RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
Battles with the Gringos, Mexico 1846-62 thumbnail

Battles with the Gringos, Mexico 1846-62

Expansion for Gringo!: The Mexican War 1846-48

Battles with the Gringos, Mexico 1846-62 Rulebook

Table of Contents

Table of Contents

  • New Rules and Rules Specific to This Expansion
    • Series Rules Additions
      • (3.0) Sequence of Play
      • (14.4) Skirmishers
      • Errata Applying to All Scenarios
  • Palo Alto
    • Historical Background
    • Map, Duration and Balance
    • Changes to the Series Rules
    • Special Rules for the Battle of Palo Alto
    • Optional Rules
    • Initial Deployment
    • (7.0) Victory
  • Resaca de la Palma
    • Historical Background
    • Map, Duration and Balance
    • Changes to the Series Rules
    • Special Rules for the Battle of Resaca de la Palma
    • Initial Deployment
    • (7.0) Victory
  • Contreras
    • Historical Background
    • Map, Duration and Balance
    • Changes to the Series Rules
    • Special Rules for the Battle of Contreras
    • Initial Deployment: Historical Scenario
    • Initial Deployment: Hypothetical Scenario
    • Victory: Historical Scenario
    • Victory: Hypothetical Scenario
  • Puebla
    • Historical Background
    • Map, Duration and Balance
    • Changes to the Series Rules
    • Range Effects
    • Initial Deployment
    • (7.0) Victory Conditions
  • Range Effects Chart Errata

New Rules and Rules Specific to This Expansion

Series Rules Additions

These rules are added to the GBACW rules in the GRINGO! battle book, pages 9 and following.

(3.0) Sequence of Play

ADD to II. Order segment:

  • E. Skirmisher Creation/Merging. Eligible units may adopt the Skirmisher formation or merge into their parent unit (see 14.4).
  • II.B. A player with a chain of command running from the Overall Commander (OC) down to a subordinate Commander may change the orders of any subordinate Commander included in that chain of command.

C and D are not used.

(14.4) Skirmishers

(14.41) Regular infantry units may detach up to 2 Strength Points (SP) as skirmishers (SK). Each SP detached forms 1 SK. They may form during Order segment II/E, Skirmisher Creation/Merging, from units that are not Disordered and are under Advance Orders.

(14.42) To form a skirmisher unit, remove the necessary SP as a step loss from the parent unit, then place the skirmisher units (SK) in the hex from which they were formed. They may leave that hex during their movement from then on.

(14.43) Skirmishers may not stack with any other unit – including other skirmishers – except their parent unit. They do not count toward stacking limits while in the hex of their parent unit.

(14.44) Skirmisher units that begin the merging procedure with their parent unit may be absorbed at the player's discretion.

Note: Players must keep a written record of the parent units of their skirmishers.

(14.45) Skirmisher units move more easily and suffer fewer SP losses from enemy fire.

  • They use the SK column on the movement/terrain tables.
  • They may use Reaction movement like cavalry.
  • They do not benefit from road or track bonuses.
  • When they fire, subtract one (−1) from their fire die result.
  • When they are targeted, subtract two (−2) from the enemy fire result.
  • They may not deliberately move so as to become adjacent to an enemy unit.
  • They may not engage in Shock under any circumstances.
  • If they are engaged in Shock, their enemy gets +1 on its Shock die roll (but see 14.46).

(14.46) If a skirmisher unit is the target of a Shock, it may, instead of defending, Disperse during the Pre-Shock Retreat phase (11.33). This also applies against enemy cavalry attacks. A skirmisher unit may not disperse if it is Disordered. When a skirmisher unit (SK) Disperses:

  • It is retreated 2 or 3 hexes from its current position, directly away from the enemy unit threatening it. It may retreat through any friendly unit, any terrain, and/or enemy frontal hex.
  • After the retreat, it is automatically Disordered.
  • It may not fire before dispersing, and 11.35 applies.

(14.47) Skirmishers are always under Advance Orders.

(14.48) Skirmisher units without enough movement to rejoin their parent unit at the start of their movement are Out of Command and may not move.

Errata (GMT Revised Errata, Part 4, Skirmishers clarifications):

  • Mexican skirmishers are marked "PA". They may be used in Contreras, but not for the initial deployment. They may also be used in the Gringo! scenarios.
  • 14.43: Skirmishers can stack with their parent even when it is stacked with artillery.
  • If a skirmisher's parent unit is eliminated, the SKs can become that parent unit by stacking together (exception to 14.43). Immediately replace the Skirmishers with the parent unit at the SP level of the combined SK (Collapsed if necessary).
  • 14.45: Skirmishers may move through friendly units without penalties.

Errata Applying to All Scenarios

The following Part 1 corrections of the GMT Revised Errata (version 10/16/19) apply to all scenarios of all three games (GRINGO!, Battles with the Gringos and Churubusco).

8.37 (addition).

  • Sections of the same battery need not stack together.
  • When stacked, treat artillery as separate batteries for UDDs and Rally rolls. When small-arms fire targets stacked artillery, assign any SP losses randomly.

10.63 (addition). Stacked sections of the same named battery may combine fire at canister ranges. The generic Mexican batteries (those identified only by battle; example, "CG") may not.

Palo Alto

Historical Background

Palo Alto, Texas, 8 May 1846. Please consult the history of the period published in the battle book of the GRINGO! box.

Map, Duration and Balance

Map. The Palo Alto map is at a scale of 120 yards (about 110 m) per hex.

Duration. The game is played until one of the players wins (see below). A game lasts about 3 hours.

Balance. The Mexican forces are twice as numerous as the US forces and have much more cavalry than they do. However, the Americans have a serious advantage in their artillery. Moreover, their commanders are much more aggressive than their Mexican counterparts (see 5.1), mainly because Arista (correctly) understands the Mexican strategy and posture, which is defensive in essence. All of this gives the US forces an advantage – not decisive, but enough to make them the favourites.

Changes to the Series Rules

(3.0) Sequence of Play. II.A. Efficiency is not used. See the changes to §5.2 below. B, C and D are not used.

(4.0) Command. There is no Army Commander and no Corps Commander. There is an Overall Commander (OC) and Brigadiers. The OC may move only during the Commander Movement Phase (IV/A).

(4.3) There are no Artillery Commanders.

(5.0) Activation.

  • (5.1) US forces add two (+2) to their initiative die roll.
  • (5.2) Efficiency is not used in this battle.
    • US forces always receive 3 Army Activation Markers (AM) each turn.
    • Mexican forces receive 3 Army AMs each turn in which they have the initiative. Otherwise, they receive 2.
  • (5.3) When an Army Activation Marker (AM) is drawn, its player may activate all of his side's units, not just some of them. The only exception is the Overall Commander (OC), who may move only during the Commander Movement Phase (IV/A).
  • (5.34) Brigade Coordination is not used.
  • (5.36) Units are never Out of Command.
  • (5.4) Efficiency Transfer is not used.

(6.0) Orders System.

  • (6.1) It is not possible to adopt March Orders in this battle. Only Advance and Attack Orders are used.
  • (6.3) The rule on Reserves is not used.

(10.0) Fire.

  • (10.5) Mexicans may not use Prepared Fire.

  • (10.61) Mexican artillery may not move and fire in the same phase.

  • (10.8) Mexicans subtract one (−1) from all their fire die rolls for conventional weapons. (13.0) Morale and Rally.

  • (13.3) Division Combat Efficiency is not used.

(14.0) Special Units.

  • (14.2) Mexican cavalry may not be dismounted.

(15.0) Engineering. This section is ignored. Nobody may build barricades.

(17.0) Fatigue. If you want to add a little more realism to your game, we suggest using this rule. However, the results of Fatigue apply to each individual infantry unit and not to Brigades. All units begin the battle with no Fatigue level.

Special Rules for the Battle of Palo Alto

(9.4) Chaparral. It was extremely difficult to move through the chaparral.¹ Therefore, only infantry units and Commanders (not cavalry, mounted or dismounted, nor artillery) may enter a chaparral hex. In addition, as soon as an infantry unit enters a chaparral hex during its activation, the player must make a UDD at the end of its movement.

  • UDD failure: loss of 1 SP.
  • UDD success: no effect.

Design note: units moving through the chaparral tend to disintegrate, some men drifting away and ending up lost.

¹ NdT: a kind of scrubland formed of bushes and brushwood found in California and Mexico.

Errata (GMT Revised Errata, Part 4, Palo Alto & Resaca de la Palma): the TEC is incorrect for Chaparral. Cavalry cannot enter Chaparral, per 9.4. Infantry may enter but must UDD for possible Step Loss. If a Step Loss occurs, the unit is automatically Disordered. Skirmishers may enter Chaparral without penalty.

(10.23) Line of Sight. The following block line of sight:

  • Light woods and chaparral. Units may fire into woods/chaparral but not through them.
  • Combat units. Line of sight may not be traced through other combat units.

Play note: there is only one elevation level (although there is in fact a ridge where the map ends, around hex 1532).

(11.5) Cavalry Charge. Certain Mexican cavalry units are Lancers (marked with an "L" on the counter). When they charge (11.51), they receive a +1 DRM in addition to any other bonus due to the Charge. This DRM does not apply to a Counter-Charge or to a normal attack or defence.

Historical note: although most regular Mexican cavalry used lances, not all regiments had them. The elite company of the regiment was equipped with them, while the remaining companies were equipped to fire with escopettes, whose range was deplorable.

(14.5) Independent Units.

  • Auxiliary Mounted of Las Villas del Norte. This was a local militia without a commander. It appears that it acted as a bodyguard for Arista, did not take part in the action during the battle, and is treated as an independent unit in the game. It begins the game under Advance Orders, and if the player wishes to change its orders he must subtract three (−3) from the order change roll (III/C/1). Any "Loose Cannon" result is treated as "Guard and Hold".
  • US Dragoons. They begin the game Mounted, under Advance Orders, and if the player wishes to change their orders they must add two (+2) to the order change roll (III/C/1). Any "Loose Cannon" result is treated as "Aggressive".

(14.7) US Supply Wagons. Wagons move like artillery units. Wagons may stack with one (1) combat unit. An enemy unit attacking by Shock a wagon that is not stacked with other units eliminates it automatically, without other consequences for the attacker (no automatic Disorder, no fatigue, no Continuous Shock).

Optional Rules

Note: the following rules improve historical accuracy at the cost of added complexity.

Mexican ammunition supply problem. Toward the end of the battle, at about 17:00, the Mexican cannons began to run short of ammunition (their ammunition train was far too distant to resupply them at the end of the day). Players wishing to recreate this problem must use rule 10.9, but applying it to artillery only. Rule 10.92 does not apply to the Mexicans.

Grass fire. In the middle of the afternoon, the enormous field of tall grass separating the belligerents caught fire, no doubt as a result of sparks thrown by the wadding of the cannons (NdT: a tampion, a plug of rope that served as wadding to hold the charge of a muzzle-loaded gun). An enormous wall of smoke rose in front of both armies and caused a pause in the fighting, during which the belligerents took advantage to reposition themselves (both sides made a 90° anticlockwise rotation). The battle continued while the fire burned out and the smoke drifted south.

To simulate this, whenever a US battery obtains a natural '9' on an artillery resolution die roll at a range of 4 or more hexes, the player checks for the start of Grass Fire. He then rolls the die once more, and if he obtains another '9', a Grass Fire starts. The game then stops for a Pause.

During the Pause, the players roll the die to determine who begins. The higher result wins (re-roll ties). That player may then move all or part of his units from their potential movement at that moment, provided they do not end within four (4) hexes of an enemy unit. When this player has finished his movement, the other player does the same.

When both players have moved their units, the game resumes with the drawing of an AM.

Initial Deployment

Mexican Army of the North

(All units are under Advance Orders.)

Hex(es)Unit(s)Hex(es)Unit(s)
1115-6Arista (OC); Auxiliary Mounted of Las Villas del Norte (2 units)1321Diaz de La Vega [c]
1004-5Canales [a]; Ranchero cavalry (2 units)14226th Infantry
1509Presidial Cavalry14231st Infantry
1510Torrejon; 7th Cavalry1424(3) 4-pounders
15118th Cavalry1425(2) 4-pounders

Notes:

  • [a] Canales. General Antonio Canales was a very good commander for guerrilla fighting, excelling at border raids, and for that reason was cordially hated by the Texans. However, this was not the case on a battlefield. This may be because, while he fought with the Mexican Army, he tried by roundabout means and negotiations with the United States government to be placed at the head of a local potentate. Historical sources, modern and otherwise, say that he "…was as sly as he looked" (see the character "El Supremo" in the film Hornblower).
  • [b] Light Detachment. The origins of this "Light Detachment", made up of a squadron of 35 men, are difficult to pin down. Some historical sources say that it came from the 1st Cavalry, but it was probably a squadron detached from the Light Mounted Regiment of Mexico, the latter being used to guard the Mexican right flank (a mission without combat).
  • [c] Vega. Vega is in command of the entire Mexican right wing. Indeed, there is no information about the presence of a third general subordinate to Arista. Ampudia was there, but it would seem he did not exercise a command at the level of La Vega or Garcia. It should nevertheless be noted that Ampudia's arrival almost coincided with the start of the battle. He brought with him the 4th Infantry, a company of Sappers, the two 8-pounders and the troops of Canales, all of which roughly formed Arista's Mexican left wing. One could speculate that Ampudia took command of these formations… but no information confirms it.
  • [d] We have inscribed the name "Tampico Veteran" on the counter representing this unit to distinguish it from the other Tampico Coast Guards.
  • [e] Sappers or engineer unit. One of the elite units of the Mexican Army.

US Army of Occupation

(All units are under Advance Orders.)

Hex(es)Unit(s)Hex(es)Unit(s)
3014-5Twiggs; 5th US Infantry3024A, 2nd US Artillery [2 units – 3 x 6lb and 1 x 12lb]
3016C, 3rd US Artillery [2 units] [a]3025, 3125Belknap; 8th US Infantry [1/8, 2/8]
3017-83rd US Infantry [1/3, 2/3]3217Taylor (OC)
3019Churchill's Artillery (18-pounders) [b]3214May's Company of the 2nd Dragoons (Mounted)
3020-1Garland; 4th US Infantry [1/4, 2/4]3416Ker's Company of the 2nd Dragoons (Mounted) [d]

Notes:

  • [a] The famous Flying Artillery battery of Samuel Ringgold, probably the most effective unit on the battlefield that day. Tragically and somewhat ironically, Ringgold was killed at Palo Alto when a Mexican cannonball landed between his thighs (and his horse). A rather macabre anecdote, it is true.
  • [b] Churchill's 18-pounders were on wagons drawn by oxen. This made them rather difficult to move during a battle.
  • [c] B, D and E, 1st US Artillery; C and K, 2nd US Artillery; A and I, 3rd US Artillery. D, E and I, 4th US Artillery being used as infantry.
  • [d] Depending on the historical sources, the family name "Ker" is not misspelled.
  • [e] Named at its formation the Corps of Observation. Before Polk decided to make official his grip on part of Mexico, the designation of Taylor's troops had been changed, more appropriately, to that of Army of Occupation.
  • [f] Use the counters marked "B" or "PA".

(7.0) Victory

Taylor tries to move south; Arista is there to prevent him. Each army wants to push the other to Retreat. An army must retreat when it has accumulated enough Retreat Points (RP) that, added to the result of a die roll (taking into account the vicissitudes of command), take it beyond its limit. The player makes a Retreat roll at the end of each turn in which the sum of his RP plus a die roll could take him beyond his RP limit.

US Army. The US player receives Retreat Points for the following:

  • 2 points for each Strength Point (SP) of infantry and/or cavalry eliminated or routed.
  • 3 points for each artillery unit (whatever its strength) eliminated/routed.
  • 1 point for each Disordered unit on the map.
  • 5 points for each wagon eliminated/routed.

Mexican Army. The Mexican player receives Retreat Points for the following:

  • 2 points for each Strength Point (SP) of regular infantry and/or cavalry eliminated or routed.
  • 1 point for each Strength Point of an independent cavalry unit, Presidial cavalry or Ranchero cavalry eliminated/routed.
  • 1 point for each artillery unit (whatever its strength) eliminated/routed.
  • 1 point for each Disordered unit on the map.
  • 1 point for each US Strength Point that leaves the map through hex 1008.

Commanders, Detachments and SK are not counted in the calculation of Retreat Points. The player with the fewer Retreat Points subtracts one (−1) from his die roll.

The Mexican Army retreats when the final result (RP + die roll) is greater than 50.

The US Army retreats when the final result (RP + die roll) is greater than 40.

If both armies retreat in the same turn, the Mexican player wins.

Resaca de la Palma

Historical Background

Resaca de la Palma, Texas, 9 May 1846. Please consult the history of the period published in the battle book of the GRINGO! box.

Map, Duration and Balance

Map. The Resaca de la Palma map is at a scale of 120 yards (about 110 m) per hex.

Duration. The game is played until one of the players wins (see below). A game lasts about 3 hours.

Balance. Once again, the Mexican forces are twice as numerous as the US forces. The Mexican losses are offset by the fact that Taylor left the artillery/infantry of Child, as well as Ker's Dragoon regiment, behind on his rear to guard the supply wagons. Moreover, the Mexicans are in a place and a situation that gives them prodigious defensive advantages. However, the soldiers are starved, tired and demoralised, and therefore in poor shape to defend themselves properly, even though they did so vigorously, but too late to change the course of the battle against aggressive Americans, intoxicated by victory after the clash at Palo Alto. If you decide to play the historical scenario, the US player is strongly favoured. However, we propose a good number of alternative historical situations which make the chances almost equal.

Changes to the Series Rules

(3.0) Sequence of Play. II.A. Efficiency is not used. See the changes to §5.2 below. B, C and D are not used.

(4.0) Command. There is no Army Commander and no Corps Commander. There is an Overall Commander (OC) and his subordinates (Commanders leading quasi-brigades). The OC may move only during the Commander Movement Phase (IV/A).

(4.3) There are no Artillery Commanders.

(5.0) Activation.

  • (5.1) US forces add two (+2) to their initiative die roll. See also the rule on Arista below.
  • (5.2) Efficiency is not used in this battle.
    • US forces always receive 3 Army Activation Markers (AM) each turn.
    • Mexican forces receive 3 Army AMs each turn in which they have the initiative. Otherwise, they receive 2.
  • (5.3) When an Army Activation Marker (AM) is drawn, its player may activate all of his side's units, not just some of them. The only exception is the Overall Commander (OC), who may move only during the Commander Movement Phase (IV/A).
  • (5.34) Brigade Coordination is not used.
  • (5.36) Units are never Out of Command.
  • (5.4) Efficiency Transfer is not used.

(6.0) Orders System.

  • (6.1) It is not possible to adopt March Orders in this battle. Only Advance and Attack Orders are used.
  • (6.3) The rule on Reserves is not used.

(10.0) Fire.

  • (10.5) Mexicans may not use Prepared Fire.
  • (10.61) Mexican artillery may not move and fire in the same phase.
  • (10.8) Mexicans subtract one (−1) from all their fire die rolls for conventional weapons.

(13.0) Morale and Rally.

  • (13.3) Division Combat Efficiency is not used.

(14.0) Special Units.

  • (14.2) Mexican cavalry may not be dismounted.

(15.0) Engineering. This section is ignored. Nobody may build barricades.

(17.0) Fatigue. If you want to add a little more realism to your game, we suggest using this rule. However, the results of Fatigue apply to each individual infantry unit and not to Brigades.

  • US units begin the battle without Fatigue.
  • For the Mexicans, see the rules below on Mexican Fatigue.

Special Rules for the Battle of Resaca de la Palma

(5.34) Brigade Coordination is not used.

(4.0) Command. There is no Army Commander and no Corps Commander. There is an Overall Commander (OC) and his subordinates (Commanders leading quasi-brigades). The OC may move only during the Commander Movement Phase (IV/A).

(5.36) Units are never Out of Command.

(5.4) Efficiency Transfer is not used.

(6.0) Orders System. (6.1) It is not possible to adopt March Orders in this battle. Only Advance and Attack Orders are used. (6.3) The rule on Reserves is not used.

(4.25) Mariano Arista. The commander of the Mexican forces was not a bad general; nor a good one either. At the battle of Resaca he was a poorly informed general, busy in his tent with some paperwork, while his second-in-command, Pedro de Ampudia, like Iago in Othello, kept letting him believe that the gunfire he heard was only skirmishing.

To simulate this, Arista begins the game Misinformed (Under Tent). This status has the following effects:

  • US forces automatically have the initiative.
  • Arista may not move.
  • Any attempt to change orders suffers a −2 DRM in addition to any other modifier.

When Arista is Alerted (the Under Tent marker is replaced by Arista's counter), all of the above penalties are cancelled. To Alert Arista, the Mexican player rolls one die at the end of his turn (in the Commander Movement Phase, IV/A).

  • On a result of 0 or 9, Arista is Alerted.
  • On a result of 1-8, Arista continues to write notes under Ampudia's influence.

Arista is also Alerted as soon as a US unit comes within 3 hexes of Arista's tent.

(4.29) US Flanking March. This rule covers the flanking march of the US troops through the chaparral to the west, around the Mexican left flank. The American player may designate one of his regiments (1 or 2 battalions) as engaged in a flanking march. These units are considered to be in command, except that they suffer no DRM when attempting to change orders. Moreover, any "Loose Cannon" result is treated as "Guard".

(9.4) Terrain and Movement.

Chaparral. It was extremely difficult to move through the chaparral. Therefore, only infantry units and Commanders (not cavalry, mounted or dismounted, nor artillery) may enter a chaparral hex. In addition, as soon as an infantry unit enters a chaparral hex during its activation, the player must make a die roll at the end of its movement.

  • If the die roll is higher than the unit's Cohesion, it loses one SP.
  • If the die roll is lower than or equal to the unit's Cohesion, there is no effect.

This die roll is not required for Detachments (6.9).

Design note: units moving through the chaparral tend to disintegrate, some men drifting away and ending up lost.

Errata (GMT Revised Errata, Part 4, Palo Alto & Resaca de la Palma): the TEC is incorrect for Chaparral. Cavalry cannot enter Chaparral, per 9.4. Infantry may enter but must UDD for possible Step Loss. If a Step Loss occurs, the unit is automatically Disordered. Skirmishers may enter Chaparral without penalty.

Resacas. The Resacas – two furrows north and south of the "lagoon" – are all that remains of an old river: a wide depression made up of pools, muddy water, brush and intertwined palm trees, the whole bounded by a slippery bank with shrubs rising between 3 and 5 feet (between 1 and 1.65 m) high. This constituted, de facto, entrenchments for the Mexicans. Only infantry may enter Resaca hexes. It costs one additional MP (+1) to leave a Resaca hex to enter another type of terrain.

Historical note: Bauer indicates that the depth of the Resaca was between 10 and 12 feet (between 3 and 4 m), which does not agree with the other historical sources nor with the course of the battle.

Errata (GMT Revised Errata, Part 4, Resaca de la Palma): the Resaca TEC omits costs for mixed Resaca/Woods hexes. Those costs are 3 for Infantry, 2 for Skirmishers, and 2 for Leaders.

(10.2) Line of Sight. The following block line of sight:

  • Light woods and chaparral. Units may fire into woods/chaparral but not through them.
  • Combat units. Line of sight may not be traced through other combat units, unless the firing unit is situated higher.

(10.8) Resacas / "Lagoon".

  • Units firing from a non-Resaca hex at a target situated in a Resaca hex suffer a DRM of −2. The reverse situation carries no penalty.
  • Artillery situated in a non-Resaca hex may not fire at units situated in a Resaca hex unless it is adjacent to a Resaca hex. However, artillery may not fire downward at an adjacent unit.
  • There is no penalty or DRM when firing from a Resaca hex to a non-Resaca hex.

Example: artillery at 5417 cannot fire at a unit at 5517, but it may fire at one at 5717. Guns at 5317 may not fire at any unit located in a Resaca hex.

Play note: there are only two elevation levels: the Resaca (low) and the non-Resaca (high).

Errata (GMT Revised Errata, Part 4, Resaca de la Palma): all three bullets of 10.8 apply both to Resaca hexes and Lagoon hexes. Apply 10.8's −2 DRM for firing at a unit in a Resaca hex from a non-Resaca hex, instead of the Resaca TEC's −1 DRM.

(11.5) Cavalry Charge. Certain Mexican cavalry units are Lancers (marked with an "L" on the counter). When they charge (11.51), they receive a +1 DRM in addition to any other bonus due to the Charge. This DRM does not apply to a Counter-Charge or to a normal attack or defence.

Historical note: although most regular Mexican cavalry used lances, not all regiments had them. The elite company of the regiment was equipped with them, while the remaining companies were equipped to fire with escopettes, whose range was deplorable.

(14.5) Independent Units. The 2nd Dragoons of May. This unit begins the game Mounted, under Advance Orders. If the player wishes to change its orders, he adds two (+2) to the order change die roll. Any "Loose Cannon" result is treated as "Aggressive".

(14.6) Mexican Detachments. The Mexicans had 5 detachments, each formed of 15 to 20 men drawn from other units. Detachments are treated as skirmishers (14.4), but they have no specific parent unit and therefore cannot merge with other units.

Initial Deployment

Historical Mexican Deployment. This deployment is faithful to the historical situation and may be used for solitaire or head-to-head play.

Mexican Army of the North [f]

(All units are under Advance Orders.)

Hex(es)Unit(s)Hex(es)Unit(s)
5915Arista (OC, Under Tent; see rules above)55136th Infantry
6017(4) 4-pounders (2 units of 2 each)551210th Infantry [2 units]
6114Canales [a]; (2) Ranchero cavalry [2 units]5510-11Sappers [2 units]
5015, 5218, 5921, 5623, 5205(5) Detachments, 1 in each hex55061st Infantry
53142nd Light Infantry [b]6719Presidial Cavalry
5315(3) 4-pounders, (1) 4-pounders, (2) 8-pounders (artillery)

Notes:

  • [a] We know that Canales and his Rancheros were present, but exactly where is a good question. They do not seem to have taken part in events, and it is possible they were left on the left of the line. However, some historical sources do place them at the position indicated.
  • [b] The 2nd Light Infantry was placed at the position indicated, then moved to 5507-8, but it is not known exactly when.
  • [c] The 4th Infantry was placed at the position indicated at the start of the battle, but rejoined a position behind the Resaca, to the right of the Tampico battalion.
  • [d] See the rules on Mexican command.
  • [e] Diaz de la Vega was the general captured during the charge of the 2nd Dragoons, a scene very popular with both artists and the public. Much glory for Charles May, captain of the 2nd Dragoons. Unfortunately, it was not he who captured him, but his bugler.
  • [f] Use the counters marked "PA".

Historical US Army of Occupation Deployment. This deployment is faithful to the historical situation and may be used for solitaire or head-to-head play.

Army of Occupation of the United States of America

(All units are under Advance Orders.)

Hex(es)Unit(s)Hex(es)Unit(s)
4620, 47202 units of Skirmishers [b]4225C, 3rd US Artillery [2 units] [d]
46212nd Dragoons of May4226Belknap; infantry 1/4 and 2/4 [e]
4323Garland, infantry 1/3 and 2/34126Infantry 1/8 [b] and 2/8
4324Infantry 1/5 and 2/5 [c]Hex of choiceTaylor (OC)

Notes:

  • [a] The artillery regiment of Child, the Dragoons of Ker and battery A of the 2nd Artillery remained in the rear to guard the supply wagons, thereby reducing the strength of Taylor's troops by an amount equal to the losses suffered by the Mexicans at Palo Alto.
  • [b] One of the Skirmishers comes from the 1/4, the other from the 1/8 US. Reduce these units accordingly. We are not sure of the origin of these 220 men deployed as Skirmishers, but they were under the command of Lieutenant Mc Call of the 4th Infantry, which gives some indication of their origin.
  • [c] Units commanded by Twiggs at Palo Alto.
  • [d] Commanded by Lieutenant Randolph Ridgley.
  • [e] Part of Garland's Brigade at Palo Alto.
  • [f] Named at its formation the Corps of Observation. Before Polk decided to make official his grip on part of Mexico, the designation of Taylor's troops had been changed, more appropriately, to that of Army of Occupation.
  • [g] Use the counters marked "B" or "R".

Alternative Initial Deployment. This deployment allows players to explore an alternative historical situation. The game will probably be more balanced.

Transcriber's note: the source prints the heading and description of the alternative deployment, but its unit entries are not printed as a separate grid. The grid above, with its notes [d] to [g], is transcribed as printed in the source.

Determining the US Entry Hexes. The US player records in writing whether his army will enter via hexes 4126 or 4408. He may bring his units on, when he decides, in the order and formation of his choice.

Mexican Initial Deployment. The Mexican player then places his units. All of his units (the 5 Detachments included) listed in the Historical Deployment are available. He may deploy them in any hex(es) south of and including row 5100.

Historical note: the Mexicans do not seem to have been aware, except when it was too late, that the approach via 5434-6921 was militarily viable. It may be useful to keep this data in mind if you want to recreate the Mexican state of mind on that day.

Optional Hidden Mexican Deployment. This option recreates the atmosphere of Taylor's advance toward the Resaca. It also gives an advantage to the Mexicans.

Note: to be considered hidden, a unit must be deployed in wood or chaparral hexes. Place units on the map only when they are revealed. Record their position in writing. Units may move and remain hidden as long as they do nothing that could reveal them (which requires a minimum of honesty and a written record of the units' positions).

Revealing hidden units. A hidden Mexican unit is placed on the map as soon as:

  • it fires;
  • it moves more than 1 hex during its activation;
  • it is spotted.

Once revealed, a unit can no longer recover its hidden status.

Spotting hidden units. A US unit that ends its movement two hexes from a hidden unit, and has a clear line of sight to it, spots that hidden unit, even if it is in chaparral.

Example: a US unit at 4819 could not spot a hidden unit at 4916. However, if it moves to 4918 and stops, it has spotted the Mexican unit.

Mexican Command. Mexican command is determined at the start of each Mexican turn as follows:

  • All units east of the road 4126-6918 are under the command of Diaz de la Vega.
  • All units west of the road 4126-6918 are under the command of Garcia.
  • Torrejon commands all Mexican cavalry except the units belonging to Canales.

Mexican Losses. The Mexicans lost about 250 men at Palo Alto, but the units that lost them are not known. To reflect these losses, roll one die for each Mexican unit, except the artillery, the Light Mounted Regiment of Mexico and the Auxiliary Mounted of Las Villas del Norte.

  • If the result is 0-2, remove one Strength Point (SP) from the unit.
  • If the result is 3-9, there is no effect.

Mexican Fatigue. The Mexican army deployed at Resaca was in poor condition. It was starved, tired and demoralised, three factors which cancelled the defensive advantages of the terrain in its possession. Those who want to replay this battle with the greatest historical fidelity should use the Fatigue rules (17.0). For each Mexican unit, roll a six-sided die and subtract 1 from the result; referring to 17.24 gives the unit's initial Fatigue level (so no unit will begin the game at Fatigue level '4').

Example: for a die roll of '3', the unit would have a "Fatigue 0" marker placed on it.

Transcriber's note: the printed example does not follow the wording exactly (3 minus 1 is 2, not 0); it is transcribed as printed. Check 17.24 of the series rules when applying it.

(7.0) Victory

Taylor tries to move south; Arista is there to prevent him. Each army wants to push the other to Retreat. An army must retreat when it has accumulated enough Retreat Points (RP) that, added to the result of a die roll (taking into account the vicissitudes of command), take it beyond its limits. The player makes a Retreat roll at the end of each turn in which the sum of his RP plus a die roll could take him beyond his RP limit.

US Army. The US player receives Retreat Points for the following:

  • 2 points for each Strength Point (SP) of infantry and/or cavalry eliminated or routed.
  • 3 points for each artillery unit eliminated/routed.
  • 1 point for each Disordered unit on the map.

Mexican Army. The Mexican player receives Retreat Points for the following:

  • 2 points for each Strength Point (SP) of regular infantry and/or cavalry eliminated or routed.
  • 1 point for each Strength Point of Presidial cavalry or Ranchero cavalry eliminated/routed.
  • 1 point for each artillery unit eliminated/routed.
  • 1 point for each Disordered unit on the map.
  • 1 point for each US Strength Point that leaves the map through hex 6919.

Commanders, Detachments and SK are not counted in the calculation of Retreat Points. The player with the fewer Retreat Points subtracts one (−1) from his die roll.

The Mexican Army retreats when the final result (RP + die roll) is greater than 45. The US Army retreats when the final result (RP + die roll) is greater than 35.

Contreras

Historical Background

Mexico, 20 August 1847. General Winfield Scott was steadily pursuing his advance toward Mexico City. Santa Anna was determined either to stop him before he reached the city, or to make him lose so many men that he would no longer be able to reach his objective. To this end, he sought to fortify the various approaches to the capital, all converging at Churubusco.

Reluctantly, he sent Major General Gabriel Valencia with the Army of the North, about 5,000 men, to guard the most westerly approaches. It was reluctant because the two men were political enemies; moreover, Santa Anna had little confidence in a man who sought to supplant him and whose military abilities he considered insufficient. According to the historian Justin Smith, Valencia had "…a neck as thick as a bull's, anchored deep in his shoulders, as if someone had tried to drive a good idea into his skull with a jackhammer."

Valencia deployed his army on a high plateau, his left wing overlooking the Northern road. (On his right, the Northern road was a causeway of boggy soil guarded by Mexican artillery, which made the approach difficult.) He knew that to the East the approach to his left wing was apparently blocked by the pedregal, a basalt mass studded with rocks and crevasses that most military experts considered impassable. The terrain most favourable to an assault (via the Padierna farm) was easy to channel for the defence. But this position was isolated and without support if the Americans managed to outflank it and launch the assault from another direction. That is what the Americans did.

We have mentioned "without support", but on 19 August Santa Anna and the veterans of Perez's "light" infantry brigade, together with 3,500 cavalrymen, had taken up positions on hills north of Valencia's army, and could have played a role in the battle. Santa Anna, doubtless for a multitude of bad reasons and without information on the intentions of the attackers, decided to withdraw his troops before the battle began the following morning.

Meanwhile, a small group of reconnaissance troops and sappers commanded by Lieutenant Robert E. Lee accomplished a feat by opening a path through the pedregal, allowing 4 of Scott's brigades to outflank Valencia's positions from the North (in game terms, they would enter via hexes 3904 and 3914) before halting for the night at the village of San Geronimo. It seems that some reserve units of General Salas, placed between the villages of Ansaldo and Peloncaohutitlin, noticed the presence of American troops at San Geronimo. They fired on them with cannon, but the guns were too small in calibre and the distance too great to cause any damage (in game terms they would have fired with a DRM of −4). The Mexicans estimated that they were dealing with reconnaissance troops and not an attack unit. Was Santa Anna not supposed to be there to prevent this kind of intrusion?

It is difficult to determine precisely who was at the head of the US troops that day. Indeed, Scott did not arrive before the 20th and followed the battle from an imposing hill east of Padierna. Scott had in fact placed Gideon Pillow at the head of the American army. The latter does not seem to have been the driving force of that day, although the arrangement of the US troops in two divisions was his work. On the ground, the true leader was Brigadier General Persifor Smith, placed with the troops at San Geronimo. In any case, since everyone claimed paternity of the victory, it is difficult to say exactly who did what.

Be that as it may, on 20 August, just before dawn, the Americans, some 3,500 strong, launched the assault from the south-western end of Peloncaohutitlin. They had discovered a ravine running from San Geronimo toward a position further south of Valencia's forces. This path, partly hidden, had allowed them to outflank the Mexican army, which, its morale low following Santa Anna's withdrawal, knew nothing of the American manoeuvre. Valencia had posted Colonel Mendoza's brigade to guard the southern end of his line, but there were neither men nor artillery on the hill at the south-western end of Peloncaohutitlin. The bayonet attack of the 4th Artillery regiment (used as infantry) under Colonel Bennet Riley completely surprised the already demoralised Mexican troops, who disintegrated almost immediately. They fled through their camp in total confusion, the men scattering in all directions without even trying to reform. In less than 20 minutes, Smith's surprise attack had completely annihilated and routed Valencia's army. The Mexicans lost 1,500 men (half of them captured), including 4 generals. On the American side, losses amounted to 60 killed and wounded. The Northern road leading to Mexico City via Churubusco was now open.

Churubusco was the next step, where the impatient and triumphant Americans would meet serious opposition from the Mexicans.

Historical note: the Mexicans call this battle the battle of Padierna, which is indeed more accurate than "Contreras", a small village further south that was not involved in the clash.

Map, Duration and Balance

Map. The map of Contreras de la Palma [sic] is at a scale of 120 yards (about 110 m) per hex.

Duration. The game is played until one of the players wins (see below). A game should last 1 hour for the historical scenario and more than 3 hours for the hypothetical scenario.

Balance. Given the historical result, the historical simulation is of little interest. Indeed, if one believes General Smith, who apparently timed the event, it took only 17 minutes for the American troops to rout Valencia's army. One of the reasons lies in Valencia's apparent ignorance of the position of the US troops, although some of his defensive dispositions contemplated the possibility of a flank attack. That is why two scenarios are proposed: one historical, in which the Americans play against the clock, and one hypothetical, which allows a freer deployment of the Mexicans as well as the grant of some additional troops. The hypothetical scenario is fairly balanced, although the solidity of the US troops and the excellence of their junior officers is an advantage in their favour.

Design notes: we chose to ignore the afternoon cannonade of 19 August (won by the Mexicans), the show of force by the US troops at Padierna, as well as the night manoeuvre, as remarkable and heroic as it was. The irregular Mexican units, the dismounted US cavalry and the artillery used as infantry have a movement allowance of 5. This reduced potential only reflects a lack of training in manoeuvre, not a lower speed.

Changes to the Series Rules

(4.1) Command.

(4.11) There is no, strictly speaking, US Overall Commander (OC), and the two Division Commanders are not used either. Brigadier General Persifor Smith is considered de facto the Overall Commander for the troops making the assault (see 5.2 below).

(5.0) Activation.

  • (5.2) Efficiency, in the terminology of the GBACW rules, is not used in this battle. When a player's Army Activation Marker (AM) is drawn, he may activate all his Commanders. The only exception is that the Overall Commander (Santa Anna or Valencia, according to the AM used) moves only during the Commander Movement Phase (IV/A).
  • US Efficiency: US forces always receive 3 Army AMs each turn. However, only Commanders within the command range of Brigadier General Smith may be activated automatically. Any Commander out of range is activated by a die roll. Roll one die and add the Order value of the Brigadier General in question:
    • 0-2: units under his command may not move, fire or make any attack whatsoever.
    • 3-6: units under his command may move half of their movement allowance (rounded down). They may fire but may not become adjacent to an enemy unit. If they already are, they may fight by Shock.
    • 7+: units under his command are activated normally.
  • Mexican Efficiency: Mexican forces receive 2 Army AMs per turn from Valencia, except on the first turn, when they receive 1 (see also the optional rule on Santa Anna below). Commanders within Valencia's command range may be activated automatically. If not, roll a die and use the table above.

Play note: if you play the hypothetical scenario, the Mexican player does not take into account the limitation of 1 Army AM on the first turn.

(5.34) Brigade Coordination is not used.

(5.36) Units are never Out of Command, except for the special case listed in the paragraph on US and Mexican Efficiency.

(5.4) Efficiency Transfer is not used.

(6.0) Orders System. (6.3) The rule on Reserves is not used.

(10.0) Fire.

  • (10.5) Mexicans may not use Prepared Fire.
  • (10.61) Mexican artillery may not move and fire in the same phase.
  • (10.8) Mexicans subtract one (−1) from all their fire die rolls for conventional weapons.

(14.0) Special Units.

  • (14.2) Mexican cavalry may not be dismounted. Dismounted cavalry (the Texcoco volunteers) may not return to mounted status.

(17.0) Fatigue. If the battle had lasted more than 20 minutes, Fatigue might have been a factor to take into account for the Americans. Indeed, they had spent much energy and time getting into position, and their night had been difficult. If you want to add a little more realism and balance to your game, we suggest using this rule. However, the results of Fatigue apply to each individual infantry unit and not to Brigades.

  • Mexicans: the Mexicans begin the game without Fatigue (they are not at their best, but they are not tired).
  • US: US units begin the game with a certain level of Fatigue. For each unit west of Padierna, roll a six-sided die, subtract 4 from the result and consult rule 17.24: this is the unit's initial Fatigue level. A result of '0' or less means no Fatigue for the unit.

Play note: for the hypothetical scenario, this rule can be a balancing factor.

Special Rules for the Battle of Contreras

(5.1) Initiative. The Americans begin the game with the initiative. For subsequent turns, the US player adds three (+3) to his initiative die roll. For the hypothetical scenario, the modifier is +2.

(9.4) Terrain and Movement.

  • Elevations. There are 5 elevation levels. Changes of elevation are generally 1 between two different levels. Certain hexsides, called "slopes" (versants), involve a change of elevation of 2 levels. At many places on the map, this change of level is combined with the presence of watercourses. The movement costs for these hexes are cumulative (so crossing hexes 1923 and 2024 is particularly difficult).
  • Watercourses. A series of small but fast streams at the bottom of ravines criss-cross the battlefield. They may be crossed only by infantry, except where a road crosses them (e.g., 3020-1).

Design note: the mule track serving Padierna could have been used by artillery to cross the watercourse as well as the pedregal. However, as noted earlier, the Americans had no artillery for this battle.

  • The parapet. Valencia built a small earthen wall overlooking the path coming from Padierna, behind which he placed 9 siege guns (no historical source explains their presence). These guns had been useful earlier in the day on 19 August, because they enabled him to repulse 2 American batteries (which were firing from the East of Padierna at a range of several hundred yards).
  • The pedregal. A basalt mass studded with rocks and crevasses that most military men considered impassable. The terrain most favourable to an assault (via the Padierna farm) was easy to channel for the defence.
  • Haciendas and villages. Ansaldo and Padierna were important farms; San Geronimo was a peasant village. Apparently, the villagers did not think it useful to inform Valencia of the presence of more than 3,000 gringos in their village. Surprising.

(10.2) Line of Sight. The following block line of sight:

  • Terrain. The orchards and the village of San Geronimo block fire from a hex at the same level or lower.
  • Combat units. Line of sight may not be traced through other combat units, unless the firing unit is situated higher.

(11.5) Cavalry Charge. Certain Mexican cavalry units are Lancers (marked with an "L" on the counter). When they charge (11.51), they receive a +1 DRM in addition to any other bonus due to the Charge. This DRM does not apply to a Counter-Charge or to a normal attack or defence.

Initial Deployment: Historical Scenario

Historical Mexican Deployment. This deployment is faithful to the historical situation and may be used for solitaire or head-to-head play. It is a rather unbalanced situation.

Mexican Army of the North [f]

(All units are under Advance Orders and an orientation chosen by the player.)

Hex(es)Unit(s)
Hex of choiceMajor General Gabriel Valencia (OC)
2030, 2130, 2230, 2231General Francisco Mejia; 1st Line, Fijo de Mexico, San Luis Potosi Activos, Compania de Garde Nationale De Alcolhua [a]
2 hexes or less from 2725General Anastasio Torrejon; 2nd, 3rd, 7th and 8th Cavalry, San Luis Potosi Activos Cavalry, Guanajuato Activos Cavalry, Guanajuato Auxiliaries squadron, Texcoco Volunteers (dismounted) [b], (2) 4-pounders. General Anastasio Parrodi; 10th and 12th Infantry, Coast Guard Battalion of Tampico, Coast Guard Veterans of Tampico, (6) 8-pounders (2 units of 3). Lieutenant Colonel Cabrera; Celaya Auxiliaries, Celaya Activos, Guanajuato Auxiliaries, Queretero Activos. General J.M. Salas; Sappers; Aguas Calientes Activos, Mixto de Santa Anna, (4) 4-pounders, (6) 4-pounders [c]
3124-5, 2926, 3026-7Siege artillery: Mejia (3) 12-pounders; Mejia (1) 16-pounders; Mejia (3) 68-pounders and Parrodi (2) 68-pounders

Notes:

  • [a] 1st Brigade of the 1st Division. This rearguard group was in reality placed under the command of Colonel Nicholas Mendoza, commander of the 1st Infantry. It is not certain that all these units were present, but given the size of the brigade one may suppose so. One may then wonder what Mejia was doing, since he had no other infantry under his orders (his cavalry being with Torrejon). We have placed Mejia in charge of all these units.
  • [b] Foot units, which could not become mounted again.
  • [c] This was Valencia's "Reserve Division". It was deployed south of Ansaldo on 19 August, and it was Salas's light artillery that had opened fire on the Americans sighted at San Geronimo. Shortly afterwards, this unit joined the main body of the Mexican forces.

Historical US Deployment. This deployment is faithful to the historical situation and may be used for solitaire or head-to-head play. It is a rather unbalanced situation.

US Forces [f][g]

(All units are under Advance Orders and an orientation chosen by the player.)

Hex(es)Unit(s)
2 hexes or less of elevation 1 from PadiernaColonel Trueman Ransom (Brigade 1/3) [a]: 9th Infantry [2 units], 12th Infantry [b]
Any hex of elevation 1 south of 1424 and west of 1633BG George Cadwalder (Brigade 2/3): 11th Infantry, 14th Infantry, Voltigeur Regiment and Foot Riflemen Regiment. BG Persifor Smith (OC) (1/2): Mounted Rifles Regiment (dismounted) [2 units], 1st Artillery (used as infantry), 3rd Infantry. Colonel Bennet Riley (Brigade 2/2): 2nd Infantry [2 units], 7th Infantry, 4th Artillery (used as infantry) [c]. BG James Shield [d]: 2 NY Vol, 1 SC Vol
1 hex or less from 281015th Infantry [2 units] [e]

Notes:

  • [a] In reality the commander of the 1st Brigade was BG Franklin Pierce, future President of the United States. But the latter had fallen from his horse the day before, which prevented him from holding his post.
  • [b] On 19 August, these two regiments (with one battalion fewer) had infiltrated through the ravines west of Padierna and had outflanked Valencia's positions at Peloncoahutiltlin to find themselves south of it.
  • [c] The 4th Artillery led the initial assault.
  • [d] Shield's Brigade was supposed to be part of the Volunteer Division, but it fought for much of the war with the 2nd Division.
  • [e] Detached from Ransom's Brigade to Smith at the last minute, it was far too distant from the other regiments to take part in the battle.
  • [f] There are no Commanders above the level of Brigade. The Overall Commander, General Winfield Scott, arrived too late and watched the battle as a spectator. The two Division Commanders, Pillow and Twiggs, remained east of Padierna and had no influence on the battle.
  • [g] On 19 August, for a short time, Magruder's battery and Callender's rocket company were involved in a fruitless cannonade with Valencia's siege artillery. Too far to reach the Mexicans, they withdrew to rejoin Taylor's field artillery. No American cannon took part in the battle of 20 August. That is why no artillery counter is provided.

Historical Demoralisation. When Valencia's men learned that Santa Anna's troops had withdrawn (they had been on a hill at the northern end of the map on 19 August), demoralisation set in quite rapidly. Valencia raged against Santa Anna, shouting that he was a traitor. In the colourful writings of the historian Justin Smith, one can read: "The soldiers heard and echoed these howls. The women (Women? Yes, the soldier's trade also involves the warrior's rest) howled. The frightened horses (apparently very clever horses) broke their tethers and scattered into the night… The whole Army was now aware."

As a consequence, the men whom the Americans attacked on the morning of 20 August were not in the best psychological state to fight. To reflect this, treat any "Disorder" result (and not "d+#") or "Retreat" result suffered by a Mexican unit as a "Rout" result.

Play note: this rule is used only for the historical scenario, because it is a terrible handicap for the Mexicans' chances of victory. It does, however, reflect what happened in reality. Apply this rule exclusively to the historical scenario.

Initial Deployment: Hypothetical Scenario

This scenario depicts what could have happened if certain historical events had not occurred. This makes the game more interesting, and the battle becomes more balanced, but also more difficult for both sides.

American Attack Plan. The American player, knowing where Valencia has deployed the majority of his forces, must plan what he intends to do.

  • Colonel Ransom's Brigade, which begins near Padierna in the historical scenario, keeps its position.
  • All the other units may be placed according to the following indications (after the Mexican has deployed):
    • West of the watercourse that flows from 3906-1127.
    • A Brigade may be placed in an area up to 2 hexes from 1131.

Note: this deployment must be decided (in writing) before the Mexicans deploy. The American player deploys his units after the Mexican player has deployed his.

Mexican Deployment. Valencia's siege artillery, 9 guns placed near the parapet, is deployed according to the historical placement. All the other units may be deployed as the Mexican player wishes, in any hex of elevation level 3 or higher situated east of the watercourse 3906-1127. Ignore the Historical Demoralisation rule stated above.

The Santa Anna Option. If you want to make the game really difficult for the American, the Mexican player may attempt to use Santa Anna and his supposed reserves, which he had at his disposal on 19 August but chose to withdraw (for reasons unknown). The Mexican player therefore has:

  • Brigade of General Perez: 1st Light [2 units], 3rd Light [3 units], 4th Light [3 units] and the 11th Infantry [3 units].
  • The Hussars of the Guard of the Supreme Power and the Light Mounted Regiment of Veracruz (Santa Anna's escort). These units are in fact useless, since they cannot cross the watercourse. On the other hand, they have superb uniforms and a truly splendid name.

These units deploy in any hex of elevation level 3 north of the watercourse 3901-1012. Santa Anna has no effect on the battle other than commanding his escort cavalry. The Brigade of General Perez depends on Santa Anna only through the draw of its activation marker (AM) and the success of that activation, as indicated below.

There is indeed an AM for the potential use of Santa Anna. The Mexican player may decide to use it in place of one of his two AMs. If the Santa Anna AM is used and the player draws it, roll a die:

  • Result 6 or more: Santa Anna is activated.
  • Result 5 or less: Santa Anna remains inactive and the AM was drawn in vain.

Once activated, he may be used only by the draw of the Santa Anna AM. The AM of Valencia has no effect on Santa Anna's troops.

Design note: we included this possibility of activating Santa Anna but with a limitation. This reflects certain human and political factors which were ubiquitous and historically unavoidable.

Victory: Historical Scenario

United States. The American player will win this battle easily. To make it a challenge in game terms, the US troops must rout the Mexican army within two turns. At the end of these two turns, if this condition is not met, the American has lost. Not so easy after all… at least not as easy as in reality (the real battle, in game terms, lasted two turns).

Mexico. The Mexican army is in total rout when it has suffered a number of Retreat Points which, added to a die roll, exceed 60. The player makes a Retreat roll at the end of each turn in which the sum of his RP plus a die roll could take him beyond this limit.

The Mexican player receives Retreat Points for the following:

  • 2 points for each Strength Point (SP) of infantry and/or regular cavalry eliminated or routed.
  • 1 point for each artillery unit eliminated.

Victory: Hypothetical Scenario

Each army wants to push the other to Retreat. An army must retreat when it has accumulated enough Retreat Points (RP) that, added to the result of a die roll (taking into account the vicissitudes of command), take it beyond its limits. The player makes a Retreat roll at the end of each turn in which the sum of his RP plus a die roll could take him beyond his RP limits.

United States. The US player receives Retreat Points for the following:

  • 2 points for each Strength Point (SP) of infantry eliminated.
  • 1 point for each Disordered unit on the map.

Mexico. The Mexican player receives Retreat Points for the following:

  • 2 points for each Strength Point (SP) of infantry and/or regular cavalry eliminated.
  • 3 points for each artillery unit eliminated.
  • 1 point for each Disordered unit on the map.

The player with the fewer Retreat Points subtracts one (−1) from his Retreat die roll.

The Mexican Army retreats when the final result (RP + die roll) is greater than 70 (if Santa Anna is not activated) or 100 (if Santa Anna is activated). The US Army retreats when the final result (RP + die roll) is greater than 65.

Puebla

Historical Background

Mexico, 5 May 1862. Puebla was a key battle in the ongoing struggle between the French Imperial forces, supporting the affable but incompetent Emperor Maximilian of Habsburg, and the local Republican opposition, often led by the Mexican national hero Benito Juárez.

In this war, the two sides had agreed on a truce, the wounded French remaining where they were, in neutral territory. Major General Lorencez, one of the least brilliant minds of the French command, misinterpreted rumours concerning the fate of these wounded and used this pretext to attack and try to take Puebla. His division, composed of more than 5,000 veteran regular troops (a number taking account of losses due to disease), decided to attack the city from the North, despite repeated warnings to attack from the East, which was less defended.

The Mexican troops, who seem to have been slightly outnumbered by the French, partly thanks to the reserve of Puebla, were veterans (of the Reform War two years earlier) and were better led and deployed. The French launched repeated assaults on the forts of Loreto and Guadalupe, the latter threatening to fall into their hands. The determined defence of the Mexicans, as well as forceful counter-attacks led in particular by the lancers, prevented the French from reaching their goal. When the rain arrived (in the middle of the afternoon) the French were beaten and they retreated (temporarily).

The Mexicans commemorate this somewhat surprising victory on their National Holiday, the Cinco de Mayo.

Map, Duration and Balance

Map. The Puebla map is at a scale of 100 yards (about 91 m) per hex.

Duration. The game is played until one of the players wins (see below). A game should last 3 hours or more.

Balance. The Mexicans are slightly more numerous than the French, but this is due to the rather ineffective presence of the Puebla Militia. On the other hand, the Mexicans have a real advantage in terms of command and positioning, which the French will have to overcome in order to win the battle. The battle is fairly balanced, and one cannot say that either side is more advantaged than the other.

Changes to the Series Rules

(5.0) Activation.

  • (5.1) Determine initiative normally. Use the Brigade Coordination value of Lorencez and Zaragoza as the DRM.
  • (5.2) Efficiency is not used. Both sides have 3 Army AMs each turn.
  • (5.3) When a player's Army AM is drawn, he may activate all his Commanders, even those not in command. The only exception concerns the two Overall Commanders (OC), Lorencez and Zaragoza, who may move only during the Commander Movement Phase.

(5.34) Brigade Coordination. Some formations exceed the size of a regiment. Whatever the number of units that make them up, they are treated as Brigades, except for:

  • French (Imperial): the Reserve Column, commanded by L'Heriller, consists of 3 regiments: the 1st Chasseurs, the 2/2 Marine Infantry Battalion, and 2 battalions of the 99th Infantry Regiment.

When L'Heriller is activated, each of the units listed above acts separately:

  • each regiment moves (and/or fires), then
  • each regiment engages in Shock.

L'Heriller's brigades may not combine these actions unless the player succeeds in doing so by rolling a die and consulting the Brigade Coordination Table. There are no Division Commanders to modify this die roll, but the Order value of L'Heriller may be used as a DRM.

Historical and design note: this reflects the better Mexican command, but also the fact that L'Heriller would have committed his reserves, the most powerful group in the division, slowly and piecemeal.

(5.36) Units are never Out of Command.

(5.4) Efficiency Transfer is not used.

(6.0) Orders System.

  • (6.1) It is not possible to adopt March Orders in this battle. Only Advance and Attack Orders are used.
  • (6.3) The rule on Reserves is not used.

(8.0) Stacking. (8.12) Only one unit may be in a Trench hex.

(9.0) Movement.

  • (9.4) Garita: a kind of fortified gate.
  • (9.4) Trench: the road between the two forts is a trench, used both for concealment and for defence. Units in a trench cannot be seen by other units situated at a lower elevation (and so cannot be fired on by them).
  • A Shock attack from any hex, except a trench hex, against a unit in a trench gives the defender a defensive modifier in its favour (see the combat tables).
  • Units moving out of a trench to engage in Shock against another unit have a DRM of +1 against it, unless they began their movement adjacent to it.

(10.9) / (10.94) Ammunition Supply (French artillery). As soon as a French artillery unit obtains a natural '9' on a fire die roll, it is at a "Low" ammunition level. Place a "Low Ammo" marker on it. If it was already at a Low level, it becomes "out of ammunition" and may no longer fire at all for the rest of the game.

Historical note: the French guns ran short of ammunition toward the end of the battle, a problem the Mexicans did not have.

(11.5) Cavalry Charge. (11.55) French cavalry receives a +1 bonus to its Shock roll; Mexican Lancers receive a +2 bonus.

(14.0) Special Units.

  • (14.2) Cavalry may not be dismounted.
  • (14.4) Skirmishers. Mexican infantry may not create Skirmisher units. All French units may, with the exception of the Marine infantry and the Marine Fusiliers.
  • (14.5) Independent Units. The French Chasseurs d'Afrique cavalry are "independent". They have no Commander. They begin the game under Advance Orders, and if the player wishes to change their orders, he must add one (+1) to the order change die roll. Any "Loose Cannon" result is treated as "Aggressive".

(17.0) Fatigue. If you want to add a little more detail to your game, we suggest using this rule. However, the results of Fatigue apply to each individual infantry unit and not to Brigades. All units begin the battle with no Fatigue level.

Historical note: Fatigue does not seem to have been an important factor in this battle. What ended the French attack was the combination of the fierce Mexican defence repelling the French, vigorous counter-attacks and… the rain. The rain began at 15:00, and it was a sign to Lorencez that nature, the gods or whatever it is were against him, and that it was definitely not his day.

Range Effects

Because the Puebla map is at a slightly different scale (100 yards per hex, whereas the GRINGO! scale is about 120 yards per hex), the Range Effects Chart printed on the Puebla Terrain Effects Chart should be used.

Errata (GMT Revised Errata, Part 4, Puebla Range Effects Chart):

  • The weapon designation "MR" on French units stands for Minie Rifles. The chart should have said MR, not MIN.
  • Muskets at 2-hex range should be 0.
  • Minie Rifles at 2-hex range should be +1.

Initial Deployment

Historical Mexican Deployment. This deployment is faithful to the historical situation and may be used for solitaire or head-to-head play.

Mexican Republican Army of the East

(All units are under Advance Orders or Attack Orders, and their orientation is left to the player's choice.)

Hex(es)Unit(s)Hex(es)Unit(s)
Fort Loreto or in a TrenchBG José Rojo: Filio de Morelia Infantry, Tiradores de Morelio Infantry, 6th Infantry of Puebla [2 units], Battery of Fort Loreto (two 12-pounders, two Mountain Howitzers)1 hex or in 2516BG Porfirio Diaz [a]: 1st and 2nd battalions of Oaxaca National Guards, 3rd Morelos Infantry Battalion, 4th Guerrero Infantry Battalion, 5th Patria (Independencia) Infantry Battalion
Fort Guadalupe or in a TrenchCol. Ignacio Alatorre: Mixed Infantry of Queretao [sic], 2nd Infantry of Puebla, 6th National Guard of Puebla (Zacapoaxtla), Morelia Cazadores Battalion, Battery of Fort Guadalupe (two 12-pounders, two Mountain Howitzers)Anywhere south of the road 2714-4213BG Antonio Alvarez: Grenadier mounted Carabiniers of Pachuca, 1st squadron of Toluca Lancers, Oaxaca Lancers squadron
2110-2211Sappers Battalion [2 units]In PueblaCol. Juan Mendez: Militia companies (of Telela, Xochapulco, Zacapoaxtla and Apulco) [2 units], 2nd Battalion Lerdo de Tejado [2 units], National Guard Battalion of Tepeaca [2 units]

Notes:

  • [a] Future president (some would say dictator) of Mexico.

Historical French Deployment. This deployment is faithful to the historical situation and may be used for solitaire or head-to-head play.

French Division of Emperor Maximilian

(The French deployed in 3 attack columns (2 of which were in fact in support of the main column), plus a reserve which was used to feed fresh troops into the assault. All units are under Advance Orders or Attack Orders, and their orientation is left to the player's choice.)

Hex(es)Unit(s)Hex(es)Unit(s)
2803-2902Col. Hennique: 1/2 Marine Infantry Regiment [2 units]1 hex or in 3602Col. L'Heriller [a]: 1st Chasseur Battalion [3 units], 2/2 Marine Infantry Regiment [4 units], 1st [3 units] and 2nd [3 units] battalions of the 99th Regiment, 2nd Marine Battery, section 'b'
3102-03, 3202-4, 3303Col. Gambier: 1/2 [3 units] and 2/2 Zouaves [2 units], 1/9 Battery (4) 4-pounders [2 units of 2 each], 2nd Marine Battery section 'a'Hex of choiceGeneral de division Charles Ferdinand Latrille, Comte de Lorencez (OC)
3405, 3504-5Col. Allegre: Marine Fusiliers [2 units], Naval Mountain Howitzer Battery [2 units]
2602Chasseurs d'Afrique 'a'

Notes:

  • [a] This is the unit of Colonel Gambier that set up with L'Heriller. You may choose with which formation this unit activates. One counter is supplied for L'Heriller and Gambier. Use only one of them.

Design note: there is debate about the artillery each side had. Some historical sources give the French 4-pounders and 12-pounders, while others give them 4-pounders and mountain howitzers. According to accounts of the battle, Lorencez opened the engagement with a barrage at a distance of 2,000 yards (1,828 m), which is rather a long distance for 4-pounders (but not impossible to reach). The effect of this barrage was, to say the least, minimal.

(7.0) Victory Conditions

Automatic Victory. The French player wins automatically by fulfilling one of the following two conditions:

  • occupy both forts;
  • occupy one of the forts and at least 4 hexes of the city of Puebla.

If one of these two conditions is met at the end of any Mexican turn, the game stops and the French have won.

Victory by Retreat. Victory by retreat is determined by counting the Retreat Points (RP) accumulated by each side. At the end of each turn (although this is not necessary during the first turns) carried out by a player, both sides roll a die, to which they add the RP accumulated so far. If this result exceeds the Retreat Point Threshold defined for its army (see below), that player has lost the game. If both players exceed this total, they may agree by mutual consent to a draw. If they do not wish to, the game continues.

Retreat Points are awarded for the following conditions:

  • 2 points for each Strength Point (SP) of infantry and/or cavalry eliminated.
  • 3 points for each artillery unit eliminated (whatever its strength).
  • 1 point for each Disordered unit on the map.

The French subtract 5 RP from their total for each fort hex they occupy at the time of the count.

Retreat Point Thresholds.

  • French threshold: 75
  • Mexican threshold: 90

Design note: many amusing films (sometimes overacted) deal with this period. My favourite is "Vera Cruz" with Burt Lancaster and Gary Cooper. The film "Juárez", with Paul Muni in the title role and Bette Davis playing the truly tragic figure of the Empress Carlota, is also interesting.

Range Effects Chart Errata

Errata (GMT Revised Errata, Part 4, Range Effects Chart for Palo Alto, Resaca, and Contreras, correction): the +2 for Muskets at 2-hex range should be −2.

1512(1) 4-pounder1426Coast Guard veterans of the Tampico company [d]
1513Light Cavalry Detachment [b]1427Garda Costa di Tampico
1319Garcia14282nd Light Infantry
1417-184th Infantry1429-30Sappers [e]
1419(2) 8-pounders1431(2) 4-pounders
1420-2110th Line1432Light Mounted Regiment of Mexico [b]
3022-3ChldArt a&b [c]3519-21Wagons (3 units)
6717
Light Mounted Regiment of Mexico; Torrejon
5818-194th Infantry [2 units] [c]67167th Cavalry
5815Veterans of Tampico, Guardacosta de Tampico67158th Cavalry
6524, 6625Auxiliary Mounted of Las Villas del Norte [2 units]
Hex of choice [d]Garcia, Diaz de la Vega [e]
1 hex or in 2213BG Francisco LaMadrid: Reforma Infantry, San Luis Rifle Battalion [2 units], 2 artillery brigadesHex of choiceMajor General Don Ignacio Zaragoza (OC)
1 hex or less from 2215BG Feipe Berriozabal: 1st Fijo de Vera Cruz Permanente Infantry Battalion, 1st Toluca Light Infantry Battalion [2 units], 3rd Toluca Light Infantry Battalion [3 units]
3906Chasseurs d'Afrique 'b'