Francis Drake
Does a third ship back to Plymouth get the Hero's bonus when the first two ships did not attack?
The designer's stated intent on BGG is the first two attacking ships home, though he calls the wording clumsy.
- Peter Hawes · Designer · 2015-11-30
- andrewbwm · Community · 2015-11-27
- killerardvark · Community · 2015-11-27
Only if it is one of the first two ships home that attacked successfully. The designer says the bonus is meant for the first two returning ships that successfully attacked, so a ship that attacked successfully can be the first or second to qualify even behind non-attackers. He admits the literal wording could also reach a third ship.