CATAN
Can expansions from different Catan editions or languages be mixed?
Replies disagree, and the rulebook does not cover edition compatibility, so the answer is a best reading.
- hakko504 · Community · 2016-08-08
- Sebastian Rapp · Community · 2013-09-18disagrees
Only partly. Mayfair editions mix only with Mayfair expansions. Other editions are language versions of the Kosmos edition, which one reply says mix freely, but a Kosmos reply says English editions are not compatible with other languages, so there is no firm answer.