Pacific Origins thumbnail

Pacific Origins

Pacific Origins Rulebook

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Zedek's Pacific Origins

Dan Zedek's remarkable PACIFIC ORIGINS game variant, included in this issue, may not be a "perfect" game. However, every gamer who has playtested it so far (and this includes about twenty hardcore gamers in California and Maryland) have found it superior to standard ORIGINS and more than a few remarked "this is the only thing that could really get me back into playing ORIGINS."

The game subject is one that defies perfection as a simulation. Many players, for example, were unhappy that they could not appropriate their PFs to Europe or the Pacific as they pleased. Obviously, this would have resulted in a very wild game almost impossible to balance. Moreover, it would be unrealistic to suppose that, say, Britain would pull out of the Pacific entirely to stop Hitler, or let Hitler have Europe to gain ascendance in the Pacific. Thus, European and Pacific PF allocations for a country like Britain represent an overall policy commitment to these respective theatres. Moreover, many of the PFs in one theatre could not have been transferred to the other even if England had desired to do so. For example, abandoning Hong Kong would not have increased England's influence in Europe—indeed, would likely have decreased it. And vice versa. The same holds with the other "two-theatre" countries.

A certain amount of PF transference could have taken place—especially in terms of fleets, etc.,—and this is abstracted in the present game in the interboard relationship rules. Readers who are interested may experiment with a Max/Min PF allocation system if they wish: wherein total PFs for both theatres are given a player each turn, and he has a certain amount of discretion as to which theatre to place his PFs within set Max/Min limits. General feeling, however, is that such rules discriminate against the one-theatre nations of Germany, Japan, and China.

Perhaps the toughest nut to crack was the problem of the Sino-Japanese War. This was a very unique event, in that it represented "hot" war being actively carried out through much of the global diplomacy era of the 1930s. Many gamers felt that it should be omitted entirely. Zedek felt it should be included as a Japanese option, but if Japan opted for a "hot" war with China it would obviously have to be a very different game design element from the standard Diplomatic Attacks that continue among non-belligerent powers. And so you have the Sino-Japanese War Table. The Japanese player must judge carefully whether, as events unfold, his best chance for a win on Objective Points lays in a major Diplomatic Assault on Western Colonies, or a "hot" war with China.

Meanwhile, Western powers can never make their colonies "safe" from Japanese diplomatic aggression, since only Japan seeks a colonial Control. The Western parent nation seeks NC (no control) for his colony and the Allies seek a mild (low point) Understanding with each other colonies. This was done to reflect their mutual self-interest in keeping their colonial possessions from Japan.

PACIFIC ORIGINS captures very well, I think, the overall strategic essence of the global diplomacy that preceded the global war of 1939-45. Obviously, this is not a simulation-in-detail. Zedek had a lot of problems to solve; he has come up with some interesting solutions and a fast, intelligent, and fun game that is well worth your time and a place in your collection.

Pacific Origins

by Dan Zedek

I. How to Play

Pacific Origins is a companion game to ORIGINS OF WORLD WAR II and is primarily designed to be played simultaneously with that game. The new mapsheet is of East Asia in the 1930s; it should be placed on a separate table, if possible, but arranged so players have easy access to both gameboards. China and Japan are also introduced as active participants, so this variant may include up to seven players. (However, five people may still play. Germany/Japan and France/China can be single players as there is no conflict of interests between these respective countries. See below). Hereafter, we shall refer to these simultaneous games as PO (Pacific Origins) and EO (European Origins).

All rules for standard ORIGINS are used except as modified or expanded here. However, the rules changes are minimal, as you will see. Thus, playtesters have found this game easy to learn, very fast moving and, perhaps most important of all—it's now interesting even to France and the U.S.A.

II. Standard Rules: Modifications & Expansions

(1) Separate National Objectives (Chart I) and PF Allocations (Chart II) are provided for the Pacific theatre. These are used in the same way as standard EO charts.

(2) PF allocations received in the Pacific must be placed on the PO mapsheet. PF allocations received in Europe must be placed on the EO gameboard. PFs of any country may NEVER be transferred from one gameboard to the other.

(3) As in standard rules, PFs received in the Pacific must be placed on the mapsheet immediately, either in one's home country or as the player desires. Notice that special holding areas in the Pacific have been provided for Britain, France, and the U.S.A. These are "home" areas for these countries in the Pacific.

(4) British, French, Russian, and United States PFs in home areas on the PO board are completely separate from similar PFs on the EO home areas. No exchanges are allowed between a nation's two home areas, nor may units in these two home areas be combined for an attack.

(5) For purposes of this simultaneous game, standard European Origins is considered to begin in 1934 and end in 1939 (instead of 1935 to 1940). This is no way changes the play of that game. It remains six turns long, and all Objectives, PF allocations, and victory conditions remain the same.

Pacific Origins begins in 1932 and ends with completion of the 1940 turn. It is nine turns in length. The German player has no active part for the first two game turns, but may if invited sit in on negotiations to pave the way for any future benefits as the situation in the Pacific unfolds.

A complete Player Turn Order is now as follows: U.S., France, Britain, Russia, Germany, China, Japan.

III. Special Interboard Relationships

Although PFs may not be transferred from one board to another, certain interboard relationships do exist and may be used to advantage by countries with PFs on both boards.

(1) Remember that Britain, France, Russia, and the United States have two Objectives Tables—one for Europe and one for the Pacific. Objective points in Europe count only toward victory on the European board. Objective points in the Pacific count only toward victory on the Pacific board. Thus, each of the above countries will have two separate Objective Point totals at game's end, and, for example, Britain could win on one board and lose on the other.

(2) The Pacific Objectives Table sometimes gives an "E" as an objective for one of the above four countries in the Pacific. This merely denotes that although there are no Pacific interests, there are European ones and these may be relevant. For example, Russia's Pacific interests with Britain are denoted by "E"; thus, although Russia cannot gain an Understanding with Britain in the Pacific, the "E" refers him to the European board, where an Understanding is possible.

(3) UNDERSTANDINGS on one board are binding on the other. If Russia should get an Understanding with Britain on the European board, this Understanding is binding to Britain on both boards.

Understandings with colonies have no significance apart from their Objective Point value. For example, a Russian Understanding with French Indochina gives Russia 2 Objective Points but does not constitute an Understanding with France. Only Japan seeks to Control colonies; parent nations seek NC (No Control) in resisting Japanese desires, and colonial Understandings merely reflect the mutual self-interest among Western powers that their colonies should be free of Japanese Control.

Players may still ALWAYS attack foreign PFs in their home countries or home "holding" areas.

(4) COMBAT. As previously stated, players may never combine PFs on the two boards for an attack. However, there is a special case in which a player may use PFs in his home area on one board to attack foreign PFs in his home area on the other board:

(a) When an opponent places PFs in your home area, you may attack those PFs only with your own PFs in that home area on that board.

(b) However, if you do not have enough PFs in the home area to make a legal attack (and you may deliberately bring this situation about during placement of PFs if you wish), then—and only then—you may elect to attack with PFs in your home area on the other board. This assumes you do have enough PFs in your other home area for a legal attack. Remember, PFs in the two home areas may not be added together: losses are taken from the area from which the attack is made.

Example: Britain has 9 PFs in England/Europe and 3 PFs in Britain's Pacific "home area". Japan has 3 PFs in Britain's Pacific "home area". If Britiain should wish to attack, she must attack with Pacific PFs at 1-1 odds, since this is a legal attack. However, if Britain had only 2PFs in the Pacific "home" area (no legal attack), she could elect to attack with the 9 PFs in Europe at 3-1 odds. In event of an exchange, British losses would have to be taken from the attacking (European) area; the two British PFs in the Pacific would be unaffected by any adverse results since they were not involved.

Notice that the above still does not entail any actual transference of PF units from one board to another.

(c) This rule would also make it legal, for example, for British PFs in the Pacific "home area" to attack German PFs in England, if Britain did not have enough PFs in England/Europe "home" for a legal attack. Likewise, France, U.S., and Russia may all use this tactic for breaking undesired European Understandings.

This also allows for a minimal amount of German/Japanese cooperation: Japan may attack British PFs in British/Pacific "home" area to prevent these units from attacking a German Understanding in England/Europe. Or, if it does not have a legal attack on Britain's Pacific "home", attack British PFs in England to weaken Britain in Europe. This is greatly to Japan's interest, as she wants to see a war break out in Europe (i.e., a German win with 15 points) since this greatly increases Japan's own possibilities, as we shall see.

Germany, on the other hand, will seldom opt to attack PFs in Pacific holding areas even if the opportunity arises. Adverse results weaken Germany in Europe, and it is no benefit to the German to eliminate (say) British PFs in the Pacific.

IV. Sino-Japanese War

(1) Starting with the 1937 turn, Japan may elect to do away with diplomacy and declare outright war on China. It is not necessary for Japan to control Manchuria or to attack/remove any Chinese Understanding with Japan.

(a) At the beginning of his turn, prior to placement of his PF allocations, the Japanese player simply announces his declaration of war. This may be done on any turn from 1937 to 1940 (although the only point of doing so in 1940 would be to convert a shared Control of Manchuria to Exclusive Japanese Control).

(b) All Chinese PFs in Japan are removed (including any Understandings) and no Chinese PFs may be placed in Japan for the remainder of the game. All Japanese PFs in China are removed, including any Understanding.

(c) If China and Japan have SHARED Control of Manchuria, this automatically converts to exclusive Japanese Control. The Chinese Control marker is simply removed.

(d) The Japanese player may now place his PF allocations as per usual. He may, and probably will, place them in China.

(e) The usual Diplomatic Attack Phase is now executed, starting with the United States (both boards) on through to Japan.

(4) [Printed as "(4)" in the source, between (e) and (g); the lettering appears to be a misprint for "(f)" and is transcribed as printed.] After all diplomatic attacks are completed, a "Turn" now has a "Sino-Japanese War Phase." Simply, it is this: at the end of any turn that Japan has more PFs in China than the Chinese do, the Japanese may roll the Sino-Japanese War Table. When allowed to roll on the table, he may roll for every city on the table.

The first time the Japanese player rolls on the table, he must roll the WAR I column; the second time he uses it, the WAR II column, etc. Thus, if he declares war in 1937, and is superior to China in PFs on every subsequent turn, he will get to use the WAR IV table in 1940.

(g) Each city needs to be captured only once. It becomes a permanent Japanese possession for the remainder of the game.

(h) If Japan captures every Chinese city, he has conquered China. All Chinese PFs are removed from the board and China scores "zero" for the game.

But this is not likely. It is possible only on the last game turn; and then only if Japan is rolling on the WAR IV Chart, and rolls a "1" against Chungking.

(i) Thus, throughout the Sino-Japanese War, China or any other Player in the Pacific may continue to place as many PFs as they please in China. Russia may even secure her Understanding (U3) with China. These foreign PFs may even be used in separate foreign attacks, if sufficient for legal attack, on Japanese PFs in China. This would be in an effort to contain the Japanese in China. (It is not likely that anybody can put enough PFs in China for a legal attack against Japanese PFs unless the Japanese player is not making an all-out effort here.)

Any turn in which Japan is unable/unwilling to place enough PFs in China to exceed Chinese PFs there, he is not allowed to roll the WAR Table.

(j) Prior to rolling the WAR Table, Japanese PFs in China may make diplomatic attacks on Chinese PFs or any other nation's PFs (except nations that have an Understanding in Japan). Only after the Diplomatic Attack Phase are Chinese/Japanese PFs in China compared to determine whether Japan may roll the WAR Table.

(k) Each Chinese city that falls to the Japanese reduces China's PF allocation per turn for the remainder of the game by the amount indicated on the WAR Table. A record must be kept of the total PFs lost; or, more simply, at time of China's PF Allocation, these "lost" PFs are physically set aside or handed to the Japanese player (he may not use them). At the end of the game, Japan gets ½ Objective Point for each such Chinese PF in his possession. Fractions are not rounded off. Japan could win by a fraction of an Objective Point.

Notice that since there is no PF allocation after the 1940 (end of game) turn, no PFs are lost from this non-allocation phase. Accordingly, no PF loss is given for Chungking.

(2) JAPANESE CONTROL OF CHINA: The Pacific Origins Objective Chart lists NC (No Control) as United States, British, and French Objectives in China but does not list a C (Control) to oppose them. Japan's stated Objective is Understanding (U1); and this would seem to give the Allies automatic NC points.

However, if Japan declares war on China, an Understanding is no longer possible. Japan is said to CONTROL China if four or more cities are captured; at such a time, Russia would automatically lose her Understanding (without it being attacked) and all foreign PFs would be removed from China without attacks. Only Japanese and Chinese PFs would remain in China; the Chinese, to try to prevent total fall of the country. Even if China survives (China still has a good chance to survive and, ironically, to win), with four cities captured, the allies lose their NC points. China is Japanese Controlled for remainder of game.

Summing up: Japan is not required to declare war on China, but may do so at the beginning of any turn from 1937 to 1940. Only in event of war do these rules apply. Japan should declare war in 1940 in any event, since (a) it would automatically convert a SHARED Control of Manchuria to Japanese Exclusive Control, and (b) some lucky die rolls would rip-off some fast NC points from the Allies. But to be sure, Japan must go to war in 1937 and make this a major effort; and win Objective Points by early capture of cities rather than diplomatic confrontations with the Western powers.

V. War in Europe

The European game ends in 1939 and the winner is determined in Europe by standard victory conditions. If a war has broken out in Europe (i.e., Germany has won with 15 or more Objective Points), Britain, France and Russia are considered to be "soaked-off" in the Pacific and the following conditions result for the final (1940) turn in the Pacific:

(1) Only the United States, China, and Japan receive their 1940 PF allocations in the Pacific. Britain, France, and Russia receive no new PFs and must play the final Pacific turn with whatever PFs they have on hand.

(2) PFs in European "home" areas may not attack foreign PFs in their Pacific "home areas" even if otherwise legal according to rule III.4 above. Nor are Understandings in Europe binding in the Pacific. The European board is dead for all play purposes in the Pacific.

(3) If there is no war in Europe, the above conditions do not occur. While the European game is still over, any Understandings there are still binding and rule III-2 interboard attacks may still be made when legal.

VI. How to Win

(1) There is a separate winner for Europe and Asia.

(2) As in European Origins, the player with the most Objective Points in the Pacific wins.

(3) To compare how the European and Pacific winners did, multiply the Asian's total by 5 and the European's by four. The higher score is the TOTAL game winner: there is still only ONE winner!

VII. War in Asia

As in European Origins, whether or not war breaks out in Asia has no effect on play or victory. However, if at the end of the game (a) Japan wins and (b) Japan is at war with China, war in the Pacific may be considered to have broken out. However, if at the end of the game Japan has completely conquered China or has not declared war on China, there is no war. Only if Japan wins the game while still bogged down in a Sino-Japanese war does the Pacific theatre of war result.

VIII. Five Player Version

The rules as given above are for seven players. However, five may also play this variant; and, indeed, may find the game more interesting.

(1) For five players, Germany/Japan should be a single player, and France/China should be a single player.

(2) The only conflict of interest entailed here is with French/Chinese Objectives in Mongolia. Therefore, in this version allow France (only) an Understanding with Mongolia even if China has exclusive Control. Japanese Control or Shared Control would not permit the French understanding.

(3) IMPORTANT: Using this variant, only nations with PFs on both boards (i.e., Russia, France, England, United States) may use rule III-4 interboard combat. This will prevent France from "sacrificing" China or Germany "sacrificing" Japan to promote a strong win on one board.

IX. Setting Up This Variant

We've tried to make this game as easy to set up as it is to play. Suggestions:

(1) Obviously, you need a copy of ORIGINS OF WORLD WAR II; but it would help if you have two copies, since you will need extra European PF counters. If you don't have two people with copies, simply order extra countersheets from the AH parts department.

(2) Chinese and Japanese PF counters are provided here, but you should mount them before play.

Clarifications

(1) The mapsheet shows a special "Holding Area" for Hong Kong. This is merely a play-aid convenience. Units placed in the Hong Kong box are considered to be in the city; thus, all PFs placed in Hong Kong are simply placed in the holding box.

(2) Manchuria and Mongolia are not considered part of any country. They are exactly like Alsace-Lorraine and the Rhineland in European ORIGINS.

Charts

Printed on PDF page 6 of the magazine scan.

Chart I: Pacific Origins Objectives Table

ObjectiveU.S.FR.BR.USSRChinaJapan
BritainEE—EU3U1
BurmaU1U1NC3—U1C1
ChinaNC3*NC2*NC2*U3—U1*
D.E. IndiesU2U2U2——C2
MalayaU2U2NC3——C2
FranceE—EEU3U1
IndochinaU1NC5U1U2U1C1
JapanU2U2U1U5U1—
ManchuriaU2U1U1U3C3C3
MongoliaU1U2U1C4C1U2
PhilippinesNC4U1U2U3—C2
USSREEE—U3U2
Hong KongU2U2NC4——C2
U.S.——E—U4U1

*See Sino-Japanese War Rules.

Chart II: Pacific Origins PF Allocation Chart

(year)U.S.FR.BR.USSRChinaJapan
19326444610
19338555813
1934106661016 (European Origins Start)
1935127771219
1936169991422
1937201111111625
1938221313131828
1939261515152031 (European Origins ENDS)
1940281717172234

Also: Cf. Sino-Japanese War Table; for every PF China loses due to Sino-Japanese war, award Japan ½ an Objective Point. Any remaining fractions are not rounded off. The Japanese player may wish to "collect" these Chinese PFs to count up after the game.

Chart III: Pacific Origins Sino-Japanese War Table

(table)Shanghai and/or PekingHankowCantonKunmingChungking
WAR I1,2,3,4,51,21——
WAR II1,2,3,4,51,2,31,21—
WAR III1,2,3,4,51,2,3,41,2,31,2—
WAR IV1,2,3,4,51,2,3,4,51,2,3,41,2,31
PF Losses1 PF each per turn2 PFs per turn3 PFs per turn4 PFs per turn—

When any of the above cities fall, the Chinese player loses the indicated number of PFs from his PF allocation for each succeeding PF allocation phase for the remainder of the game. These Chinese PF losses should be set aside or given to the Japanese player for holding (he may not use them); at the end of the game, the Japanese player gets ½ Objective Point for each such Chinese allocated PF. Fractions are not rounded off — Japan could win by a fraction of an Objective Point.

Obviously, there will be no PF allocation Phase after the 1940 turn. Since this is the only turn on which Chungking may be captured, it has no PF Loss value; nor is there a PF loss for any cities captured in 1940.

Thus, Japan's only motive for attacking in China (1940) would be (a) to gain the four cities necessary for Control of China, or (b) try to knock China completely out of the game, which is a long shot but worth it if China should be ahead on points.