Merchants & Marauders FAQ
525 questions players ask · Updated Nov 14, 2026 · Full rulebook
OverviewExpansion
- Do Indian Treasure, Marooned and The White Lady use a Scouting or an Influence check?
- What if no flag token is available for a nation when Attack on San Juan resolves?
- What makes a player a pirate under the rules?
- When you sell a ship with Ship Modifications, can you place one of its tokens in the port where you are selling it?
- Does buying the Cargo upgrade let a ship carry more than 5 cargo cards?
- Do you have to be in your home port to win with stashed gold?
- If two players reach 10 Glory Points in the same turn, does stashed gold break the tie before the Glory track?
- When one player declares 10 Glory Points, do the other players get a final turn?
- Does the game end as soon as stashed gold brings you to 10 Glory Points?
- Does St. Maarten give you a second treasure chest for extra stashes?
- Is there a fee for depositing gold into your stash at St. Maarten?
- Are player-controlled ships ever Naval ships for card effects and bounties?
- Does becoming a pirate change my captain's nationality when my own navy hunts me?
- If I hold a Letter of Marque, which nation am I, and what happens if that nation goes to war?
- How many bounty tokens are there in the game?
- Where does a bounty token go for a nation that is at war?
- What counts as food for the Plague and Famine events?
- Does Crew in crew combat include every person on the ship?
- Does the captain count as crew, and what crew do you keep when you switch to a new ship?
- Can ship modifications raise a ship's stats above 5?
- Is a ship's maneuverability marked on the board like hull and masts?
- Do ports count as sea zones for NPC adjacency?
- Where are the ports on the board, and what does the flag show?
- Can players pay each other gold for help, such as to take a hit or assist in combat?
- Can players trade cargo or make deals with each other?
- Can a new captain earn another Glory Point for buying a Frigate or Galleon?
- Does capturing or finding a Frigate or Galleon earn the Glory Point for buying one?
- Can glory points go past 10 on the track?
- Can you add only some Seas of Glory modules to the base game?
- Are the Frigate and Galleon meant to cost the same?
- Are the extra Men-of-War in the box needed for play?
- How does Captain Sikuma's re-roll ability work?
- Can you spend gold from your stash outside your home port?
Game Setup
- Does Captain Power's ability apply only to Storm cards?
- Should the start player rotate each turn?
- If two players start in the same port, can the second player redraw his captain?
- Can players start the game with captains of the same nationality, or the same home port?
- Can you look at your captain card before choosing your ship type?
- Where are merchant tokens placed at setup, and when are they redistributed?
- How many Glory cards does Dominique de Richery start with?
- Must a player choose to be a pirate or a merchant from the start?
- Can tokens mark mission locations instead of placing the mission cards on the map?
- Does every player start the game with a Glory card, and where are Glory cards kept?
- Does recruiting the first ship's crew cost gold at the start of the game?
- How many crew does a Sloop start with, and does Extra Hammocks add crew automatically?
Playing the Game
- Must you spend all three actions in your turn?
- Must you take Move, Scout and Port actions in a fixed order?
- Can your first action of the game be a port action?
- Is one Event Card drawn per round or at the start of each player's turn?
- Does "turn" in the rulebook mean one player's turn or the whole round?
- Do you take all three actions before the next player's turn starts?
- When do NPCs placed by "at the end of the turn" event text arrive?
- Does a loyalty drop from an NPC event apply to every player?
- How long does a Storm or other weather event last?
- Does a Storm cost an action for a captain who is at sea when it is drawn?
- Does a Storm cost you an action or damage if your ship is in port?
- How is storm damage resolved, and how often does a storm hit?
- If two Storm cards come up in the same round, which one applies?
- Does the Attack on San Juan event end, and can Spain recapture the port?
- Do seamanship successes reduce the hits from the High Seas event?
- Can you sell Food at sea while Famine makes Food in demand?
- What does the Plague event do to captains in a port?
- Can you take the port action more than once in the same port in one turn?
- Can you repeat the same port activity, such as acquiring a rumor, in one port action?
- In one Shipyard visit, can you repair, modify and buy Special Weapons together?
- Must selling goods be your first port activity?
- If you end a turn in port, can you use port activities there next turn without moving?
- Does moving into a port and then taking a port action cost two actions?
- Does land block movement between adjacent sea zones?
- Can you enter a location while you have a bounty from the nation that owns it?
- Can more than one ship occupy the same port at once?
- Can you scout from port, or be scouted or attacked while your ship is in port?
- Can NPC ships hunt a ship that is sitting in port?
- Can you scout the same target twice in one turn, including after a ship flees?
- Can you scout another captain during their turn or off-turn?
- Can you scout a captain when you move through their sea zone?
- Does a bounty from another nation raise your scouting skill?
- Does being scouted by an NPC or another player cost you an action?
- Can you play Clemency in the middle of a Merchant Raid?
- Can you attack a player who only moves between ports on their turns?
- When a player reaches 10 Glory Points, do the other players get a final turn?
- If several players reach 10 Glory Points, how is the winner decided?
- Does stashed gold count toward Glory Points?
- Can you spend, move or withdraw stashed gold outside your home port?
- Can you always enter your home port, even during a war, plague or bounty?
- How do you enter Port Royal with an English bounty?
- Can a pirate enter a port of a nation it has a bounty against?
- What happens to your ship in a port when its nation goes to war with the port's nation?
- Do frigates become Men-of-War when a War card is drawn?
- How does the At War event card place and remove war flags?
- Can you take a Letter of Marque from a nation you already have a bounty from?
- Does a Letter of Marque change how other nations treat you as a pirate?
- What counts toward a Letter of Marque's Glory Point, and does its gold count?
- How much cargo can you hold while you are in port?
- How many cargo cards do you draw when you buy goods again in the same port?
- Can you discard all cargo you draw when buying goods, or use a Favor to replace it?
- When buying goods, which in-demand good is discarded and redrawn?
- In Santo Domingo, can you pay 1 gold to redraw cargo on a second consecutive buy?
- What price do you pay for several copies of one cargo good?
- How do cargo prices work in Nassau?
- How does Contraband work when buying, selling or repairing?
- How does buying three cargo for a free fourth work, for example in Cartagena?
- In Cartagena, can you find a Spanish merchant without a scouting roll?
- What does Caracas let you draw when buying goods?
- Must you show cargo you buy at a discount to another player?
- Can you sell goods at the port where you bought them, on a later turn?
- How much do goods in demand sell for, and does a port's base value change that?
- Do you get a Glory Point for selling three in-demand goods?
- After you sell an in-demand good, can you sell other goods in the same port action?
- When a demand token is replaced, is the new one drawn before the old one goes back?
- Do demand tokens run out, and do used tokens go back into the pool?
- Must you sell all of your cargo when you sell at a port?
- Can you check a rumor and acquire another in the same port, or roll for a rumor you just drew?
- Does checking a rumor at sea use up one of your actions?
- Which skill do you roll for a rumor, and does the icon decide it?
- Can a rumor that needs a sea search be tried in port?
- What happens when a rumor's roll fails?
- How many rumors can you acquire or try in one port action?
- Do you pay the 2 gold to try for a rumor if the roll fails?
- Can you hold more than one rumor, and where do rejected rumors go?
- Does a proven rumor you keep still take up your rumor slot?
- Do you get a Glory Point for a proven rumor?
- If your captain dies during a proven rumor's effect, do you still get its Glory Point and card?
- Does a scouting rumor count as a target in a sea zone?
- How does the Myriad of Goods rumor work?
- Does Witches Galore let you hire a Specialist for free in any port?
- Can you play A Desperate Employer right after drawing it as a mission reward?
- Which stats does a Slave Galleon from a rumor use?
- When a Wounded in Battle rumor is in play, does it replace an NPC search?
- Can you complete a rumor in a port of a nation you hold a bounty from?
- Must you claim a mission in port before attempting it or buying its goods?
- When is a replacement mission drawn?
- How many missions can you hold, and must you complete a claimed one?
- Can you keep a claimed mission and attempt it on later turns, and does failing its requirement lose it?
- Can you claim and complete a mission in the same port action?
- What happens to a mission card when you fail it or complete it?
- Can goods or a rumor acquired in the same port action count toward a mission?
- Must a mission or rumor requirement, such as having no Spanish bounties, hold until completion?
- Can you replace undesirable missions on the board without claiming one?
- When are the rolls for A Father's Plea made, and does it need travel?
- Where does the princess start on Royal Escort, and what does the mission need?
- How does Lead the Way move the Spanish naval ship?
- Does fleeing from a Joined Forces battle fail the mission, and where does the battle restart?
- Can you use Taking Sides' free hit ability repeatedly?
- Does Salvage Pulley need crew combat as well as an influence check?
- On Prisoner Transport, when must you free the prisoner?
- Does storm damage count toward Storm Chaser?
- Does a seamanship roll in a Diving Bell mission count as an extra turn?
- What does the forbidden-date mission's 5 gold reward mean?
- Does a mission to board a naval ship need you to defeat its captain?
- Can you complete Arms Smuggling with a Spanish bounty, or buy cargo before delivering naval arms?
- How does the Connoisseur mission complete with spice?
- On Old Providence, does the 3-gold wood bonus apply once or for each wood card?
- Does one round of Crew Combat fulfill Free Lilly, and does defeating the ship add its own Glory Point?
- When can you attempt the Fierce Loyalty leadership roll?
- Do Specialists stay with you permanently, and are they lost when crew takes damage?
- How does the Savant specialist's guess work on the first card?
- Can Alexandre Villon enter a port of a nation with a bounty on him, and how often can he try an influence port action in an illegal port?
- How many cargo cards can Pepijn van Avezaath carry?
- Which discarded cards can Thomas Nelson take, and when?
- Does Christian Marquis ignore storm effects completely?
- How does Percival Whitewood's extra cargo draw work?
- Does Van Riebleeck's negate ability cancel a hit before hit locations are rolled?
- Does Meike Beerens' +1 seamanship bonus apply to a Strong Gale roll?
- How does Crow's Nest affect scouting?
- Does Extra Cannon Port keep a cannon if all your cannons are destroyed?
- How does the Reinforced Hull token work, and what does it cost to refresh?
- How much does a ship modification cost, and where can you buy one?
- When are face-down ship modification tokens revealed, and can you buy one right away?
- Can you buy a ship modification you just placed in the port you are in?
- Can you buy a ship modification that would push a stat above 5?
- Do ship modifications transfer to a newly bought ship?
- Do Special Weapons transfer to a new ship?
- What happens to a Special Weapon after you use it or sell it?
- Can you sell your old ship before paying for a new one, and how does trade-in work?
- How much do you get when you sell a ship, and can you sell your only ship?
- When you buy a bigger ship, do you keep your crew, and must you recruit the rest?
- Can a repair take a ship above its printed values?
- How much crew do you recruit with a Leadership roll in port?
- Does losing crew affect your specialists or your ship's movement?
- What happens to Merchant tokens when there are none left, or too many are removed?
- When several players' effects trigger at the same moment, who resolves first?
- When an event card says "and/or", who decides which effects apply?
- In a Location Raid, are cards discarded during the Ground Assault?
- How do stat rolls work, and what is a success?
- Is ending your turn after a Port action an official rule to speed up play?
- Does a port's nationality change last for the rest of the game?
- Does being forced out of a port cost an action?
- Do you need to be in your home port to declare victory with 10 points?
- What counts as being in port rather than at sea?
Merchant Raids
- If your cargo hold is full, can you throw existing cargo overboard to take cargo from a Merchant Raid?
- Can Special Weapons be used during a Merchant Raid?
- Do Special Weapons in a raid let you reroll dice or get more successes than you rolled?
- Must you spend Special Weapons tokens before using your successes on cards during a Merchant Raid?
- In a Merchant Raid, can one success be used for more than one action?
- In a Merchant Raid, must you declare an exchange or draw before you see the new card?
- Can you raid more than one merchant in a single turn?
- Is a merchant token removed from the board if you scout it and then decline to raid?
- What happens when more than eight Merchant tokens are on the Merchant track?
- Can you scout for or raid a merchant in a sea zone that has no merchant token?
- How does the Havana fourth card work in a Spanish merchant raid?
- Can you use a success to exchange a Flee card drawn in a Merchant Raid?
- Does the merchant escape when the escape icons equal your Maneuverability, or only when they exceed it?
- Does a Maneuverability lead give an extra seamanship die in a Merchant Raid?
- Can you attempt a Merchant Raid if part of your ship is already destroyed, or what if a location is destroyed mid-raid?
- Which ship modifications still matter in a Merchant Raid?
- Do you keep the cargo cards you draw in a raid, and is there a cap on how many you can draw?
- When can you play a Glory card that cancels a hit during a Merchant Raid?
- Does San Juan's +3 plunder bonus count toward the 12 gold needed for a Glory Point?
- Does bonus gold from a Letter of Marque or a mission count toward the 12 gold for a Glory Point?
- Does San Juan's +3 plunder bonus move to the new nation's merchants when San Juan changes nationality?
- In a sea zone with a port, can you choose the port's nationality for the merchant you raid?
- Does a Merchant Raid count as defeating a ship for a mission or rumor?
Bounties & RewardsExpansion
- When do you receive a Bounty?
- Does a successful scout give you a bounty, even if the other captain then escapes?
- When does a captain become a pirate?
- How many bounties do you get for a battle with a Naval ship?
- Do you get a bounty for sinking a Naval ship that attacked you?
- Does a pirate get a bounty when a ship attacks it, or when it defends itself?
- Do you get a bounty for attacking a non-pirate player?
- Do you get a bounty for attacking or defeating a pirate player?
- Can a pirate defeat another pirate player and claim the reward?
- Do you get gold for sinking or defeating an NPC pirate ship?
- Do you get a Glory Point for defeating an NPC ship, including a pirate sloop?
- Do you get a Glory Point for buying a Frigate or Galleon, and can you get it more than once?
- Does a successful rumor plus buying a Frigate or Galleon give two Glory Points?
- Does a Galleon or Frigate you receive from a rumor give a Glory Point?
- Do you get a Glory Point for completing a mission on top of the normal reward for the action that completed it?
- Do you earn a Glory Point if your ship sinks at the same time, or if the opponent flees?
- Do you need to board a ship to defeat it for a bounty or Glory Point?
- Do you get a Glory Point for defeating a merchant?
- Does a rumor or mission that pays 12 or more gold give an extra Glory Point?
- What is the maximum number of bounties you can have from one nation?
- Do bounties from different nations share one bounty track?
- Can you pay 5 Gold to remove a bounty before a Naval ship in your sea zone scouts you?
- Can Clemency remove a bounty you picked up earlier in the same turn?
- What does 'your next turn' mean on the Clemency card?
- Can Clemency remove both bounties from attacking a Naval ship?
- If you become a pirate in a sea zone that holds a Naval ship, does it scout you right away?
- Can a Naval ship or pirate scout you while your captain is in port?
- Can you attack merchants or ships of your own nationality and take a bounty from your own nation?
- Do players represent their nation when bounties or wars apply?
- Does being at war with a nation make attacking its ships bounty-free?
- Does a war change how Naval ships pay or hunt for bounties?
- If your nation is at war with another and you hold bounties from that other nation, do the navies still hunt you?
- Does a war pardon your existing bounties, or turn a pirate into a navy ship?
- If a bounty or war makes a nation an enemy while your captain is in its port, can you still take port actions?
- Can you enter a port that belongs to a nation you have a bounty from?
- Can you still enter your home port if its nation is one you have a bounty from, and does your nationality change with the port?
- Can a captain with a bounty enter Port Royal while his nation is at war with the port's nation?
- Can you switch from merchant to pirate, or back, during the game?
- Do you get the start-of-combat bounty if the other player started the battle?
- How many bounties does a Merchant Raid give?
- What do you need to claim a Letter of Marque mission, and does claiming give a bounty?
- Does holding a Letter of Marque change which ports you are allowed to enter?
- Are you still treated as a pirate by other nations after you remove all your bounties while holding a Letter of Marque?
- Does the Native Village give you bounties?
Glory CardsExpansion
- Can Perfect Navigation let you take a second Port action in the same turn?
- Does Loose Cannon still work if you have no cannons, or when the damage comes from a Long Gun?
- Can you play the Escort card on a battle you start yourself?
- If a Naval ship protected by Escort defeats the player, can the attacker plunder the player's ship, and what bounties does the attacker get?
- Does the Lead the Way mission make you fight the Player pirate, and does that earn a Glory Point?
- Is the French Merchants Must Die mission complete after defeating three French ships, or only when you earn 15 Gold?
- With a Letter of Marque, can you enter the other nations' ports, and what nationality do you count as?
- With the Survivor card, can you keep both your Rumor cards and your Mission card?
- If you cannot pay to hire a Specialist, is the Specialist card discarded?
- Are Glory cards discarded after they are played?
- Which discarded Glory Cards can Captain Thomas Nelson take?
- Can Captain Thomas Nelson take a Glory card that a player has just played?
- Can a Master Gunner's owner still play Cannon Re-roll on his own roll?
- After a naval battle or merchant raid, can Salvage What You Can repair any damage you choose?
- Can a Carpenter repair the Reinforced Hull?
- Can you play the Pardon Glory card before a hostile Naval ship scouts you at the start of your turn?
- Can Fast Learner be played to trigger Mutiny on the same captain again?
- Can Fast Learner repeat a Mutiny against a captain who did not meet Mutiny's requirement?
- If the NPC ship called in by the Escort Glory card loses combat, what happens to the player who played the card?
- Can you play a Glory card on another player's turn or to help another player's roll?
- Can Fast Learner copy Perfect Navigation?
- What does Ship with a History keep for your new captain, and does it include special weapons?
- Are Glory cards hidden or public?
- When your captain dies and you played Survivor, what can the plunderer take?
- Can you hold more than one Specialist of the same type?
- Are Specialists limited by your ship's crew size?
- When New Tricks shuffles the Glory deck, is the discard pile shuffled in too?
- When can you play a Glory card that does not say when it is played?
- Do the Glory cards that ignore a Hit-icon and that cancel a Hit-icon differ in effect?
- Does the Prisoner Transport card's ability to ignore one hit apply in every round of Crew Combat?
- Does Fast Learner have to be played immediately after the copied Glory card resolves?
- Can a Glory card that lets a defeated captain keep his ship be used after a loss to an NPC pirate, and what about a player captain?
- What is the maximum number of Glory cards you can hold at once?
- Do you get a Glory Point for buying a Frigate or Galleon more than once, and for capturing one?
- Does the victim of the Thievery Glory card need to be in the same port as you?
- Can a crew-combat or seamanship re-roll Glory card reroll both your dice and your opponent's?
- Do you get a Glory Point for defeating a pirate sloop or brig NPC?
- Do hired Specialists count against the Glory card hand limit of 4?
- Does stashing gold give a Glory card?
- Can any player complete the Ghost Ship rumor, or only the player who found it?
- If a Mutiny card is played on you after a merchant raid worth 12 or more gold, do you still get the Glory point?
- Do Specialist Glory cards stay in your hand after you play them?
- Does the False Colors card require two successful scouting rolls, each with at least one success?
- Can you redraw a Glory card if it would give you a duplicate specialist?
- Can you keep a rumor specialist such as Alan MacCall alongside a Glory specialist with a similar role?
- Can you play Naval Activity after being scouted or while a battle is underway?
- Does Ship's Surgeon's immunity to the Plague event let you enter a plague-struck port?
- If I hold four Glory cards, can I play a pardon card before drawing a fifth from defeating a player?
- How are Glory cards played during another player's turn resolved?
- After your captain dies, do you get a new Glory card?
- Does the Frame Glory card let you keep the card if the Influence check fails?
- What carries over to your next captain when the Ship With A History Glory card is used after losing crew combat?
Non-Player CaptainsExpansion
- When do newly drawn Non-Player Captains enter the game?
- Does a newly drawn NPC move or scout on the turn it arrives?
- What happens when a new event card brings in a nation's NPC that is already on the board?
- What happens to the NPC card underneath when an NPC is sunk?
- Do NPC ships move only when an event card shows their flag?
- Where does an NPC go when the card's direction is blocked by the map edge or a missing zone?
- Does an NPC ignore its event-card direction when a matching player is in an adjacent sea zone?
- Does a captain sitting in port count as being in the sea zone for NPC movement and hunting?
- If an NPC is waiting outside your port, does it leave when another pirate enters its sea zone?
- Which player does a naval NPC move toward when several match its hunt priorities?
- Which captains do NPC pirates hunt, and how are ties broken?
- Does a naval ship at war with you hunt you even if you have no bounty from its nation?
- What changes at sea while a War is in effect?
- If a war breaks out while your ship is in an enemy port, can you stay and act?
- How long does a War last once it starts?
- Are naval ships Man-o-Wars during a war, including new captains?
- Can you buy, sell or keep a Man-o-War, and how do you get one?
- Does a Man-o-War NPC revert to a frigate when peace returns?
- Do Seas of Glory Man o' War NPCs revert to frigates at peace?
- Why does the game include four brown Man-o-War pieces, and can more than two be on the board?
- How many NPC ships of each kind can be in play at once?
- How is a naval captain's Scouting value determined?
- Do NPCs scout before the round's event card is drawn?
- Are NPC movements on an event card resolved before the card's text is read?
- Does an NPC's hunt by itself start a battle?
- Can an NPC scout or attack your captain while your ship sits in port?
- When does a hostile NPC scout a player?
- Does a hostile NPC scout you immediately when it moves into your sea zone?
- Can the same NPC scout you twice in one turn?
- Can you scout the same NPC again after a failed scout on your turn?
- Can you attack a naval ship or pirate NPC by scouting it on your own turn?
- Do NPC pirates scout or attack player pirates?
- While the Hunted mission is active, where are new NPC pirates placed?
- If you become a pirate, do NPC pirates still attack you?
- If you become a pirate partway through your turn, does an NPC in that zone scout you right away?
- If you gain a bounty mid-turn without leaving the sea zone, can a naval NPC there scout you?
- Does moving through a sea zone with an NPC trigger a scouting roll?
- Does a naval ship still scout for a player with a bounty when pirate NPCs share its sea zone?
- Do NPC pirates scout players when a naval ship shares their sea zone?
- Do two NPC pirates in the same sea zone scout for players?
- Do two naval ships in one sea zone both scout for a player who enters it?
- Do NPC ships fight each other when they share a sea zone or are at war?
- If two NPCs find the same captain in one zone, who fights first?
- Who controls an NPC in combat, and can it flee?
- Does an NPC keep damage from one battle into the next?
- When an NPC wins its scouting roll, who starts the battle?
- What ships do naval and pirate NPCs use on the board?
- Can an NPC pirate keep a ship it captures from a player?
- Do NPC ships return to their spawn zone at the end of a turn?
- Does Caspar De Rivera's power let him steer the Spanish naval ship past hunt priorities?
- Can Sikuma force a re-roll on any pirate's successful scouting check?
- When a Too Quiet event gives one NPC two movement cards, how does it move?
- Can you use your Glory card benefits when fighting on behalf of an NPC?
- Are NPC ships affected by storm weather events?
- Do NPC pirates scout French captains in Tortuga?
- What does Invisible mean for a sea zone such as Trinidad?
- Is the Treasure Galleon a naval ship for the Well Connected Victim glory card?
- Can the Treasure Galleon or any ship hold more than one NPC upgrade?
- When a Naval Fort moves an NPC that is not on the board, does it enter immediately or at the end of the round?
- Does every player lose Loyalty when any NPC card is drawn?
- How many pirate ships can be on the board with the expansion?
- Does a mission that names the Pirate Sloop also apply to the Pirate Brig?
- Does Crijnssen's Seamanship rise with your bounties?
- What does the compass rose symbol on Man o' War captain cards mean?
- After a naval ship is moved onto an opponent pirate, does it scout and hunt immediately?
CombatExpansion
- Who is the aggressor when a Naval ship scouts a pirate and starts the battle?
- Who declares their combat action first in a round?
- In the first round of naval combat, can either captain choose something other than Shoot?
- Can you always choose the Shoot action, even with no cannons?
- If both your Masts and Cannons are destroyed, does combat continue?
- If both captains choose Flee, do they escape without a roll?
- Do you roll one die per cannon in naval combat?
- Does a ship with Maneuverability 2 or more above its opponent get an extra Seamanship die?
- How are ties in a Seamanship contest resolved?
- What happens when neither captain rolls a success in a Seamanship contest?
- Do you need to win the Seamanship contest to board an enemy ship?
- How many hits does a Shoot inflict when you lose or tie the Seamanship contest?
- If you win the Seamanship contest, do you fire every cannon even with only one success?
- Does cannon damage reduce your hits when you lose or tie the Seamanship roll?
- Are hits from both captains in the same round resolved at the same time?
- If your cannons are destroyed in a round, do they still fire that round?
- If you choose Board or Flee, do you still fire your cannons?
- If you choose Shoot and your opponent chooses Board, who fires and when does boarding happen?
- How do you successfully flee in naval combat?
- If a ship tries to flee and wins the Seamanship roll but the shooter also rolled a success, does the fleeing ship still take damage?
- How does a naval battle end?
- Where does a ship end up after a successful flee from naval combat?
- After you flee from a battle you started by scouting, can you keep using your remaining actions?
- Does a Captain get a Glory Point when the opponent flees?
- Do you gain a Glory Point for sinking an NPC ship?
- Can you flee or shoot once crew combat has started?
- What counts as a naval battle for abilities that only work in naval battles?
- Who rolls the hit-location dice when a cannon hit lands?
- When a hit rolls skulls, who chooses the damaged location?
- Where do extra hits go once a location is already destroyed?
- What can a ship with no masts do in naval combat?
- If your Masts are destroyed, do captain or ship bonuses still add dice to your Seamanship roll?
- If your Masts are destroyed, do you roll only one die for Seamanship checks outside combat, such as storms?
- Do Masts use the Hull's Toughness value or Maneuverability on the player board?
- Can you board an enemy, or be boarded, when your Crew location is destroyed?
- Do dead crew reduce how many cannons you can fire?
- How are excess cargo cards removed when damage cuts your cargo capacity?
- When a ship with an Extended Cargo Hold is hit, does the hit reduce cargo from 5 to 4?
- Can the captain who wins a boarding recover cargo lost to cargo damage?
- How does Pepijn van Avezaath's extra cargo card work when your cargo holds are hit?
- Does Captain Felipe's hit-relocation ability help in crew combat?
- Does Machiel van Riebeeck's ability to negate a pirate cannon hit apply once per whole battle?
- What do Chain-shot and Grapeshot change in a naval round?
- When do you declare and use Grappling Hooks, Chain-shot or Grapeshot in ship-to-ship combat?
- How many of each special weapon can you have?
- Are special weapons lost after you use them in combat?
- How many dice can Grappling Hooks re-roll?
- When do Long Guns fire, and can you add chain-shot or grapeshot to them?
- When you board an enemy ship, do both players fire their swivel guns?
- Can swivel guns be used when you have no cannons left?
- Can you fire swivel guns before crew combat when a Slave Galleon Rumor sends you into crew combat?
- Can Reinforced Hull be used during crew combat?
- When is Reinforced Hull used, and must you use it?
- Can Reinforced Hull cancel a hit taken in a merchant raid?
- When can Chasers fire relative to a Flee declaration?
- Can a Chaser hit sink the target before any dice are rolled?
- Do Chaser shots still happen if the Seamanship roll to flee fails?
- If Chasers reduce a fleeing ship's Masts to zero, does its Flee still resolve that round?
- If cannon fire kills your last Crew before you board, is the boarding cancelled?
- If enemy swivel guns remove your boarding party's last Crew right before crew combat, does crew combat still happen?
- If cannon fire sinks your ship or destroys its masts before you board, does the boarding still happen?
- Does losing crew combat kill your captain, including when a mission or Rumor forces the fight?
- In crew combat, how many dice does each side roll, and how do hits apply?
- Can you inflict more hits in crew combat than the opponent has crew?
- Can you call off crew combat once you have boarded?
- What happens when both captains lose their last crew in the same round of crew combat?
- If both captains lose their last crew in a crew combat started by a Rumor, does a captain die, and is the Rumor discarded?
- What carries over when you capture or claim a ship?
- When you sink an opponent's ship versus board it, what do you keep or lose?
- Can a player get a Man-o-War by capturing a naval vessel?
- If an NPC wins crew combat against your ship, does it take your ship?
- If you win combat as the defender on the opponent's turn, do you get an extra action?
- Must you scout another player's captain before naval combat can begin?
- Can you scout the same target twice in one turn?
- Can you attack or board a ship in port?
- Does a naval ship scout you if you turn pirate in a sea zone it already occupies?
- Can a player pirate attack an NPC pirate ship?
- After a pirate or NPC flees from combat and is found again, is it at full strength?
- Does Fog let you skip the Seamanship contest in the first round?
- In Joined Forces, if a Naval ship flees the Pirate Sloop, does it also escape the player's ship?
- Can a Glory card that re-rolls Seamanship dice reroll your opponent's dice?
- Can another card reroll a Gust of Wind success?
- Can you add a Double Shot special weapon to Long Gun results?
- Does Carved Hull's -1 Seamanship leave a masts-destroyed opponent with any dice?
- Must you choose a hull when distributing shots with Double Shot?
Plunder
- If Attack on San Juan changes San Juan's nationality, do the new nation's merchants give extra plunder value?
- After you board and take an enemy ship, does it keep its damage?
- When you take an enemy ship by boarding, which crew do you bring across?
- Do ship modifications transfer when you claim an enemy ship?
- Can you sell your old ship when you capture a new one by boarding?
- Can you place a redistributed ship modification in the port where you buy a ship, then buy it back the same turn?
- If another player plunders your ship, what happens to your captain?
- When you plunder a player, which of their Rumor cards do you keep?
- When you claim an NPC's ship, do you swap its miniature for one in your player color?
- Does the Letter of Marque merchant raid bonus count toward the 12 gold needed for a Glory Point?
- Does the +3 plunder value from raiding Spanish merchants in San Juan count toward the 12 gold needed for a Glory Point?
- Can you claim a pirate ship after you defeat it in boarding?
- After winning Crew Combat against a Naval ship, what do you take, and must you keep the ship?
- If an NPC boards and beats your captain, does the NPC take your gold, cargo and ship?
- After winning a ship battle against another player, can you take their gold, cargo or ship?
Dying & Retirement
- When your captain dies or retires, what do you lose and what do you keep?
- If a captain dies and no Captains are left to draw, does the game end at once even if later players could still reach 10 Glory Points that turn?
- Does losing a Crew Combat always kill your captain, even when a card or mission does not say so?
- Does losing your last crew to cannon fire kill your captain?
- Is there a Glory card that keeps a captain alive after death?
- After your captain dies, which ship does the replacement start with, and where is it placed?
- How much gold does a replacement captain start with?
- How do you retire a captain, and does it cost an action?
- When does your replacement captain first take a turn?
- Do you draw a new Glory card for the replacement captain?
- If a pirate NPC is in the sea zone of the captain you draw, must you draw another captain?
- If you reach 10 Glory Points and your captain dies later in the same round, does your win still stand?
- When your ship is sunk, do its ship modifications go back to the ports before you draw a new captain?
Merchants & Marauders: Seas of GloryExpansion
- Can you play a Glory card that escapes when an NPC finds you after the other player plays Escort in response to your scout?
- With the wind set in one direction, do the free move and the penalty apply only when moving exactly that way?
- When a storm moves in a wind direction, does it keep going in the printed direction over island artwork?
- If the wind needle lands between two directions, do you re-spin or take the closer direction?
- With variable player order, when is a captain's extra action taken?
- With Seas of Glory event cards added, does running out of the event deck still end the game?
- Are the Seas of Glory event cards shuffled into the base event deck?
- Can Grand Calico Campo transfer ship modifications to a ship acquired as a prize?
- Does Captain Gil del Lobo stay out of English ports while he holds an English bounty?
- If Captain Kayati's player uses the Surrender Glory card, does he restart with his starting frigate and English bounties?
- Can you hire a Specialist for free from the Glory deck, or only one already in your hand?
- If an NPC upgrade would exceed a Man-o-War's maximum of 5 cannons or hammocks, what do you do?
- When drawing cargo in a port with the Contraband module, which cards are redrawn?
- If the Prosperity event picks Port Royal while the Earthquake has destroyed it, does Prosperity still apply?
- How does the Plank ship modification prevent a loyalty loss?
- Can you take two port actions in one turn in different ports?
- Can you use the free movement from the weather spinner after you have spent all your actions?
- If you use the Pleased loyalty free specialist hire, can you hire before selling goods in port?
- When Heated Shot sets the target ship on fire, can the damage location change each round?
- When an event card moves all six NPCs, in what order do they move?
- How many pirate NPCs can be in play at once, and do a Pirate Brig and Sloop count as the same?
- Are NPC ships affected by the wind direction?
- Do pirates hunt or scout around the Spanish Treasure Galleon?
- With Double Shot, which hit locations can the skull hits spread across?
- Does a contraband cargo card take up a cargo space?
- Does attacking a Missionary cost crew, and which hit icons matter?
- Can a non-pirate use a Naval Fort against a nation you are at war with?
- How far does a Naval Fort's ship move go?
- Does a Restless loyalty space stop you recruiting crew for free?
- Can you use a Town to hire a specialist?
- Which event cards cost Loyalty when drawn?
- When a bounty nation has no Naval ship on the board, which Naval ship does Pirates Must Hang draw?
- How does Enrique Clemenza's starting mission count as claimed?
- Does ground assault combat last only one round?
- Do you get a Glory card when a location raid plunders 12 gold and earns a Glory Point?
- In Mardi Gras, does one Rum sale count toward the discard of two Rum for the mission?
- Does damage from an on-board storm count toward the Storm Chaser mission, and can Christian Marquis claim it?
- Does being scouted by a naval NPC while you are a pirate, or at war, give you a bounty?