Battle of Honey Springs
Battle of Honey Springs Rulebook
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
- Game Components & Scale
- Counter Information
- Markers
- Preparation for Play
- Sequence of Play
- Officers
- Command Activities
- Operational Actions
- Artillery Operations
- Movement
- Reinforcements
- Attack from March
- Stacking
- Zones of Control (ZOC)
- Combat
- Artillery Combat
- Cavalry Combat
- Army Cohesion
- Victory
- Honey Springs, July 17, 1863
- Alt-History
- Historical Commentary
Game Components & Scale
Map
Each map shows an entire battlefield and surrounding countryside. Terrain is overlain with a hexagonal grid to simplify movement and combat resolution. One hex on the game map covers approximately 400 yards of ground from face to opposite face.
Time
Daylight Game Turns span one hour of real time. Dawn and Dusk Turns telescope 5–6 hours into one Turn to allow for administrative activity, rest and the difficulty of travel or combat in darkness.
Units
Each counter represents a maneuver unit, HQ or leader. Symbols or numbers identify strength, speed and type, and identify the unit's Chain of Command.
Counter Information
Unit Type
Infantry, Cavalry & Artillery units are shown by symbols for crossed rifles, blanket roll or cannon ball. HQ fronts feature Tents; the reverse Wagons or Cavalry Escort. Indian unit symbols include stylized arrows.
Officer Formation ID
Officer & units of a formation have unique letters or numerals on the counter face, and a colored band across the counter's lower face. Units directly subordinate to the Army Commander have no formation ID. Honey Springs, Creek units have no formation leader, so that only Cooper & Walker may command them. Watie commands Cherokee units when he is present.
Size
Units are Sections [••], Batteries [I], Battalions or Squadrons [II] or Regiments [III].
Brigade affiliation
A name or letter to the left of the Unit Type symbol denotes the unit's Brigade.
Colored Backgrounds
US units are generally blue, Confederates grey. Cavalry have a yellow fill to their unit type symbol.
Combat Value
Combat Value (CV) points rate unit fighting strength. A CV point is about 80–100 infantry. CV reflects superior tactics or leadership in a few elite units. Very green or poorly led units, like most of Cabell's AR Bde, are weaker than manpower might indicate.
Artillery CV measures close range combat power (cannister or rapid fire ball) at ranges of 400 yards or less, @1 CV per cannon, adjusted for shot size & other variables.
Cavalry CV assume up to 25% horseholders for dismounted combat. Some cavalry units are only equipped with pistols & sabres and suffer accordingly. General HQs are specialized cavalry or train units to which special rules apply.
Movement Value (MV)
Shows the relative speed of units over the course of one Game Turn. Movement rates reflect time for dressing ranks, waiting for orders, rest breaks, confusion and combat. Most cavalry action is assumed to be dismounted or to include time to prepare terrain for mounted charges. Road and Forced Marches are modeled explicitly.
Other Information
A unit's reverse shows characteristics which change with unit Disorder: Artillery lose Long Range Fire capability, Cavalry Combat value decreases and its Movement value increases.
Officers may Rally units in Disorder. Otherwise they do not command or coordinate them.
Unit ID's are listed for historical interest.
Officers
Each Officer counter represents one senior officer and a few aides and couriers.
Officers are identified by a name, photograph and rank symbol – stars for US leaders and stars & wreath for CS officers. Minor Leaders substitute a battle flag.
Army Commander. The senior officer present on the game map is the Army Commander [p. 4].
Formation Leader. Officers or Minor Leaders command "formations".
Minor Leader. Minor Leaders are junior officers given independent missions during the battle. In Honey Springs, all Officers except Blunt, Cooper & Watie are Minor Leaders to reflect lack of training, experience and staff.
Officer Efficiency Rating. Officer counters have an Officer Efficiency Rating of 1 or 2 in the lower left corner.
Formation ID. Formations are identified by a letter and a uniquely colored band on leader & unit counters.
Markers
Markers remind players of game functions. Included markers are not game limiting factors – make additional ones as necessary. See Marker types, next Page.
Game Markers (key printed on p. 4): Game Turn; Player Turn & Weather (Clear Weather, Rain); Army Demoralized; 5 Nations Demoralized; Council of War; Fatigue 5N; Fatigue C; Cabell Demoralized; Formation Fatigue; Operations Order; Artillery Survey; Hasty Works; Rally; Reorganize; Loot.
Dimmed Markers are not used in Honey Springs.
Preparation for Play
Choose a scenario. Decide if Alternate History options will be used. Place At Start units, officers & markers as listed in the Scenario instructions. Remove units lost prior to the start of the Scenario. Scenarios list arrival times for reinforcements. Alternate History options may remove or add units. Begin play.
Sequence of Play
Game Turns are resolved in the order given below, except that the game begins at 10am on the Union Player Turn. There is no 10am Confederate Turn.
Confederate Player Turn
Command Activity Phase
Officer placement: Place Officers on the game map. Officers remain in place until wounded, overrun or the next Friendly Command Activity Phase.
Determine Officer Availability
Officer Actions: Place Officer Action markers (Artillery Survey, Rally) on any Officers engaging in those activities.
Movement Phase
The Confederate Player moves any or all units as desired, subject to all applicable restrictions and paying costs determined by command, weather or terrain restrictions. During Movement, units may execute Attacks from March.
Combat Phase
The Confederate Player executes all attacks and implements outcomes in any order he chooses. When combat outcomes call for losses or retreats, the owner of the unit(s) involved chooses from any permitted options. Make advances or retreats after combat immediately following the combat that generates them.
Union Player Turn
The Union Player executes an identical sequence.
Turn Record
Advance the Game Turn marker on the Turn Record Track. Game continues til the end of the Dusk turn.
Victory
Scenario Victory Conditions determine the winner.
Officers
Officers represent commanders or subordinates capable of independent action on the battlefield. Officer types include Army Commanders, Formation Leaders, and Minor Leaders.
Chain of Command
An Officer may command units which are in Good Order and in command range.
Good Order
A unit is in Good Order if not on its Disordered side at the beginning of the current Player Turn.
Command Range
Reduced range typicaly reflects too few, inexperienced or inept staff officers.
-
An Officer may command all units in his placement hex, provided at least one unit eligible by rule 2, below, is also present in that hex.
-
An Officer may command to the limit of his Command Range if one of these relationships exist:
- The Army Commander, the senior officer on board, may command any unit or train.
- An officer may command a unit of his Formation.
- Tandy Walker may command any 5 Nations unit.
- An officer commands an Army Train if he commands its escort.
- An officer may command attacks involving units eligible as described above, and any 1 other friendly Artillery unit firing at Long Range.
Command range for Officers is up to 3 hexes (2 intervening hexes) between officer and subordinate unit, unless further defined by Special rule.
Minor Leader command range is always 1 hex.
Officer Seniority
Federal: 1 Blunt; 2 Judson; 3 Phillips.
Confederate: 1 Cooper; 2 Cabell; 3 Watie; 4 Walker.
Officer Efficiency
Officers are rated on a scale of 0 (standard), 1 (energetic or experienced), or 2 (excellent). Leader ratings influence the commander's availability and quantify his tactical skill.
Officer Placement
An Officer's placement hex identifies the area where his attention is focused. Markers note major officer actions.
Army Commander must place in compliance with the first priority below for which he qualifies:
- Up to 9 hexes from his current location.
- Up to 9 hexes from his deployed HQ.
- In the same hex as his mobile HQ.
- Up to 9 hexes from a LOC hex.
Formation and Minor Leaders must place in compliance with the first priority below for which he qualifies:
- Up to 9 hexes from his current location.
- Up to 6 hexes from any subordinate unit.
- In the same hex as a deployed Army HQ.
- Up to 9 hexes from a LOC hex.
To place "up to 6 or 9 hexes" from a point, trace a path across passible terrain from start to placement hex. The path must stop at the first enemy ZOC encountered. If the start location is in an enemy ZOC, the officer may only place at that location.
Instead of placing, any Officer may choose to be unavailable for the Game Turn.
Availability
Test officer availability, beginning with the Army Commander, after every officer is placed.
An officer is available if a modified roll of 1 die plus his officer efficiency rating totals 4 or more. Placing on a deployed HQ modifies the roll by +1.
When an Army Commander is available, he may modify the availability die roll of one or two of his subordinates by a total amount equal to his own efficiency rating. [e.g. Blunt may assign 0 or 1 point to subordinate leaders' availability rolls.] To benefit, officers must place within 3 hexes of the Commander's location, OR if the Army Commander is at his HQ, he may modify the availability of any officer to whom he can trace a movement path free of impassible terrain or enemy Zones of Control [see page 7].
Removing an Officer from the Map
A senior officer's time is full of things that don't show in the game. Listening to intelligence reports, orders from superiors, arranging for ammo resupply, and so on. Officers also get caught up in combat and can't break free.
Officers are removed from the map if:
- They are not Available after Placement.
- The officer is alone in an enemy Zone of Control at the end of any Movement or Combat Phase.
- An enemy unit enters the officer's hex by movement, advance or retreat during combat.
Officer Casualties
Civil War Generals were often in the thick of fighting. When they became casualties, their replacements took time to become effective.
An officer who:
- commands an attack when an A Loss occurs or
- is in a hex with a unit which suffers a D Loss, or
- finds himself alone in a hex in an enemy Zone of Control,
...may become a casualty. Resolve the outcome from the Officer Loss Table of the Combat Results Table. Effects of Officer Loss.
Remove the Officer from play. If a Replacement Officer is available (on the reverse of the Officer counter) place the replacement 1D6 turns ahead on the Game Turn Track as a reinforcement.
Replacement Officer efficiency ratings reflect their relative unfamiliarity with the tactical situation. If a Replacement Officer becomes a Loss, remove the counter and place it ahead a further 1D6 turns.
Headquarters Units
Each Army has a HQ unit.
Effect: An Officer's availability die roll is increased by 1 if he is placed in the same hex as a deployed HQ.
Moving HQ's: A General HQ moves as an Army Train, a Cavalry HQ as cavalry. A HQ is always in Good Order.
Deploying HQ's: Deploying consumes an entire Move Phase in the Deployment hex. Deployed HQ's flip to a mobile HQ during a friendly Move Phase (at no MV cost) or as soon as an enemy moves adjacent.
Command Activities
Movement Command
Units not in a superior officer's command range at the start of a Movement Phase reduce their movement allowance by 1. Units moving only on roads or turnpikes and cavalry units are not affected.
Attack Command
An officer may command one attack per combat phase involving Good Order subordinates in Command Range. At least one attacker must be adjacent to the target. Attacks may include artillery firing at long range.
Commanded attacks receive a favorable odds shift equal to the commander's officer efficiency rating in addition to any other combat modifiers.
Operational Actions
An officer may undertake ONE operational action detailed below in each Game Turn, in addition to any movement or combat command. Place a marker with the officer to indicate the action chosen.
Rally
An officer may rally subordinate infantry from Disorder. Place the officer with the infantry, and a Rally marker. Infantry remaining in place return to Good Order at the end of the Movement Phase.
Cavalry and Artillery can Self-Rally or move.
Artillery Operations
Most artillerists lacked experience in the finer points of their trade. Some officers, especially Regulars with prewar artillery experience could direct artillery wisely.
An Officer may perform Artillery Survey.
Artillery Survey
Place an officer and an Artillery Survey marker with one or more Good Order artillery units. Units remain in place during the friendly Movement Phase.
A Survey becomes active at the start of the current Friendly Combat Phase. A Survey remains in effect while the hex is occupied by friendly artillery.
Artillery Fire Range is 6 hexes from a Surveyed hex.
Movement
During the Movement Phase, the active player may move units in any direction or combination of directions. Players may choose to move all, some or no units in any Movement Phase.
No enemy movement is allowed during a friendly movement phase. Only Attack from March combat can take place.
Units move individually from hex to an adjacent hex, paying the single highest movement cost associated with the terrain in that hex, plus the cost for crossing water hexsides. (see Terrain Effects). During Attack from March, a single stack begins and moves together, at the MV speed of its slowest unit.
[see also: road movement, below.]
If a unit lacks sufficient movement points to enter a hex, it may not do so. Movement points may not be accumulated or transferred. Units may move into or through hexes occupied by friendly units.
A unit may never enter a hex occupied by an enemy unit. A unit may enter a hex only occupied by an enemy Officer. The owner immediately removes the Officer from the map. Check for officer casualties.
Minimum Movement
Instead of other movement, a unit may move one hex, across any hexside and into any terrain passable by that unit type. This ends its move for the Phase.
Units may conduct Combat or Attack from March, across hexsides and into hexes only accessible by Minimum Movement.
Road Movement
Units moving into a hex along a road only pay the movement costs associated with the road regardless of other terrain. Exception: ZOC's.
A unit which uses its entire movement along any combination of Towns, Roads or Trails moves at its full printed MP. It is always under movement control.
Terrain Effects
Terrain Effects on Movement & Combat are outlined on the Terrain Effects Chart. (The Terrain Effects Chart is not included in this booklet.)
Reinforcements
Reinforcements enter play as indicated in the Scenario rules. Officer reinforcements are placed on the entry hex in the turn of entry. Command range for Reinforcements is measured to their entry hex.
Reinforcements may voluntarily delay entry until a later Turn. Units which are held off board may shift their entry hex by 1 hex for each 2 MP expended. Reinforcements may enter on the turn of shift, using whatever movement remains.
Entry expends the cost of terrain in the entry hex.
Forced March
An officer may personally supervise subordinate units arriving on the field as reinforcements. Place the officer at the entry point of a group of subordinates scheduled to arrive next Game Turn. Roll 1D6. Deduct the Officer's efficiency rating.
Effect
- 1 or less: Group enters in the current Turn.
- 2—4: Group enters during the current Turn, expending 1 extra Movement Points (MP).
- 5: Group enters during the current Turn, expending 1 extra MP. One entering unit (of the owner's choice) is eliminated due to straggling.
- 6 plus: Group enters on original schedule.
Forced marching units enter the map in Disorder.
This rule primarily exists to add uncertainty and cost to screening and delaying actions. It is also an incentive to try your share of those ill-planned hasty attacks that were such a feature of Civil War generalship.
Attack from March
- A single stack of Good Order Units may Attack from March during the friendly Movement Phase.
- All Attackers except supporting Artillery must begin and end movement in one single stack.
- One Artillery unit from the same formation may support an Attack from March by ranged fire.
- An Attack from March expends 1 MV from each attacker in addition to any other movement costs.
- Officers may command Attacks from March.
- Combat is resolved, with a -1 shift Defensive modifier, against all adjacent enemy.
- Outcomes are applied immediately.
- After resolution, including advance after combat, participants have finished their Movement Phase.
- Units ending their move adjacent to an enemy must fight in the following Combat Phase.
Stacking
4 units of any type or subordination may occupy a single hex at the end of a Movement Phase or after any advance or retreat during a Combat Phase.
Any number of units may traverse a hex during movement. Leaders & Markers never affect stacking.
Retreat After Combat
Units retreating after combat may not normally retreat to a hex that would be overstacked. If no other retreat is possible, retreating units suffer 1 Loss and survivors remain in place. [Combat Results Table.]
Zones of Control (ZOC)
A Zone of Control represents the area a unit defends by extending its formations, maneuver or fire. It also represents uncertainty as to an enemy's exact location and the defender's ability to maneuver to counter threats.
Zones of Control (ZOC) affect enemy movement and combat. Units are never affected by friendly ZOC's.
A ZOC exists in every hex adjacent to a combat unit [Exception: across impassible hexsides].
A unit exerts a ZOC at all times. Multiple units or sides may exert a ZOC into the same hex.
Officers & deployed HQ's have no ZOC's.
Units must stop moving on entering an enemy ZOC. Units which begin a Turn in an enemy ZOC may leave, but not enter another enemy ZOC during the same Movement Phase.
Units may move from one enemy ZOC to another only as a result of advance after combat. Units may not retreat into an enemy ZOC.
Units may not use Road Movement rate to enter an enemy ZOC. They pay other costs of terrain instead.
Combat
The Combat Results Table provides more detail. (The Combat Results Table is not included in this booklet.)
Combat occurs between adjacent units. Attacking artillery may support combat with Long Range Fire. Resolve combat using the Combat Results Table and the procedure below:
- Every enemy unit in a friendly ZOC at the start of the Combat Phase must be attacked.
- Every friendly unit in an enemy ZOC must attack some enemy.
- The attacker may freely distribute attacking units and may resolve attacks in any order.
- Each unit or leader may fight in one combat per Combat Phase.
- The combat strength of all defenders in a single combat are treated as one total. Exception: Counterbattery Fire [p8].
- At least one attacking unit, and all non-artillery units must be in the ZOC of all defenders. Other artillery in range and line of fire may participate.
- Defenders in more than one hex may be attacked as one Combat provided every attacker is adjacent to all defenders. Artillery Long Range Fire must also have a Line of Fire to all defenders.
Resolving Combats
- Compare the attacker's total Combat Value & Artillery Long Range Fire Value with the total Combat Value of all Defenders.
- Reduce the strength comparison to a ratio of Attacker vs Defender. Truncate to the nearest ratio found on the Combat Results Table (CRT).
- Truncation favors the Defender. (e.g. 13:7 = 3:2 Odds, 5:6 = 1:2 Odds.)
- Determine raw Odds before any modifications.
- An unmodified Combat Odds Ratio of less than 1:3 has an automatic outcome of AE. Odds Ratios in excess of 5:1 begin on the 5:1 column.
- Various conditions detailed on the CRT shift the column on which an attack is resolved. Determine the net shifts of all conditions and apply the result as a single odds shift. Eg. A 15:2 attack across a Creek is resolved as 5:1, shifted to 4:1.
- Odds ratios originally 1:3 or greater which are shifted below 1:3 are resolved on the 1:3 column.
- Roll 1 die. Cross-reference the result with the appropriate column of the CRT to find the Outcome.
- Defenders use the Covered Terrain rows of the CRT if they occupy terrain defined as Cover on the Terrain Effects Chart.
- Combat Outcomes vary in their effects among different unit types. See Combat Results Table.
Apply each Loss, Retreat or Advance completely, before resolving the next combat.
Artillery Combat
Combat involving artillery is resolved identically to other combat, with these exceptions:
- Artillery always defends with its Combat Value, never its Long Range Fire Value.
- Artillery units never advance after combat.
- Artillery firing Long Range Fire are not affected by most combat outcomes.
The Combat Results Table provides more detail.
Long Range Fire
Good Order Artillery may fire at a range of up to 3 hexes in the friendly Combat Phase alone, with other artillery or in coordination with other combat units adjacent to the target.
- Artillery in a Surveyed position fires up to 6 hexes.
- Long Range Fire in Honey Springs always uses an artillery unit's Long Range Fire Value.
- Artillery in an enemy Zone of Control may not use Long Range Fire.
- Long Range Fire cannot occur at Dawn or Dusk.
Counterbattery Fire
Artillery firing Long Range Fire may target all the artillery units in one hex, ignoring all other units.
Line of Fire
Artillery long range fire requires an unobstructed Line of Fire. Determine the most direct pathway from firer to target. Fire on this pathway is blocked only by hexes containing terrain defined as blocking on the Terrain Effects Chart (TEC). Firing to and from Hilltops and Crests is explained on the TEC.
A comprehensive explanation and example of Line of Fire is given on the Terrain Effects Chart.
Cavalry Combat
Cavalry were neither intended nor used to assault or hold ground at all costs.
If all units of one side in an enemy ZOC are Cavalry, AE results of A Loss & EX results of A or D Loss are ignored. DE outcomes are not modified.
Army Cohesion
Army combat effectiveness is diminished by casualties, stress and extreme fatigue. These effects gradually reduce combat power and maneuverability. Eventually units become demoralized and unwilling to continue the fight.
The rules which follow assume combat stress is experienced as fatigue, and that a command's combat loss level serves as a proxy for its level of combat stress.
Disorder
A unit is Disordered when it:
- Participates in Combat or Long Range Fire.
- Forced Marches,
- Moves during Dusk or Dawn Turns.
Invert the unit to show Disorder status at the end of the Phase in which the cause occurred.
Units in Disorder may not be commanded by their Officers.
Rally & Self-Rally
Units return to Good Order by a Rally Action [p. 5].
Fatigue
Fatigue measures ability & desire to continue combat. Cumulative casualties cause formations to Fatigue.
Procedure: Place eliminated units on their Fatigue Tracks. If the total Combat Value of Losses exceeds the number inside the Fatigue box, the formation is Fatigued.
Effect: A Combat involving one or more Fatigued Attackers is modified 1 odds shift in the Defender's favor.
Demoralization
An army becomes Demoralized when, at the beginning of any Player Turn, its total casualty level exceeds the number specified in the Scenario notes. The instant this occurs, place the Army Demoralization Marker on the current Game Turn box of the Turn Record Track.
Effects
- Units of a Demoralized Army must be under officer command to enter an enemy ZOC. An uncommanded unit in an enemy ZOC must exit during the friendly Movement Phase if possible.
- A combat involving one or more Demoralized defenders modifies the odds by 1 shift in the attacker's favor.
Demoralization is permanent, & may affect both Armies at once.
Calculating Combat Value (CV)
Use the Combat Value on the Good Order side of the counter to determine Fatigue or Demoralization.
Line of Communications (LOC)
A Line of Communications is a line of hexes, unobstructed by enemy units or ZOC's, to a friendly entry point. LOC's are specified in the Scenario set up for each game.
The 3 hexes nearest the testing unit can be over any passable terrain. The remainder of the LOC must be in Town, or along a Turnpike or Road. Test Confederate units first, then Union.
At the end of the scenario, eliminate any on-board units which cannot trace a LOC.
Victory
Evaluate victory at the end of a scenario. Victory is primarily determined by casualties, including Line of Communications losses, demoralization, and pursuit.
Pursuit
Pursuit is conducted by fresh (non-fatigued) units exiting from an enemy LOC entry hex on or before the last turn of the scenario. A friendly LOC must exist to the exit hex.
- Pursuing infantry or artillery units score 1 point each. Pursuing cavalry units score 3 points.
- Subtract 1 point for each Fatigued and 3 points for each Fresh enemy cavalry unit previously exited via that LOC hex.
- If Pursuers have a positive total value, score as VP. If the net is 0 or less, pursuit has no effect.
Relative Casualties
Each side determines victory points from the schedule in the game's scenario. Subtract the Union total from Confederate and compare the net to determine the winner and level of victory.
Honey Springs, July 17, 1863
Blunt's plan was simple: drive straight through the ambush, force Elk Creek, then take Honey Springs Depot.
Length
Honey Springs lasts from the Union Player Turn, 10am until the end of the Dusk Turn. (10 1/2 Game Turns) There is no 10am Confederate Player Turn.
The game may end earlier, at the end of a Player Turn which began with no enemy units on map.
Deployment
Federal units: All Federal units enter from hex 0301. 3 IHG enters at 11am; all other forces enter at 10am.
Five Nations Units: The 5 Nations Indian Brigade (5N) begins deployed on the starred hexes, within stacking limits.
Special Rules
Rain (Cloudburst)
See Terrain Effects Chart (TEC).
Reinforcements
Starting 2pm, the Confederate Player rolls 1D6 for reinforcements. On a "1" Cabell's Brigade (Cabell, Hughey's Artillery and 5 CSA Conscript Cavalry units, chosen at random) enter at hex 0912.
The remaining CSA Conscript Cavalry are put aside. They do not enter play and are only used for "Fog of War" purposes. If Cabell's Brigade has not entered by game end, they are considered to have "exited" for adjudicating Victory.
Creeks & Cherokees
Creek and Cherokee regiments may not stack, participate in a combat commanded by an officer, advance after combat into a hex occupied by a regiment of the other Nation, or retreat into such a hex except when no other retreat is possible without additional Loss.
CSA Conscript Cavalry
Cabell's Arkansas Cavalry were conscripts with minimal training, armament or motivation. Until they are committed to battle, no one has any idea of their value.
Conscripts, with an "Untried" [?] side, have the following special characteristics:
- Conscripts enter play on their Untried side. Neither player may examine their reverse.
- Conscripts involved in Combat or Attack from March are revealed when the odds are determined during resolution. A Conscript with revealed value of "0" is eliminated as soon as discovered. If a "0" Unit was the only Southern combatant, the Result is automatically DE.
- Untried units defend against Long Range Fire with a value of 2. They are revealed on a DE Result.
- Conscripts in the same hex as an Officer are in Good Order. Otherwise, they are in Disorder.
Line of Communications
US LOC traces to 0601; CS LOC to 0312 or 0912.
Demoralization
- US = 26 CV points
- 5 Nations = 20 CV pts; Cabell's Bde = 6 CV pts.
Victory Points
USA Casualty Scores
- Eliminated Confederate unit: - 3 VP
- CS Leader eliminated: - 2 VP
- Cabell's CSA Brigade Demoralized: - 4 VP
- 5 Nations Brigade Demoralized: -4 VP
- Honey Springs Depot controlled: -12 VP
- Excess Pursuing units: Cav -3 VP, Inf/Art -1 VP
- Alt-history awards: -4 or -8 VP
CSA Casualty Scores
- Eliminated US combat unit: 4 VP
- US Officer eliminated: 2 VP
- USA Demoralized: 10 VP
- Honey Springs Depot controlled: 12 VP
- Each excess Pursuing Cavalry unit: 3 VP
- Excess Pursuing units: Cav 3 VP, Inf/Art 1 VP
The signs are as printed in the booklet.
Victory Levels
Confederate Victory
- Decisive Victory: 6+VP
- Victory: -5 to +5 VP
Union Victory
- Victory: -6 or fewer VP.
- Decisive: -15 or fewer VP.
Historical Result — -9 VP US Victory
Honey Springs ended Rebel control of the upper Arkansas River Valley and the beginning of Federal resettlement in Indian Territory.
US VP: -21
- Enemy losses = 9 VP;
- Control of Honey Springs Depot = 12 VP
CS VP: 12
- Enemy losses = 12 VP
What is a "Victory"?
Who "won" the Battle of Honey Springs is complicated by politics and the larger picture.
James Blunt's Army of the Frontier was better armed and trained than the Five Nations Brigade. Also, Blunt collected a much larger force than Dan Cooper thought he would have to face. So the Five Nations start at a combat power disadvantage. Blunt needed a BIG victory because he couldn't afford to keep the army at Fort Gibson. Inflicting a few more losses than he received wasn't enough. He had to capture the Depot or beat the enemy badly. So US Victory Levels are higher than usual.
Low scores for CS unit loss reflects troops leaving ranks because of useless weapons. These will return after the fight and so aren't as important as losses to Blunt's irreplaceable veteran frontiersmen.
Order of Battle
Southern Order of Battle
5 Nations Brigade (Indian Brigade) — D. Cooper, Commanding
- Headquarters (1-3)
- Creek Mounted Rifles
- 1 Creek (5-5)
- 2 Creek (5-5)
- Cherokee Mtd Rifles
- Stand Watie
- 1 Cherokee
- 2 Cherokee
- Choctaw/Chickasaw Mounted Rifles
- Tandy Walker
- Walker (6-5)
- Lee's Texas Battery (3-1-4)
- 20 Texas Dismounted Cav. (5-4)
- 29 Texas Cavalry Regiment
- 1 Bn (4-5)
- 2 Bn (4-5)
- 5 Texas Partisan Battalion (5-5)
- Scanland/Gillette's Texas Cavalry (3-5)
Cabell's Arkansas Brigade — Cabell, Commanding
- Hughy's Battery (4-2-4)
- 5 Conscript Regiments, from:
- 1 AR*
- 2 AR*
- Hill*
- 1 TX*
- Crawford
- Palmer*
- Woolsey
- Mnkn
(*) Historically Present
Federal Order of Battle
Frontier Division — J. Blunt, Commanding
- Headquarters (2-5)
Judson's Brigade — Judson
- 1 Kansas Colored Vols
- 1 Bn (6-4)
- 2 Bn (6-4)
- 2 Indian Home Guard
- 1 Bn (5-4)
- 2 Bn (5-4)
- 6 Kansas Cavalry (6-5)
- Pack Artillery (2-1-4)
- 3 Wisconsin Cavalry (6-5)
- Pack Artillery (2-1-4)
- 2 Kansas Battery (4-3-4)
Phillips' Brigade — Phillips
- 2 Colorado Infantry (5-4)
- 1 Indian Home Guard
- 1 Bn (5-4)
- 2 Bn (5-4)
- 3 Indian Home Guard (6-4)
- Hopkins Battery (4-3-4)
Alt-History
Stand Watie
Colonel Stand Watie was the charismatic and able leader of the slaveholding Cherokees. His battlefield presence would have been an immense aid to General Cooper.
- Stand Watie is placed starting 11am. Watie may command all but Creek units.
- The Union receives 4 VP if this option is chosen.
Indian Gunpowder
Indian Brigade Ammunition was defective, resulting in greatly diminished firepower. Better ordnance would have a very great effect on the battle:
- Attacks by Confederate units receive a +1 (right) shift. Federal attacks receive a -1 (left) shift. Artillery fire is not affected.
- This option is revealed when the first combat is fought.
- During Cloudburst, US & CS attacks incur only the US -1 shift penalty.
- The US Player receives 4 VP if this option is chosen.
Historical Losses
Union: Bn., 1st KS Colored; Bn., 2nd CO Vols; Hopkins KS Bty.
Confederate: 20 TX Cav (Dm); Walker's Cavalry; Lee's TX Bty.
Historical Commentary
War comes to the Indian Territory
The Civil War threatened the Five Indian Nations with catastrophe. The tribes had recovered from the 1838 Trail of Tears. The Indian economy of cattle, cotton and slaves compared favorably to White Mississippi planters. However, hard currency was rare. The Civilized Nations depended on Federal treaty aid to buy tools and modern amenities.
Furthermore, "wild" Comanches to the west threatened the Cherokee, Choctaw, Chicasaw, Creek and Seminole farmers, who relied on the U.S. Army for safety. Now the Five Nations was on its own in a hostile environment, and their leaders were unsure what to do. Chief John Ross' view from Talequah, the Cherokee capitol, illuminates the difficulties.
The Cherokee divided into two factions. The Southerners wished to assimilate more closely with the Mississippi valley. Their leaders, like charismatic Stand Watie, saw their future with the Confederacy. John Ross' supporters, called "pin" indians, were abolitionist, pro-Union and committed to traditional Indian customs. Indian peacetime contact with Washington, however, led through Fort Smith, AR, now in Southern hands.
By April, 1861 the U.S. Army evacuated its Indian Nations posts from Fort Smith to Fort Cobb, regrouping at Fort Leavenworth, KS. A Confederate cavalry brigade under ex-Texas Ranger Ben McCulloch in nearby Arkansas meant the Union could no longer protect the Five Nations.
In early 1861, Missouri refused President Lincoln's call for troops and turned out its State Guard under Maj Gen Sterling Price to oppose the Federal government. With Arkansas also pro-South, access to Federal support lay through Kansas, prostrated by the drought of 1860-61 and unable to help.
Meanwhile the Cherokees' neighbors gradually took sides. In February, 1861 the Choctaws voted to seek relations with the South. The Confederacy's Commissioner of Indian Affairs, Albert Pike, was greatly respected among Indian leaders. Soon the Seminole and Chickasaw declared for the South.
Union defeats at Bull Run, VA and Wilson's Creek in nearby Missouri in the fall of 1861 precipitated matters. On August 21, the Executive Committee of the Cherokee Nation severed relations with the United States and allied with the Confederacy. The Committee offered a regiment of Cherokee Mounted Rifles, conditional on receipt of Confederate arms.
Nevertheless a strong minority, including John Ross and John Drew, remained opposed to slavery, and might change sides if opportunity arose. While the Cherokee deliberated, ex-Indian Agent Col. Douglas Cooper formed a Choctaw and Chicasaw Mounted Rifle Regiment, raised, without weapons, in late July.
Creek Paramount Chief Opoethlehola remained loyal to the Union. In August he requested help from Washington and gathered his men to resist Confederate inroads. Tribal factions, led by Daniel and Chilly McIntosh formed the Creek Mounted Rifles for Confederate service. Cooper, leading the Indian Mounted Rifles plus the 4th Texas Cavalry, moved to overawe Opoethlehola. In skirmishes lasting from mid-November until the ragged and starving survivors reached Kansas in January, Cooper, with Col. James McIntosh' CSA cavalry, chivvied the Creeks and Cherokee loyalists north.
In early 1862 the Trains-Mississippi was quiescent. Samuel R. Curtis' 12,000 man US Army of the Southwest watched McCulloch and Price in NW Arkansas. Price and McCulloch weren't speaking to one another, so CSA Major General Earl Van Dorn took charge of both, uniting them with an Indian force under newly commissioned Brigadier General Albert Pike. With 15,000 men, Van Dorn planned to smash Curtis, drive to St. Louis and on to glory.
Uncooperative Curtis handled his small army brilliantly and drove Van Dorn from the field at Pea Ridge. John Drew's Cherokee Rifles promptly offered their services to the Union. Pike's remaining Indian troops returned to the Five Nations.
Meantime, Kansas feared for its safety. With few Federal troops for home defense and burdened with destitute loyal Indians, state officials authorized two Indian Home Guard regiments, officered by experienced whites. Drew's Cherokee Mounted Rifles transformed to the 3rd Indian Home Guard. Abolitionists began forming a State regiment of ex-slaves in defiance of Lincoln's ban on black soldiers.
These regiments, with the 2 Colorado Infantry, 6 Kansas Cavalry & 3 Wisconsin Cavalry formed the core of the Army of the Frontier, Kansas Division. Brigadier General James G. Blunt, Kansas medical doctor, abolitionist, friend of Lincoln's political ally, the radical Sen. Jim Lane, got the job. His mission was to secure the borders with the Five Nations. Blunt's pugnacity delivered much more.
Blunt and Brigadier General James Herron orchestrated a decisive victory at Prairie Grove on December 7, 1862, pushing the Southern frontier back to Little Rock. Blunt's reward for Prairie Grove, plus a later raid to the Arkansas River, was promotion from Lincoln and vituperation from his superior, John Shofield, on sick leave in St. Louis during the battle. Schofield forthwith banished Blunt to the frontier.
Ever combative, Blunt took to the newspapers, allied with Senator Jim Lane. Lane's enemies, Led by Kansas Governor Curtin, in turn began a campaign of invective against Blunt. After he thwarted Curtin's scheme to issue Kansas officer commissions as political favors, pressure to relieve Blunt mounted. Lincoln's patience with everybody grew thin. By 1863, Major General Blunt badly needed a victory.
1863 in Indian Territory
Back in the Five Nations, the Confederate shoestring was frayed. Arms for the Mounted Rifles were castoffs, gunpowder was impure and scarce, uniforms non-existant. Promised white reinforcements turned out to be a few hundred Texas cavalry. Lingering effects of Pea Ridge, Prairie Grove and Grant's siege of Vicksburg drained the Confederate Trans-Mississippi of troops. The only slim comfort was the Union's apparent disinterest in the region.
Nevertheless, Union cavalry patrols probed deep into Cherokee land while Indian units like Colonel Stand Watie's 2nd Cherokee Mounted Rifles preyed on supply convoys and isolated detachments. Union Fort Gibson marked the edge of disputed land.
Douglas Cooper, now commander of the Five Nations Indians, called on General William Cabell at Fayetteville, AR, for reinforcements. Cabell agreed to bring a cavalry brigade to Honey Springs Depot, in the Creek Nation. In reaction, Blunt staged to Fort Gibson, picking up various reinforcements, including the 1st Kansas Colored, a mule train, and a friendly newspaper reporter and sketch artist.
Battle of Honey Springs
On July 17, the Army of the Frontier moved out, pushing back Confederate mounted scouts. About 2 miles from the Depot, his men sighted enemy troops in the tree line in front of Elk Creek. Blunt halted for an early lunch, then, about 10am, advanced over a low rise and into combat.
Blunt's two US brigades were in line, cavalry on each flank and infantry in the center, anchored on the 1st Kansas Colored. 12 cannon gave supporting fire. The 3rd Indian Home Guard probably formed a tactical reserve during the early battle.
Cooper's Indians, on paper, had a larger army, but his squadrons were thin. The Confederates were crippled by their poor gunpowder. Lee's artillery were cast-off experimental 1lb Steel Rifles. Federal Indians were drilled as infantry. Their muskets & obsolescent "indian rifles", forced the fight to point blank range.
The initial firefight was inconclusive. Then 2nd Indian Home Guard mistakenly advanced in front of the Federal battle line. Their officers' command to fall back was heard by the 20 TX Cavalry, who thought the Federals were beaten and charged. Instead, the 1st Kansas Colored, who had been prone, rose, volleyed, and charged, shattering the Confederate battle line.
The Southerners held long enough for Capt. Lee's 4 gun battery to fall back over the bridge, then the whole force broke for the creek. On the south side, Col. Tandy Walker's Choctaw & Chickasaw Rifles held briefly, but the whole force was pushed back by stages to the Depot. There a third stand was made, but by late afternoon Blunt's men held the field.
Cabell's men were nearby, slowed by the need to keep his conscripts from deserting and by uncertainty as to the situation. When they finally came in sight they could only parry Blunt's pursuit and rally the survivors. The next day everyone retreated.
After the Battle
Blunt's victory did him little political good. His enemies accumulated new evidence of corruption and misuse of funds. When he was surprised and his escort nearly annihilated by Quantrill's raiders at Baxter Springs, Kansas newspapers made him a laughingstock. His military usefulness seemed at an end. Ironically, at the very end of the war, Blunt's love of a good fight would again save Kansas during Stirling Price's October, 1864 raid. At the battle of Westport, Blunt held up Price's veterans until Union reinforcements could drive him from the State. Blunt's final victory enabled Kansas militiamen to return home in time to re-elect Senator Jim Lane in the November election. After the war, Kansas' only Major General was unable to maintain his wartime popularity. He left Kansas for Washington, where he died, obscure and insane, in 1881.
Colonel Stand Watie, who missed Honey Springs, was a thorn in the side of the Union until the very end, when then-Brigadier General Watie became the last Confederate General to surrender his army.
Soon after Honey Springs, John Ross left Talequah and the Cherokee Nation to settle in Philadelphia. The Cherokees came out of the Civil War poorly, as the Federal Government refused to renew their broken treaties, while much Cherokee land was given to other tribal groups. Loyal Indians of the Home Guard regiments received veteran benefits, but lost treaty rights alongside their rebel brothers.
Militarily, Honey Springs firmed the Union hold on the Arkansas River Valley. This lush granery would no longer provide Confederate armies with beef, grain and horses. Irrelevant to the larger campaigns that decided the war, vital to the Indian Nations, Honey Springs Depot is today a quiet Oklahoma Battlefield Park, a forgotten footnote of history.