Dungeon Lords
When a Witch Hunt lets you forfeit a monster or gain 3 Evil, can you take the Evil option without a monster or at the top of the Evilometer?
You can take the forfeit option only if you own a monster to forfeit, so without one you must gain 3 Evil. Gaining Evil is not a cost, so you take it even at the top of the Evilometer, where it simply has no effect.