RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
Churchill thumbnail

Churchill FAQ

305 questions players ask · Updated Nov 16, 2026 · Full rulebook

General and AppendicesKey ConceptsConference Sequence of PlayConference ProceduresDecision SegmentWar PhaseConference Post-Mortem or Allied VictoryScenarios and Secret AgendaSolitaire Rules

General and Appendices

  • What changed between the first and second editions of Churchill?
  • After Roosevelt dies, do cards and rules that name Roosevelt apply to Truman?
  • Can Truman be used as a staff card or leader before Roosevelt dies?
  • Does a UK Clandestine Network in a colony cost the UK the 2 VP for an empty colony?
  • Do Fronts score victory points for every space they pass, or only the final space they reach?
  • Does the UK get 2 or 3 VP for entering Central Italy before Normandy?
  • If a Soviet front advances into Korea and then enters Japan, does the Soviet player score both the Korea and Japan VP?
  • Does the USSR get extra German technology chits when it is the only power to enter Germany?
  • Does the USSR get a bonus for being the only power to enter Berlin?
  • If Churchill is removed by his heart attack, does Clement Attlee take over as the British conference leader?
  • How many VP does the USSR's Manhattan spy-ring track score?
  • Must players sit in a particular order relative to the leaders, and does 'to the left' follow the table or real-life seating?
  • Which errata version of Churchill is current, the 2 September 2015 or the 5 September 2015 one?
  • Do first-edition owners need a replacement Stalin card or an errata?

Key Concepts

  • Can naval support markers move to another front, and do they stay on the board between turns?
  • Can the Mediterranean Front ever enter Germany?
  • Does Roosevelt's bonus Political Alignment marker apply when he is played on any issue, or only on the Global Issue?
  • When is Truman's Inexperience dice roll made relative to choosing how to use him?
  • Does Truman's Inexperience penalty cancel his Attribute bonus when the A-Bomb is in the Trinity space?
  • When are Stalin's Paranoid and Truman's Inexperience dice rolled?
  • Which health roll applies when Sir Dudley Pound activates and Churchill's card is used?
  • If I discard a staff card like Henry Arnold or Dudley Pound to use my Leader card, does that staff card make its health roll?
  • Can you play a staff card in the Meeting Segment and choose not to apply its results?
  • Do staff card attributes that name an issue, such as Cunningham's European Leadership bonus or Ernest Bevin's Soviet Pol-Mil penalty, apply when the card is played on a different issue?
  • Can Truman be used as an active leader in the conference when Roosevelt dies?
  • How many Clandestine Network markers does Stalin's leader card give when played on a Pol-Mil issue?
  • If a staff card's issue is later debated by another player, does the card's non-strength attribute still happen?
  • Under the Harry Hopkins card, when does his strength drop to 2, and when is it fixed at 5?
  • When the US is involved in a tie, does the US win it outright or choose who wins? Who decides the order of placement when players tie?
  • Is a leader who cannot attend still active until he debates or breaks a tie?
  • Can a leader advance, debate and break a tie in the same conference?
  • Does a staff card's 'if leader active this conference' attribute apply only until the leader is used?
  • Are political or naval markers gained from a staff card attribute, such as Churchill's or Knox's bonus, placed immediately?
  • While a Global Issue is neutral, can players remove another player's markers from countries connected to the Western or Eastern Front, and which countries count as connected?
  • Can a country hold a Clandestine Network from one player and a Political Alignment marker from another?
  • Can players give away or swap an unplaced Clandestine or Political Alignment marker in a negotiation?

Conference Sequence of Play

  • Who is second place for Victory Condition 2 when two players tie for the most VP?
  • How is a tie for the most VP at game end resolved, including a three-way tie, and does breaking it win the game?
  • How are the end-of-game VP adjustments for an unsurrendered Axis (Condition 3) applied in the second edition?
  • In tournament victory (Condition 3), if the UK and USSR tie for the top score, do both subtract 5 VP before the final tiebreaker?
  • If the US is involved in an Agenda tie, does the US win it, and who breaks the tie when the US is not involved?
  • When a leader breaks a tie, must a staff card be discarded, is the leader inactive afterward, and can an inactive leader still break a tie?
  • Can the Axis armies not placed by dice be set up as soon as the conference card is revealed?
  • Can Stalin's leader card advance an issue in every conference?
  • How is the winner decided under Broken Alliance (rule 4.42) when the leader is more than 20 VP ahead, and when the top two scores are tied?
  • Is the point gap for the Axis-surrender victory condition 15 or 20?
  • Is there a die roll to determine the game winner in the second edition?
  • Does Tournament Scoring apply only in the Tournament Scenario?
  • Why do players collect multiple conference victory markers?
  • How is the conference card chosen for each conference?
  • Do players choose a fixed number of issues for the conference table, and are conference card issues added to the normal ones?
  • In the Agenda Segment, where does an issue go when a leader breaks a tie and all three players are tied?
  • What counts as an available issue for the high-value card in the Agenda Segment?
  • Are staff cards played during the Agenda Segment discarded, including the card that wins the Agenda bid?
  • Do staff card special abilities or penalties apply during the Agenda Segment?
  • In the Agenda Segment, is the UK +1 applied before subtracting the lowest card value when placing an issue?
  • What are the Condition 1 and Condition 2 victory checks when both Axis powers have surrendered?
  • Are Allied offensive and naval support markers placed before Axis reserves are committed?
  • Is there a limit on Clandestine Networks and Political Alignment markers on the board?
  • Why are Clandestine Networks and Political Alignment markers worth anything?

Conference Procedures

  • Does the Yalta card's 'Pressure for declaration of war against Japan' put the USSR Declares War on Japan issue on the table?
  • Can an issue that crosses the zero space be moved onto a third player's track during the Meeting Segment?
  • When is Stalin's paranoia die roll made relative to the Stalin card?
  • What happens to issue markers after a conference ends?
  • Can an issue be stopped in the centre of the table?
  • Can Harry Hopkins stop Strategic Materials in the centre of the table?
  • Does Roosevelt's Global Issue bonus apply if Churchill has already captured the Global Issue?
  • When is a leader's attribute bonus checked if the issue moved earlier in the turn?
  • If an issue is advanced onto a leader's chair, can it still be debated, and which track bonus applies?
  • When an issue is debated, how far does it move?
  • Can any issue advance be debated, or only an advance that would reach a leader's chair?
  • Can an issue be advanced or debated more than once in a conference?
  • Does debating an issue earn a pass option, and can it be earned twice before your next turn?
  • Does the card that first advanced an issue count as a debate for the Soviet Nyet bonus?
  • Who can debate an issue that a Leader advanced, and can a Leader be debated by a staff card?
  • Can a Leader barred from advancing issues still debate or break a tie?
  • How does a Leader become inactive, and can an inactive Leader debate or break a tie?
  • Can Stalin's leader ability cover both the A-bomb and a Pol-Mil issue?
  • Does using a Leader cost a staff card, and how many cards does each player hold after the Agenda?
  • Do staff card attributes apply in the Agenda Segment, and do they apply when a card is used to debate?
  • Does a bot's Leader card count when it picks its highest-value card for agenda issues?
  • What value does a Chief of Staff card have when ranking cards for the Bot?
  • Where does the agenda winner place his issue when the card totals differ, and where does it go on a tie?
  • Can a conference card placing an issue take the number of issues on the table above seven?
  • Can a player choose both copies of the US Production issue during Agenda Selection?
  • Is the staff card that wins the Agenda Segment returned to the deck or discarded?
  • Are the staff decks reshuffled before every conference?
  • Do conference card instructions override the general rules when they conflict?
  • When a conference card adds or removes markers, is that applied before or after the players' Pol-Mil and leader placements?
  • Do Axis units placed by a conference card take precedence over normal Axis reserve placement?
  • Where do reserves go when a conference card calls for them without naming an army or navy?
  • When a conference card gives several Clandestine Networks or Political Alignment markers, do I roll on the Pol-Mil table once or once per marker?
  • In what order do players place Clandestine Network or Political Alignment markers when a card lets several of them place?
  • Do clandestine markers gained from a conference card add to the base marker a player normally receives?
  • Does Conference 4B's Turkey negotiations text remove two Clandestine Networks from the UK?
  • Does the Tito conference card remove every non-USSR clandestine network on the board?
  • When a player debates an issue, does Francis Biddle's -1 strength on the Soviet track apply?
  • Does Sir Andrew Cunningham's '+2 if European Leadership change' need the command to actually change hands?
  • Do players have to sit in a particular order around the table?
  • Is the Health roll the sum of two dice or either die?
  • Does the Theater Leadership example of play give the UK an extra offensive support marker?
  • Does the Battle of the Atlantic or another conference card effect apply every turn, or only when the card is revealed?
  • Does the Northern Flank U-boat die roll still apply when the German Navy cube is no longer on the board?
  • When a Leader breaks a tie in the Agenda Segment, does his card value count?

Decision Segment

  • Where can a Directed Offensive be placed?
  • Can a Directed Offensive be placed in the Arctic Theater?
  • On a Directed Offensive placed on an amphibious entry space, can the owner choose naval support once three naval markers are already in the theater?
  • Who pays the production for a Directed Offensive placed on another player's front?
  • Does a Directed Offensive still need production if its owner won that issue himself?
  • Does a Directed Offensive's production count toward a production amount a conference card requires in the same theater?
  • After a failed Normandy or Manchuria attack, is the conditional issue removed, and what is needed for a retry?
  • Can offensive support be placed on a front that cannot advance?
  • Can offensive support be placed on another nation's front?
  • Does naval support add to a front's combat strength when it attacks?
  • When a card places support 'in a Theater', does the marker go to the Front or the Theater box?
  • If a card calls for production or support on a front that is already at its last space, is the production still spent?
  • Must a player spend all of his production markers?
  • Can leftover production be spent to help another player's front advance?
  • How many production markers does each power receive each conference, and when are they allocated?
  • In what order do players allocate production?
  • Are Theater Leadership support markers placed with regular production, and can they pay for a Directed Offensive?
  • When another player wins your named Production issue, can you place the production marker where you like?
  • What does the Strategic Materials issue give when it is won, and what if it ends in the centre?
  • Does a card's bonus for a production issue apply when it is played on the Strategic Materials issue?
  • Do won Pol-Mil issues need production to produce Political Alignment and Clandestine Network markers?
  • In what order are Theater Leadership bonuses and leadership changes resolved?
  • When Theater Leadership changes hands, does the outgoing or incoming commander get support in that conference?
  • Does the theater commander get support when no Theater Leadership issue is on the table?
  • Does winning a Theater Leadership issue still give its bonus if command does not change hands?
  • How much offensive support can one player get from Theater Leadership in one conference?
  • Where must Theater Leadership support markers go?
  • Can production be added to an A-Bomb roll after the die is rolled?
  • If Stalin wins the A-Bomb Research issue, does the US still roll for its A-bomb advancement?
  • Does the Manhattan Spy Ring need Stalin's card to win the A-bomb issue, and can the Soviet spy marker run ahead of the US marker?
  • Is the A-Bomb Research issue removed from play once the US marker reaches Trinity?
  • If you win the Global Issue and a Global marker can move, must you move one?
  • Can a Global Issue marker that has left its neutral space ever return to neutral?
  • Can Political Alignment markers be placed in Greece or Denmark while the Churchill-Stalin Global Issue is neutral?
  • If a Political Alignment marker cannot be played because the Global Issue is neutral, can you keep it for a later turn?
  • Can an unplaced Political Alignment marker be used to remove one of your own markers from the board?
  • Can a Political Alignment marker be removed where a Global Issue restricts its placement?
  • Does offensive support carry over to the next conference, or can it be saved for a later declaration of war?
  • Can naval support placed in one theater be moved to a different theater in a later round?
  • When is the three-naval check made for Arctic production?
  • Does the Murmansk Convoy production still apply after Germany surrenders?
  • Does the USSR still need three naval markers in the Arctic to get Arctic production after Germany surrenders?
  • Is Murmansk Convoy production discarded after use, and can it come in the same conference as Arctic production?
  • Does a conference card's theater production instruction still apply in a theater where the Axis power has surrendered?
  • If a conditional issue such as Second Front starts in the centre of the table, can it be played and left there without moving?

War Phase

  • Can a player remove another player's Political Alignment marker by discarding his own unplayed marker?
  • Can a player remove an opponent's Political Alignment marker while a Global Issue is neutral?
  • Can a player remove several opponent Clandestine Networks in one country or colony during the same segment?
  • Is there a limit on Clandestine Network or Political Alignment markers?
  • After a front removes a Clandestine Network from a country, can a new one be placed there?
  • When a front advances again, are Clandestine Networks removed from countries that were already behind the front?
  • After a Soviet front advances into a country, which Clandestine Networks are removed?
  • When a front advances, which countries become 'behind the front'?
  • Is Persia connected to the Mediterranean front, so that it goes behind the front when the front passes?
  • When several players tie for placing Clandestine Networks or Political Alignment markers, who places first?
  • Must a player place a Political Alignment marker if a legal space exists?
  • Are unused Political Alignment or Clandestine Network markers kept for a later conference?
  • Does the Free Europe Global Issue let you place Political Alignment markers without a Clandestine Network?
  • Can political alignment markers be placed in European countries while the Churchill-Stalin Global Issue is neutral?
  • Are Belgium and the Netherlands connected for the Churchill-Stalin Neutral restriction on Political Alignment markers?
  • How is a Front's strength for an advance calculated?
  • How do Axis reserves interact with Offensive Support markers on a front?
  • Are Offensive Support markers removed after a front's die roll, and do they carry over to the next conference?
  • Are Naval Support markers removed after a front's advance die roll, like Offensive Support?
  • Do Naval Support markers add to a front's strength or to the die roll?
  • Do Axis reserves stay on the board between conferences or on a front after the advance?
  • When does a Kamikaze space trigger: when support is placed, or when the front actually enters?
  • If the Japanese navy removes a naval marker so a front has fewer than three for an amphibious entry, what happens?
  • If a front lacks the three naval markers needed to enter an amphibious space, do Japanese armies still go into Japan?
  • When several fronts try to enter Japan, how are the Japanese armies divided among them?
  • Where does the Japanese navy go when Central Pacific cannot attempt an advance?
  • Does the Japanese navy step (7.64, step 4) apply to a front with zero modified strength?
  • If a conference card places an IJN cube, is the War Phase IJN placement roll still made, and can another naval marker be removed?
  • When the IJN sorties with two navies available, how many are used at once?
  • After a conference card sends out the IJN, do you still roll for its elimination?
  • Does the IJN still deploy and remove a naval marker when no front can advance?
  • Does the IJN sortie resolve before the front advances, so the Allies should keep an extra naval marker?
  • What does a conference card saying 'IJN sorties' mean?
  • How does a front's strength of 10 or more change its advance roll and breakthrough?
  • Can a front break through from the Rhineland or Prussia straight into Germany?
  • Can a front break through into Japan?
  • Do German reserves in a second advance space, such as Germany, reduce a breakthrough roll?
  • Can a front on the track move backward after it has advanced?
  • Do fronts advance in a fixed order, so that an earlier front's entry into Germany blocks a later one?
  • Can two fronts enter Japan in the same conference, or does the first entry stop the second?
  • Can the Soviet Front still enter Germany and score after the Western Allies have already taken it?
  • When several fronts attack Germany or Japan together, can their Offensive Support be shared?
  • When the Western and Eastern Fronts both enter Germany, how are the German armies placed?
  • If only the Western Front enters Germany, does the even-split rule for multiple fronts apply?
  • When two armies already sit in Germany for priority 1, can the same two also satisfy the Normandy priority?
  • How many German armies go to the Eastern Front in the Europe reserve placement?
  • Does a front that could enter Germany only by breakthrough count as attempting to enter, triggering the first priority?
  • If the Mediterranean front is already fully advanced, do Axis reserves rolled to it still go there?
  • If a German reserve must go to the Mediterranean front but the Allies have already advanced to its end, do you re-roll?
  • When Axis reserve placement is required but the cubes run out, do extra cubes in the box count as reserves?
  • When the Western Front is in the Western Theater box and a random Axis placement lands there, where does the army go?
  • Where do German army reserves go when the Soviet Winter Offensive or a random reserve sends one to a front?
  • What does the German navy reserve do when it is placed in the Western Theater box?
  • Is the German naval reserve ever active again after the Western Front enters the UK/Bolero space?
  • Must the Western Front make an advance roll to enter the UK/Bolero space?
  • Does the Eastern Front's four-army placement depend on the US Front having left the UK/Bolero space?
  • After an Axis power surrenders, what can still be placed in its theater?
  • After Germany or Japan surrenders, can fronts in its theater still advance?
  • After Germany surrenders, does the Mediterranean (Italy) front still advance?
  • After Germany or Japan surrenders, are Axis reserves still placed for that power, and do leftover reserves matter?
  • Can the Pacific fronts still advance once Japan has met its surrender conditions?
  • Do fronts finish advancing before the Axis surrender conditions are checked in the same War Phase?
  • Can the Mediterranean Front advance into Germany?
  • What happens to the Mediterranean front once it reaches Northern Italy?
  • Where does an Axis reserve rolled as a 6 go when the Arctic has fewer than three naval support markers?
  • Are naval markers in the Arctic removed before or after German reserves are placed there?
  • Does the Murmansk Convoy condition still resolve after Germany has surrendered?
  • For Axis reserve placement, does 'Germany' mean the Germany box, or also West Germany and East Germany?
  • Is the Western and Eastern Front goal West Germany and East Germany, or the Rhineland and Prussia?
  • Do Japanese armies go to Manchuria before the USSR has declared war on Japan?
  • In the training scenario, do Japanese reserves go to Manchuria before the USSR has declared war?
  • Does a Soviet move into Nomohon from the Far East Theater box need a die roll when no Japanese forces oppose it?
  • If a Directed Offensive targets the Far Eastern Front while the USSR Declares War on Japan issue is not active, what happens?
  • Can the USSR advance into Manchuria after a successful breakthrough while at war with Japan?
  • Does the Soviet entry into Manchuria remove all Japanese armies from the game?
  • Is a Japanese army placed in Iwo Jima when it is a B-29 space?
  • Do Japanese reserves named on a conference card go to front entry spaces or to the theater box?
  • When the IJN is placed by a conference card, does the Allied shoot-back die roll (step 5) still happen?
  • Can the Soviet Far East front in Korea decline to invade Japan?
  • What does conference card 8C (Leyte Gulf) place?
  • Does Operation KE stop the Southwest Pacific front from advancing?
  • What does the Operation Grenade event do with a German reserve?
  • Are Axis reserves placed in a front that cannot advance because of too little naval support?

Conference Post-Mortem or Allied Victory

  • Did the victory conditions change in the second printing of Churchill?
  • How does Condition 3 victory work when the leader is ahead by a small margin?
  • Does Japan's Emperor Surrender need Germany's surrender in an earlier conference, or can both happen in the same conference?
  • If a Front enters Japan in the same conference Germany surrenders and the US has the A-bomb, is the Emperor surrender route still used?
  • When are victory points scored, and do conditional points count once their condition is met during play?
  • When is the Emperor's surrender condition checked relative to Pacific front advances?
  • With both Axis powers surrendered, does a score gap of 20 or less let the higher scorer win outright?
  • Where do Axis reserves go after the War Phase ends?
  • If the Trinity A-bomb space is reached during the Decision Segment, does the game end immediately?
  • Do conference card instructions such as placing production or Murmansk Convoy still happen after an Axis power has surrendered?
  • Do offensive and naval support markers stay on the board between conferences, and what is reset at the end of a conference?
  • When a player wins a conference, do both the US and UK score the 3 VP, or only one of them?
  • If Germany or Japan surrenders during a conference, does the order in which fronts resolve matter?

Scenarios and Secret Agenda

  • How many VP do the US and UK score when several of their Fronts reach Japan?
  • Do Pacific Front VP spaces score for spaces a Front passed through, or only for the space where it ends?
  • Does a Soviet Front score 8 VP for Korea and again for invading Japan?
  • If a Front is in Japan, do US Fronts in Okinawa and Kyushu still score, and does the 8-VP cap apply?
  • Do the US get 5 VP each for holding Okinawa and for holding Kyushu, or only one of them?
  • Do colonies count for Clandestine Network VP where a space has no Political Alignment marker?
  • Does the inter-service rivalry bonus apply when the two US Pacific Fronts are only one space apart?
  • Does the US still get the 5 VP for Japan's surrender if a Front occupies Japan?
  • When the US and UK both have Fronts in an Axis country at its surrender, how many VP does each side score?
  • Which Axis countries count for the 8 VP per Axis country item on the victory point schedule?
  • When Germany surrenders, does the USSR score 8 VP for its Front entering Germany?
  • Does the Soviet player get the extra 5 VP for occupying Germany when the US and UK only hold West Germany?
  • How does MacArthur's return to the Philippines change the UK and USSR Philippines VP?
  • How many VP does the US get for a Front in Iwo Jima?
  • If a Front has entered Japan, does the US still score the Iwo Jima points?
  • Does the UK score its 2 VP for a colony that holds another player's marker?
  • Does Churchill lose the 2 VP for an empty colony when he places a Clandestine Network there?
  • Are colonies treated like countries for Political Alignment scoring?
  • Can the US or USSR place or remove Political Alignment markers while colonialism is in effect?
  • Why do the training and tournament scenarios start with Political Alignment markers while the Global Issues are neutral?
  • Do the starting markers or track positions give VP at scenario setup in the training or tournament scenario?
  • Are both IJN navies available at the start of the Training Scenario?
  • Can the tournament scoring variant be used with any scenario, or only the tournament scenario?
  • Does the game end once all issues have been won or removed from the track?
  • What do the national flag markers and the flag front blocks do?
  • If one player's Front is in Japan and another player's Fronts are not, are VP subtracted or redistributed?
  • Can a Front on the Mediterranean track invade Germany?
  • If the UK helps a US Front invade Japan while its own CBI Front sits on a 5-VP space, what does each player score?

Solitaire Rules

  • How do bots pick the card to play for the Agenda when several cards share their highest value?
  • How does a bot read the second highest and second lowest values when card values repeat?
  • When a bot's highest-value card has no issue it can table, does it move to the next card?
  • Does a bot's issue choice for an agenda winner use leader attributes?
  • Does a bot advancing an issue use a leader's or a situational conditional attribute, or only the card value?
  • What value does a Chief of Staff card have when a bot or solitaire player chooses it?
  • How do Theater Leadership issues work for the solo bots, and where does a bot place the support it wins?
  • Where does a UK Bot place the bonus Offensive or Naval Support it gets from winning European Leadership?
  • Does a bot hold its strongest card back for last, including when it debates an issue?
  • How many Offensive Support markers does each bot place in the Western theater after D-Day succeeds?
  • How does a bot pick its agenda issues when it holds several staff cards?
  • When a US or UK bot's staff card has a Pol-Mil attribute but a Pol-Mil issue is already taken, what does the bot pick?
  • What happens to Pol-Mil issues a bot wins but cannot activate?
  • How is a negative-attribute staff card such as Bevin valued by a bot in the Meeting Segment?
  • When the bot and the human tie on the Agenda and no leader breaks it, how is the tie resolved?
  • Do bots break an Agenda tie by committing their Big Three leaders, or do they save them?
  • May a player override a bot move that is obviously sub-optimal?
  • Do Leader cards count toward a bot's staff card choices, such as the agenda card choice or picking issues from hand?
  • Will a bot debate an issue that a Leader advanced from the Center of the Table?
  • How does the Stalin bot choose which staff card to debate with?
  • Does the Stalin bot debate every issue that Roosevelt advances onto its track?
  • How does the Stalin bot handle the USSR declares war on Japan issue?
  • Will the Stalin bot ever place a Directed Offensive in Manchuria?
  • When the Stalin bot wins Theater Leadership, how is control of the theater decided?
  • Does the US bot ever advance the Second Front issue?
  • When the US bot must choose between tied options, such as the UK and USSR on the conference card, what does it do?
  • What does the bot instruction 'Implement A-Bomb Research' mean for production?
  • Does the Roosevelt bot debate issues other than the A-bomb and Global Issue?
  • Does Truman's card or bot text work the same as Roosevelt's for the solo bot rules?
  • In the Churchill bot's debate step, should the country be the UK or the US?
  • Did the second printing change the bot rules?
  • Does a Soviet staff card's 'place Offensive Support' text affect the Agenda issues?