RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
Carcassonne: The City thumbnail

Carcassonne: The City

← All Carcassonne: The City questions

Can a tile be placed so that it encloses wall pieces, traps a wall end, or lies beyond the wall?

The rulebook only bars tiles beyond the walls; the enclosure reading comes from several agreeing posters.

  • Carcassonne: The City rulebook · Rulebook · Walls, Towers, and the City Gate
  • notquitekarpov · Community · 2011-09-28
  • gillum · Community · 2015-12-29
  • toulouse · Community · 2004-12-27
  • ekted · Community · 2005-10-24
  • rkonigsberg · Community · 2025-05-06disagrees
  • timonkey · Community · 2025-05-06disagrees

No. The rulebook says tiles cannot be placed beyond the walls, and players read that to mean a tile may not cover a wall or wall space, enclose the wall, or let the gate start inside a hole in the city. A hole that is walled off from the outside is fine as long as the outer wall can still run around the city.

More Carcassonne: The City questions · Full rulebook