A Game of Thrones: The Card Game (Second Edition) FAQ
311 questions players ask · Updated Nov 15, 2026 · Full rulebook
General
- Do deluxe expansion boxes count as core sets?
- If Oldtown's revealed card does not match the named card type, where does it go?
- Does Melisandre's Favor stop controlling the attached character when it is sacrificed at the end of the Dominance phase?
- Does Tyrion Lannister's gold ability depend on which player initiates the Intrigue challenge?
- Does Cersei Lannister's ability trigger when you discard cards to pay your own costs?
- Is there a limit to the number of characters or locations a player can have in play?
- Can you use Meager Contribution's gold bonus more than once per round if you have several copies?
Tutorial Joust Game Setup
- Can I place two Limited cards, such as two copies of a Limited location, during setup?
- Can an attachment placed in setup be attached to a legal target in the opponent's setup cards?
- Do cards placed during setup count as marshaled or played, so that their marshal and play abilities trigger?
- Does Noble Lineage's power icon still apply when it is played during setup?
- Are characters placed in setup standing, and does Sansa Stark begin kneeling if you start with her in setup?
- Must face-down setup cards be arranged in rows by card type?
- In the tutorial Stark versus Lannister game, do you lose instantly if your deck runs out?
Key Concepts: Timing, Interrupts and Reactions
- Does Vengeance for Elia stop Dagmer Cleftjaw's claim ability when both respond to the same military claim?
- In what order are competing replacement interrupts resolved, and does the first player choose?
- If two replacement effects target the same claim, which one applies?
- When Vengeance for Elia and The Seastone Chair both trigger, which one applies?
- Is there a difference between an interrupt and a reaction, and when does each resolve?
- In what order are multiple reactions to the same trigger resolved?
- Which interrupt takes priority when one ability says "would" and another interrupt does not?
- Are interrupts and reactions mandatory, and can you delay using one?
- If a character is saved from being killed, can its "when killed" interrupt still trigger, such as Shireen Baratheon's?
- Can Maester Aemon save himself when he dies?
- What does it mean that Bran Stark is immune to opponents' plot effects?
- Can a kneeling card still use its reactions, abilities and actions?
- Where does the power from a "for your faction" effect go, such as Sansa Stark's reaction?
- Does Randyll Tarly stand again while a constant strength boost keeps raising him?
- Is the discard required when Viserys Targaryen's interrupt resolves, and is triggering it optional?
- Does The Boy King still give power when the character it is attached to is kneeled?
- Why is Varys's ability an Interrupt rather than a Reaction, and is it optional?
- Does Cat Stark's ability block constant abilities, such as Tywin Lannister's strength bonus or an agenda's constant ability?
- Can Treachery cancel an event or a constant ability?
- If Treachery cancels Throwing Axe, Margaery Tyrell or Ice, what happens to the costs and effects?
- Does Catelyn Stark stop Cersei Lannister's claim-raising ability during an intrigue challenge?
- Can Grenn's power-move reaction target Jon Snow when Jon is only participating in the challenge?
- Does Jon Snow (Night's Watch) stand when you win a challenge he took part in, and which defenders does his reaction stand?
- Does Intimidate let you kneel a character after you win a challenge as the defender?
- Can Trading with the Pentoshi's gold be cancelled by a plot card?
- If you win a challenge and draw from Lannisport, can you play Tears of Lys in the same reaction window?
- Does Devout Free Rider stop a player giving gold to an opponent during the challenges phase?
- How does the event Words are Wind work when an opponent's event would initiate?
- Can Ser Dontos keep Sansa Stark alive by saving her from kills?
- What happens if a participating character loses its challenge icon in the middle of a challenge?
- When does a character reduced to 0 STR by Drogon's -4 STR effect die?
- If my character is the sole attacker and I remove it after a "When I Woke" reaction decides the winner, do Unopposed and the claim still apply?
- Does Trial by Combat change the challenge type, or only the claim type?
- Can you use Arianne Martell's action to save her after the opponent plays Dracarys on her?
- If Bran Stark cancels Tears of Lys, is the poison token still placed?
- Does Widow's Wail's +2 STR trigger Randyll Tarly's reaction every time it is attached?
- Can Risen from the Sea save a character who was killed by Dracarys?
- When a Martell plot deck is recycled, does the used plot pile reset for Doran Martell or Dawn?
- Does Heads on Spikes putting a character into the dead pile count as killing it?
- Can Grey Wind's kneel ability be used while he is defending or after he has been declared as a defender?
- Can The Seastone Chair replace the claim value of an unopposed challenge with one kill?
- Can several interrupts be triggered on the same character, and does stacking apply to actions?
- Does Pleasure Barge's immunity stop card draw effects from it being cancelled?
- Can Beric Dondarrion's kiss tokens be reduced to zero with Nightmares, and does he always end with six?
- Can Tyene's reaction target a character whose intrigue icon Nymeria removed?
- If Drowned God's Blessing is on a character saved by Risen from the Sea, can the opponent cancel the save with Hand's Judgment?
- Can Blood Magic Ritual save a character that has no attachments, and does it attach?
- Does Catelyn Stark's Wolves of the North power gain trigger when Wildfire Assault kills Stark characters?
- Does Robert Baratheon's +1 STR per other kneeling character count characters that knelt to attack in the same challenge?
- If Hand's Judgment cancels Put to the Torch, does the cancelled copy still count toward its once-per-challenge limit?
- Does Tyrion Lannister's reaction gain 2 gold when the opponent's Catelyn Stark initiates an intrigue challenge?
- How do you return A Dragon Is No Slave from the discard pile to your hand?
- Can Prince's Loyalist or Harrenhal cancel keyword abilities?
- If the second player plays an interrupt without giving the first player a chance, can the first player still resolve the card they meant to play?
- Can a card be knelt to pay an ability at any point, and can Maester Aemon save a Night's Watch character during Tears of Lys?
Key Concepts: Duplicates and Uniques
- Do duplicates stay with a unique character when control of it changes?
- What happens when a unique character returns from Journey to Oldtown after you have played another copy?
- If an opponent controls a unique card you own, can you put another copy into play or take control of one?
- Can you take control of an opponent's unique character when you already have a copy in play, or when a copy sits in the opponent's dead pile?
- If you draw a unique character whose copy is in your dead pile, can you keep it or play it?
- Is a character card a duplicate while it is still in your hand?
- Can you play a duplicate of a unique character with Arianne Martell to bring it into play, and does Arianne return?
- If you take control of a character, do you also get its attachments and duplicates?
- Can a sacrificed character be saved by a duplicate, or does sacrifice count as a kill?
- If a character is about to leave play, can you discard a duplicate to keep it in play, and what happens if you decline?
- Does a Discard effect kill a character?
- Can a duplicate save Varys when his ability removes him from the game, and what happens to his duplicates and other copies?
- Can a duplicated Varys trigger his ability twice in the same turn?
- Do duplicates save a character from Varys and from Valar Morghulis?
- Can you duplicate unique locations and attachments, or only characters?
- Can a unique card be duplicated if its title matches but its text differs?
- Where does a duplicate go when it saves a unique character, or when it is removed to save a character?
- Can you play a copy of a unique card as a duplicate, or marshal a unique character, when a copy is in your dead pile?
- Does a character in your dead pile stop other players from playing a duplicate of that title?
- Can a unique card enter play as a duplicate outside the Marshalling phase, for example from Queen of Thorns?
- Can a duplicate of one version of a unique character be used as the active character, for example to swap Asha Greyjoy's versions?
- If a unique character is killed, can you still play your own copy?
- When a unique character dies, do other copies of its title leave the deck and hand?
- Can a unique character in play stay in play when a copy of it is in the dead pile?
- Can Fire and Blood put a unique character from the dead pile into play when another copy is still in the dead pile?
- Can Aeron Damphair put a duplicate from the dead pile onto a character already in play?
- Can Risen from the Sea be played in the same window as a duplicate's save, and what happens to the duplicate?
- When a unique card with a duplicate leaves play, what happens to the duplicate, and to attachments' duplicates when the attached character dies?
- Does a unique character that a duplicate saves keep its power tokens, and are duplicates discarded when the card really leaves play?
- Does a character saved by a duplicate count as killed for triggers such as Rakharo's or Robb Stark's reactions?
- How does Wildfire Assault interact with characters that have duplicates?
- Can a duplicate or bodyguard save a character reduced to 0 STR, and does a character brought back to 0 STR die again?
- Can a military claim kill two duplicates of the same character to satisfy a claim of 2?
- Can you play multiple copies of a Limited location that reduces a card's cost, over different turns?
- Does Melisandre trigger off of herself when she is marshalled?
- Does playing a duplicate count as marshaling, so that a card's marshal or reaction abilities trigger again?
- Can a duplicate save a character brought in and then removed by Hear Me Roar at the end of the turn?
- Can you marshal a duplicate for free, and can you search your deck for one?
- Can you marshal a duplicate in the same turn a unique is put into play?
- Does marshaling a duplicate stand a character that is kneeled?
- Does a duplicate marshaled onto a unique card go on top of or under the original?
- How do multiple copies of a unique attachment like Lady work, and does the attachment's ability fire again?
- Can a duplicate save a unique character that would be killed by First Snow of Winter?
- Is a Bodyguard attachment the same as a Duplicate, and how do they differ when the character leaves play?
- If Ghaston Grey returns a character that has duplicates, what happens to the duplicates?
- Can you save Ghaston Grey with a duplicate after using it?
- If a burn effect like Targaryen Dracarys kills a character with duplicates, do all copies die?
- Can a duplicate save a unique character from Coldhands' remove-from-game effect?
- Can a duplicate save a character that has Milk of the Poppy attached?
- How are duplicated characters handled when Valar Dohaeris moves unchosen characters to the bottom of the deck?
- If a duplicate and Blood Magic Ritual both respond to the same would-be-killed trigger, which one saves the character?
- What does "remove from the game" mean for a card like Varys, and can you play another copy afterward?
Key Concepts: Control and Ownership
- Can you spend gold on a character you took control of to pay its ability cost?
- Where does a card go when it dies, is discarded, or leaves play while an opponent controls it?
- Who controls a character that returns to play after a temporary removal, if you gained control of it in the meantime?
- Does Marriage Pact stop its character from challenging the Marriage Pact controller?
- Can Melisandre kneel a character right after she is played, or does she trigger herself?
- Can you play an attachment such as Milk of the Poppy on an opponent's character, and who controls it?
- Can you kneel an opponent's character, or kill one, to pay the cost of a card's ability?
- Can Maester's Chain remove a Condition attachment that the opponent controls?
- If Oldtown reveals a card and you guess the wrong type, where does the card go?
- What happens to an attachment when the character it is attached to leaves play?
- Who owns a card that you take control of?
- Can I look through my discard pile or dead pile at any time?
- When winning one challenge triggers two of my reactions, can I choose which one resolves first?
- When Valar Dohaeris is revealed, can the chosen characters include characters in the discard or dead pile?
- If Milk of the Poppy blanks Yoren after he has taken a character, does that character return to you?
- Can a card ability or kill effect target a card outside play, such as a King in an opponent's deck?
- Can I sacrifice a card whenever I want, for example Esgred?
- Does a power token on a character stay there when the character changes control under a Ward attachment?
- Can a character's Reaction ability trigger if that character is killed, such as Joffrey Baratheon's power when he dies?
- Can you sacrifice an attachment on a character you took with Take the Black if the attachment's controller is still your opponent?
Key Concepts: Kneeling, Standing and Icons
- Can a character have more than one instance of the same challenge icon, and how do icon modifiers work?
- Can Ygritte be brought into play knelt by Val's ability, given she cannot be knelt by card effects?
- Can a character that participates in a challenge without being declared use stealth, for example after Azor Ahai Reborn?
- Can you remove an icon that a character does not have, such as with Nymeria Sand?
- How much STR does Robert Baratheon gain from kneeling characters, and does it count opponents' characters and change during a challenge?
- Does Sansa Stark enter play knelt when Fortified Position is in play?
- Does a character need the challenge's icon to take part in that challenge through a card effect?
- Do I have to kneel a card to use its Action ability?
- Must a card with a plot value modifier or a passive gold bonus, such as Roseroad, be kneeled for the bonus to apply?
- If a character loses all its challenge icons, is it removed from the game?
- How many Limited cards can you play or marshal, and can several be in play at once?
- Does Jon Snow have to kneel to participate in challenges, and can he be declared as an attacker?
- Can Eddard Stark defend more than one challenge in the same round after kneeling?
- Can you use Dracarys to kill an attacker when Daenerys is standing and gives -1 STR to opposing attackers?
- Does Daenerys Targaryen's -1 STR apply when she is attacking or defending, and must she be participating?
- Does Stannis's restriction on standing stop locations or attachments from standing?
- Can a knelt character's ability still be used, and can a knelt card's gold bonus still be gained?
- How does Forced March's repeated kneel work, and whose characters kneel?
- Can a card give a character an icon or stealth it does not print, and does Milk of the Poppy remove it?
- Do keywords and renown granted by an attachment still work on a character blanked by Milk of the Poppy or Fortified Position?
- If Dolorous Edd is put into play by an intrigue attack, do I pay his marshalling cost?
- Can a card effect reduce a character's STR below zero?
- Does Barristan Selmy's interrupt save a Lord or Lady from being killed by a military claim?
Key Concepts: Power, Renown and Winning
- Does a Renown character still gain power when it wins a challenge while defending?
- Does a Renown character gain power if its text was blanked earlier in the challenge but the blanking ended before keywords resolved?
- If you have no power tokens on your faction card, can you still gain power from Renown or an unopposed challenge?
- Does Jon Snow gain a power token for each challenge he wins while carrying Longclaw?
- Does Myrcella Baratheon gain Renown in every challenge type?
- Do power tokens on a character count toward the 15 power needed to win, and do they leave with the character?
- If Stannis gained power from Lightbringer's renown and Lightbringer is discarded, does the power stay on Stannis?
- In a power challenge, can you steal power from a character, or take power from the supply when the opponent has none?
- Can you kneel your faction card more than once in a round?
- Does the win condition change to something other than 15 power with larger decks?
- Does winning dominance require a standing character?
- Does Intimidate use the total STR by which a challenge was won, or the STR difference between the two characters?
- Does Intimidate need the character with the keyword to be attacking, or only participating in the challenge you win?
- Does 'Your King Commands It' stop non-King, non-Queen characters from starting power challenges?
- Does The Wall's +1 STR stop while The Wall is kneeling, and can it be knelt again for its 2 power?
- Does For the Watch let the Night's Watch player win the first challenge against them automatically?
- When does Harrenhal's Prized keyword give the opponent power?
- How does Loot pay its X cost from the opponent's gold pool, and do cost reductions change X?
Key Concepts: Other Key Concepts
- Can an attachment be played on a character with No attachments, and does it stay on a character whose text box is blanked?
- Does Fortified Position's blanking apply to every player's characters, or only to yours?
- Does a plot card's text beginning with 'You' apply only to the player who revealed it?
- Can a player look at or ask about the contents of the opponent's deck, such as to check for a King for King's Hunting Party?
- Does Milk of the Poppy on Daenerys stop her from gaining the bonus abilities from her dragons?
- What is the difference between 'removed from the game' and 'removed from play'?
- When Tickler makes you discard a copy of the opponent's discarded card, where do you look for that copy?
- Can The Eyrie protect a character from military claim, and can you use it on an opponent's character?
- After Varys is removed from the game with his own ability, can another copy of Varys be played and use the ability?
- If a character is targeted by Stealth and the stealth character leaves the challenge, can the stealthed character still be declared as a defender?
- When a character is sacrificed, does it go to the discard pile or the dead pile?
- Does Khal Drogo's extra military challenge require him to be participating in that challenge?
- Can you play a second Robert's Warhammer while the first is in the discard pile after it was sacrificed?
- Can Milk of the Poppy be attached to an attachment such as Maester's Chain to blank it?
- Does an effect that targets characters also affect Army cards?
- What happens when Called Into Service reveals a dead character?
- Is there a limit to how many characters you can have in play in a joust or melee?
- Does the Search keyword draw the searched cards one at a time, or look at all of them at once?
- Do revealed plots include used plots, and can a card that says 'revealed plots' target used plots?
- What happens to a plot after it is used, and when can a used plot be played again?
- Does gold placed on Red Cloaks stay on the card between rounds, and can you spend it?
- What does X mean on The Things I Do For Love?
- Can Consolidation of Power be used on your own character?
- Is it mandatory to discard an attachment when the Confiscation event's condition is met and the attachment is your own?
- Can a card with Bestow be given gold during setup?
- Can Plaza of Punishment target a character with 0 STR and kill it?
- Is Night's Watch Jon Snow's ability optional when The Prince's Pass makes him a target?
- When King Robert's Warhammer sacrifices after kneeling characters with total STR equal to the attached character's STR, which STR counts?
- Do plot card values add to challenge strength?
- If you win a challenge with The Hound and your hand is empty, must you return The Hound to your hand?
- Do Winter or Summer plots in the used pile count for plots that check for other revealed Winter or Summer plots?
- How does Balon Greyjoy's constant STR check apply to a defender whose STR equals Balon's when a challenge is initiated?
- When Sneak Attack and an effect that lets you initiate an extra challenge are both in play, how many challenges can you initiate?
- Can Hand of the King or Master of Whispers be used against a player you support?
- What can a cancel or block effect, such as Catelyn Stark's passive, stop?
Phase Sequence
- Do I have to reveal a new plot card every round?
- In what order do two When Revealed plot effects resolve, and who decides?
- How is a tied initiative broken during the plot phase?
- Do I draw cards in round 1 after setup, and when do I discard at the end of it?
- When is income collected in the Marshaling phase, and do gold icons on cards I marshal this turn pay out?
- Does Tywin Lannister's gold-based strength count gold stored on him, and which gold modifiers count?
- Can I use a card's ability right after marshaling it in the same phase?
- In the Marshaling phase action window, do players take one action each in turn, or can one player act several times in a row?
- Can you use Illyrio's Estate during the Marshaling phase when you are not the active player?
- When can an attachment such as Milk of the Poppy or Bodyguard be played?
- When can a redirect like Crown Regent, or a reaction like Winterfell, respond to a challenge that was just initiated?
- Is announcing a challenge a single step, or can a reaction come between the announcements?
- Does a character need the challenge icon to stay in a challenge after it has been declared?
- Can a character without the matching challenge icon join a challenge through a card ability?
- When can an Ambush card such as Queen's Assassin be played, and what does the number in parentheses mean?
- Can a character ambushed after defenders are declared still defend or join the challenge?
- Does a character put into play with Ambush stay in play after the challenges phase?
- Does Fealty reduce the cost of an Ambush card such as The Queen's Assassin?
- Can an interrupt or reaction event such as We Do Not Sow be played outside an action window?
- Who acts first in an action window, and when does the window close?
- When two players want to play non-Action events at the same time, who resolves first?
- Is there an action window in the Plot phase before plots are revealed?
- How many action windows are in the challenges phase, and is there one after the last challenge?
- Are Challenges Actions extra actions, and can the opponent use them during my challenges?
- Can The Water Gardens pay for Vengeance for Elia after strengths are compared in a military challenge?
- Must challenges be declared in a fixed order, such as intrigue, then military, then power?
- Can a player start more than one challenge of the same type, and do extra-challenge effects beat Sneak Attack or 'cannot' text?
- How does At Prince Doran's Behest replace a plot, and what if it is your seventh plot?
- Does The Prince's Pass, which triggers after you lose a challenge, change the challenge result, the claim or the unopposed bonus?
- When an ability such as Marched to the Wall resolves, are all its targets chosen before any character is discarded?
- When does Dracarys kill a defending character at 0 STR, and does that death count as claim?
- Can Dracarys be played outside the Challenges phase?
- After a challenge is won, what resolves first: reactions, the unopposed bonus, the claim or keywords?
- When is a challenge unopposed?
- What does winning an unopposed challenge give you, and does the claim still apply?
- Do reaction bonuses such as Superior Claim or A Feast for Crows' +2 power add to the normal power from winning, or replace it?
- Does winning a Power challenge gain power when the opponent has no power, and can a military or intrigue claim take more than the opponent has?
- How are challenge strengths totaled, and who wins a tied challenge?
- Do characters at 0 STR still participate in a challenge, and can a side with 0 total strength win?
- Can a challenge end with neither side winning, and what if the only attacker is removed or drops to 0 STR?
- When you win a military challenge, who chooses the character to kill, and can a duplicate or bodyguard save it?
- In a military claim, can one character be chosen twice, and what if the claim is greater than the number of characters?
- What do you lose when you lose an intrigue, power or military challenge, and does a losing defender leave play?
- Can the same character attack more than once in a challenges phase?
- Do Insight, Renown and Pillage trigger when you win a challenge as the defender?
- Can you play an event drawn by Insight during the same challenge's winner resolution?
- Does Intimidate resolve after the claim, and does its amount change if the winning side's strength changes later?
- How is dominance strength counted, and does gold count if you have no standing characters?
- When Supporting the Faith and Lions of the Rock both trigger, which resolves first?
- Does Alannys Greyjoy's reserve reduction apply if she is killed or ambushed?
- If a card removes a character from a challenge, does the character stand back up?
- If an effect stands a challenging character after it is declared, does it leave the challenge?
- Does Walder Frey's attack-as-a-group rule apply to other Frey characters, and can they be removed one at a time?
- Can Catapult on the Wall kill a character that is not attacking?
- Can Eddard Stark defend against more than one challenge in a round?
- Does Wardens of the South's strength bonus apply to each character in each challenge, and does it last beyond the challenge?
- Can Castle Black stand a defending character, and does that character still count in the challenge?
- Can you declare defenders more than once in a challenge, and does a character stood during an action window still defend?
- Does What I Do For Love cancel an opponent's challenge action?
- Can the Sunspear reaction be used when you have no characters to defend with?
- Can a character that joins a challenge after it is initiated, such as Ser Alliser Thorne, be targeted by stealth?
- If you take control of a kneeled character with Take the Black, does it stay kneeled, and does it count for dominance?
- If a character leaves play before the challenge outcome, does it still contribute its strength?
- How long do 'until end of round' and 'until end of phase' effects last, and does a phase cover both players?
Melee Rules
- Does a Melee game end after a fixed number of plots or a time limit?
- Do multiple additional challenge effects stack in a Melee game?
- Can I search an opponent's discard pile for a card in a Melee game, for example with Yoren?
- In Melee, if a plot says to choose and kneel a character, does each opponent kneel one character?
- In Melee, can I play an attachment with a positive effect, like Syrio's Training, on another player's character?
- In Melee, can you split your three challenges across different opponents in one turn?
- In Melee, can a supporting player declare defenders in place of the challenged player?
- In Melee, can you attack an opponent whose standing characters cannot oppose the challenge?
- After a Crown Regent redirects a challenge, can the new target be a player you support?
- When a Crown Regent redirects a power challenge in Melee, can the attacker make a second power challenge against the original opponent?
- If you draw your last card in a Melee game, are you eliminated immediately?
- In Melee, can a player who is not in a challenge take actions during it, such as playing an event that affects the attacker?
- In Melee, does Master of Whispers let you discard cards from every opponent's hand after winning an Intrigue challenge against one of them?
- How many Core Sets does a Melee game for five or six players need?
Deckbuilding
- Can a deck include cards from a house other than its faction card?
- Does a Banner agenda's 12 non-loyal cards need 12 different card names?
- Does being a card of a faction make a card loyal?
- Is Arya Stark a loyal character?
- What does the Fealty agenda do, and is it used in standard play?
- Can a single Core Set build a tournament-legal deck?
- How many copies of a card can a deck contain?
- What is the minimum deck size?
- Can a deck include two different versions of a unique character with the same title?
- Do different printings and card types with the same title count toward one three-copy limit?
- Can any card be included more than three times in a deck?
- Do plot cards count toward a Banner agenda's non-loyal cards or Fealty's neutral limit?
- How many copies of the same plot can go in a plot deck?
- How do you tell which plots are loyal or house-specific, and can you include another house's loyal plot?
- Can players in the same game have identical plot decks and agenda cards?
- Do two players sharing one collection each need their own three copies of the core sets?