Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage
← All Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage questions
Does withdrawing from a battle count as losing it for political consequences?
Section 16.2 says the Retreat Table is not used, and 15.5 applies only to the loser, so the rulebook supports this directly.
- Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage rulebook · Rulebook · 16.2 A Successful Withdrawal
- Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage rulebook · Rulebook · 15.5 Political Consequences
- andylatto · Community · 2017-10-04
- John_B_Firer · Community · 2017-10-05
- MD1616 · Community · 2013-10-16
- Karel · Community · 2007-11-27
No. A successful withdrawal is not a defeat. The withdrawing side makes no Retreat Table roll and loses no PC markers, while both armies still roll on the Attrition Table for battle casualties (16.2 and 15.5).