RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
Bay Area Regional Planner thumbnail

Bay Area Regional Planner

Bay Area Regional Planner Rulebook

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

  • Components
  • Your Objective
  • Setup
  • Zoning
  • Round Structure
    • 1. Start Each Round by Drawing an Economy Card
    • 2. Decide Where to Upzone
    • 3. Adjust Commute and Rent Based on Total Bay Area Housing Surplus/Shortfall
    • 4. Adjust Commute Based on New Development in the Outer Counties
    • 5. Advance Year Marker by 1 Space and Start Next Round
  • Economy Cards
  • Goal Cards
  • End of Game

Components

Contents of the game as listed on the rules page:

  • 1 board
  • 1 set of rules
  • 13 Goal Cards
  • 14 Economy Cards
  • 4 Commute Time counters
  • 1 Median Rent counter
  • 1 Year Counter
  • 6 Upzoning markers
  • 108 Zoning Tiles

The print-and-play pages also include the printable sheets for the Zoning Tiles (R-1, R-2, R-3, C-4, C-5, D-6, D-7, D-8, C-2 and Open Space squares), the Rent and Commute counters, the Upzoning markers and the board. These sheets carry no rules text beyond their labels.

Your Objective

You will be given cards, each with two policy goals, which may include keeping commute times low, lowering rent, or preserving open space and existing neighborhoods.

Every round, you and the other players will decide where new development occurs in the Bay Area. Don't worry about how the other players do - consider it a success if you're able to meet all but one of your goals at the end of the game. If you can get them all, even better!

Three reminders appear on the rules page:

  • Shorten commutes and make rent cheaper by building extra housing to create a regional surplus.
  • New housing away from downtown will increase commutes in the county it's built in.
  • Depending on the economy, 50,000-300,000 new homes are needed each round, for a total of approx. 2 million new homes by the end of the game.

Setup

  1. Set the Bay Area Median Rent counter at $2200.
  2. Set the Commute Time counters for the four outer counties on the corresponding circles.
  3. Distribute Goal Cards face up among players.
  4. Shuffle Economy cards and place face down.

Goal Cards per player

# of Players2-345-67+
Cards per Player4321

For a more challenging game, distribute some or all of the extra goal cards to the more experienced players.

Zoning

Each square on the board is a zoning tile. Zone types are:

  • "R" Residential zones (R-1, R-2, R-3): building new or adding density to bedroom communities that aren't next to jobs has a major impact on commuter traffic.
  • "D" Downtown zones (D-6, D-7, D-8): major job centers. Adding housing in or adjacent to downtowns does not have any impact on traffic.
  • "C" Commercial zones (C-2, C-4, C-5): office parks or mixed use shopping streets with housing above. New housing in or next to C zones have a minor traffic impact.
  • OS (Open Space): the green zone shown at the start of the Upzoning Pathway.

Each zone tile shows its zone type and, in thousands, the number of housing units it holds. Not all squares contain housing units. The printed examples show that two squares are adjacent when they share an edge, and not adjacent otherwise.

Round Structure

THERE ARE 12 SIMULTANEOUS ROUNDS, EACH REPRESENTING 2 YEARS.

There are no individual player turns - everyone makes decisions together.

Each round proceeds in this order:

  1. Start each round by drawing an Economy card.
  2. Decide where to upzone.
  3. Adjust commute and rent based on total Bay Area housing surplus/shortfall.
  4. Adjust commute based on new development in the outer counties.
  5. Advance Year marker by 1 space and start next round.

1. Start Each Round by Drawing an Economy Card

Draw an Economy card and read its New Housing Demand and Maximum Upzoning. The Maximum Upzoning on the current Economy card is the highest new zone that may be placed this round.

2. Decide Where to Upzone

  • Up to 6 squares may be upzoned each round. Each square may only be upzoned once per round.
  • Upzoning brings a zone up one level (i.e. from C-2 to R-3 or from R-1 to R-2). See Upzoning Pathway.
  • Anyone can suggest any number of upzonings at any time.
  • Everyone must be in agreement for a square to be upzoned. Place the new zone and an upzoning marker on the square to indicate that it is a newly upzoned square.
  • You can't upzone any squares in Marin.

Upzoning Pathway

The zone types run in this order, with the number printed on each zone giving its housing units in thousands:

  • Open Space (OS)
  • R-1 (25), R-2 (50), R-3 (75)
  • C-4 (100), C-5 (150)
  • D-6 (200), D-7 (250), D-8 (300)

C-2 sits off the main line of the pathway and is shown with an arrow to R-3. OS leads to R-1.

The highest new zone that may be placed this round is specified on the current Economy card.

3. Adjust Commute and Rent Based on Total Bay Area Housing Surplus/Shortfall

  • If total housing units added was less than the new demand: for every 25,000 units short, move rent up 1 space, and commute time in all counties up 1 space.
  • If total housing units added was greater than the new demand: for every 25,000 units surplus, move rent down 1 space, and commute time in all counties down 1 space.

If commute time reaches 55 minutes in any county, or if Bay Area Median Rent reaches $3000, game ends and everyone loses.

4. Adjust Commute Based on New Development in the Outer Counties

This step applies to the outer counties: Alameda (AC), Contra Costa (CC), Santa Clara (SC), and San Mateo (SM).

  • No impact if upzoning took place on or adjacent to an existing D zone.
  • +1 min: each upzoning that is on or adjacent to an existing C zone but not on or adjacent to an existing D zone increases commute by 1 minute in the county it's in.
  • +2 min: each upzoning that is not on or adjacent to an existing C or D zone increases commute by 2 minutes in the county it's in.

Note: Adjacent is defined as sharing an edge. Existing means the square was already a C or D zone at the start of the round.

5. Advance Year Marker by 1 Space and Start Next Round

Game ends at the end of the 2038 round.

Economy Cards

There are 14 Economy cards. Each shows a name, a New Housing Demand and a Maximum Upzoning:

  • Recession (3 cards): New Housing Demand 50,000 units. Maximum Upzoning R-2.
  • Economic Boom (3 cards): New Housing Demand 200,000 units. Maximum Upzoning D-8.
  • Bubble? or is it different this time? (3 cards): New Housing Demand 300,000 units. Maximum Upzoning D-8.
  • Standard Economy (5 cards): New Housing Demand 100,000 units. Maximum Upzoning D-6.

Goal Cards

There are 13 Goal Cards. Each card carries two goals, numbered x.1 and x.2. The goals are listed below by number, with the two goals on each card together.

Goals 1.1 and 1.2

  • Goal 1.1 - Protect View Corridors: No C-5 or D zones in Alameda County
  • Goal 1.2 - Commute under 40 minutes in Alameda County and Santa Clara County

Goals 2.1 and 2.2

  • Goal 2.1 - Save the East Bay Hills: At least 5 R-1 zones and 5 OS zones in Alameda County
  • Goal 2.2 - Commute under 40 minutes in Alameda County and Contra Costa County

Goals 3.1 and 3.2

  • Goal 3.1 - Keep Small Towns Small: No more than 4 C or D zones total in Contra Costa & Santa Clara Counties combined
  • Goal 3.2 - Commute under 40 minutes in Santa Clara County and Contra Costa County

Goals 4.1 and 4.2

  • Goal 4.1 - Protect Natural Habitat: No more than 2 Open Space (OS) zones upzoned anywhere
  • Goal 4.2 - Commute under 40 minutes in San Mateo County and Contra Costa County

Goals 5.1 and 5.2

  • Goal 5.1 - Maintain supply of single family housing: At least 8 R-1 zones in Contra Costa County.
  • Goal 5.2 - Commute under 40 minutes in San Mateo County and Contra Costa County

Goals 6.1 and 6.2

  • Goal 6.1 - Minimize new shadows: No D-8 zones anywhere
  • Goal 6.2 - Commute under 40 minutes in Alameda County and Contra Costa County

Goals 7.1 and 7.2

  • Goal 7.1 - Protect Neighborhood Character: At least 10 original R-2 zones and 2 original C-2 zones remaining
  • Goal 7.2 - Commute under 40 minutes in Santa Clara County and San Mateo County

Goals 8.1 and 8.2

  • Goal 8.1 - Lower median rent to $1600 or less
  • Goal 8.2 - Commute under 40 minutes in Santa Clara County and San Mateo County

Goals 9.1 and 9.2

  • Goal 9.1 - Save SF's Historic Neighborhoods: At least two R zones in San Francisco
  • Goal 9.2 - Commute under 40 minutes in Santa Clara County and Alameda County

Goals 10.1 and 10.2

  • Goal 10.1 - Don't urbanize the Peninsula: At least 5 R-1 zones in San Mateo County
  • Goal 10.2 - Commute under 40 minutes in Alameda County and San Mateo County

Goals 11.1 and 11.2

  • Goal 11.1 - Protect rent controlled housing stock: At least 4 original R-3 zones remaining
  • Goal 11.2 - Lower median rent to $1800 or less

Goals 12.1 and 12.2

  • Goal 12.1 - Save San Francisco's Unique Cultures: No changes to at least 2 zones in San Francisco
  • Goal 12.2 - Lower median rent to $1800 or less

Goals 13.1 and 13.2

  • Goal 13.1 - Save the Trees: No more than 2 Open Space (OS) zones upzoned anywhere
  • Goal 13.2 - Lower median rent to $2000 or less

End of Game

  • The game ends at the end of the 2038 round.
  • If commute time reaches 55 minutes in any county, or if Bay Area Median Rent reaches $3000, game ends and everyone loses.

Editorial note: the printed setup does not state where the Year Counter starts. The year track on the printed board runs from 2016 to 2038, which matches 12 rounds of 2 years each.