La Guerre du Bien Public, Montlhéry 1465
La Guerre du Bien Public, Montlhéry 1465 Rulebook
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
1 – Overview
Game scale: a combatants counter represents 1,500 - 2,000 pedestrians and 750 - 1,000 cavaliers on the front side (recto) and half as many on the back side (verso). An artillery counter represents 100 cannons of all types and calibers.
Time scale: the game lasts the number of rounds defined in the scenario. A round's duration depends on the season; a game round during harsh weather months (November – February) lasts twice as long as a round during mild weather months (March – October).
The game is played with a six-sided die.
2 – Definitions
Active player / inactive player: the player with the game phase is called active (attacker or besieger); the player who is not in his game phase is called inactive (defender or besieged).
Army: a stack of one or more units commanded by a commander whose counter is placed on top of the stack.
CF: Combat Factor, representing the combative value of the troop.
Commander: a named political and/or military figure is a historic commander on the recto of the counter; an anonymous commander is on the verso.
First player, second player: defined in the scenario. The first player plays first for each game round; the second player takes the second phase (see 6. Game Sequence).
FV: Fortress Value. The higher the value, the better it can withstand a siege.
Garrison: a stack of one or more units commanded or not by a commander, whose counter is placed at the bottom of the stack (if applicable).
LR: Line of Retreat, a tactical zone allowing for withdrawal from a combat.
Movement capacity: the limit of movement points (MP) that can be used to carry out movement.
MP: Movement Point for moving on the strategic and tactical maps.
RF: Range of Fire, used during the resolution of fire during battles.
RP: Recruitment Point, used to rebuild one's armies.
R&R: Reinforcements and Replacements.
SS: Strength Step (a counter has 2 SS on its recto and 1 SS on its verso). The artillery only has one SS. Its verso has the colours of the opposite camp to indicate that it has been captured by them following a combat. The CF on the recto can be different from the CF on the verso.
SZ: Strategic Zone on the strategic map.
TC: Tactical Capacity, a characteristic of the commander indicating his quality on the battlefield.
TZ: Tactical Zone on the tactical map.
VP: Victory Point.
1D6: one six-sided die.
3 – Counters
A counter is characterised by six parameters:
- its type of combatants or its principal combat weapon;
- its movement capacity in MP;
- a combat factor CF;
- an RF expressed in the number of TZ (the shooter's TZ is not counted);
- its cost in recruitment points, expressed in RP;
- a colour code for its nationality.
Some units are not necessarily present in every game in the series:
- AR: Archers
- CA: Cannon (all calibres)
- CB: Crossbowmen
- GD: Heavy cavalier (Gendarme, Man-at-Arms, Chevalier)
- MC: Medium cavalier (Coutilier, Brigandiniers)
- MCB: Mounted crossbowmen (Cranequinier)
- MI: Militia
- PI: Pikemen
A commander is characterised by four parameters indicated on the counter:
- his tactical capacity TC;
- his movement capacity, used on the strategic map and the tactical map, expressed in MP;
- his rank, expressed by 1, 2 or 3 stars (the more stars, the higher the rank);
- his nationality (commanders of the same camp, regardless of their nationality, can command all the units of this camp, barring any exceptions mentioned in the specific rules).
The recto is a named historic commander; the verso is an anonymous commander used after the elimination of a historic commander.
4 – Objectives
To win, players must obtain VP by controlling strategic regions, demoralising the allies of the enemy, and through military victories. Each scenario specifies the victory conditions in terms of VP. Victory is determined on the last round of the game, except where specified otherwise in the scenario.
5 – Strategic Map
The strategic map is composed of SZ characterised by a maximum of five parameters:
- Identification number;
- Movement cost: by default, each movement by an army in an SZ costs 1 MP, except those with a mountain symbol, which cost 2 MP;
- Number of VP for an objective SZ;
- Number of RP to recruit new replacement troops;
- FV of 1, 2 or 3 points. By default, each SZ contains a FV = 1. Greater FV are indicated by a legend.
Note: given the scale of the game and the surface of an SZ, there is always a town surrounded by ramparts or a fortified castle to house a garrison.
An SZ is either controlled, neutral or disputed.
- An SZ is controlled when:
- a control marker is placed on an objective SZ, or with RP;
- only one camp (army or garrison) physically occupies this SZ;
- an SZ is part of the territory of a non-neutral ally;
- an SZ is part of the national territory of a camp.
- An SZ is disputed when two camps occupy the same SZ during a siege or a battle, or when neither camp occupies it through units or markers.
- An SZ is neutral when the power that has this SZ did not enter the war with a camp (see 14 scenario), or if it left the war after a neutralisation (see 11. Diplomacy).
Control of an objective SZ
The SZ control marker with its camp's colours is placed in this SZ, either at the end of a victorious combat or after passing through, or being the last to stop in, this SZ, whether or not it leaves a garrison. The presence of combat units is not required to control the SZ.
When a camp controls an SZ, it benefits from its FV, its VP and its RP, with the following exceptions and limitations:
- if the SZ belongs to the national territory of the principal opposing power, the player neither benefits from its RP nor may it deploy R&R in this SZ;
- if the SZ belongs to an ally of the opponent, the player benefits from its RP but may not deploy R&R in this SZ.
Naturally, the opponent whose SZ are occupied may not benefit from his RP in the two cases above, nor deploy R&R.
6 – Game Sequence
A – Phase of the first player
- Reinforcements & replacements (see 7)
- Strategic movement (see 8)
- Fatigue & desertion (see 9)
- Resolution of battles (see 10)
- Resolution of sieges (see 10)
B – Phase of the second player
- Reinforcements & replacements
- Strategic movement
- Fatigue & desertion
- Resolution of battles
- Resolution of sieges
C – Mutual administrative phase
- Diplomacy (see 11)
- End of the round: the time marker is moved forward
- Determination of victory at the end of the last round of play (see 12)
7 – Reinforcements & Replacements
There are two ways to bring units into play during the game: as reinforcements and as replacements.
7.1 Reinforcements
A reinforcement is a unit or a commander that enters into play for the first time. A reinforcement intervenes:
- when it is indicated on the time scale / round counter;
- when the conditions are met for an exceptional reinforcement (see scenario).
When a reinforcement is available, it is placed according to the instructions in the scenario, in the corresponding SZ, during the Reinforcements & Replacements Phase. If there is no specific indication, the reinforcement is positioned in the form of an army or garrison, as the owner chooses.
When the arrival SZ of a reinforcement is controlled by the enemy by the presence of an army or a garrison, the reinforcement is held off until the following round, and at that point enters the game in an SZ adjacent to the SZ initially intended, or in the latter if it frees up. A control marker does not suffice to block the arrival of a reinforcement in the SZ initially intended or in an adjacent SZ. As long as an SZ has not been freed up, the reinforcement may not enter into play. In no case may a reinforcement enter a neutral SZ.
Once an allied power enters the game, its RP are available for its camp and its SZ are accessible to both camps.
7.2 Replacements
7.2.1 Overview
A replacement is a previously eliminated unit or a commander that returns to play from the pool of eliminated units. The number and the type of units available are limited to the counters previously eliminated and to the RP available during this round.
Special case for cannons: an eliminated unit of cannons goes into the pool of eliminated units and can return as a replacement in its original camp. A cannon that is captured by the enemy camp during a combat is immediately turned over to present the side of its new owner. It is then considered as a unit of this camp and may be employed for combat and replacement like any other unit of its new owner.
Special case for a historic commander: unless otherwise indicated in the specific rules (see 13.1), the verso of a commander counter represents a standard commander.
7.2.2 Calculation of RP
Number of RP available: each camp tallies the RP and SZ that it controls. RP represent soldiers as well as the money to recruit and equip them.
7.2.3 Purchasing replacements
RP are used to "buy" units at full or reduced strength; the cost is indicated in RP on each counter. RP cannot be spent to bring to full strength a diminished unit already present on the map. RP that are not spent are lost.
The active player may buy units from his camp or from his allies'.
7.2.4 Placement
Replacements are deployed by the active player to SZ bearing the shield of the purchased unit (see scenario). The number of RP indicated in each SZ has no influence on the number of units that can be placed there. It is prohibited to place a unit in an SZ controlled by the enemy. Players choose the placement in an SZ as either an army or a garrison if the commander is already present or was just placed there. Placement is not considered as a movement for fatigue and desertion.
8 – Strategic Movement
8.1 Overview
Units may not move on their own on the strategic map. The commanders alone or with units – thus an army – may carry out strategic movements.
An army must complete its movement before continuing on to the movement of another.
It is not permitted for a unit to begin its movement with one commander and finish with another.
Each unit may only move once per round. It is therefore not permitted to take back a unit that has already moved, whether a garrison or an army.
8.2 Procedure
The allocation in MP of an army is indicated by the value of MP of its army commander (commander with the highest rank present, located on top of the stack).
The army is moved from one SZ to another by paying 1 MP (clear terrain) or 2 MP (mountain, forest) to enter the SZ. One may only move from an SZ to an adjacent SZ, or one with a connecting point.
An army in an SZ may separate, without surcharge in MP, into as many armies as commanders are present to carry out various strategic movements. Several armies from the same camp that meet up in the same SZ are consolidated in the form of a single stack, garrison or army, with the highest-ranking commander. For no extra cost in MP, an army that carries out a movement may leave or pick up on the way units of a garrison or another army if the latter has not already carried out its movement.
It is not permitted to carry out movement in an SZ if the power to which it belongs has not yet entered the game. It is permitted to carry out movement in an SZ of a power that became neutral (neutralised) after combats or diplomacy.
A commander may move alone at the same cost as if he were accompanied by an army.
A garrison may be transformed into an army by placing its commander on the top of the stack and spending 2 PM; this is considered a movement for fatigue and desertion.
On the other hand, an army may be transformed into a garrison freely by placing the commander at the bottom of the stack.
An army that enters an occupied enemy SZ stops its movement. A siege or battle marker is immediately placed, according to 10.1. If the enemy SZ is unoccupied, the army may continue its movement and place a control marker, if need be.
Movement Example
Phase of the French camp: since the commander Louis XI is placed on the stack of counters, this is an army that may move. The army moves from SZ n° 28 to SZ n° 42 for a cost of 3 MP (1 MP per SZ in clear terrain) out of Louis XI's 4 MP. The army enters a SZ controlled by the adverse camp and must stop. The two units of archers of the garrison of SZ n° 36 are added to the army during its passage. In SZ n° 43, commander Brezé goes from the position of garrison – under the stack of counters – to army – on top of the stack of counters – for a cost of 2 MP. Then, he spends 1 MP to reach SZ n° 42 and stops. These two French armies that meet in the SZ are consolidated under a single stack with the highest-ranking Louis XI as its commander.
The number of SS in this army is 9 units at full strength for 18 SS, plus the unit of cannons that only has one SS (the recto is still on the enemy's colours to signify its capture), for a total of 19 SS. Fatigue and desertion is determined in column 10-19.
The game round takes place during fair weather, so there is no modifier for harsh weather. The result of the 1D6 roll is 5, to which is added a modifier of +1 for the movement carried out, for a total of 6. The army must eliminate 4 SS; the player eliminates 2 units of archers at full strength.
9 – Fatigue and Desertion
Armies and garrisons may be diminished by fatigue and desertion. For each stack – whether or not it carried out a movement on the strategic map during the previous movement sequence – it is necessary to check if SS have been lost. A movement is considered to have been carried out as soon as an MP has been spent in the army or garrison that comprises the stack (by movement or transformation of a garrison into an army).
The number of SS of a stack comprising an army or a garrison is used to determine the column on Table 1: Fatigue and Desertion.
Proceed as follows: roll 1D6, adding any modifiers (all cumulative), and cross the result of the modified die roll with the determined column. The indicated number corresponds to the losses in SS to be eliminated, as the owner chooses. The eliminated units are placed in his camp's pool of eliminated units.
Table 1: Fatigue and Desertion
Size of the garrison or the army in number of SS, calculated at the end of the strategic movement sequence.
| Modified die | [1-4] | [5-9] | [10-19] | [20-29] | [30 and +] |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 and - | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 |
| 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 3 |
| 3 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 3 |
| 4 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 |
| 5 |
Modifiers:
- Garrison: -1
- Movement in at least one SZ requiring 1 PM (plain): +1
- Movement in at least one SZ requiring 2 PM (mountain, forest): +2
- Round in a harsh period (from November to February): +1
Results 1, 2, etc.: number of SS eliminated, to distribute uniformly among the units, beginning with those with the weakest CF.
Note: an army that does not move receives neither bonus nor penalty.
10 – Combats
10.1 Overview
Combat ensues when units from the two camps are found in the same SZ. If both camps have armies, this is a battle. If one of the camps has a garrison, it is a siege. In the latter case, if a commander is present in the garrison, it is possible to combat as an army in a battle (as the inactive player chooses).
For each disputed SZ, place a siege or battle marker, then resolve the combats – battles then sieges – in the desired order. Battles and sieges are resolved on the tactical map.
10.2 Tactical Map
Dedicated to combats and tactical movements, this map is composed of several TZ that represent a typical positioning of combatants on a battlefield in the West in the 15th and beginning of the 16th centuries. The tactical map is divided into two equal parts – one for each camp – of 10 TZ (5 TZ per camp): left wing, right wing, 1st, 2nd and 3rd line, and an LR used by units that withdraw from the battlefield after a tactical movement.
The eligible conditions for combat are:
- hand-to-hand takes place between two TZ connected by a dotted line;
- fire is carried out between two TZ located within fire range.
10.3 Battle Procedure
10.3.1 Deployment
Beginning with the defender, each player deploys on his side of the tactical map.
The players are free to deploy to their 5 TZ, respecting the following constraint: one third of the SS or more must be deployed to the first line. The army commander is placed freely and must be visible: this is the highest-ranking commander, or the one chosen by the player in the case of a tie.
10.3.2 Random Events
Before each battle, determine if a random event occurs. The active player rolls 1D6, the result of which is checked on Table 2: Random Events. The consequence of each random event – applicable for all combat rounds for this battle – is indicated in section 13, Specific rules for the proposed game.
Table 2: Random Events
| 1D6 | Random Event |
|---|---|
| 1 | Arms at their sides or treason* |
| 2-4 | Nothing |
| 5 | Unmanned wing |
| 6 | Rain or snow** |
Legend:
- * If Commander Maine is present at the battle, the event Arms at their sides is replaced by Treason. This treason result is ignored if the Count of Maine is in the same TZ as King Louis XI.
- ** If the game round is during a harsh weather period (November – February), the rain event is replaced by snow.
10.3.3 Choice of Tactical Markers
Each camp has tactical markers that are both general and specific to a camp. The tactical markers are only useable once per battle, during a determined combat round. Only the tactical markers Ditch and Fence may be used during all the combat rounds. As these are prepared elements, if they are used they must be revealed during the first combat round.
- Presentation of markers (see 13, Specific rules for the proposed game)
- Choice of markers
Each player secretly chooses a number of markers less than or equal to the TC of his army commander. He places them face down near the army commander for use during the combat rounds.
10.3.4 Combat Round
The active player must attack during the first combat round. After this first round, the attacker keeps the initiative to pursue or stop the combat.
10.3.4.1 Tactical Choice
During this tactical sequence, the defender announces how many tactical markers – among all those chosen – he will use for this round, then the attacker does the same. Each player may use 0-2 tactical markers per round. The markers chosen for a round are revealed and must be used during this combat round – fire, hand-to-hand, counter-attack, tactical movement – then discarded, with the exception of the Ditch and Fence markers, which are kept for the duration of the combats.
The markers that are chosen but not used are kept for another combat round and are placed face down on the tactical map, near the army commander.
10.3.4.2 Fire
Only the units with a non-zero RF may fire. Beginning with the active player, players fire alternately, one of the attacker's units then one of the defender's. The RF of a unit is determined from its TZ – of its camp, or the opposing camp if it is conquered – that it occupies. A shooter with RF equal to 1 that is located on its 1st line or one of its wings may fire on the 2 wings and 1st line of the opposing camp. In the same way, a unit with RF equal to 2 may also fire on the 2nd enemy line, etc. The fire takes place all-out: the TZ of the unit that fires does not have to be connected to the TZ of the targeted unit; it must simply be within RF. One unit may be the target of numerous shots.
Fire procedure:
- Before firing, if necessary, the attacker and the defender simultaneously reveal their tactical markers chosen for the shoot. One player not playing a marker does not prohibit the other from doing so. A marker is valid for all the fire of this combat round.
- The attacker chooses a target in a TZ located in the RF of the firing unit (see the tactical map). The attacker rolls 1D6. If the result is less than or equal to the CF, the shot is successful: remove 1 SS from the targeted unit, possibly modified by the tactical marker. Otherwise it is a failure.
- Then the defender does the same.
- The players alternate. If one camp still has units to fire while his opponent has no more, he has them fire one after another until they have all fired.
- On a result of 1, a historic commander present in the targeted TZ can be eliminated: roll 1D6 for each commander present in the targeted TZ. For a result of 1, the commander is eliminated and placed in the pool of eliminated units. He can return to the game as a standard commander, unless otherwise specified in the specific rules (see 13.1), during the R&R sequence.
10.3.4.3 Hand-to-hand
Hand-to-hand procedure:
- Only one TZ of the inactive player may be attacked per combat round.
- The active player indicates the attacked enemy TZ, then his TZ that participates in the attack. These TZ must be adjacent (connected by a dotted line).
- The tactical markers chosen for the hand-to-hand are revealed simultaneously by the two players. The tactical markers may be held onto and revealed during a counter-attack.
- Calculate the sum of the CF of all the attacking units (including those that fired) and divide this number by the sum of CF of all the units of the attacked TZ. The result is a ratio Attacker/Defender, which is simplified to a ratio 1/2, 2/3, 1/1, 3/2, 2/1 etc. by rounding in the defender's favour. Ex: 9/10 becomes 2/3 on the Combat table.
- Then the attacking player checks to see if he has a tactical advantage that will give a modifier (this modifier only benefits the attacker when he attacks from a conquered enemy TZ), as follows:
- Attack from the 1st or 2nd line toward the 2nd or 3rd opposing line respectively (i.e. the opposing line is crushed): +1
- Attack from one of the two wings toward any opposing central line (i.e. flank attack), or from a central line toward a wing of the same edge: +2
- Attack from the 2nd or 3rd line toward the 1st or 2nd opposing line respectively (i.e. attack on the rear): +3
- The attacker rolls 1D6, to which he adds the tactical advantage modifier, and crosses the modified result with the column corresponding to the strength ratio established in Table 3: Combat.
Table 3: Combat
Ratio A/D, rounded in the favour of the defender.
| 1D6 | 1/2 and - | 2/3 | 1/1 | 3/2 | 2/1 and + |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 4*R/0 | 2*R/0 | 1*/0 | 1/1 | 1/3R |
| 2 | 4*R/0 | 2*R/0 | 1/0 | 1/1 | 1/3R |
| 3 | 4*R/0 | 2R/0 | R/0 | 1/1 | 1/3R |
| 4 | 3R/1 | 1/1 | 0/R | 0/2R | 0/4*R |
| 5 |
Modifiers:
- Siege of a fortress: for the besieged, shift one column to the left per point of FV not eliminated by a cannon shot.
- Battle: modifier linked to the tactical advantage, to be added to the result of the 1D6 roll for a battle (it only benefits the attacker when he attacks from an opposing, conquered TZ):
- Attack from the 1st or 2nd line toward the 2nd or 3rd line respectively: +1
- Attack from one of the two wings toward any central line: +2
- Attack from the 2nd or 3rd line toward the 1st or 2nd line respectively: +3
Results:
- Losses are expressed in the form A/D.
- The tactical marker Charge doubles the defender's losses.
- The tactical markers Charge and Dismount entail for the attacker the elimination first of all units that made it possible to use these markers.
- 1, 2, etc.: number of SS to remove.
- R (Battle): retreat of one TZ for all the units except the cannons.
- R (Siege): the result is ignored for the besieger and the besieged, except for an exit.
- *: elimination of a historic commander, during a battle or a siege, on the result of a 1D6 roll = 1. An anonymous commander ignores this result.
10.3.4.4 Combat Results
- The result gives the losses in SS for the attacker/defender. These losses are to be allocated as the owner chooses among the units of the TZ, except for specifications regarding tactical markers.
- A result R indicates an obligatory retreat toward an adjacent TZ for a battle, and an exit for a siege. For a siege – without exit – this result is ignored by the besieger and the besieged.
Note: cannons cannot retreat even if they have a non-zero movement capacity. They are either taken by the adversary who advances in the TZ after a hand-to-hand, or eliminated, as the attacker chooses.
- A retreat takes place by placing the units on a line located behind and adjacent to the TZ of origin (the retreat from the 3rd line or from a wing occurs toward the LR). If retreat from a TZ is impossible (presence of enemy units), the troops remain in place and suffer 1 additional loss (one counter is diminished, player's choice).
- Advance after combat: after the evacuation of the TZ by retreat or elimination of enemy units, the victor may advance all or part of his units that participated in this combat in the TZ that is left free, except for the cannons.
- An asterisk * indicates the possible elimination of a historic commander: roll 1D6 for each commander present in the concerned TZ. On a result of 1, the commander is eliminated and placed in the pool of eliminated units. He can return to the game as a standard commander, except where otherwise indicated in the specific rules (see 13.1), during the R&R sequence.
Elimination of a historic commander:
- If the highest-ranking historic commander of an ally is eliminated, this allied power is considered neutralised. Its units and commanders are immediately removed from the game, and the alliance cursor is placed at the centre of the diplomacy table, giving the indicated VP.
- If the army commander whose TC determined the attribution of the number of tactical markers is eliminated, he is immediately replaced during the combat round by the historic or anonymous commander ranked just below him, present on the map. In the case of equivalent ranks, the choice is made by their owner. A new army commander does not choose new markers; he keeps – as his TC allows – those that were selected, minus those that have already been used.
- If a historic or anonymous commander finds himself alone in a TZ after the elimination of his units:
- During a battle, he is placed in the closest TZ in terms of movement cost containing units of his camp, including the LR. If no units of his camp are present in the 6 TZ of the tactical map, he is eliminated.
- During a siege, he is placed in an adjacent SZ controlled by his camp, otherwise he is eliminated.
An eliminated commander is placed in the pool of eliminated units and may return the following round during his camp's R&R sequence, without spending RP, as an anonymous commander. His positioning follows the same rule as the placement of a unit.
If the army finds itself without a commander, it loses the battle and the remaining units retreat according to 10.5.1.
10.3.4.5 Counter-attack
The inactive player may carry out a hand-to-hand on his own initiative (a counter-attack, without fire sequence) under certain conditions, from any TZ, even the one that was just attacked, toward any eligible TZ of the adverse camp, including the TZ from which he was just attacked. The conditions are as follows.
The inactive player must have at least one commander in the chosen TZ to counter-attack. Tactical markers may be revealed during this sequence – by the two camps – before the die roll. If the test fails and the counter-attack does not occur, these markers are considered lost for both camps.
The result of the 1D6 roll must be less than or equal to the TC of this commander. If this is not the case, the counter-attack does not occur. If this is the case, engage in a hand-to-hand according to 10.3.4.3; the inactive player is considered in this case as the Attacker and the active player as the Defender. An advance after combat is possible for the camp that counter-attacks.
Only one counter-attack may be attempted per combat round. Once it has been attempted – successful or not – move on to the following sequences of tactical movements.
10.3.4.6 Tactical Movements
These movements take place in addition to the advance after combat. A tactical marker may be revealed, if necessary (see 13.0, Special Rules). The active player first, then the other player, can move a number of units – at full strength or … diminished – less than or equal to the TC of the army commander, as well as an unlimited number of commanders.
Transcriber's note: the source text breaks off in the middle of this sentence ("at full strength or ….") and resumes with "… diminished" at the top of the next page; the printed wording is kept as it appears.
Movement takes place by spending the necessary MP – indicated on the dotted lines connecting the TZ – to penetrate a TZ of its camp, or the opposing camp if it contains no enemy units.
It is prohibited to penetrate a TZ that contains units of the adverse camp unless they are cannons (which are then captured and turned over to the second side, or eliminated, player's choice).
A unit that spends MP to reach the line of retreat is placed in an adjacent SZ at the end of the battle, according to 10.5.1.
10.3.4.7 End of the Combat Round
At the end of the combat round, the active player has the choice of withdrawing or pursuing the combat.
- If the player decides to proceed with the combat, begin another full combat round starting with the Tactical Choices (10.3.4.1).
- If the player decides to withdraw, the inactive player may immediately – without a test – carry out a counter-attack. Then the battle is over, regardless of the result of the combat.
10.3.5 End of the Battle
The battle is over when:
- all the units of a camp are eliminated;
- all the units of a camp have retreated away from the battlefield via the LR;
- the units of a camp have no commander (historic or anonymous);
- or the active player decides to end the battle.
Proceed with the verifications of the battle consequences (see 10.5).
10.4 Siege Procedure
10.4.1 Deployment
All the units of the besieged and the besieger are deployed on their respective sides on the tactical map, in the second line TZ for the besieged and the first line TZ for the besieger. The besieged's first line TZ is left free to resolve a potential exit. No random event is determined and no marker is used for the resolution of a siege.
10.4.3 Artillery Fire
Transcriber's note: the source numbers both this sub-section and the assault below as 10.4.3; the printed numbers are kept.
The active player carries out his artillery fire. He rolls 1D6 per artillery unit: the roll is successful if the result is less than or equal to the artillery's CF. Each success reduces by 1 point the FV for the resolution of the assault for this round only. (note 2) An FV can never be negative.
Note 2: in fact, the FV of a fortress is returned to its maximum level at the end of each siege round. We consider that the breach is repaired during the lapse of time separating two siege rounds.
Then the following sequences in this order:
10.4.3 Assault
The active player adds up the CF of all his units (note 3, including the artillery) and divides them by the sum of the CF of all the besieged units (including the artillery). The result is a ratio of Attacker (besieger) / Defender (besieged), which is simplified to the form 1/2, 2/3, 1/1, 3/2, 2/1, rounding in favour of the defender. This ratio indicates the column from which the column shift connected to the FV – modified or not – takes place.
- On the table of combat resolutions, shift to the left the number of columns equal to the FV, modified after successful artillery shots where necessary;
- No tactical marker is used;
- The active player rolls a die and applies the results;
- The results are applied according to 10.3.4.4.
Any result R for the besieged or the besieger is ignored, except for an exit.
Note 3: the dismounted cavalry thus constitutes a backup infantry.
10.4.4 Exit
The inactive player has the possibility of making one attempt to exit per combat round. Once the attempt has been made – successfully or not – move on to the following sequence. This exit takes place under the following circumstances:
A commander must be present among the besieged.
The result of the 1D6 roll must be less than or equal to the TC of this commander. If this is not the case, the exit does not take place. If the result does allow for this, carry out a hand-to-hand according to 10.3.4.3 with the following specificities:
- A number of units of the besieged player's choice (except artillery) and the commander whose TC was used to determine the exit must be placed in a 1st line TZ on the tactical map;
- No tactical marker is used;
- The inactive player is considered in the case as the Attacker and the active player as the Defender.
An advance after combat is not possible for either of the camps. If there are only one or more artillery units of the besieger remaining in the TZ (he who defends during the exit) and there are still units of the besieged remaining (he who attacks during the exit), the latter has the possibility either to eliminate them or to return them to the fortress; in this case, turn the counters over so they show the side of their new owner.
A result R for the besieger eliminates an artillery counter. A result R for the besieged only puts an end to the exit.
Example of Combat
- Deployment. The two camps have an army in the same SZ. The French army is composed of 7 units of 2 SS and one unit with 1 SS, for a total of 15 SS. The Breton army is composed of 5 units with 2 SS, totalling 10 SS. This is therefore a battle with 10 SS or more on each side; the victor will benefit from 2 SS. It is the French player's phase. The French is the attacker and positions himself second; the Leaguer is the defender and positions himself first. A third or more of the SS must be placed in the first line: the Breton places all his archers in the first line, the gendarmes on the right wing and the coutiliers on the left wing. The French places all his archers, the artillery and Louis XI in the first line, and the gendarmes, coutiliers and Brezé on the right wing.
- Determination of the random events for the battle. The result of the 1D6 roll is 5, or Unmanned Wing. Roll 1D6 again to determine the wing to unman; the result of the roll is even, so the unit of the Breton left wing is placed in a central line. The latter chooses the first line.
- Tactical markers. The tactical capacity of the highest-ranked commander of a camp's army determines the number of tactical markers available for his camp: four markers for Louis XI and three markers for the Duc of Bretagne. These markers are chosen secretly by each player. The French takes Battery, Rain of Arrows, Fence and Charge. The Breton opts for Fence, Ditch and Dismount.
- 1st round of combat.
- Tactical choice. The Breton defender announces that he is using 2 tactical markers; the French attacker does the same.
- Resolution of fire. The two players simultaneously reveal their markers used for fire. The Breton player reveals Fence and Ditch (these are prepared elements that must be revealed during the first round of combat) to protect the first central line; the French player reveals Fence to protect the first central line and Rain of Arrows. The shots are presented as follows: unit A targets B, roll 1D6 = X, result; no effect, 1 SS the counter is turned over, 2 SS the counter is eliminated.
- First French shot: F1 targets B1, roll 1D6 = 4, result; no effect.
- First Breton shot: B2 targets F1, roll 1D6 = 2, result; 1 SS the counter F1 is turned over.
10.4.5 Pursue or Let Up?
If the result of the assault or the exit leads to neither the elimination of the besieged nor that of the besieger, the active player has the choice between pursuing a full round of siege – limited to five full rounds – or stopping the siege and withdrawing his army to an SZ according to 10.5.1. After the fifth round, the besieger is required to withdraw to an SZ according to 10.5.1.
10.5 Consequences of the Battle or Siege
10.5.1 Retreat of the Vanquished
The victor is he who remains in the SZ. Once the battle is over, the army that voluntarily stopped the combat withdraws to an adjacent SZ free of enemy units. If the army should retreat to enemy territory (national territory, or with a control marker for this nation), the army that withdraws reduces by 1 SS all the surviving units; those that are already reduced are eliminated. It is possible that the army that withdraws takes control of an SZ.
The besieger remains in the SZ if he has eliminated all the besieged, or leaves the SZ if he voluntarily stops the siege or after the fifth round of siege, and must retreat toward an adjacent SZ.
An army that retreats to an SZ already containing an army or a garrison of its camp is immediately added to it and remains in this form, army or garrison. If no unit is present, the player can choose to keep the army in this form or convert it to a garrison.
An army that cannot retreat is eliminated.
10.5.2 Control of the SZ
If the active player is victorious, he takes control of the SZ, in the form of an army or a garrison, as he chooses.
10.5.3 Attribution of VP
In the case of a battle, if both combatting forces each had a strength of at least 10 SS at the beginning of the combat, the victor immediately obtains 2 VP.
In the case of a siege, if the non-modified FV of the SZ was 2 or 3, the victor immediately obtains respectively 1 VP and 2 VP.
In any case, if the active player is the victor and the captured SZ is a strategic SZ, he gains the VP associated with control of this province.
10.5.4 Adjustment of Cursors
Adjust the cursors of the allied powers, where necessary, for an eligible battle or siege (see 11. Diplomacy).
Note: the besieger that stops the siege voluntarily, or after a retreat after the 5th round of siege, has no consequence on diplomacy.
10.5.5 Moving on to the Next Battle
The active player moves on to the following battle. When all the battles have been resolved, move on to resolving the sieges. When they have all been resolved, the active player's phase is over and players move on to the following phase.
11 – Diplomacy
The ally of a camp is either a major power or a minor power. The neutralisation awards a variable number of VP (see 13. Specific rules for the game). Each ally has an alliance cursor that moves on Table 4 of Alliances, from its position of indefectible allied power toward neutrality, passing by an intermediary zone of doubt. In this final situation, the random events Arms at their sides and Treason may apply before a combat. The cursor of an ally is moved after the combat, even if none of its units participates in the combat (note 4).
Note 4: the defeat of the principal power to which a minor power is allied is consequential enough – loss of prestige and credit – to justify disengagement from an alliance.
Each battle or siege won by a camp – eligible for the attribution of VP – moves each alliance cursor of the allies of the adverse camp one square toward the zone of neutrality, that is to say toward the middle of the table. The cursors of the allies that are not yet in play are not concerned. When an allied power of a camp at the beginning of the game becomes neutral, the opposing camp obtains the number of VP indicated on the table of alliances. The units of the allied power that became neutral are definitively removed from the game during the diplomacy sequence of the game round during which the cursor was moved toward the zone of neutrality, except for specific rules (see 13.0 Specific rules for the game).
If the units – garrison or army – of an allied power that has become neutral are removed from a controlled objective SZ, the control marker for this SZ does not change and remains in place as long as an opposing army has not taken control of it.
The control by a camp of all the SZ that make up the territory of an adverse allied power has no influence on diplomacy and modifies neither the position of the cursor nor the presence of its units on the map (note 5).
Note 5: at the beginning of the Renaissance, Europe comprises a myriad of fiefs of all sizes – kingdom, principality, duchy, county, seigneury, etc. – which are not necessarily connected geographically. A power may have part of its territory occupied but possess other exterior resources.
Table 4: Table of Alliances
Alliance with Charles of France (left) and Alliance with Louis XI (right). The cursor of each ally starts at the position printed in brackets, or enters the table in the round printed in brackets.
| Certain (left) | Doubt (left) | Neutral | Doubt (right) | Certain (right) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bourbon (beginning); Armagnac (round 4); Lorraine (round 5) | 2 VP (note 1) (note 2) | Savoy (round 2) | ||
| Brittany (beginning); Burgundy (round 3) | 4 VP (note 1) (note 2) | Foix-Béarn (beginning); Milan (round 5) |
Note 1: VP attributed for the neutralisation of the adverse ally. Note 2: all the units and commanders are eliminated from the game.
12 – Victory
VP are indicated on the VP accounting scale marked from 0 to 9 by positioning the VP cursor on the appropriate number. From 0 to 9 VP, use the counter ×1 of the VP cursor; for 10 VP or more, use the counter ×10 and position it on the corresponding number times ten.
- The VP won after a battle, a siege or the neutralisation of an allied power are recorded during the combat sequence that allowed them to be obtained.
- The VP obtained by the control of objective SZ are only counted up on the last round of the game.
The attribution of victory points occurs for each of the following actions:
- Battle won, engaging at least 10 SS in each camp: +2 VP to the victor.
- Siege won by the besieger or the besieged, in the case that the besieger is eliminated or retreats to an SZ whose FV = 2: +1 VP; if the FV = 3: +2 VP. No VP are attributed for FV = 1.
- Objective SZ – indicated by a symbol on the map: number of VP indicated for its control.
- Power of the opposing camp neutralised: +2 VP for the minor allies of the adverse camp that are neutralised, and +4 VP for the neutralised major allies of the adverse camp.
13 – Specific Rules for the Proposed Game
These rules complete or replace certain points of the standard rules described thus far.
13.1.1 Reinforcements and Replacements
There is no R&R sequence during the first round of the game.
13.1.2 Strategic Movement
Inviolability of Brittany: no French or allied army can penetrate Brittany (SZ N° 14 and 23) before round 3.
a – Louis XI prefers to punish the weakest Leaguer, the Duc de Bourbon, first, and is satisfied with keeping a close eye on Brittany to avoid their supply to the Burgundians.
Parisienne militia: this unit cannot leave SZ N° 1. If it must retreat with an army, it is eliminated. It can only be placed in R&R in this SZ N° 1.
Commanders and subordination: all the commanders of the same camp, regardless of their ownership / nationality, can command all the allied units of this camp.
13.1.3 Random Events
Arms at their sides and treason: these events only apply to the active player. Rain / Snow: apply to both camps.
The details of each event and their consequences are described below:
- Arms at their sides (note b) or Treason: any unit present of an allied power of the active camp whose marker is in the zone of doubt on Table 4 Alliances does not combat (note c). These units are immediately placed on the LR. No redeployment may be carried out. If this event brings about the withdrawal of the entire army of a camp present on the tactical map, it is a victory for the opposing camp, eligible for obtaining VP if the conditions are met. If the French commander Maine is present at the battle, the event Arms at their sides is replaced by Treason. This result only concerns the French camp and is ignored if the Duc de Maine is located in the same TZ as King Louis XI.
- Unmanned wing: the defender – thus the inactive player – is surprised by the attack; one of its wings contains no units. For an even die roll result, move the units present in the left wing to a central line, as the player of the concerned camp chooses. On an odd result of 1D6 roll, move the units present in the right wing to the central line, as the concerned camp's player chooses. If there are no units present in the wing designated by the result of 1D6, ignore this event; this event is not transferable from one wing to another.
- Nothing: no random event.
- Rain: no shot by firearms – the cannons – is possible. These units can only combat in mêlée. The RF of the archers is diminished from 3 to 2. The RF of the crossbowmen does not change.
- Snow: the maximum RF – for the cannons – is limited to 1 TZ. The RF of the crossbowmen – mounted or not – remains at 1.
Note b: only concerns the allied troops present for the battle. Once the battle is over, the power for which the random event was drawn remains allied with the camp with which it began the battle. The random event is considered a short-lived episode that is quickly resolved diplomatically. It could be that the random event occurs while the designated allied power is the only one represented on the tactical map.
Note c: choice of the allied power. If several allied powers are eligible for this event, only the ally whose units total the lesser number of SS is concerned. In the case of a tie, the result of the higher 1D6 roll determines the implicated power.
13.1.4 Tactical Markers
Applicable for fire:
- Battery: useable for each cannon counter of one's camp. The losses inflicted on the opposing camp for each shot are doubled (note d).
- Harassment: useable for each shot by the crossbowmen or mounted crossbowmen of one's camp. The losses inflicted on the opposing camp for each shot are doubled (note d).
- Fence: useable only if an infantry unit is present during the deployment. This marker, positioned in a TZ, cancels out the effect of a tactical marker Rain of Arrows or Harassment for each shot, except for a shot in the rear or on the flanks. The effect of this marker is valid for all the rounds of the battle for this TZ (note e).
- Rain of Arrows: useable for each shot involving archers from his camp. The losses inflicted on the opposing camp for each shot by archers are doubled (note d), even if the random event Rain is drawn.
Applicable for hand-to-hand:
- Cavalry charge (note f): useable for a hand-to-hand involving at least one unit of men-at-arms (GD, MC). The losses of the defender are doubled. If the attacker suffers losses, they must first be absorbed by the units that allow for this marker to be played.
- Dismount (note g): useable for a hand-to-hand involving at least one unit of men-at-arms (GD, MC) of one's camp. The CF of each GD and MC unit present in the TZ that benefits from this marker is augmented by a modifier of +1. If the attacker suffers losses, they must be absorbed first by these units.
- Ditch: useable only if an infantry unit is present during the deployment. This marker, positioned in a TZ, cancels out the effect of a tactical marker Charge, except for an attack at the rear or on the flanks (see the tactical advantage modifiers). The effect of this marker is valid for all the rounds of the battle for this TZ.
- Spike: useable for a hand-to-hand involving at least one unit of pikemen; cancels out the effect of a Charge tactical marker.
Applicable for fire or hand-to-hand:
- Combination of the two tactical markers Ditch and Fence (in addition to the individual effects): only for the units located in the TZ in which these markers are placed. This allows for the suppression of a result R (retreat) and to diminish the losses by 1 SS. The effect of these combined markers is valid for all the rounds of the battle for this TZ.
Note d: this result only applies to the targeted unit. If it suffers a loss of 1 SS × 2 and only has 2 SS, it is eliminated. If it suffers a loss of 1 SS × 2 and does not have more than 1 SS, it is eliminated and the remaining loss is not attributed to another unit but is ignored.
Note e: the loss of 1 SS is applied without being doubled.
Note f: for the game on the War of the Public Weal: this marker is only available to the French camp, French & Milanese. In reality, the gendarmes and coutiliers of the other powers were not sufficiently trained in spear use.
Note g: for the game on the War of the Public Weal: the Burgundians use this method borrowed from the English who used it during the Hundred Years' War. By extension, their allies use it.
13.2 Levels of Victory
The victor is the player that obtains a level of victory greater than that of his opponent. There are three victory levels:
- Crushing victory for a number of VP greater than or equal to 20. If this is a League victory, each ally negotiates "for his own good" (note h) with Louis XI and wins his case. If it is a victory for France, certain princes are dispossessed of their holdings and return to the ranks (or potentially have their bodies altered…).
- Decisive victory for a number of VP between 15 and 19. Peace returns to the kingdom. If it is a victory for the League, a few provinces or towns are yielded by Louis XI… all the better to take them back later on. If this is a victory for France, the seigneurs are dispossessed of their goods.
- Marginal victory for a number of VP between 10 and 14. A short-term truce is declared, satisfying neither party; a new confrontation takes shape.
If the two players are eligible for the same level of victory, even with a slightly different number of VP, the match is a draw.
A player always has the option of stopping the game if he considers he no longer has any chance of winning it.
Immediate victory: if commander Louis XI dies, the League player immediately wins the game. The death of his brother, the Duc de Berry, does not end the game.
Note h: phrase excerpted from the Mémoires of Philippe de Commynes.
14 – Scenario
14.1 Identification of Shields
France and her allies
- Dauphiné (belongs to the Kingdom of France, of which Louis XI is the Dauphin). This "ally" has no diplomacy marker.
League of the Public Weal
- England (only the archers are in the service of Burgundy; England was in a state of peace with France during this period). This "ally" has no diplomacy marker.
- Berry (symbol for the League of the Public Weal).
14.2 Initiative and Placement
Initiative: the first player is the one playing the camp of the Kingdom of France.
Placement: the units are grouped into garrisons or armies, as the player chooses.
14.2.1 Placement of the French
- SZ N° 13: 1 × GD, 1 × MC, 1 × AR, 1 × CA, 2 × MI
- SZ N° 12: 1 × AR
- SZ N° 38: Commander Louis XI, commander Brezé, commander Maine, 2 × GD, 2 × MC, 7 × AR, 1 × CA
- SZ N° 38: Comté de Foix-Béarn: commander Foix-Béarn, 1 × MC
Transcriber's note: SZ N° 38 is listed for both French placements as printed.
14.2.2 Placement of the League
- SZ N° 45: Duché of BRITTANY; Commander Bretagne, commander Berry, 1 × GD, 1 × MC, 5 × AR, 1 × CA
- SZ N° 34: Duché de BOURBON; Commander Bourbon, 1 × MC, 1 × AR
14.3 Duration, Alliance, Control, VP
- Time counter: on the time counter / round counter, on March 1465.
- Duration: 9 rounds. Beginning: March 1465. End: November 1465.
- Table of Alliances: place the Bretagne (Brittany), Bourbon, and Foix-Béarn cursors in the designated boxes on the Table of Alliances.
- SZ control markers: a Kingdom of France control marker is placed in each of the SZ N° 6, N° 12, N° 13, N° 21, N° 31. A control marker for the League is placed in each of the SZ N° 1, N° 28, N° 29, N° 34.
- VP cursor: recto VP multiple of one and verso VP multiples of 10, on the 0 square of the VP tallying scale.
14.4 Reinforcements and Replacements
- Round 2 (April):
- Duché of SAVOY: commander Seysell, 1 × CB in SZ N° 30. Place the Savoy cursor in the square on the Table of Alliances.
- DAUPHINÉ: commander Malortie, 1 × AR in SZ N° 31.
- Round 3 (May):
- Duché of BURGUNDY: commanders Charolais and Saint-Pol, 2 × GD, 2 × MC, 4 × AR, 1 × PI, 1 × CB, 2 × CA, 1 × AR in SZ N° 1. 1 × AR in SZ N° 18. 1 × AR in SZ N° 19. Place the Burgundy cursor in the square on the Table of Alliances.
- Round 4 (June):
- Duché of ARMAGNAC: Commander Armagnac, 1 × MC, 3 × AR in SZ [blank in the source]. Place the Armagnac cursor in the square on the Table of Alliances.
- Round 5 (July):
- Duché of MILAN: commander Sforza and 1 × CB, 1 × Gendarme in SZ N° 31. Place the Milan cursor in the square on the Table of Alliances.
- Duché of LORRAINE: commander Lorraine and 1 × PI, 1 × MCB in SZ N° 5. Place the Lorraine cursor in the square on the Table of Alliances.