Ancient Pub Battles
Ancient Pub Battles Rulebook
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
- Overview
- How the Turns Work
- Movement
- Spotting
- HQs
- Rallying
- How to Attack
- Support
- Flanking
- Combat
- Retreat
- Multiple Combat
- Charge
- Elephants
- HQs and Command
- Setting Up a Battle
- Leaving the Battlefield
- Winning a Battle
- Fallen Commanders
- Multiplayer
- Optional Combat Modifiers
- Translator's Notes
- Quick Reference
Overview
Note: each block represents 2,500 men. Two blocks together represent a legion or a division.
You build your army secretly, using points. Your unit types stay hidden from the enemy until contact. Do you have a small elite force or a large mass of mediocre troops? A large body of cavalry? What is the structure of your army and the quality of its command? (See Setting Up a Battle.)
Translator's note: the fog of war created by the blocks adds to the tension of the battle.
There is no board in this game. Most ancient battles took place on plains, so you play directly on the table.
Troops
Your troops are the rectangular blocks, the wooden pieces coloured red (Romans) or white (Carthaginians). Apply the stickers carefully. They show the troop types (see Setting Up a Battle for details).
All troops begin the battle FRESH (fresh and organised). When a troop is FRESH, turn the block so that its sticker faces you and is hidden from the enemy. Troops become SPENT through losses in combat and by retreating. Turn the block over, sticker up, to show that it is SPENT.
SPENT means the troops are shocked and disorganised. They can still move and fight but are vulnerable and easy to destroy. HQs can rally troops and turn their blocks back to FRESH later, during a movement.
HQs
The cubes represent commanders or headquarters (HQs).
What are they for? Without HQs, your army simply sits where it is. You need HQs to move your troops, rally them, take the initiative and launch your troops at the right moment.
How the Turns Work
Each HQ (cube) has its own command chit (disc). Place the sticker on the widest part. At the start of the turn, place all the command chits of the HQs together in an opaque bag. Use only the chits for the battle being played!
Then draw one chit at random. The corresponding HQ may now move and activate the troops it commands. (See HQs and Command.)
Activated troops may EITHER move OR rally, but not both.
To attack, simply move your troops into contact with the enemy (see How to Attack).
After moving and rallying, resolve the combats between opposing forces in contact. Combats continue until all contacts are broken.
Keep drawing the chits one at a time, carrying out movements and rallies, then resolve combats until there are no chits left to draw. This completes the turn.
At the end of the turn, turn all HQs back to their FRESH status. But not the troops! They can only become FRESH again by rallying. Put all the command chits back in the opaque bag. Check losses for the fall of a commander and remove his chit from play (see Fallen Commanders). Turn the black die to show the new turn number. You are ready to begin a new turn!
Translator's note: blocks are not assigned to a particular commander as in the Pub Battles Muskets battles. Any HQ may freely command any block. Yes, this means that some troops will move and fight several times in one turn.
Movement
Activated troops may pivot and move toward their front by the distance shown on the ruler. Use the mounted-troop distance for HQs and cavalry (and elephants). Use the foot-troop distances for infantry.
(The printed rules show two movement rulers, one for foot movement (infantry) and one for mounted movement (cavalry). The rulers themselves are graphics and their distance figures are not printed in the text.)
During movement, troops may move diagonally up to 45 degrees.
Pieces may not overlap one another. Pieces may not pass through enemy or friendly pieces.
You may pivot once for free. Each additional pivot costs 1/3 of the maximum movement.
You may pass between 2 pieces if the majority of the block's width passes through.
Spotting
If you can see a block, the enemy must tell you its unit type (cavalry or infantry) on request. All pieces block line of sight. You can only learn the quality of blocks at contact, not that of supporting units.
HQs
HQs cannot attack or be attacked. They cannot be overrun and do not block movement. Simply push them back when you move.
Rallying
Instead of moving, an activated piece may Rally. Turn the block to its FRESH status. You may also pivot the block and change its front at the same time.
How to Attack
Simply move your troops forward to contact the enemy. You must be able to move your piece so that the majority of the blocks are in contact.
Support
One piece, no more, may be placed directly behind a block as support. Only the front piece counts for combat. If the front piece is destroyed or retreats, the supporting block may either Retreat OR advance into the vacated place and continue the combat.
Flanking
If you can attack the flank or rear of the enemy, you gain a bonus in combat. To flank, the centre of the attacker must lie behind the front of the defender, as shown in the printed diagram. Blocks need not be perfectly aligned to make a flank attack.
Combat
All pieces in contact form a combat. Resolve the combats one by one until all contacts are broken. The attacker (the player who has just moved) chooses the order of combats.
Note: finish all combats BEFORE drawing a new chit from the bag.
Procedure
Resolve combats step by step as follows:
| Step | Action |
|---|---|
| 1 | Pieces in contact fight. Apply hits immediately. |
| 2 | The defender decides to retreat or to stay for another round. |
| 3 | The attacker decides to retreat or to stay for another round. |
| 4 | Repeat until the contact is broken. |
Fighting
To fight, the owner of each piece in contact rolls 3 dice. You score a hit on a result of 4, 5 or 6.
Translator's note: both opponents roll their 3 dice at the same time. A combat is a risk for both the attacker and the defender.
Modifiers
Modify the die result as follows:
- +1 if you flank the enemy block.
- -1 if you fight a piece on your flank.
- +1 for cavalry attacking SPENT (disorganised) infantry.
- -1 for cavalry fighting FRESH (cohesive) infantry.
Applying Hits
Apply the hits to the pieces in contact as follows:
| Piece | Result |
|---|---|
| FRESH block | Is turned over onto its SPENT side (sticker up). |
| SPENT block | Must retreat. |
| Block that has already retreated | Is destroyed. |
Hits are cumulative. So 2 hits on a FRESH piece turn it over and force it to retreat. 3 hits on a FRESH piece (or 2 hits on a SPENT piece) destroy it. Excess hits are lost. Do not apply them to supporting pieces.
Unit Quality
The Elite block absorbs the first hit in a combat, with no effect on it.
The Auxiliary block counts the first hit in a combat as 2 hits. Apply the absorbed and additional hits once per command chit drawn.
The Detachment block rolls only 1 die in a combat and is destroyed by 1 hit.
Retreat
The block must pivot 180 degrees, changing its front, then move 1/3 of its movement away from the combat. Its movement may be diagonal but may not make an additional change of front.
You may not retreat through enemy or friendly blocks. EXCEPTIONS:
- A supported piece may retreat through its support.
- The supporting unit may in turn retreat through the front piece that has already retreated.
You may retreat through a gap between 2 friendly units if the majority of your piece's width passes through it.
If the block cannot retreat under these conditions, it is destroyed.
A voluntary retreat by a FRESH block turns it SPENT.
Cavalry Retreat
A FRESH cavalry piece in defence may choose to retreat before combat IF it is in contact with infantry.
Multiple Combat
Resolve multiple combats as a single combined combat. Start with the 2 pieces initially in contact. Additional blocks roll their dice in the order in which they joined the combat. The pieces decide whether to stay or retreat in the same order. Then begin a new round.
Charge
A charge is a special attack that allows cavalry to resolve combat immediately after its movement, instead of waiting until all movement is finished.
Conduct charges one block at a time, at any moment in the movement phase. You may not charge with support or in conjunction with a flank attack.
After resolving a charge (even if you were forced to retreat), you may pivot to change front and charge again, for as long as there is a target within 1/3 of mounted movement.
Elephants
Elephants can be devastating but are also unpredictable. They may even turn against their own troops. They move at mounted speed.
Modifiers:
- +1 for elephants fighting any piece.
- -1 for any piece fighting an elephant.
After a combat, elephants MUST charge the nearest piece, friend or foe (other than an elephant). Determine the target at random if several are equidistant. Elephants continue to charge until they are destroyed.
If an elephant inflicts no hits on a dice roll, control of the elephant passes to the opponent. The block is turned over, moves and immediately attacks the nearest enemy piece.
HQs and Command
Commanding. After the HQ has moved, it may command troops in one of 2 ways:
- Contact: Move into contact with a friendly piece. You may command that piece and all the other friendly pieces in contact with it. This works as a continuous chain of command, so you can command your entire army in its movement as long as the pieces touch.
- Command range: Move the HQ. You may command any piece within 1/3 of the HQ's mounted movement. You may not trace this command range through enemy pieces.
Note: to be commanded, only part of the block needs to be within range, not the whole piece.
Note: HQs cannot move other HQs.
Note: being in contact means sharing an edge. A corner is not enough.
Changing the Turn Order
A FRESH HQ may attempt to change the activation sequence after a command chit has been drawn.
If you do not wish to move immediately, you may try to delay your move. Roll a die less than or equal to your HQ's command level. If the result is a success, draw a chit at random, THEN return your own chit to the bag. In case of failure, you must play immediately as planned.
IF you wish to play before the chit drawn from the bag, you may try to bring your turn forward. Roll a die less than or equal to your HQ's command level. If the result is a success, remove your chit from the bag and play your HQ. The HQ drawn first remains drawn out and will move afterwards. If your roll fails, leave your chit in the bag; you will play when it is drawn.
Whether the attempt succeeds or fails, turn your HQ cube to its SPENT side after the attempt.
After an attempt, other FRESH HQs may attempt to change the turn. Carry out the attempts in the order announced. There is no limit to the number of turn-change attempts as long as a FRESH HQ remains.
SPENT HQs function normally for the rest of the game. This means they can no longer attempt to change the turn.
Tip: wait to see the chit drawn before attempting to change the draw.
Translator's note: a good general will seek to impose his will on the opponent by taking the initiative, or by keeping reserves to strike last (which prevents the enemy from reacting). The command level is shown on the cube by the number of black squares. Example: Caesar is a good level-4 general. He needs a 4 or less to change the turn (2 chances in 3!).
Setting Up a Battle
Build your army secretly, up to the maximum number of points, as follows:
| Roman name | This piece | Costs this many points |
|---|---|---|
| Velites | Detachments: Psiloi | 1 |
| Hastati | Auxiliaries, warrior bands | 2 |
| Principes | Regular infantry | 3 |
| Triarii, Tormenta | Elite infantry, artillery | 4 |
| Equites | Cavalry | 6 |
| Elite cavalry | 8 | |
| Elephantus | Elephants | 6 |
| Dux | HQ | Its command level |
Note: the hastati represent less disciplined troops, such as warrior bands and allies.
(The printed rules do not state a points total for the army. The table above gives only the cost of each piece.)
Example
- 4 infantry and an HQ of level 3: 4 x 3 + 3 = 15 points.
- 4 auxiliaries and an HQ of level 2: 4 x 2 + 2 = 10 points.
Note the average ratio of pieces to HQs for an army (for example, 6 pieces for 1 HQ).
You are free to experiment and build whatever army you want.
The Battlefield
Define a square whose side is equal to 2 mounted moves (length and width). You may set up your army in any formation. The opposing armies begin at a distance of one mounted move from each other.
Leaving the Battlefield
Count the blocks that retreat off the battlefield as destroyed. Blocks that leave the battlefield voluntarily (without retreating) may not return to the combat, but they count as half their value for victory.
Winning a Battle
Play a maximum of 8 turns. At the end of the game, you collect the points of the enemy units you have destroyed, including the values of destroyed HQs and of units that have left the battlefield (these count for half). The player with the most points wins.
Fallen Commanders
When your troop losses reach the average number of pieces per HQ, remove one HQ at random at the end of the turn.
For example, for an army of 18 blocks with 3 HQs, the average is 6 pieces per HQ. So remove 1 HQ when your losses reach 6 blocks or more. When the losses reach 12 or more, remove another HQ.
Multiplayer
Although this game is ideal for solo or two-player games, the system can easily be adapted for several players. The compact size of the battlefield can make the play area feel cramped. This can be solved easily by using figures! Simply double or quadruple the scale for more space.
Each player controls one or more HQs.
Players may communicate freely before the game. During the game, players may only communicate with each other IF their HQs are in contact.
Optional Combat Modifiers
- -1 Swords against spears on the first turn.
- -1 Spears against swords on later turns.
- -1 Swords against mounted troops.
- 0 Spears fight normally against elephants.
These modifiers add realism, but also add time, work and mental fatigue. It is up to you whether to use them.
Translator's Notes
The Pub Battles system draws on Kriegspiel and on the staff tools of the 18th and 19th centuries, which positioned units according to reports reaching headquarters, using lead or wooden blocks. Roughly speaking, you have before you what a commander-in-chief sees in his command tent. The blocks representing units descend from older battle representations in which coloured lines decorated hand-drawn maps. The idea was to bring those representations to life. Formations of line and column up to 1914 match this rectangular symbolism exactly.
The heart of the game comes down to a few simple points:
- A random sequence of unit activations, which good generals can try to master (the poor, or the less good, suffer events and lose the initiative).
- Players give orders to their formation after the draw: rally, move, change front, support, engage the enemy.
- Players receive the results of the engagements.
- A new turn begins, in which new orders must be devised from the new situation.
All of this is simple and fits together well.
At the level of the brigade or division (depending on the game), tactical options are limited, but a few obvious military principles remain:
- Flank the enemy to engage them from a position of superiority.
- Cover your flanks.
- Support your shock unit to exploit or reinforce a major attack.
- Use terrain in defence (woods, river, hills...).
- Know how to use the fog of war against your opponent (detachments, for example).
- Threaten, fix, turn, break through.
- Keep fresh reserves.
- Spare tired units.
- Know your strengths and weaknesses (command, units, terrain), and those of the enemy. (For example, Hannibal excels in command but cannot ask everything of his auxiliaries. He can therefore choose to strike when he wants without the enemy being able to respond.)
- With artillery, disorganise the enemy before charging them.
- Strike the enemy after its activation, so that it cannot slip away from you.
- Take the initiative and get your forces onto the best ground before the enemy.
- ...
In short, the school of war.
The dice are built into the tactical system: the uncertainty of the black swan has to be simulated. Through modifiers, they add to the probability of winning a combat without guaranteeing victory.
I have kept the English words "Fresh" and "Spent" for 2 reasons:
- Because the diagrams illustrating the rules use the English words, reading will be easier.
- Because although the word "fraîche" (fresh) is well understood, "dépensée" (spent) is less clear, and "désorganisée" (disorganised) contains only part of the reality it covers.
The Pub Battles system adapts particularly well to play with figures, whatever the scale, since all movements are measured with rulers.
By contrast, there will no longer be much real fog of war, since the troops are visible.
Pub Battles is a game system for gentlemen. The spirit of the rule must sometimes be applied, sometimes the spirit of the battle. Nothing stops you from adding or removing a rule point. I confess the system gives me satisfaction, from antiquity to the revolutionary wars.
Last point: I am not a professional translator, so there is no need to shout.
Quick Reference
Game summary
- Draw a command chit. Turn change possible per HQ. HQ moves. Activated units: MOVE or rally. Units in contact fight.
- Draw another command chit. Turn change possible per HQ. HQ moves. Activated units: MOVE or rally. Units in contact fight.
- Draw another command chit. Turn change possible per HQ. HQ moves. Activated units: MOVE or rally. Units in contact fight.
- ...
- Draw ends when the bag is empty.
- Check for fallen generals.
- Put the chits back in the bag.
- Reactivate the HQs.
- Advance the turn die.
- New turn.
- End: turn 8 or destruction of the enemy army.
Combat modifiers
- Elite: absorbs the 1st hit.
- Auxiliary: 2 hits instead of 1 in the first round of combat.
- +1 for an attacker that flanks.
- -1 for the block that is flanked.
- -1 cavalry against Fresh infantry.
- +1 cavalry against Spent infantry.
Charge
- 1/3 of movement.
- 1 piece at a time.
- No support.
- +1 elephants against any piece.
- -1 for blocks against elephants.
Elephants
- Must charge.
- +1/-1.
- No hits means the opponent takes control of the elephant.
Optional modifiers
- -1 Swords against spears on the first turn.
- -1 Spears against swords on later turns.
- -1 Swords against mounted troops.
- 0 Spears fight normally against elephants.