Die Macher FAQ
107 questions players ask · Updated Nov 16, 2026 · Full rulebook
Components and Setup
- Where does each party's Party Membership marker start?
- How many media and meeting markers does each player have, and can other pieces stand in when supply runs out?
- Does setup give each party a starting meeting marker on the board?
- How many state boards are used in a game, and are they chosen at random?
- How many players does Die Macher support, and what changes with four?
- How do starting bonuses work in the preliminary phase, and are the choices placed on the board right away?
- What do the options in the second column of the preliminary scoring card give?
- Can you place initial setup votes on a state that is not yet revealed?
Rounds and Turn Order
Party Platform
- In the Party Platform Conference, do you draw back up to three before or after discarding?
- During the Party Platform Conference, can you swap a face-up party policy card for an identical card from your hand?
- Can a party platform hold two copies of the same policy, or a contradictory one?
- Where do replaced party policy cards go, and when does the hand refill?
- Can you discard your whole party policy hand in the Party Platform Conference?
- Are discarded party policy cards kept face down?
- When the party policy deck runs out, is the discard pile reshuffled?
Shadow Cabinet
- Must a Shadow Cabinet media action remove another player's marker, and what does it cost?
- Does each Shadow Cabinet card you played give its action, or only one action in total?
- In what order are Shadow Cabinet cards paid for and resolved?
- Can a player put more than one Shadow Cabinet card into the same state in a round?
- Does a Shadow Cabinet popularity action raise your own popularity and lower another party's?
- If a poll or Shadow Cabinet card gives a +2 popularity move, do you move up two spaces from your current position?
- Can a card with a key issue or doubler tile be exchanged, or the tile removed by media control?
- Can a card with a key issue tile go onto the National Board after an election?
- Must you pay for a Shadow Cabinet card you placed, even if you no longer want its effect?
- When a Shadow Cabinet card with a telephone symbol is played, must I place a coalition tile?
Coalitions
- In what order are coalitions formed, and can I offer a voluntary coalition on my turn instead of forcing one?
- Does a rejected coalition offer end your turn, and can you make several coalition attempts?
- When a player can both force and invite coalition partners, who decides which partner to approach?
- Who may join a coalition, and how many matching policies does a partner need?
- Does a coalition tile on a future state board stay there until that state's election, and when is it removed?
- Can coalitions form in the seventh and final election?
Media Markers
- Who has media control in a state?
- Can a media-majority player change a regional opinion before all five media spaces in the state are filled?
- What does media control let a party do with public opinion cards, and when?
- In what order is media control applied when exchanging a public opinion card?
- Can a party move its media markers, or move one to free room on a state board?
- When do media markers return to their owners after an election?
Public Opinion Cards and the Exchange Pool
- Can identical or opposite opinion cards sit in the Exchange Pool at setup?
- What happens to identical or opposite opinion cards during setup?
- How many cards does the Exchange Pool hold, and how many are dealt at setup?
- Does the Exchange Pool refill after a card is taken from it?
- Can you take any card from the Exchange Pool, or only the top card of a stack?
- When an opinion card is exchanged off a state board, does it go into the Exchange Pool or the discard pile?
- Can a face-down popular opinion card on a federal state be chosen for replacement during Media Influence?
- When can a player with a vote majority swap an opinion card?
- Can the current state's opinion card be changed by converting meeting markers or by a vote majority?
- Can a public opinion card on a state board be replaced with its opposite?
- Do Yes/No and More/Less opinion cards mean the same thing?
- Are Yes/No and More/Less opinion cards contradictory to each other?
- Are the Valley Games cards with an arrow and those with a checkmark different positions?
Meeting Markers and Votes
- Do you need five meeting markers in a state before converting any of them into votes?
- How is the factor for converting meeting markers calculated, and is there a minimum?
- Are meeting markers in the current election state converted into votes before it is scored?
- Can a single party's votes go above 50 in a state, or only a coalition's?
- Can you buy meeting markers for states other than the current one, and convert them there?
- During Organize Party Meetings, does each player place markers on all active boards before the next player acts?
- How is the coincidence rating scored?
Opinion Polls
Winning an Election and Ties
National Board
- Where does an election winner's media marker go on the National Board, and why are there two spaces per round?
- After a single-party victory with free spaces, must you place two national opinion cards?
- Can a national opinion be secured more than once, or can a third identical card be placed on it?
- How is a secured national opinion removed from the National Board?
- When a National Board card is replaced, do the cards to its right slide left to fill the gap?
- Which National Board cards can be replaced, and by what?
- In a coalition win, who places national cards and media markers first, and can the junior partner replace the senior partner's card?
- Where do opinion cards pushed off the National Board go?
- Does the National Board start the game with any opinion cards?
Party Membership and Contributions
- When national opinions raise party membership, do the opposing opinions subtract?
- Do seats won in an election count toward party membership?
- When accepting or declining a contribution, do you add the dice or take the largest?
- Who gets the three bonus dice when a player declines a contribution?
- What numbers are on the special dice, and how many members can a contribution risk cost?
- In what order are contribution cards played and revealed?
- Are party contributions made in rounds 6 and 7?
- Are used Contribution and Shadow Cabinet cards removed from the game?
Money and Payouts
- How is end-of-election money calculated, and do seats pay out after rounds 6 and 7?
- Does leftover money count for anything at game end?
- Is each player's money hidden information?
- What do media markers and meeting markers cost?
- Can players pay each other money, or pay for votes or actions, in negotiation?
- When a coalition wins an election, do the members split the seat payout or each receive the full amount?
Between Elections and the Last Rounds
- Does a newly set-up state board give each party a free meeting marker?
- Do boards 5 to 7 start with a free party meeting marker, like the first four boards?
- Do the trend markers reset to zero when a new state is revealed after a round?
- What happens in round 7, and does party membership change after the last election?
- In the last two states, can meeting markers be converted for the seventh state before the sixth is scored?
- What is the No Coalition tile for, and is it used in the short game as well as the full game?
- Can you act on future state boards before their election, and is the seventh board set up like the others?
- How are the opinion cards dealt onto the new board set up at the end of round 3?
- After a region is finished, when is a new region set up, and which boards are reused?
- What happens to leftover opinion cards and the Exchange Pool when a state is finished?
Game End and Scoring
- Is there an official tie-breaker when two players finish with the same score?
- How are the end-game party membership bonuses split when players tie for first or second?
- Is a secured national opinion card worth extra points at the end of the game?
- Why do media markers from early elections score more victory points than those from later elections?
Editions and Variants
- How many rounds does the short game have?
- What rules changed between the 2nd and 3rd editions of Die Macher?
- Can you take a secondary shadow cabinet action without its main action, and how many actions can you take?
- Can a player skip an exclamation-mark shadow cabinet action so that a later player can use it?
- In the first edition, can the winner of a poll auction buy several poll cards and publish only one?