RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
Crime Stories thumbnail

Crime Stories

Crime Stories Rulebook

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

  • Components
  • Game Variants
  • Setup
  • Game Flow
  • Step 1: Beginner or Advanced Player?
    • a) Beginner's Game
    • b) Advanced Game
  • Step 2: Writing Short Stories
  • Step 3: Investigation
  • In Five Steps to Becoming a Crime Writer: Your Path to Becoming a Crime Stories Master

Components

86 investigation cards, of which:

  • 30 perpetrator/victim cards
  • 16 motive cards
  • 20 crime scene cards
  • 20 cause of death cards

24 story cards 1 rulebook

You will also need pencils and paper.

Game Variants

Beginner's game: For a simpler and quicker game, use the 24 story cards. This variant gives you a feel for the game flow and for how short stories can be structured. It has the advantage that you do not have to invent your own short stories. For this reason we recommend it for your first game.

Advanced game: In this variant you can let your creativity run free and write your own short crime stories! Use the 86 investigation cards for this.

You can of course also combine both variants, so that some players use the story cards and others use the investigation cards.

Setup

Sort all cards by their back into 5 separate stacks. Shuffle the stacks and place them face down side by side in the middle of the table. Also provide each player with a pencil and paper.

Game Flow

In Veit Etzold Crime Stories you become authors yourselves. You begin the game with 5 story elements, which represent the key facts of your short story. A player who wishes to use the story cards draws one of these cards from the stack and reads it without showing it to the other players. It specifies the story elements, the short story and its title.

A player who wishes to use the investigation cards begins with their help, using 5 story elements: one each from the categories perpetrator, victim, motive, crime scene and cause of death. Each player then has 10 minutes to write their own short crime story based on these elements and then give it a title. In turn, each of you names the title of your own short story, whether it was specified by a story card or written yourself. Now the other players must, through skilful questions, first determine the 5 story elements and then the specific short story with all its twists. As soon as the investigations for all players' short stories have been completed, the game is over.

A player who wants to simply help investigate without having a short story of their own may of course do so. However, these instructions assume that every player takes on the role of author once.

Let us look at the individual steps in more detail:

Step 1: Beginner or Advanced Player?

a) Beginner's Game

For the beginner's game, the thriller expert Veit Etzold has written 24 short stories exclusively and specifically for Crime Stories, which you will find on the story cards. Each already includes a title and, highlighted in colour, the 5 story elements.

If you want to get to know the game first, you can use these cards to help you. A player who uses a story card skips Step 2: Writing Short Stories and goes directly to Step 3: Investigation.

[Card illustration, caption:] The story elements have the colouring of the corresponding investigation cards. Perpetrator and victim therefore share the same colour, but within the context of the story it is clear who takes which role. The reference at the bottom edge is not part of the short story. If you do want to know where the inspiration for the respective short story came from, you will find the answer here.

[Card illustration labels, in order: Title; Crime scene; Perpetrator/Victim (two labels); Cause of death; Motive; Reference ("Based on: example story").]

b) Advanced Game

For the advanced game you need the investigation cards. They show the story elements of the 5 categories perpetrator, victim, motive, crime scene and cause of death. Perpetrator and victim share one card, since with these cards you must decide which of the two categories each one applies to. The remaining categories each have their own card stack, so there are four card stacks in total. You can also tell them apart by their colours.

Each investigation card gives you exactly 1 term: on perpetrator/victim cards it is the name that is not crossed out. On motive cards the term is printed large on the card. Crime scene cards show a city map on which the crime scene is marked. Cause of death cards show a largely blacked-out extract of a police report. The term is highlighted in yellow.

Anyone who wants to use the investigation cards writes the 5 categories on their paper and then draws a total of 3 cards. You may draw at most 1 card each from the motive, crime scene and cause of death stacks; you may draw at most 2 cards from the perpetrator/victim stack. If you wish, you may, if you do not like one drawn card, put it back under its stack and draw a new card instead. The new card may come from a different stack. Keep your cards secret from the other players at all times.

Write the drawn story elements from the investigation cards on your paper accordingly. For drawn perpetrator/victim cards you must decide whether to enter them as perpetrator or as victim. If you have drawn 2 such cards, you must designate one as perpetrator and one as victim. You may invent the two remaining story elements yourself.

PerpetratorVictimMotiveCrime sceneCause of death
BrotherHousekeeper??Library??

(Illustration of a worksheet after drawing. The two question marks mark the elements that the player still has to invent.)

Laura has written the categories on her sheet and then drawn 3 cards: 1 crime scene and 2 perpetrator/victim. She therefore writes "Library" under "Crime scene" and decides to use the "Brother/Sister" card's brother. He is to be the perpetrator in her short story. She enters the housekeeper under "Victim". So she already knows that an as yet undefined brother will kill a housekeeper in a library. She invents the two remaining elements for the categories "Motive" and "Cause of death" herself. Possibly the brother in her story is being blackmailed by the housekeeper and therefore kills her. Then Laura could enter "Blackmail" under "Motive". There are no limits to her imagination at this point.

When all players have noted their 5 story elements, you begin Step 2: Writing Short Stories.

Step 2: Writing Short Stories

Now take 10 minutes. Use an alarm, a stopwatch or a normal clock. Within these 10 minutes each of you must write your own short story and give it a title. Each person works on their own short story during this time. Your short stories may be as elaborate as you like, contain twists and surprises, be based on real-life models, be richly embellished, or, or, or... Just observe the following rules; beyond these, it is entirely up to you:

  1. Do not show anyone your story elements or your short story.

  2. All 5 story elements, that is both those from the investigation cards and those you invented yourself, must appear in your short story and must take exactly their respective category.

  3. The terms on the cards may be interpreted broadly.

    The cause of death "Suffocation" can, for example, occur through strangulation, drowning or gas. A "cable" can be a thin telephone cord, but also an overhead power line. The "scientist" can be anything from a chemist to a historian. The "bridge" can be small, wobbly and made of wood, or refer to the Golden Gate Bridge. The "hospital" can be a simple field hospital, and the "street" anything from a dirt track to a motorway.

Four more tips:

  • Watch the time, because within 10 minutes you must write down both a short story and its title.
  • Short stories with twists and surprises are particularly exciting; excessively absurd constructions, however, will probably spoil the fun.
  • Feel free to agree with all players on a longer time window, e.g. 15, 20 or even more minutes, if that helps you while writing.
  • Even if it seems obvious: your short story does not necessarily have to be set in the present day or in a society you are familiar with. If you have not drawn the "shotgun", you can for example set your short story in the Middle Ages.

The title you give your short story at the end will be the only clue your fellow players have at the beginning to determine the story elements. So choose a title that is not too obvious, but still make sure it has a connection to your short story.

Example: If a cult in your short story sacrifices humans to its demonic master with a ritual dagger, "The Dagger of the Followers" is an unsuitable title, because it already gives away the cause of death. "Your Life for Ner'zhul", on the other hand, reveals nothing, but still points your fellow players in the direction of the occult machinations of your story.

At the end of Step 2, Laura's sheet could look like this:

PerpetratorVictimMotiveCrime sceneCause of death
BrotherHousekeeperBlackmailLibraryFall

"The Maggot in the Bacon"

The successful author Romy Repulsa has taken in her small-time criminal and homeless brother so that he does not go further off the rails. Her housekeeper finds the dubious house guest a thorn in her side. When she repeatedly sees how he tramples on his sister's helpfulness and begins to steal minor valuables and even sell her possessions, she gives him an ultimatum. She would refrain from pressing charges if he leaves the estate and never returns. Unwilling to risk his situation, he lies in wait for the housekeeper in the library, pushes her down the stairs and disguises it as an industrial accident.

When all players have written down their short story together with its title, you begin Step 3: Investigation.

Step 3: Investigation

Decide together which short story you want to start with. Its author names the group the title of the short story, and the person to the author's left asks the first question. Questions are asked in turn until all 5 story elements have been correctly determined. Afterwards, the short story as a whole must be determined in the same way. This means that questions continue to be asked until all important details and the connections between the individual elements are known.

Observe the following rules for the questions:

  1. Only questions that can be answered with "Yes" or "No" may be asked.
  2. Answers may, in addition to "Yes" and "No", also contain gradations of these, e.g. "rather yes", "can be said that way", "not relevant", "rather no", etc. There is nothing to prevent you from finding a middle ground that works well in your group.
  3. As long as a question is answered positively, the questioner may keep asking. If a question is answered negatively, the next person clockwise takes their turn.
  4. When the group has found out one of the story elements, this must be announced.
  5. If the group is totally on the wrong track and cannot get any further, you may give hints at your own discretion.
  6. The group may discuss freely among themselves and exchange assumptions.

When you have solved the first short story, the investigation of the next player's short story begins. When you have solved the short stories of all players, the game is over.

It can of course also happen that you cannot get any further with an investigation. If you believe that you cannot fully solve a short story, you may of course abandon the current investigation and move on to the next short story.

In Five Steps to Becoming a Crime Writer: Your Path to Becoming a Crime Stories Master

The following writing workshop is part of the printed rulebook and is included in full, except for the author's byline and sign-off.

Every hero needs a villain:

"Every film is only as good as its villain," Alfred Hitchcock, the old master, knew. If you want to develop your own murder case or your own crime story for this game, you should first ask yourself who the villain is. For every hero needs first of all an opponent to set out on the hero's journey or, as an investigator, the investigative journey. In this case the heroes are your fellow players, who want to solve the murder case or the "Crime Story". Wherever a hero or heroes are on the move, there must also be a villain. Without a villain the hero is out of work. And without a perpetrator the investigator has nothing to do.

Every good story, whether a short story, a thriller or a crime film, follows the typical four-part structure: the situation in which the investigator starts in a certain state; then the disaster, in which he is confronted with the villain, who initially appears overpowering; the turning point, at which the hero surprisingly succeeds in turning fate and fighting evil; and the happy ending that awaits the hero and his surroundings once evil has been defeated.

Of course the villain or murderer also needs a victim. Even though the masked "unknown, dark man" who appears out of nowhere is often seen in crime fiction, statistically speaking most murder victims knew their killer.

In the game "Crime Stories" we have five classifications that you need in order to catch the murderer. These classifications also help when you design your own Crime Stories. They are: perpetrator, victim, motive, crime scene and cause of death.

Perpetrator and victim:

Statistically speaking, most murderers are men and most murder victims are women. This is also true of serial killers. Serial killers kill according to their sexual preference, and since most murderers are heterosexual men, most victims of serial killers are women. You could therefore consider whether the perpetrator is a man or a woman and whether the victim is a man or a woman.

Example: Let us assume that the perpetrator is a man and the victim is a woman.

Motive and motivation:

A murderer rarely kills out of sheer malice alone; he usually also has a motive. This motive determines why the perpetrator kills at all. The word "motive" derives from the Latin "movere", which means "to move". Here too we ask ourselves what it was that "moved" the perpetrator to kill the victim. If we make a short detour into psychology, we find that there are seven basic emotions. Five of them are negative: contempt, anger, sadness, fear and disgust. Surprise is neutral, and only joy is positive. A rather gloomy prospect, isn't it? Behind this pessimistic selection lies our old self-preservation instinct in the brain, which still thinks we live in the dangerous Stone Age: if we overestimate dangers, it does us no harm. If we underestimate them, the sabre-toothed tiger may eat us. The fine saying applies here: better a living pessimist than a dead optimist.

The investigators of the Behavioural Science unit at the FBI also distinguish, for serial offenders, between the modus operandi and the signature. The modus operandi shows the way in which the offender, based on his offender profile, committed the murder. For example, the serial killer Ed Kemper always killed women whom he either knew or had met as hitchhikers. He usually shot them and sexually assaulted them before or after death. The signature, on the other hand, is what goes beyond the modus operandi and is not necessarily required for the crime. It often has a symbolic character. Kemper not only murdered his mother, but also cut out her larynx and threw it into the garbage disposal, because the "nagging of his mother" got on his nerves too much. The larynx was here the place where his mother's scolding was produced by the vocal cords. The modus operandi and the signature play no primary role in the game, but they can help to refine the story.

If this seems a little too abstract, the good old seven deadly sins help us further. These are: pride, envy, wrath, sloth, greed, gluttony and lust.

From these basic emotions the further course of the Crime Story can be spun (here more extensive than necessary in the game):

The wife (the victim) sought out a younger lover (her motive: lust) in order to cheat on her husband, whom she increasingly finds unattractive (disgust). The husband, however, already suspects this and has therefore commissioned a hacker, who has supplied him with software to hack the wife's mobile phone. This way the husband learns that his wife is meeting a younger lover. The husband's emotions are anger and wrath (a negative emotion and a deadly sin in one), possibly also contempt for his wife. To make matters worse, the lover works for a competing company of the husband's, which has just snatched a contract away from him. The husband therefore feels envy in a double sense: once because the other man has taken not only the contract but also his wife. His motive is to take revenge on his wife.

So we already have: the perpetrator (the husband), the victim (the wife) and the motive (revenge, envy and the fact that the husband feels pushed aside by his wife).

The crime scene:

The place where a murder happens is the "crime scene". You can let your imagination run free regarding the location. The following possibilities exist here; of course the selection is by no means complete and can be extended at any time by your (dark) imagination.

  • Precarious milieu, squalid flat, alcoholics consume alcohol and drugs and get into an argument
  • Normal surroundings, middle-class house, relationship crime and family drama
  • High society, villa
  • Clan and mafia structures, villa or basement, lonely bridges, car parks or underground garages
  • Battlefields, where murders go virtually unnoticed
  • In the city, where the anonymity of the big city helps, while everything is also closer together
  • In the countryside, where everyone knows each other but lives further apart from others
  • In a train, aeroplane or coach; this is of course delicate, since the murderer cannot flee. Here care must be taken that the murderer can distract as well as possible from his deed, or disguise the whole thing as an accident or suicide
  • In a stranger's house: the intruder may have the element of surprise on his side, but on the other hand the resident knows the house better and can, for example, set traps
  • In one's own house: many relationship crimes take place in one's own home, so that statistically it is one of the most probable places for a murder

For our example case, the place would be the shared flat of the (soon to be former) couple. After the surveillance of the wife's phone, the following happens:

At home the situation comes to a head: the husband confronts his wife with the affair. As the argument escalates, he threatens to kill the young man. The wife does not take the husband seriously and goes out onto the balcony to smoke a cigarette. The husband follows her and asks her why she is cheating. She looks him up and down disdainfully and says only: "Just look at yourself."

Cause of death:

Here too reality is merciless: there is usually only one way to come into the world, but thousands of ways to leave this world, not always voluntarily. Below we have listed a few of these methods of murder. Since the wickedness of human beings knows no bounds, you need not know any bounds here either.

  • Poisoning
  • Gang shootings
  • Murder by arson: a house or flat is set on fire with the aim of killing its resident. There are also arsonists who are aroused by setting buildings alight and watching them burn.
  • Robbery and murder: use of violence to obtain the victim's money. The intent to kill may be impulsive or calculated.
  • Serial murder: a murderer kills again and again, often members of a certain group, a gender, or residents of a place. The killer usually does not stop so quickly, especially when he gets better at killing.
  • Ritual murder: the killer believes he is being controlled by a higher power. Especially in America, some killers claim this afterwards in order to be considered not criminally responsible and to be sent to a closed institution rather than end up in the electric chair.
  • Murder to eliminate someone who knows too much; this occurs frequently in the area of organised crime.
  • Murder by a contract killer: contract killers are hired and paid for the targeted elimination of specific targets.
  • Revenge killing, often in the heat of the moment, or also deliberate.
  • Murder disguised as suicide: often the victims are hanged or laid on railway tracks.
  • Murder disguised as an accident: for example, the victim is beaten to death and then thrown from a building, ideally in such a way that everyone thinks the person was just cleaning windows.

Of course there are also numerous ways of sending another person to the hereafter. The most common are: beating to death, stabbing, cutting the throat, shooting, burning, throwing from a height, drowning, strangling, choking, suffocating, poisoning, or locking up and letting starve or die of thirst.

Let us return to our crisis couple. How does it continue? The argument escalates. The wife has just insulted the husband, whose nerves are no longer very steady. That is too much. The husband loses his temper and, full of rage, gives his wife a powerful shove. She crashes against the balustrade and, from the momentum, falls over the parapet. The balcony is on the sixth floor, the wife falls six storeys and is dead instantly.

Reality and fiction:

Mark Twain already knew it: what is the difference between fiction and reality? Fiction must always make sense. From my own conversations with investigators and forensic pathologists I know that reality is often considerably more illogical, more drastic and more shocking than any thriller. So if you have a particularly unusual idea, of which you have read, for example, in the newspaper or in an FBI case book, you may freely use this story. Bear in mind, however, that the "ordinary" reader is more accustomed to logically constructed crime stories and may need more help in solving a somewhat more absurd case.

Otherwise let your imagination run free, and I wish you lots of fun and spine-chilling moments while playing, and of course also while designing your own Crime Stories!

[Author's sign-off and credits omitted.]