the cost of the Empower action on Facilitate, and what does Lethargy do?
- Does Entranced trigger when the Hunter visits a villager?
- When does Entranced's draw happen during a Witch visit?
- What does Conjuring (card 33) double?
- Do allies affected by Tardiness still need upkeep paid?
- Does Tardiness eliminate allies until the end of the game?
- Does Witch card 147 stop the Hunter's clue distribution, and when is it used?
- Does an empowered familiar ability cost 2 influence on top of the card's own cost?
- What does the stronger effect of card 46 cost?
- How does the cost reduction on March at Dawn work?
- In what order are a Witch visit's steps resolved when a familiar is used?
- Can Flagon of Oblivion be played on a villager that has no Hunter pawn?
- Does Disorientation's cost limit use the printed cost or the calculated cost?
- What does the card Whispers in the Dark do?
- If an enchantment says the Hunter may allocate no more than one asset per turn, does an investigation's extra asset still add to the total?
- Who decides the villager the Hunter must visit when the Hypnosis curse is in play?
- If the Captivation familiar's Empower is used, do you still remove a secret from each villager of the faction?
- Does the Captivation familiar's effect require a secret token on every villager of the faction before it can be used?
- If a card says the Witch visits a villager, do visits made with the familiar pawn also count?
- What does the Qualm familiar do to an investigation card?
- Does a Witch Charm that decides the Hunter's first action resolve as soon as it is played?
- When a card makes the Hunter reveal a suspect card, who chooses which card to reveal?
- Do you pay a Familiar card's cost again every time you use its Familiar action, as with Learn Secrets?
- Is there a limit of one Familiar skill per turn, and can a returned Familiar be used again?
- Do two Hypnotism enchantments in play stack, so the Witch controls the Hunter's first two actions?
- Does the Suggestion card require a Secret on the villager to pay the cost of preparing that villager?
Actions
- If a location with an action pawn on it is removed, does that pawn still count as used for the turn?
- Can you remove your own action pawn to ready a villager?
- What does the Ready a Villager action cost?
- What does it mean for a villager to be ready?
- When distributing clues or secrets on a visit, can you take them from other villagers instead of the supply?
- Can you distribute an asset onto the villager you are visiting?
- When distributing several clues or secrets, can they all go on one villager?
- Are the steps of a villager visit mandatory, or can you visit just to block a villager?
- In what order do investigations, distribution, villager skills and the Familiar step resolve on a visit?
- Can several of your pawns use the same action spot on your player board in one turn?
- Can the same villager or location be used by two pawns in one turn?
- What does the eye symbol on a board action mean?
Witch Actions
- Does performing the Witch's ritual trigger investigation cards?
- Must the Witch convert 3 Secrets into a Favor when she has them on the visited villager?
- On the Witch's first turn, must both of her regular pawns visit villagers of the same faction?
- Can the Witch distribute Secrets onto a Brew instead of a villager?
- Can the Witch convert Secrets from a villager other than the one she is visiting?
- Can the Witch consume a Brew in the middle of a Visit a Villager action?
- When the Witch uses her Familiar pawn to visit a villager, does the villager's normal action still happen?
- Is there a limit to the number of Favors on one villager?
- Does a Familiar card's bonus trigger only when the Familiar pawn visits a villager, or on any action?
- Why does the Witch have a Ready a Villager action if she always goes first?
- Can the Witch visit the same villager in consecutive rounds?
- When the Witch converts Secrets into Favors, are the converted Secrets returned to the supply, and does conversion come before distribution?
- Can the Witch use her Familiar pawn as a normal worker without a Familiar card in play?
- When a villager has two Favors, does its skill repeat, and does the Witch need another pawn?
Hunter Actions
- Must the Hunter's Eliminate Villager be the first action of the Hunter's turn?
- Where does the Hunter's action pawn go when eliminating a villager, and does the villager need a pawn on it?
- What clues does eliminating a villager need, and what happens to the clues when it is eliminated?
- What happens to an eliminated villager's Suspect card?
- How much Evidence does a visit give the Hunter, and where does it go?
- What does the Exonerate Villager action cost, and can the Hunter use it more than once in a turn?
- Where do exonerated Suspect cards go?
- Where do the clues for lifting an Enchantment come from?
- Does Isolation stop the Hunter from raiding a villager that is not next to it?
- Does Raid Villager use a single action pawn placed directly on the target villager?
- Which clues pay for Raid Villager, and does the target need clues on it?
- Do investigation cards on a villager trigger when the Hunter raids or eliminates that villager?
- Does Hunter Adams add 1 Influence to each card played, and can the Hunter play fewer than two cards?
Winning the Game
- Does eliminating an innocent villager count toward the Hunter's exoneration win?
- Can the Hunter deduce the Witch when only the suspect cards of eliminated villagers are left?
- Can the Witch get her third Favor and perform the Ritual in the same turn?
- How many action pawns does Perform Ritual take, and where is the pawn placed?
Advanced RulesExpansion
- When a restriction conflicts with a bonus, which one applies?
- If two copies of the same card are in play, does an effect that changes a value trigger twice?
- What counts as 'in play' for effects that remove cards?
- What rules limit a custom deck, such as its size and copies per card?
- Can Beyond the Palisades cards be mixed with base game cards in a custom deck?
- Who chooses the red, blue and green factions, and does the choice matter once play starts?
- How does the Mysterious Chest scenario work for visits and elimination?
- Can the Hunter discard a Location or Ally with Lost in Plain Sight on it to make room for a new card?
Pagan: Beyond the PalisadesExpansion
- When a player removes Gloom, must the tokens come from their own cards?
- Can Gloom tokens be added to the Emit card (#96), and does Emit count as a Gloom card?
- What does the Expose card do to a Gloom card, and can it remove Gloom from an enchantment?
- Who gets the Cleanse benefit when the last Gloom is removed from a Witch card or a Hunter card?
- Does removing a Gloom card with a card effect, such as Expose, or eliminating its villager, trigger that card's Cleanse?
- How does Cleanse happen, and is it an action the Hunter can take?
- How is Gloom removed from an enchantment, an investigation, a location or a charm, and does Cleanse still apply?
- What does Lift Enchantment cost for a Gloom enchantment such as Invisible Barrier?
- Are Gloom tokens on the green Tainted villagers removed when the Hunter visits them?
- Does the Hunter get the Gloom bonus when visiting a villager that has Gloom tokens on it?
- Does Invisible Barrier apply to Gloom cards of both players, including the Hunter's locations and investigations?
- Does Herdsman trigger for each Gloom token removed when several are removed at once?
- Does Willow Shrub's ready-villager effect cost a Clue?
- How does the Perplex charm work on the villagers of the targeted faction?
- Does Scenario 11's Hunter bonus trigger on the skulls placed when the card enters play?
- Does Scenario 11 have a Both effect?
- Do green villager skills, such as Mother Grace's, count pawns on other factions?
- How do the Household villager skills count action pawns?
- Can Beyond the Palisades be played without the base game?
- Can Beyond the Palisades be played without a scenario card?
- Does playing the Rally card require discarding clues to ready villagers of the chosen faction?
- Does Mental Image let the Witch choose which Suspect card the Hunter reveals?