Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage
← All Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage questions
Is a retreating army's size counted before or after the losses taken on the retreat?
Section 15.1 puts battle and Retreat Table losses before the retreat; the order of the entry penalty and the stop test is not in the text, and posters split on it.
- Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage rulebook · Rulebook · 15.1 Retreat Procedure
- Hannibal: Rome vs. Carthage rulebook · Rulebook · 15.3 Penalties on Retreats
- Peter White · Community · 2008-01-08
- qzhdad · Community · 2008-01-09disagrees
After the losses that come first. Battle casualties and Retreat Table losses are removed before the retreat starts (15.1), so the army that retreats is the reduced one. The rulebook does not say whether the extra CU lost on entering an enemy-PC space comes off before you check the stop condition. Most players take it on entry and then compare, but a poster argued the original size should count.