Macao
Can a punishment marker ever be removed once you have taken it?
The rules have no removal step, and the one thread that discusses it agrees, so it is a reading rather than a ruling.
- Rokkr · Community · 2010-06-28
No. Once taken, a punishment marker stays with you for the rest of the game, and nothing in the rules discards it. The abbot card only protects you from the markers taken at game end.