RulesPal
Chat
Rulebook
FAQ
Arkham Horror (2005) thumbnail

Arkham Horror (2005)

← All Arkham Horror (2005) questions

Is a spell exhausted when its casting roll fails, and can you retry it with a helper?

Repliers in one thread mostly read a failed cast as exhausting the spell, but a dissenting reading of the card wording is left open.

  • StygianTraveler · Community · 2011-10-31
  • ColtsFan76 · Community · 2012-04-11
  • StygianTraveler · Community · 2011-10-31
  • Nethog · Community · 2011-10-31disagrees
  • ColtsFan76 · Community · 2011-11-09

Usually yes. Casting exhausts the spell whether or not the Spell check passes, and it refreshes at the next Upkeep, so you cannot retry the same spell that turn. Its hands stay tied up for that combat round. A spell that succeeded with a combat-long bonus keeps its hands for the whole combat. One poster argues the card says cast, not successfully cast.

More Arkham Horror (2005) questions · Full rulebook