Hannibal & Hamilcar FAQ
411 questions players ask · Updated Nov 17, 2026 · Full rulebook
General and Components
- Who holds Naval Supremacy in Hamilcar, and is it a Politically Significant space?
- How many rounds can a naval battle last in Hamilcar?
- Do I need the upgrade pack or new rulebooks to play Hannibal and Hamilcar?
- Do the revised Hannibal and Hamilcar card wordings change how the game plays?
- Is Claudius Caudex a 3/3 or a 3/2 General?
- Can Claudius Pulcher be used in Hannibal?
- Where on the Miat can a third PC be placed?
- Which General cards changed between the Anniversary and Golden Geek editions?
- Which Gisgo is the upgrade: the one that intercepts on a 1-2, or the one that receives two Tactic Cards in a Naval Battle?
- Are Hamilcar and Hamilcar Barca the same general?
- Does the circled number on a General card show strategy or battle rating?
- Is Lipara part of Sicily for province purposes?
- Is 'Sicily' on a card the province or the wider region?
- Does a walled city's capacity limit CUs and supply trains separately?
- Can Hasdrubal's army combine with Gisgo's army before Carthage loses a battle?
Setup and Sequence of Play
- How many turns does the Campaign: Iberia scenario last, and where does it end?
- Which generals does Carthage start with in the first Hannibal scenario, and where do they begin?
- Which Carthaginian generals are used in the Hannibal scenarios, and are the elephant-icon generals used without the Additional Generals option?
- Is Flaccus used in Hannibal or Hamilcar?
- Is P. Cornelius Scipio used in Hamilcar?
- Can a card's Operation Points be spent entirely on placing PCs in the Miat, and can several PCs be placed that way?
- Can a player activate more than one general with a single strategy card?
- What happens if the Iberia scenario runs out of strategy cards with only the base deck?
- Which strategy cards does the Iberia campaign scenario use?
- Who chooses which side goes first each turn?
- Can a general activated more than once in a round still move again in the same turn?
- Does the Price of Failure and Sun of Macedon expansion cards go into the deck from the start?
- How do I tell which version of a leader or strategy card belongs to Hannibal and which to Hamilcar?
- Why are there two Syracuse city tiles?
- Which side of the board is used for the Hannibal and Hamilcar games?
- How do you match Generals with the same name to their setup tokens?
- Is Bomilcar used in scenarios 6 to 9 when he is absent from the Carthaginian setup?
Reinforcements
- Do Xanthippus and Hamilcar Barca leave the board at the end of each turn?
- When can Xanthippus or Hamilcar Barca be hired in Hamilcar?
- Is Flaccus removed from play when new Consuls are elected in Hamilcar?
- Does Duilius need Roman War Chest OPs to become Proconsul?
- Are generals drawn from the Carthaginian pool in Hamilcar chosen or drawn randomly?
- Does Carthage get new generals during the game?
- Can Philippos be placed in a port that holds an enemy army, and does a battle start?
- How does Philippos enter the game?
- Are a Roman general or consul removed from play permanently, or can they return?
- Can the same Consul be elected again in the following turn?
- Can Carthaginian reinforcement generals that are not on the turn track be drawn before their turn?
- How many generals does Carthage receive each turn in the Hamilcar game?
- Are Strategy cards that bring reinforcements onto the map treated as Reinforcement Events even without the helmet icon?
- Does Manpower Shortage block the Dictator event (card 80) from being played?
- Can Rome receive reinforcements while Roma is under siege?
- Can Allied Auxiliaries place CUs in a besieged walled city, or with a besieged general?
- Where can newly elected Consuls be placed, given that the Golden Geek and 20th Anniversary rulebooks differ?
- Can a newly elected consul be placed in Rome when no Roman CUs are there?
- How many Roman CUs must stand in a stack for consular reinforcements, and must each consul have its own stack?
- When does a displaced general return to play?
- Can Carthaginian generals eliminated in battle return to the game later?
- Can a general recruit a CU in a province it does not control at reinforcement?
- Where can Carthage place its reinforcement CUs when Carthago Nova is Roman-controlled?
- Does Carthage keep five generals if Hannibal dies?
- Where can reinforcements be placed in the Iberia and Italia scenarios?
- Can reinforcements be placed in a besieged Walled City, or in one an enemy general occupies?
- Can Carthage place a displaced General in a space where another Carthaginian General already stands?
- Can a Roman proconsul be moved to another 5-CU stack before consuls are placed?
- Can reinforcements be placed in a walled city where an enemy general sits but no siege points have been scored?
Strategy Cards
- Which provinces does the Hostile Tribes card cover, and does a province stay hostile after it is conquered?
- What does it mean to play Hostile Tribes as a Counter Event?
- Is a space with a neutral Tribe hostile for the Hostile Tribes card?
- Does adding optional Strategy Cards to the deck reshuffle it and end Cato's or Hanno's effect?
- What does the Rules Used note '8 Strategy Cards' in Tutorial 1 mean?
- Does a reserve battle card played as a probe keep the probe's conditions?
- When is a Strategy Card considered finished for Scipio's Roman Diplomat flip?
- What does the infantry or mobilization icon in the upper corner of a Strategy Card do?
- Can one card's Operation Points both move a General and convert an enemy PC under him?
- What does the R symbol at the bottom of some strategy cards mean?
- What are the Major Campaign and Minor Campaign cards, and do they let a side go first?
- Why would you discard a card instead of playing it in the strategy phase?
- Can a CU already moved in a Major Campaign be moved again by another general?
- Can a Counter Event card be played against another Counter Event card or cancel a campaign?
- Can a truce be broken by playing an event that removes your own siege points?
- Can a 3-OP Strategy Card used to raise troops also provide its OP or trigger its event?
- Does a Counter Event card that shows the truce symbol end a truce?
- Are Event cards discarded after use?
- Can you keep unused Strategy Cards for a later turn?
- Can the three OPs of a card used for Training or Shipbuilding be split among actions?
Strategy Card Notes
- Which General becomes Dictator when the Hannibal Dictator card (#80) is played?
- What happens to the Archimede token and the Citadel when Syracusae is conquered?
- If Rome conquers Syracusae, is Carthage's naval bonus token removed?
- Who decides whether Punic Faith cancels a Roman event?
- Does the Traitor in the City event skip the second die roll?
- How are Storms at Sea losses assigned among warships, CUs and Supply Trains?
- Does the Good Omen card's plus or minus 2 apply to any die roll?
- When are Cruel Sea and Storm at Sea applied during a multi-leg naval move?
- What marker does the Citadel card (#91) use?
- Can the Citadel card (91) be placed in a city that already has siege points?
- Does storm attrition from Storms at Sea (#129) hit only CUs, or other units too?
- Can the Dictator card (#136) be used for its OPs, shipbuilding or adding a CU?
- Does Bad Omens apply attrition to warships in a naval battle?
- How are Mercenary PCs removed from the Miat card (card 100), and does removing them replace a card play?
- Does Good Omen (card 84) modify siege die rolls?
- Does the Hostile Tribe event work on a Carthaginian friendly tribe?
- How many PCs does the Naval Raid card (108) remove, and can the removals be split?
- Can Gades switch to Roman control under card 71?
- What happens to a Carthaginian army inside Syracusae when Hiero allies with Rome?
- Can any general conduct the move in the Hidden Cove strategy card?
- How do campaign cards let generals move by sea, and how many CUs can they carry?
- Can two generals on a campaign card move together to get around the 10-CU stack limit?
- Does Carthage still place a PC on Hidden Cove when the naval move is cancelled by Bad Weather?
- Is the Siege Train an event card?
- Do Revolt events flip or remove walled city PCs?
- Does Maharbal's Cavalry cancel the automatic initiative of Double Envelopment?
- Does Mare Nostrum need an empty enemy port, or just an enemy-controlled one?
- If Punic Faith cancels Forced March, can the general still move?
- Do Siege Train units count as a CU for stacking capacity, and when is the Carthaginian Siege Train destroyed?
- How can the Carthaginian Siege Train be removed from the map once placed?
- If Rome retakes Syracuse after Carthage allied with it, does Carthage keep the Syracuse naval bonus?
- Under the Syracuse Allies card, are CUs and generals in Syracuse eliminated, or only if the city is under siege?
- During a Truce, can a player move through an enemy PC or CU space?
- Can Bad Weather be played after a general reaches a third space, and does it change anything over an earlier play?
- Can Revolt (card 87) be played near a Carthaginian-friendly tribe or walled city inside a Roman province?
- If Carthage is allied with Syracuse and Rome retakes the city, is the alliance kept, and does the naval bonus still apply?
- Must an army already be in Tarentum for the Traitor in Tarentum card to apply?
Stacking and Subordination
- Who commands when two generals of equal rank share a space?
- Which general commands a stack of two equal-rank generals when it is attacked?
- How is leader rank decided between generals?
- When two armies share a space during a reaction, do they merge into one stack right away?
- Is there a limit on how many CUs can stack in one space?
- What happens to subordinate generals when their commander's army is wiped out?
- Can a proconsul take CUs from a consular army and leave the consuls with five?
- When an evading army holds two consuls, must the Roman player change command to a particular consul?
- Can a lesser-ranked general move through a space holding a higher-ranked general?
- Can subordinate generals be left behind, activated separately, and take CUs with them?
Movement
- Is a General displaced when all his CUs are lost to attrition, storms or the Land Battle Casualties roll?
- Is a General displaced when all his CUs are lost to the Retreat Die roll?
- Can an army leave a walled city when enemy CUs are outside it?
- Which mountain passes are the Alps passes, and how are they marked on the map?
- Which die modifier applies when an army crosses a mountain pass?
- Can two generals combine under one campaign card and then attack together?
- Can a general pick up CUs after already moving, and how far can they go?
- Can a moving general pick up only some CUs from a space shared with a higher-ranked friendly general?
- Can a general's subordinate units keep moving under a second general in one campaign card, and does the four-space limit cover the whole card?
- After a battle, can a second general move into the space and pick up the army's CUs under a campaign event?
- Can a subordinate general siege the same space after his army fought a battle under the same campaign event?
- Does the Strait of Messana block land movement when Carthage controls only one of the two spaces?
- Can a general or army move inside or outside a friendly walled city without spending movement, and who decides its position?
- How many CUs can fit inside a Walled City?
- Can CUs inside a Walled City move out during your own turn?
- Can a force enter an enemy-held walled city without besieging it?
- Can an army pass through a space containing an enemy walled city?
- Can an army move through a tribe space without completing subjugation?
- Can a 3-CU consular army overrun a single enemy CU?
- Can an army keep moving after it wins a battle, including one that an interception started?
- Can a lone general with no CUs try to avoid battle before an enemy army displaces him?
- What happens to Scipio Africanus or Hannibal if displaced in the classic scenario?
- Can I split a stack and send two generals in different directions with one card?
- Do elephants count toward the 10-CU movement limit?
Naval Movement
- Which Strategy cards allow Naval Movement, and how many CUs can an army carry by sea?
- How many legs of Naval Movement can a General make in one activation in Hamilcar?
- What is the maximum size of a Roman fleet in Hamilcar, and what limits its growth?
- In Hannibal, can a Major or Minor Campaign card, or a two-ship card, allow two naval movements?
- How many generals can make a naval move when activated by one campaign card?
- How many PCs does the loser remove after a naval battle?
- After a naval interception battle, can the intercepting fleet keep moving, and who is active if it lands in an enemy space?
- Does the Mare Tyrrhenum interception ban stop a fleet from being intercepted along its whole path?
- Can a fleet be intercepted in the port where it embarks?
- Can a naval tactic card bring in ships that are not part of the battle?
- Can Carthage intercept a fleet from Carthage when the MIAT is not warlike?
- If the non-active player skips a possible naval interception, does the mover take Naval Supremacy?
- When is a general displaced in a naval move or naval battle?
- How is an intercepting fleet built and tracked in Hamilcar?
- Can a naval move go directly into a Walled City while some CUs stay outside?
- Can a naval move into a Walled City space be intercepted?
- Does a naval battle round continue for a player who has no ready warships?
- After winning a naval interception, can the moving fleet keep moving or must it stop?
- Can an army mix land and naval movement in Hamilcar, and how many points can it spend on naval?
- Is naval interception the only way to start a naval battle?
- Can a naval move be intercepted by land forces, or a land move by naval interception?
- Can the initiative player's tactic card end a naval battle early?
- Does a naval army overrun a lone enemy CU after sailing in?
- Can a general in a besieged city intercept once the siege is lifted?
- Are there modifiers on naval interception rolls in Hamilcar?
- Can an intercepting fleet pick up a higher-ranked general along its route?
- When a fleet loses a naval battle, where do its units go back to?
- Can Skilled Crews return a warship that Shoals has spent?
- Must a sea lane connect the interception location with the intercepting general's station?
- Which battle rating does Kyklo use in a naval battle when the commanding general is not an admiral?
- Does the Evasion card cancel a naval interception only if you fail the die roll first?
- Does a card that cancels a naval interception stop the moving unit from continuing?
- Can an intercepted naval move back up one space?
- How are port values and modifiers applied in the naval movement table?
- After a naval move, how many movement points remain for the general?
- Can an army move one land space as part of a naval move that costs three movement points?
- Can a fleet pick up troops at a port mid-naval move and keep sailing?
- Does naval interception into a friendly space holding your PC need an interception roll?
- Can a naval move enter a friendly unbesieged city while enemy CUs are camped outside?
- Can warships be eliminated, not just flipped to their spent side?
- When do warships become spent?
- Are thunder symbols used only with the Cruel Sea card?
- Do storm symbols on sea lanes matter only when the Cruel Sea card is played?
- Does the naval table's blue dot apply to a fleet carrying more than one CU?
- Does a naval move require a die roll for Rome, and can a fleet siege a walled city immediately on arrival?
- Can a fleet sail into an unbesieged enemy walled city outside the walls and start a siege?
- How are ships allocated when a fleet attempts several naval interceptions?
- Can a fleet fight a naval battle or intercept without a General in Hamilcar?
- Does Pulcher's special ability still allow four spaces of naval movement under the seamanship rules?
- When several generals in a port could make a naval interception, can the player choose which one does?
- After an inconclusive naval battle, where does the passive player end up?
Land Interception
- Can a subordinate consul intercept with fewer than five CUs, leaving the other consul below five?
- If a fleet crosses several sea lanes, can each leg be intercepted by land forces?
- When an interception makes the other army avoid battle, does the intercepting army still complete its move?
- Does an army that already occupies a space give the intercepting army a bonus battle card?
- Can an army that successfully avoided battle join an interception declared from its original space in the same card play?
- Does a failed interception cost anything, and can the defender still avoid battle against that army?
- Do an intercepting army and the friendly CUs already in the intercepted space fight together?
- Does an overrun happen before or after an interception in the same space?
- Can a second general intercept the intercepting army to join a battle caused by an interception?
- Can an intercepting general bring only part of his army to an interception?
- When a subordinate general makes a land interception, whose Battle Rating is used?
- Can an army inside a walled city intercept an adjacent army?
- Can an army intercept a sortie made from inside a walled city?
- Can an army intercept into a space that holds non-moving enemy CUs?
- Can two armies both try to intercept into the same space?
- Can an army intercept a retreating General and his army?
- When an intercept and an avoid-battle reaction are both possible, which is resolved first?
Avoiding Land Battles and Pursuit
- Does moving into a walled city in the same space cost extra movement points?
- If an army avoids battle but leaves one CU with its General behind, must the attacker fight?
- Can a defending army move into its walled city when an enemy army enters the space?
- Can a force of CUs with no General avoid battle, intercept, or move into a walled city, or can it only retreat?
- Can an army split its CUs between a walled city and the open space, then avoid battle with the part outside?
- Can an army avoid a land battle by making a naval move?
- If an army avoids battle and a friendly general intercepts the attacker, and both succeed, what happens?
- If an army avoiding battle must leave behind CUs above the 10-CU limit, must the attacker fight them?
- If Scipio Africanus is displaced, is he removed from the game?
- Can an army drop CUs off while avoiding a land battle?
- Can a besieging army avoid a land battle, and can it return by naval movement afterward?
- Does an enemy army's move stop when it enters a space holding a lone enemy General with no CUs?
Land Battles
- Can Hamilcar use battle cards instead of dice for land battles?
- In Hamilcar 1.0, do Romans get extra battle cards in Latium or is there a cap on allied battle cards?
- When two consular armies attack the same enemy space, do all their CUs fight in one battle?
- What die level does each army start with in a Hamilcar land battle?
- Which general's Battle Rating is rolled when changing initiative, intercepting, or retreating?
- Does Latium count toward Rome's Italian ally battle cards?
- Which general fights the land battle after an admiral-led naval move lands?
- Can two generals activated by one campaign card fight a battle together and add their battle cards?
- If the winning army is reduced to no CUs by casualties, is it still the winner?
- Is there an official battle-card-less land combat system?
- How many battle cards does each side receive for allies in a land battle, and does the battle's location matter?
- When a battle is fought, can the defender refuse to match the attacker's battle card and end the battle?
- Who commands a combined army when two generals fight a battle together?
- In a battle after an interception, which side is the attacker?
- If a defending stack has more than 10 CUs, do all of them fight?
- How many political control markers does the loser remove after a land battle?
- Do CUs left inside a walled city fight without a general, and can they join a relief attack?
- How do retreat die symbols determine CU losses?
- Can a general who already fought a land battle be activated again on a later strategy card?
- Can a player play more than one event card before or during a battle?
- Can a general move with one general and attack with another in the same activation?
- Must the defender match the attacker's battle card, or lose the battle?
- After a successful counterattack, who is the attacker?
- Is there a limit on how often a defender can counterattack?
- Does the defender automatically gain initiative after a counterattack?
- Does an elephant unit need its own battle card, and who wins if a player cannot play a battle card?
- Does a force with no General get battle cards for a general's rating or for allies?
- When is the change of command roll for a consular army made?
- Do allies help a land battle only in provinces their side controls?
Retreats and Withdrawals
- Is an attacking General who withdraws and loses all his CUs to the casualties roll displaced?
- If a defending army retreats out of reach of the second attacking army, can it still be attacked?
- Does sea withdrawal need both an Admiral and Naval Supremacy?
- Can an army retreat by sea into an enemy-controlled port in Hamilcar?
- How do the retreat dice and last played battle card determine retreat losses?
- If a retreating army enters an enemy PC or non-friendly tribe, does it lose an extra CU even if a friendly army is already there?
- After a land interception, who starts the battle with initiative, and when can the winner of initiative withdraw?
- Can a retreating army retreat into an empty field that has no PC marker?
- Can an original attacker withdraw to its starting space if that space holds an enemy Political Control marker?
- Can an intercepting army retreat to a different space than the one it entered the battle from?
- Can a force that attacked by sea retreat back across the sea after losing?
- Is withdrawing after winning the initiative roll a valid tactic?
- Can a sortie attacker disengage to an adjacent space instead of returning to the city?
- Can a retreating army that landed by sea retreat into a friendly Walled City in the battle space?
- Can a retreating army overrun a lone enemy CU to avoid the extra retreat loss?
- Can a retreating force go into a friendly Walled City in a space with no enemy present?
- What happens to a general who loses all his CUs in a battle but is not displaced?
- Do you lose the battle automatically if your withdrawal attempt fails?
- Can the defender attempt to withdraw from a land battle?
- If your withdrawal attempt fails, can you try to withdraw again?
- If a general is displaced, are his subordinates displaced too?
- Can a retreating force retreat into or through a space holding fewer friendly CUs?
- What is the difference between retreat roll casualties and retreat losses?
- Does a general become displaced if his CUs are lost to the land battle die roll?
- Can a losing army retreat into a space where the enemy is besieging a walled city?
- Can a withdrawing army move more than ten CUs into the adjacent space?
- When is a General displaced after his army loses units?
Elephants
- Is the Elephant Fright alternative rule a separate card in the Hannibal deck?
- Is the Elephant charge die roll resolved before or after Battle Cards are dealt?
- Does a failed elephant charge against Roman CUs without a general cost Carthage a battle card?
- Can Rome or Carthage place elephants as ordinary reinforcements?
- Do Carthaginian elephants count as CUs for battle cards and elephant charges?
- Are Carthaginian elephant counters limited?
Consuls and Consular Armies
- After a consul or proconsul is replaced in the Roman reinforcement phase, does the old one return to the general pool or get eliminated?
- Where are newly elected consuls placed when no space has a stack of five Roman CUs?
- Can a Roman Consul who cannot leave Italia be placed outside Italia during Reinforcements?
- Do the proconsul rules apply to Scipio Africanus, and is there a penalty if his troops are short?
- Can a consul move with no CUs?
- How many Roman CUs must be in a space to place a consul, and can one join a stack with fewer?
- Does an Aristocratic Roman Consul remove its PCs only when it is displaced?
- If two Admiral Roman Consuls are drawn or elected in one turn, can both carry out Naval Reforms?
- Can an eliminated Proconsul ever come back?
- In Hamilcar, how does Rome get back a Consul who was eliminated?
- Can two consuls in one army split up if one would be left with fewer than five CUs?
- What is the minimum size a Consular Army must keep in Hamilcar?
- What happens when Rome runs out of Roman generals for consuls?
- Can a Consul's army move through or join another consular army in the same space without stopping?
- Can a consular army with fewer than five CUs still move, fight, or besiege?
- If a consular army with fewer than five CUs meets friendly CUs in a space, must it take them into the army?
- Must Rome keep a proconsul's army at five CUs during reinforcement?
- Are consuls returned to the pool before the random draw for next turn's consuls, so they can be drawn again?
- Can a retiring consul become a proconsul in the Golden Geek edition?
- Can one consul leave Italy when the other consul must stay with five CUs?
- Can Scipio Africanus enter the game before turn 6 or be elected consul?
- Can a proconsul who enters a besieged city with a consul perform the siege?
- When a consul is appointed Proconsul, does he move to the old Proconsul's space?
- Can a proconsul move with fewer than five CUs, or split off from a consul's stack?
- Can a proconsul pick up CUs from a consular army?
- When a consul's army retreats with only a few CUs left, can the consul leave units behind?
- Is the larger pool of Roman generals in the Second Punic War scenario mandatory?
- Is a proconsul the same as a consul for consul rules?
- Must a moving consular army leave CUs for a consul it passes through?
- Do displaced Roman generals come back?
- Does a proconsul need a minimum number of CUs?
Political Control
- Can a player flip enemy PCs in a space where the flipping side has a CU?
- How many spaces must a player hold to control a Province?
- How many Political Control counters make up Sicilia, and do Lilybaeum or Lipara give their own ally battle card?
- How is the Lipara space treated under the rules?
- Do enemy PCs change side just because an army moves across them?
- Is Samnium a Politically Significant Province, and does it give political points?
- Do PCs placed in the Miat stay there at the end of a turn?
- How and when does Carthage move PCs out of the Miat, and must it play a card to do so?
- Are spaces not connected to a sea lane ports for political isolation in Hamilcar?
- Does Lilybaeum count toward control of the Sicilia province?
- Can a Roman Political Control marker stay in place when an enemy CU sits on it and the space is isolated?
- What happens to an enemy CU on a PC removed by political isolation?
- Does Carthage's political isolation link to a friendly tribe count for a PC?
- Can Political Control markers be placed anywhere on the map?
- What does it mean for a Political Control marker to trace a path back to a friendly space?
- Does a Carthaginian PC on the Balearic Islands vanish without a road connection?
- After losing a battle, must PC markers be removed near the battle?
- Is Syracusae allied with Carthage when Carthage conquers it?
- When I lose CUs in a land battle, how many Political Control markers do I lose?
- Do units on an enemy PC convert it automatically each Strategy Phase?
- Can a PC marker on a port use that same port to avoid political isolation?
- Can either side place PC markers on an unoccupied island such as Corsica or Sardinia?
- Can a general move and also flip a control marker with the same activation?
- Is a PC isolated if a friendly CU is in its space but enemy PCs surround it?
- How many extra CUs and Generals can Carthage gain from the Miat?
Sieges and Subjugation
- How does a siege or subjugation work?
- Does a siege continue into the next turn on its own, or must the general be activated again?
- Can a general already sitting in an enemy walled city siege on a later turn, and what card can start the attempt?
- Does a siege need three CUs on every roll, and does it end if the besiegers drop below three?
- What ends a siege, and does a failed siege roll move the general out of the city?
- Can a general siege in the same activation in which he fought a land battle?
- Can a general roll for a siege right after moving into an enemy walled city?
- What happens when a general moves into a walled city held by an enemy force?
- Can you take an empty enemy walled city by walking in, or overrun a lone unit inside it?
- Can the attacker enter the walled city right after a successful siege?
- Do you need to enter the city to besiege it, and does besieging cost extra movement?
- Can Fulvius roll again after losing a CU on his first siege or subjugation roll?
- Can a subordinate general dropped off by an activated general siege after that general moves on?
- Which siege die does each side roll?
- Does Carthage roll the red die when subjugating a tribe?
- Does a siege of Carthage get a -1 modifier on the siege roll?
- Does Capua use a different siege die from other cities?
- Does Naval Supremacy change the die used for tribal subjugation?
- Does subjugating a Carthaginian-friendly tribe require converting it to neutral first?
- Can Carthage flip a neutral tribe to its own side with an operation point?
- Can a subjugation be stopped partway, and does a tribe stop enemy movement?
- What is a Walled City or Tribe marker, and how is it converted?
- Do Rome and Carthage need three siege points to fall, and does losing the capital end the game?
- What does the Carthaginian Siege Train card do in a siege?
- Can more than one Siege Train be on the map at the same time?
- Does a Siege Train stay on the map when the General with it leaves?
- Can a besieged walled city with CUs but no General sortie?
- Can a besieged army sortie, and can its garrison join a relief army's battle?
- When besieged units join a relief army's battle, which general commands?
- Can units that sortie retreat back into the walled city?
- What advantage do units inside a besieged walled city give the defender?
- Does Marcellus have to move his consul, or have eight CUs, to siege?
- When a consul and a proconsul share a stack and the proconsul is activated, whose siege ability is used?
- Can a campaign card siege the same walled city twice?
- With Charles's siege variant, does Carthage still roll the white siege die?
Attrition
- Does the Epidemic card's attrition count Supply Trains?
- Does naval winter attrition apply to both players at the end of each turn?
- Do armies moving through neutral or hostile tribe zones suffer attrition?
- Do storm icons on the sea lanes cause attrition when Cruel Sea is not played?
- Which warships suffer naval attrition in Hamilcar?
- Are Storm at Sea attrition rolls made separately for CUs and ships, and on which sea lane?
Victory
- Can Rome lose Hamilcar by controlling too few provinces?
- Does Samnium count toward Rome's three-province requirement in Italia, and when is the count made?
- Does Year End Political Consequences apply in Hamilcar, and can PCs removed by it be placed again?
- Who wins ties in Hamilcar?
- Who wins a tie at the end of a Hannibal game, or what counts as a draw?
- How is the winner decided when the game ends?
- Does Massilia count toward Rome's three required provinces?
Special Abilities
- Can Regulus keep moving after winning a battle?
- Does Scipio Africanus roll two dice for a siege only when he is activated by a Forced March card?
- Does Gisgo's interception penalty for entering a Roman PC space still apply?
- Where must Fabius Maximus be placed when there is no five-CU stack in Italy?
- Does Marcellus's siege ability require playing a campaign card?
- Can Hanno use his ability after a battle or an overrun, and does he need a CU?
Optional Rules
- Can battle cards be used instead of the Hamilcar dice system in land battles?
- Does the Hercules Pillars optional rule have to be used when Mauretania is in play?
- Is Mauretania playable in the basic game?
- Is Bomilcar part of the vanilla Hannibal game?
- Can the Carthaginian player use the red siege die under the optional siege rules?
- Does the optional card-removal rule apply to basic cards without an elephant icon?
- What does an X in the optional cards distribution chart mean?