RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
1846: The Race for the Midwest thumbnail

1846: The Race for the Midwest FAQ

238 questions players ask · Updated Nov 16, 2026 · Full rulebook

SetupPrivate Company DistributionSequence of PlayStock RoundOperating RoundsBankruptcy and Closing a RailroadAdvancing the Game PhasePrivate Company AbilitiesTile Manifest and UpgradesGame End, Winning and EtiquetteTwo-Player VariantReference and Examples

Setup

  • Where does the money go when a private company is bought, tiles are laid, or an Independent railroad starts?
  • Should the extra bank money be removed at setup, and how much stays in the bank in a 5-player game?
  • In a 3- or 4-player game, are the removed private companies and corporations shown to everyone?
  • Do the home cities of corporations removed at setup stay blocked for the whole game?
  • How many trains of each type does setup use for each player count?
  • Are the Independent railroads' two yellow trains counted in the setup yellow total?
  • Are some corporation station tokens double-sided, and why?
  • Which corporations and private companies are removed in 3- and 4-player games?
  • How many privates and blank cards are used in a five-player game with the second-printing privates?
  • Why does the game box hold more bank money than the starting bank size?
  • Do tokens on the start spaces of companies not in the game block routes?
  • Does the New York Central start in Cleveland or Erie?

Private Company Distribution

  • How does the private company draft end once the remaining cards get down to the number of players plus two?
  • When the last private in the draft is passed on, how does its price fall, and who must take it at $0?
  • How is the last private handled when only one private is left in the deck?
  • During the private company draft, does face down mean the drafter must not look at the drawn cards?
  • How are the private companies distributed at the start of the game?
  • How many private companies can one player draft in the private company draft?
  • What is the starting price of the Big 4 private?
  • If a private's price falls to $0, must the next player take it and still pay its debt?
  • When a private's price is reduced, does the Michigan Southern or Big 4 starting treasury drop too?
  • Can a corporation buy a private company from another corporation?
  • Can a player buy a private company from another player?
  • What is the most a corporation can pay for a Michigan Southern or Big 4 private company?

Sequence of Play

  • Is the priority deal passed clockwise or to the left of the last player?
  • Is the first operating round run in reverse stock price order for the whole game?
  • In what order do the Michigan Southern and Big 4 operate, and does the first-operating-round reversal apply to them?

Stock Round

  • Can a player sell shares of a corporation that has not yet operated?
  • Does selling shares lower a corporation's stock price?
  • Can a president sell several shares in separate steps during one stock round turn?
  • Does a corporation closing lower the certificate limit, and does a player's bankruptcy change it?
  • Does the 12-certificate limit in a four-player game count certificates or individual shares?
  • Can a player with only two shares become president of a corporation?
  • Can a president pay for a track or token placement from personal cash when the corporation is out of money?
  • Must a corporation redeem shares when more are in the stock market than players hold?
  • Does a corporation need 50 percent of its shares sold before it can open?
  • What is the highest starting share price a new corporation can choose, $150 or $165?
  • Is there a limit on how many shares of one corporation a single player may own?
  • Does a corporation's stock price move up at the end of a stock round when all its shares are held by players?
  • Which corporation operates first when two corporations share the same stock price?
  • Can a player buy a share directly from a corporation's treasury without being its president?
  • Must a player start a corporation in the first stock round?
  • Can a player sell a share in a company and buy it back in the same stock round?
  • Can a player at the certificate limit buy a share that would give them the presidency and bring them back under the limit?
  • When a corporation's president changes, must the former president float another company?
  • Can a player buy and sell more than once in a single stock round?
  • Where do shares sold by a player in the stock round go?
  • Is it legal to launch a corporation as a decoy in the first stock round and choose the real company last?
  • Can players trade shares directly with each other?
  • How does control of a corporation pass to another player, and can a president's certificate be sold?
  • When a corporation is launched, can the president buy more than the president's certificate in the same stock round?

Operating Rounds

  • In what order do corporations operate in the first operating round?
  • Does a newly floated corporation get a free train or earn revenue in its first operating round?
  • Can a train bought with an Independent Railroad run for its new corporation in the same operating round?
  • Can a corporation buy an Independent Railroad when it is at its train limit?
  • How many shares can a corporation issue?
  • Must a corporation redeem shares when more shares are in the Stock Market than players hold?
  • When during its operating turn can a corporation issue or redeem shares?
  • Does issuing shares at the start of an operating turn lower the stock price?
  • How does issuing shares in a forced train purchase affect the price and the cash received?
  • Can a forced train purchase issue shares that would drop the price below $20?
  • In a forced train purchase, must the corporation issue the maximum number of shares?
  • Can a president sell shares during a forced train purchase if the sale would cause a presidency change or closure?
  • In what order does a forced train purchase raise money?
  • If a president cannot fund a forced train purchase, does the presidency pass to another player?
  • In a forced train purchase, can the corporation buy either train type?
  • When must a corporation buy a train?
  • Can a corporation buy a train from another corporation, and does that satisfy its forced purchase?
  • Can a corporation buy more than one train in an operating round?
  • Can a corporation change a train's type after buying it, or buy a returned train as the other type?
  • How many trains can a corporation own, and do phased-out trains count toward the limit?
  • Can a corporation with two trains buy the first Phase IV train?
  • Can a corporation discard or sell a train to make room for a newer one?
  • What does a phased-out train do before it is removed?
  • Can a phased-out train be bought from the bank pool or from another corporation?
  • How many tiles can a corporation lay or upgrade in one operating turn?
  • Can a tile be upgraded twice in one turn, for example yellow to green to brown?
  • Must an upgrade keep the existing track connections of the tile it replaces?
  • Must a newly laid tile connect to the track already printed on neighbouring tiles?
  • Which newly placed track must connect to one of the corporation's tokens?
  • Must a city tile lay or upgrade connect to the corporation's track?
  • Can a corporation upgrade a tile it is not yet connected to, if the upgrade creates the connection?
  • Can a corporation move a placed token, or place a station in a city it reaches only by backtracking?
  • In what order can a corporation lay tiles and place its token during its turn?
  • Can a corporation place a reserved-space token and a regular token in the same operating round?
  • What does it cost to lay or upgrade a tile?
  • Is a bridge, pass or tunnel cost paid again when a connected hex is later upgraded?
  • What do the Detroit upgrades cost?
  • Can the Illinois Central lay track for free in its land-grant spaces?
  • Is the Port Huron to Sarnia link a bridge or a tunnel?
  • Can you lay a tile on a grey hex such as Salamanca?
  • Which home-city tiles can be upgraded to brown?
  • Can a corporation reuse tiles it returned after an upgrade, and are the #7, #8 and #9 tiles limited?
  • In a half dividend payout, does a corporation receive money for the shares it holds in its own treasury?
  • How is a half dividend payout rounded?
  • How far does the stock price move after paying a dividend?
  • What does the earnings-per-share track record, and how does a corporation's marker move?
  • Can a route turn around, reuse an edge or backtrack, and can a train leave a city by any track?
  • Can a single train run through the same tile twice?
  • Can several trains of one corporation visit the same city in one operating round?
  • Must a corporation's routes use distinct track, even on a shared final approach?
  • Does a route need to start or end at one of the corporation's tokens?
  • Can a route start or end in a city wholly occupied by other corporations' stations?
  • Can a route run through a city where other corporations hold every spot?
  • Can a route run through an off-board area?
  • How do N/M trains count cities for revenue?
  • Can an N/M train extend its route only to collect Mail Contract income, without counting those cities for revenue?
  • Can a route visit more than one Chicago city, or visit Chicago twice?
  • Can two of a corporation's trains run into Chicago Connections?
  • If another corporation's token fills one Chicago spot, can routes still reach Chicago?
  • How does the East-West route bonus work?
  • Can an East-West bonus be claimed while skipping an off-board end, and must a token city be counted?
  • Can another corporation take a reserved city spot before the reserving corporation launches or closes?
  • Do reserved spots and home-city blocks end in Phase IV?
  • Does upgrading a city that has a reserved spot cancel the reservation?
  • Does a reserved token space in a city mean one specific spot, or the whole city?
  • Can the B&O or PRR place its token in its reserved city without a track connection, and what does it cost?
  • Can a tile be laid on a reserved city spot or in Fort Wayne before the reserving company places its token?
  • Can a route run through the home city of a corporation that is not in play?
  • Can a train run through a vacant reserved city spot, such as Erie's while Erie is in play but not yet launched?
  • Can another corporation place a token in the home city of a corporation that is in play but not yet launched?
  • Who can buy a private company, from whom, and for how much?

Bankruptcy and Closing a Railroad

  • After a corporation closes, can another corporation place a token in its former home city spot?
  • Does a player's bankruptcy change the certificate limit?
  • Can a president sell shares to drive a corporation's price down until it closes?
  • Where does the leftover treasury cash of a closed corporation go?
  • Does a bankrupt player's remaining stock lower the share price when it is sold to the market?
  • After a bankruptcy, does the corporation buy a train right away if it can afford one?
  • Are an unbought independent railroad's station tokens removed in phase III or phase IV?
  • What happens to a bankrupt player's private companies if bankruptcy occurs before Phase III?
  • When a president goes bankrupt on a forced train purchase, are all of his shares sold, including presidency certificates of other corporations?
  • If a bankrupt president's presidency certificate ends up in the bank, must the corporation buy a train?
  • If a president cannot raise enough cash for a forced train purchase, is the result bankruptcy or a presidency change?
  • What happens to a bankrupt player's shares and cash?

Advancing the Game Phase

  • Are unpurchased private companies and their markers removed when Phase III begins?
  • What is the difference between a phased-out train and a removed train?
  • When the first Phase IV train is bought, what happens to remaining Phase I and II trains?
  • Does a company that buys the first train of a new phase run its phased-out trains once more?
  • Can a company at its train limit buy a train that would trigger a phase change and phase out its own trains?
  • Are the Michigan Southern and Big 4 tokens removed at Phase III if no railroad bought those companies?
  • Does the start of Phase III remove player-owned privates before a corporation can buy them?
  • Can a train that is being phased out be bought from another corporation?
  • What happens to an independent railroad's treasury if no corporation has bought it when Phase III starts?
  • Does Holland's off-board value go down in Phase III?
  • When does the next phase begin in 1846: when the first train of that phase is bought, or after the next stock round?
  • After a corporation buys the first Phase IV train, do its Phase II trains run one more time, and do they count against the train limit?
  • Can a corporation buy private companies in Phase III or IV?
  • If a corporation bought an independent before Phase III, does the bought 2-train survive the start of Phase III?
  • What happens if a corporation holds more trains than the limit when a phase advances?

Private Company Abilities

  • Can a player use a private company's ability before a corporation buys it?
  • Do the Michigan Central and Ohio & Indiana tiles laid by a corporation have to connect to each other?
  • Does a corporation need a connection to its own token to use a purchased private company's track or token ability?
  • Do purchased private companies keep producing income after a corporation buys them?
  • Does using a private company's special ability close that private?
  • When can the Steamboat Company port marker be placed or shifted?
  • Can the Steamboat port marker be shifted more than once in one operating round, and how often can it move?
  • Can a corporation move the Steamboat port marker right after it buys the Steamboat Company?
  • Can a corporation buy the Steamboat Company between running two of its routes, then move the marker and run another route?
  • What happens to a Steamboat marker assigned to an Independent railroad when a corporation buys that Independent railroad?
  • Does a Steamboat or Meat Packing marker count as a token for connections, blocking, or running routes?
  • Which markers transfer to a corporation when it buys a private company?
  • Can the Steamboat port marker be moved during or after Phase III, and which corporation holds it then?
  • Do the Steamboat markers stay on the board when the Steamboat private closes in Phase III?
  • What do the two sides of the Steamboat port marker ($20 and $40) mean?
  • If a port-symbol tile is upgraded, does the port still exist?
  • Does every port symbol on the map give a $20 bonus, and who collects it?
  • Who collects the Steamboat Company's port bonus and its income?
  • Does the Steamboat port bonus apply to a train that passes through a port city without counting it as a stop?
  • Can the Steamboat port marker be assigned before the Steamboat private is bought into a corporation, and is it lost if the private never is?
  • What does assigning the Steamboat port marker to a corporation or Independent railroad do?
  • Can the Steamboat token benefit two different companies in the same operating round?
  • Can the owner of the Steamboat Company shift its port marker before any railroad buys it?
  • Can the Steamboat port marker be moved after the owning corporation has paid its revenue?
  • How do the two markers for Meat Packing and the Steamboat Company work?
  • Can a corporation collect the Meat Packing bonus before it has bought the company?
  • Does the Meat Packing Company marker add its bonus to all corporations' routes?
  • Does a Meat Packing Plant bonus apply to every city in the Chicago hex or only one?
  • Can the Chicago & Western Indiana owner place its extra token in the same operating round as its regular token, and without a connection?
  • Does the Chicago & Western Indiana owner need a track connection to place its Chicago token?
  • Can a corporation that owns the Chicago & Western Indiana build track out from its Chicago token?
  • If a corporation already has a token in Chicago, does buying the Chicago & Western Indiana give it an extra token?
  • When a corporation buys the Chicago & Western Indiana, must it place the Chicago token right away?
  • When does the Chicago spot reserved for the Chicago & Western Indiana become open to other corporations, and does the buyer keep a reservation?
  • Can the Chicago & Western Indiana token be placed in any Chicago space?
  • Does the Chicago & Western Indiana give its owner a teleport to Chicago?
  • When can the Lake Shore Line upgrade be used?
  • Can the Lake Shore Line upgrade Toledo before green tiles are in play?
  • Can the Lake Shore Line's upgrade be used more than once, and can it upgrade both Cleveland and Toledo?
  • Can the Lake Shore Line upgrade Toledo or Cleveland without a traceable connection, and can it place a token there unconnected?
  • Does the Lake Shore Line ability waive the cost of upgrading Toledo?
  • How does the Little Miami's track power connect Cincinnati and Dayton?
  • Does using the Little Miami skip the printed $40 cost on the Cincinnati edge?
  • Can the Ohio & Indiana owner lay its free tiles separately, interspersed with other tile lays in one turn?
  • Does the Tunnel Blasting Company discount apply to every terrain cost in a hex with a mountain and bridges, or to a bridge a connection crosses?
  • Does the PRR's Fort Wayne or the B&O's Cincinnati teleport end when the reserved token space is released in Phase IV?
  • How does the Mail Contract's $10 bonus count locations, including N/M extra stops and off-board spots?
  • Does Mail Contract income go into the railroad's treasury or into its dividend?
  • Are the small dots on reserved private company spaces, such as the O&I and Michigan Central, city spaces?
  • Where do the Big 4 and Michigan Southern tokens go, and how are they replaced when bought?
  • What happens to an independent railroad when a corporation buys it?
  • Can an independent railroad run before a corporation buys it in the same operating round, and can the bought train run that round?
  • Can a corporation buy an Independent Railroad if that puts it over the train limit?
  • After a corporation buys the Big 4 or Michigan Southern, can it still use that railroad's extra tile lays?
  • Can the Big 4 or Michigan Southern withhold its revenue?
  • Do the Michigan Southern and Big 4 have station tokens while they are independent?
  • Can a corporation buy a private company from any player, and for as little as $1?
  • Can a corporation with no cash use an independent railroad's treasury to buy the independent?
  • How many times can a private company's ability be used?
  • Can a company use a tile-laying private's extra tile-lay power at any time after buying it?
  • Can the Michigan Southern and Big 4 each lay two tiles per operating round?

Tile Manifest and Upgrades

  • Can the pre-printed yellow Wheeling tile be replaced by another yellow city tile?
  • Can a grey hex be upgraded?
  • Who pays a hexside cost, such as a bridge, pass or tunnel, when a tile is laid across it?
  • What is the total cost of upgrading Detroit when the upgrade also connects to Windsor?
  • Does the 40 in a white circle in Detroit affect the cost of upgrading Detroit?
  • Is the Chicago & Western Indiana's reserved token spot still shown after Chicago is upgraded?
  • Can a yellow city tile in an empty city hex be upgraded to green, brown, or gray?
  • Which cities can never be upgraded beyond green, including their home tiles?
  • Can a tile lay permanently block one of Chicago's token spaces, for example with the #25 tile?
  • Can a train run into Chicago Connections before Chicago is upgraded to green?
  • Can two trains of the same corporation pass through green tiles 16, 19 and 22 in one operating round?
  • What do you do when the unlimited yellow tiles #7, #8 or #9 run out?
  • Do the port symbols on Wheeling remain after Wheeling is upgraded?

Game End, Winning and Etiquette

  • Can players trade, give or sell assets to each other by agreement?
  • When does the game end after the bank runs out of money?
  • How does the bank run out to end the game?
  • How are the dividends from the last two operating rounds counted in final scoring?

Two-Player Variant

  • Is there an official two-player variant for 1846?
  • In the two-player variant, which private companies are removed from the game?
  • In the two-player variant, what happens when both players pass in a row?

Reference and Examples

  • How long does a reserved hex or city spot stay reserved?
  • Does the GMT edition of 1846 change the rules from the original DTG version?
  • What does the Z stand for in Z tiles?
  • What do the different numbers in off-board areas such as Holland, Windsor and the red zones mean?
  • Where does money paid for trains, track, stations or shares go?
  • How many trains of each type are in 1846 for each player count?
  • Does 1846 use restrictive, permissive or semi-restrictive track laying?
  • What do the dotted lines on the map, between the river and the lakes and in Cincinnati and Cumberland, signify?