RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
Viticulture Essential Edition thumbnail

Viticulture Essential Edition

← All Viticulture Essential Edition questions

When a visitor says "up to" (e.g. harvest up to 2 fields), can I choose to do zero?

The designer ruled on this directly on BGG in 2018.

  • jameystegmaier · Designer · 2018-04-01
  • Stonemaier Games — Viticulture FAQ · Official document · Gameplay
  • TimothyP · Community · 2020-09-20
  • runtsta · Community · 2020-09-21
  • MrAlza · Community · 2021-03-22
  • EricHogue · Community · 2018-05-22disagrees

No — Stonemaier's FAQ says an "up to" effect must be fulfilled to some extent, so "plant up to 2 vines" means planting at least 1. The designer calls this a global rule: you can't make zero wine and still claim a reward for having made wine. On cards that pair an "up to" effect with another fixed effect, some players treat doing only the fixed part as enough, but the official wording favors doing at least one.

More Viticulture Essential Edition questions · Full rulebook