Black Fleet FAQ
69 questions players ask · Updated Nov 20, 2026 · Full rulebook
Setup
- Can ships stop on or pass through distant sea spaces?
- Can two merchant ships start from the same port?
- How many goods can a merchant or pirate ship hold?
- Can you look at your own development cards at any time?
- What goods do the colored cubes represent?
- Are gold and silver doubloons worth the same?
- What is the Pirate Lair space on the board for?
- Can ships with island-crossing abilities cross the peninsula on the board?
Turn Overview
Play your ships
- Is selling and loading goods one action or two?
- Can you sell only part of your cargo, or load more while still carrying goods?
- Must a merchant restock with the goods color of the port where it delivered?
- Can a pirate ship carrying cargo attack a merchant ship?
- Can a pirate bury treasure before attacking in the same turn?
- Can a ship take its action during movement on a space holding a friendly ship?
- Is attacking mandatory when a ship ends its move next to an enemy navy ship?
- Can a ship retrace spaces it already passed to finish its movement after its action?
- Where do sunk merchant and pirate ships re-enter the board?
- Can a pirate sell goods it pillaged at any port under Smuggler's Code?
- Can a ship move through another ship?
- Can a ship attack across one in-between space, such as an island or an occupied space?
- What do the dashed lines across islands mean, and can ships cross islands?
- Can a pirate attack an empty merchant ship?
- Does placing a pirate on a distant sea space cost movement, and can it stay there?
- Can a ship sell, load, or attack partway through its movement and then keep moving?
- Can a navy ship attack more than one pirate in a turn?
- Can a pirate attack another pirate ship?
- Does a pirate earn 2 doubloons even when the merchant it robs does not sink?
- Where do the 2 doubloons for a sinking or an attack come from?
- Does Fast Loading trigger again when a sunk merchant re-enters and then delivers?
- Is movement mandatory, or can I move fewer spaces than the movement card allows?
Development cards
- Can a pirate use the Pirate Hideout card more than once in one move?
- Can a pirate enter the board directly onto a pirate hideout?
- Can you use all of your flipped development cards every round?
- Can you pick a different ship to receive the Tide Tables bonus each turn?
- What does the False Colors development card do?
- How does the Expert Crew card let you use two movement cards?
Playing fortune cards
- How much do Extra Order fortune cards pay when more than one is played on one delivery?
- Does the Extra Order bonus still apply if the goods go to a different port?
- Can a Naval Breeze and Duplicate Order together move both navy ships 4 spaces?
- Can a ship moved by Lucky Winds pass through your own ships?
- Are fortune cards one-use or permanent?
- Does the Secret Orders 3-doubloon bonus require playing Duplicate Order?
- What does Whirlwind do, and must the two swapped ships be adjacent?
- Can Whirlwind swap two ships that belong to opponents, or a navy ship?
- Can you play a fortune card in the middle of a ship's movement?
- Do fortune cards played in one turn stack their effects?
- Do two Mercantile Breeze cards played in one turn add together?
- Can Mercantile Breeze be combined with Freak Winds?
- Can Lucky Winds move an opponent's ship that is off the board?
- Does playing Lucky Winds stop my own ships from taking actions?
- How do Freak Winds and Expert Crew work together?
End of Turn
- When is the required fortune-card discard made, and can you play cards first to avoid it?
- Is there a limit on how many fortune cards you can hold?
- How many fortune cards does a movement card make you draw?
- Does Weather Forecast's extra draw happen before discarding the fortune card a movement card requires?
- After playing Expert Crew, how many movement cards do you draw?